HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

feralimal

-15 karma · joined May 9, 2020

submissionscomments
feralimal··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
What is a matter of fact?

I'll save you some time, it is that we can verify personally. If I can verify it, I can say 'its true' and that 'I know it'.

But the problem is that most individuals verify very little - its beyond ridiculous how little we verify. If we see something on TV, we think we have verified it! Did we verify the film Independence Day?!

All day long, individuals will say 'I know' or 'its true'. Even though they haven't verified their assumptions, if they even know what their assumptions are. Most people's lives are based on massive, unverified assumptions. They are so big, that they cannot consider questioning them - they have to be true or they may have a mental breakdown!

Say most people 'know' that we are on a globe. How? Have they experienced the globe? How was it proven to them that this wasn't a flat plane? Do they really 'know' it, like they know the chair they are sitting on? They do not. So, when they say 'they know' what do they mean? Its a hypothesis, or a belief, or faith. They believe they know.

So, if we were honest to ourselves, and accounting for our assumptions, we should say, 'I believe' such-and-such. But we say 'I know'. What is it to do that?

If you ask me, this is a lie. We lie to ourselves and to those around us. We live in a world of lies, of false, unverified information - and yet we call it knowledge. Its actually quite amazing.

feralimal··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
The questions about fundamentals - cooking, reading. I would of course agree that these are useful to the individual. Now coding - again the skill is neutral. But what you code might not be. Why do you code what you code? Should you code in a bank, a facebook algorithm, etc? Are you actually undertaking your life in a positive way, or are you making gains at another's expense?

Do you think training is a neutral act? Is it possible that training can be subversive to the trainee?

Perhaps you will see my position as a political, anti-statist one. I see it as an individualistic perspective. If an individual is trained in academic philosophy, in order to provide 'production of well argued original works of academic philosophy' why is that valuable? To me, there is no value there at all. As an individual, I want to uncover the innate understanding we all already have.

Have you ever heard about people who go through half their life, having trained to be doctors, or solicitors, only to then realise that they didn't want to do that? I would say that these are the lucky ones - they have wasted only half their lives, and though they have much to undo, they at least they are honest enough to change their position and try to find something authentic and innate to them. Most people do not do that. That is the power of training and education, IMO. In it for the money, sell your granny.

In my view, this is what training at a higher level is to train people NOT to look inside themselves for answers, but to refer to an external authority. This applies to academic philosophy as much as any other area. Love of wisdom, becoming oneself, makes way for the production of 'original works of academic philosophy'. Beyond the basics, education seems to me about disempowering the individual, for the benefit of some imagined 'collective'. In fact, that collective is so individual who has their hands on the levers of governance, but let's not think too closely about that.

feralimal··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
"You are right that you don't have to be a trained philosopher to think for yourself. In the same way that training in martial arts helps with punching, or training in coding helps you write better software, training in thinking helps you think."

Thank you. But are these comparable? Is thinking competitive and there's a winner? What is it to be trained to think? If that training hadn't happened, would the un-trained person not be thinking? Or, would you be thinking along a more natural way? Is it more akin to building one or other type of sandcastle, rather than to be a better fighter?

The way I view it, the only thing an individual can do is try to be the winner for themselves - they need to progress their understanding of themselves as much as possible. In nature there's no competition - there are needs that might or might not be met.

But, if you want to harness or direct individuals into a collectivised state, yes, you need to train them, and they will produce what you call 'original works of philosophy' on the basis of all the thought that has preceded them. As if 'a body of original works' is important to an individual. They may be renumerated for their trained thinking. As if renumeration is something the individual would ever want.

feralimal··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
Can one make anything other than anecdotal arguments? If your arguments aren't based on your personal reasoning, what are they based on?

Also, I don't agree that you need to be trained philosopher to think for yourself. But why do you say so? What is it that the training provides?

feralimal··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
I agree that technology requires philosophy.

But 'the world' requires philosophy - technology is just an extension of the world. Discomfitingly, 'the world' or 'society' is really just an idea in an individual's mind - these are just ideas that don't exist independently of individuals. What is really required is for individual's to consider their positions, and to extend whatever they reason into action in the real world.

The unfortunate reality is that 99% of people do not consider their positions at all, they simply accept what they are taught as true. However, whether they have considered their worldview deeply or not, they do have one. The default one is what was embedded in their education. Unfortunately again, the nature of education is to make one think in a communitarian way - ie to think 'we', 'society', 'the world', etc. Education does not care for the individual - its aim is to produce individuals that are malleable to the needs of 'society'. So communitarian (not individualistic) thinking is the order of the day.

So, sadly, most people, don't really think at all, they are just running their 'educational programming'. Those who are most educated are often the most inactive thinkers. Their position is that they 'believe they know' without having verified anything personally.

Nevertheless, everyone has strongly felt opinions, such that they are able to say: 'we need to do such-and-such a worthy cause'. Well, who is 'we'? Why is 'such-and-such' a worthy cause? Do we really need to do it? Do I have the right to force another to do anything? The means to analyse these quite simple questions are beyond the means of most.

Anyway, for my sins, I do try to provide my philosophical perspective on things around here. I'm skeptical (most would say ultra-skeptical) and given my understanding of the world, I'm not convinced that technology is helping us. This is not a popular opinion around here! But I will persevere.

feralimal··on George Orwell’s 1984 through a neuroscience lens
Thank you! I've been getting some flak on my 1984 comments!

On mental health, I still like the old quote: "It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society" (Jiddu Krishnamurti)

Cheers!

feralimal··on The Semantic Future of the Web
I get you! This is something that impacted blind individuals. I didn't know. Thanks.
feralimal··on George Orwell’s 1984 through a neuroscience lens
I'm not clear what your position is, but what does it say about one, in one can only see the tyranny in a book but not be able to see it in real life?
feralimal··on George Orwell’s 1984 through a neuroscience lens
And - to go further still - Orwell, Huxley (and perhaps Zamyatin) fulfil the 'Goldstein' role, IRL.
feralimal··on George Orwell’s 1984 through a neuroscience lens
I would suspect that Yevgeny Zamyatin would also have been privy to the plan. Aldous Huxley too.
feralimal··on George Orwell’s 1984 through a neuroscience lens
If Big Brother hadn't told you about Covid, would you even know?
feralimal··on The Semantic Future of the Web
> Sadly modern day web browsers have such less support for it that they even dropped the media device targets from the CSS spec, which I think is morally wrong.

'Morally wrong'? This is an interesting phrase to use - are you able to explain more on this?

feralimal··on New UK police speed gun can read license plates from half a mile away at night
Isn't there meant to be a curve of around 8 inches per mile?
feralimal··on George Orwell’s 1984 through a neuroscience lens
Great to hear that science (neuroscience) here is catching up with Orwell. It is a great book, and Orwell was spot on with so much of what he wrote. How did he do it?

I think I know. I don't think Orwell (Erik Blair) was writing a book about a dystopian future. No. I think he was writing about the dystopian present he was already aware of, and then projecting that a little into the future. From personal experience with the BBC, he knew what news and history really were. As a connected individual (allowed to finish his work on the private owned island of Jura) he was aware of the plans that were in place.

So, I don't see 1984 as a dystopian vision of the future. I see it as a far more straightforward projection of what was already in place. We may be unaware of our prison, but Orwell was not - and was telegraphing it to us.

And most of us still do not get it, and cannot see it. We are glad big Brother is making us wear masks to help us breath better, that we are keeping away from our families because of love, that we will be 'cured' by a 'vaccine'.

And if you draw attention to this around here, you won't be thanked! We're not coding a harder, more impenetrable prison - we're making a better future, right?

feralimal··on Nietzsche on Truth and Lie (1991)
"people who don't think truth can be known, often act with a great deal of certainty about things they believe to be right."

Great comment.

It is very rare, in my opinion to find anyone who isn't acting on beliefs as if they were knowledge. 99.999% of people are unable to understand that what they think is 'knowledge' is actually a set of unverified assumptions. These assumptions are presented as true at school, in work, on TV, etc and they see that everyone else treats these assumptions as true, so... well they are true, right?

People cannot accept holding something as a hypothesis. They may even say they do this, but they do not change their hypotheses when they get new information. If pushed, they may state something to be a 'hypothesis' and that they use the word 'know' as a shortcut to that - all fine - but then if they are presented with additional information they cannot take it on and will reject it. Cognitive dissonance has no place in their minds - it is a tension that is unacceptable. Apparently most of us seek certainty and prefer a certain story to just resting with the evidence.

The idea of 'believing we know' permeates our lives, and is why I argue that science is religion. And beliefs held as true operate on fundamental levels, despite a lack of verified evidence.

TLDR, people prefer stories to truth.

feralimal··on We can have democracy or we can have Facebook
Yuck. Neither democracy nor facebook, thanks. Nor any nannying or moralising about hate speech.

Sticks and stones may break my bones but words can never hurt me. Or you.

feralimal··on Why there is no legal remedy for Covid
23m podcast
feralimal··on Diem – A rebrand of Facebook’s Libra
It doesn't mention facebook. Why?

If you look at the members section, at the bottom of this page, facebook is not there.

https://www.diem.com/en-us/association/

feralimal··on This is Real, That's Not
I like the observations you make, and I think you are correct in them.

I object to this though:

"Collective failure of imagination"

There is so much wrong with that statement, I barely know where to start.

Government is a collection of individuals. Individuals do have imagination. But in this case, no imagination is even required - as you point out there is the previous 9 months of data.

What we find is no interest in improving the situation of those in the worst position. Have you considered the possibility, that it is government that creates these situations in the first place?

More broadly, I object to the commonly held idea that government is there to help us at all, despite that being what we are taught in its schools. It is there to rule us.

You can confirm this if you can break down the word 'government'. 'Govern' (has root as kyberenetes) means rule with authority. '-ment' means relating to minds, like 'mental'. The word literally means 'rule minds'.

feralimal··on A Japanese shop is 1,020 years old
"(Some of the oldest companies, including Ichiwa, cannot definitively trace their history back to their founding, but their timelines are accepted by the government, scholars and — in Ichiwa’s case — the competing mochi shop across the street.)"

Skeptic that I am, I wanted to see the proof. There isn't any - its just a claim. Its just a sweet story.

In fact, I suspect that this is some sort of tourism puff piece, PR of some sort, perhaps by the Japanese tourism board to drum up enthusiasm. Maybe they are planting seeds for when the lockdowns are over.

feralimal··on Only distributed fact-checking can keep up with democratized distribution
Here is the full quote. I think its even better:

"Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience. They may be more likely to go to Heaven yet at the same time likelier to make a Hell of earth. This very kindness stings with intolerable insult. To be "cured" against one's will and cured of states which we may not regard as disease is to be put on a level of those who have not yet reached the age of reason or those who never will; to be classed with infants, imbeciles, and domestic animals."

feralimal··on Only distributed fact-checking can keep up with democratized distribution
Who arbitrates?

Is it whoever owns big corporations? Is it the mainstream media? Are they trustworthy? Is it the government? Scientists? Which one of us holds the truth?

One man's facts are another man's lies. And this is fine. We should be able to tolerate multiple opinions. Labelling things as 'hate speech' and denying people the right to speech doesn't help!

I think C S Lewis said it best:

"those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience"

feralimal··on Second Swiss firm allegedly sold encrypted spying devices
What kind of action do you expect to see?

You do realise that governance is how corporations manage the people, not how people manage corporations, right?

feralimal··on The Purpose of Writing
Great article - I agree! In fact, the author could go further IMO.

"However, more often than discovering that your ideas are wrong, you will discover something different: that you do not know what you think."

Writing and thinking (2 sides to the same coin IMO) have been illuminating to me. Hence I have moved to becoming a skeptic (ultra-skeptic in most people's opinion). Knowing what you know, and why you know is everything. 'Believing you know' is everywhere...

We live in a world of stories.

feralimal··on Microsoft's Creepy New 'Productivity Score' Gamifies Workplace Surveillance
As bad as it is, isn't it great that they announce that they are spying on us? They wouldn't really need to - how would we know, if they didn't?

Enough naivety...

If people don't think that this has been going on for years, or that they actually announce Orwellian surveillance, I'm not sure what to tell you! We have been already living in a track and trace world - what is happening is that it is becoming overt. And there is nothing to be done about it. We all need the paycheck, right?

Even if there is a massive outcry about this - and I doubt there will be - they will just come back and do it another way. They claim it is a right for employers to get the 'metrics'.

What's kind of dark, twisted and funny, is that the people building the cages of today and tomorrow, are doing so with open eyes - technologists are some of the most surveilled people about, but - no problem! - we'll code tomorrow's hell for you!

feralimal··on Microsoft 365 has employee surveillance and analytics built in
I did say 'apparently'. :) Good research though!
feralimal··on Microsoft 365 has employee surveillance and analytics built in
Well, conspiracy has a bad name, but really I think that's the only domain you can understand the possible reality of what's been planned and undertaken in this world nowadays.

It really should be a bad term - of course very powerful people conspire to ensure that they get the best they can. And that would mean writing legislation, defining what education is, etc, etc. Its all very obvious...

feralimal··on The New York Public Library’s Last, Secret Apartments (2016)
This building doesn't even look like it was originally a library. It looks like it was repurposed to be a library.
feralimal··on Microsoft 365 has employee surveillance and analytics built in
The wider aspect to this, is that this is occurring as part of the new governance system that is currently revealed. That is technocracy. Everything will be measured, and the system will self-manage and re-allocate resources as it sees fit.
feralimal··on Microsoft 365 has employee surveillance and analytics built in
In conspiracy culture, this is called predictive programming. We are shown the ideas in films etc, so then when it appears in reality, we don't react in shock and reject it. Rather we shrug and are resigned to its appearance in reality.

This also correlates to the idea of boiling frogs. Apparently, if you turn up the heat slowly the frog will stay in the warm water and be boiled, as opposed to jumping out, which is what happens if you place the frog directly into warm water.

← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →