HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

feralimal

-15 karma · joined May 9, 2020

submissionscomments
feralimal··on The Uniqueness of Mammals
You have not produced a new species, when you reproduce different looking dogs. You might classify that as a new species, but it is not a new species in any meaningful or underlying way. You are talking about a system of classification that only exists in the minds of men. I will agree that these are somewhat useful distinctions in order to allow us to navigate and describe our world, but let's not kid ourselves that we are describing some underlying reality.

> First of all, as I explained earlier, I don't need to literally see it happen to understand how it must have. The present derives from the past, and if you simply extend how we see genetics working today into the past (or future), evolution is in fact the only possible result (assuming no magical forces are acting). Your way of thinking is a dead end for any process that lies outside the limited human senses: if something is smaller than what we can see, or further away than we can see, or takes longer than a single human lifetime, it would be completely out of the reach of science. I do not accept this view of the world, and I don't see any reason why theories couldn't be extrapolated beyond what is immediately visible.

You are lost in the stories. You think that because you have classified something as a new species, it is a new species. You can say what I say is a dead end. That's fine. I'm just not prepared to extrapolate theories ad infinitum. I'm certainly willing to entertain them. I'm not prepared to treat them as true or as knowledge, without actually being able to confirm them. Evolution might be as described, but I can't know that it is, as I am unable to confirm it. We are not given information to allow us to understand - we are given claims that we have to accept as true.

> If I understand what my eyes see, and I understand how a lense works, and I understand how an electron microscope works, then I can trust that the image the electron microscope is drawing of a microbe is true, even though if I take away the microscope I can only see a mess. The same works if you apply this reasoning backwards in time, even over millions of years.

My point is that you do not understand. You believe you understand. You are standing on belief, not knowledge. Knowledge is certain, indisputable. Beliefs might or might not be true.

> The crisis of reproducibility is a tangent, and it only affects a limited set of fields, it is not a crisis in all of science.

Well, I understand that you think this is a tangent. But for me, I see this as evidence of nefarious activity. Science is presented as a completed package, we are masters, etc. Yes, there are some bits that are changing, but we've got the big pieces in the right place. I think this idea - that science is basically right - is dangerous and plays on our ego. We think we know, but we have belief. We cannot be critical of the pronouncements of science. This 'science' is really religion.

Cutting to the chase, I think science has been bent to conform to some ideas that those that bent it, want us to accept. Those that bent it, have also ensured that we are all educated (indoctrinated) in these dogmas. We are presented with theories, we are not given the evidence we need to know, but we are told to believe these are truth. As children, we are pushed into a situation where we take these ideas as true articles of faith or nothing. And as we prefer a story to the absence of one, we cling to it. This is not logic, it is a psychological trick. At the end of this process, as adults, we have beliefs masquerading as knowledge.

This makes for very rigid thinking, such that whoever holds to it, cannot even consider other possibilities. To do so would be to destroy their sense of self. So 'adults' will double up and reject alternative ideas as they are seen as a personal attack. And they are - they are attacking that adult's beliefs - they must be rejected, as a Christian would reject some science explanations. This is not the way of science and the scientific method. We should be grateful for alternative ideas, as we will likely discover something new. But no, what we have is the idea that 'the science is in' and we just have to accept it. Science is a powerful means of control. Just like religion used to be.

feralimal··on The Uniqueness of Mammals
I'm glad it is fascinating. You should think on this, and realise how much trust and faith you are putting into the stories you are told, and how much or how little it coheres with what is the gold standard - your personal experience.

Yes - at school, I think you were convinced I think by water condensating and by the loud pop (as was I). This is almost the definition of a magic trick! You are told it explains something, but of course at that age, you wouldn't have looked at the experiment with a critical or knowledgeable eye. The evidence that we were shown as kids should not be considered rigorous or acceptable in science - mixing invisible gases in an open container that allows air in, is not rigorous. Personally I have not seen any examples of this experiment that are undertaken in what I deem to be an acceptable scientific manner.

I too believe that computers work. :) I don't dispute that we are able to use things to create some excellent technology. What I dispute that we know what we're doing.

What I'm saying is that we do not get to see or understand the first principles. We do not see them in almost any of the science we are presented when we are taught at school. What we are given are claims and explanations that are not supported by the evidence. We are put in a position where we are forced to trust. It seems we require an explanation, so much so that we will latch on to any story rather than sit uncomfortably with one or 2 open-ended hypotheses.

The heart of the issue, we are not given evidence to know, we are given a claim to believe. I can know I am resting on a table. I can know that if I drop my pen it will fall on the table. There is no debate to be had. There is a clear path to experience, or empiricism. Empiricism is purported to be the basis of science, but some very basic ideas are not actually possible to experience it seems.

In the original article here, evolution is the implied explanation. But, we have no means to test or confirm the truth or not. We cannot see evolution occurring. (Feel free to point me to an article or something that you think shows this.) Yet we are all taught it as if it was true! If it is as I say, what we are presented with is an unfalsifiable theory which is without evidence. This is to say it is based on trust and faith. This is religious thinking, and is no different to a religion.

Finally, are you aware of the replication crisis in science?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis

and

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-39054778

"According to a survey published in the journal Nature last summer, more than 70% of researchers have tried and failed to reproduce another scientist's experiments."

There should be 100% replicability, not 30%. Science shouldn't be about playing the odds in a casino.

And as to the science we do, funding is probably the most serious issue. All science funding comes from the government, the military and corporations. These 3 entities form our governance structure. This is to say they have vested interests in ensuring that only certain areas are looked into, the point being is that science is not an independent field of enquiry - it is about what is expedient to the governance structure.

feralimal··on The Uniqueness of Mammals
To say 'I remember my birth' is hearsay. When we give our birth date, we are effectively lying, as we don't know, even though we were there.

I believe that there is a past that was laid down. But I don't think we know it. We are told and taught is what is most expedient in order for our behaviour to be managed. (Take a look at Star forts to see what I mean - you weren't taught about this global build style at school.)

As we don't experience evolution, why should we believe it is true? We can experience selection of the best fruit etc, choosing and breeding the best tomatoes - but this is not evolution. This is just selective breeding.

In the same way as I think history is whatever is expedient, I think the same about science (and religion).

I personally believe that the scientific method is a fantastic way to better understand the world. But it has to be done personally. The problem is that science does not use the scientific method, regardless of how much it pays lip service to it. Science relies on trust and scientists have faith that all the steps are there - its just they were taken by someone else. But the steps are not there, and no one is checking anything. These are mistaken assumptions, or stories and no one seems to care or notice.

If you want an example of how little we know in science, try and make water out of the 2 gases, in controlled conditions. I will pre-empt any further questions on this, until you have looked online, or put up an experiment of your own. There are lots of loud pops, but what I see is water already in the air condensating against the glass. If you find a good example of water being created - and we should be able to create buckets of the stuff right? - please run it past me and see if I agree. I promise to be fair, and explain my reasoning if I disagree.

My view is that we live in a fabricated reality, where we have created types and classifications - but that these are ideas in our own minds. We are not describing reality, we are describing our classifications. We are lost in our stories.

feralimal··on The Uniqueness of Mammals
Very interesting article.

"Morality did not occur in humans spontaneously. It must have had animal precedents."

This statement has so much embedded in it, its hard to know where to start. This comes after having listed a bunch of traits that we share with animals.

My view is that we mammals emote in the same wayas us. Mentally though, human thinking and conceptualising is at an entirely different level. We can think about concepts. We are not the same mentally. This is not a value judgement - it is not better or worse, and quite possibly it is far worse - without language, we would live in a world of lies or at best, mis-interpretations and mis-understandings. But it is evidently orders of magnitudes different to animals.

Which brings me back to the quote. Embedded in it is the belief in evolution, which I can re-state as 'human morality arose out of animal behaviour via the process of evolution'.

Like the bible, evolution is just another story. When we want to say 'we know', we need to have a direct path to a real situation - no steps can be missed! But we don't have that - we were taught stories as if they are true. The reality is that they are hearsay. I haven't seen evolution. Its just a story an explanation believed to be knowledge.

Perhaps the theory has some explanatory power, although it is also a possibility it is taught to confuse us and keep us intentionally ignorant. We do not know. However, when we say we know but do not, we are proudly and arrogantly wearing our ignorance as a badge of honour!

I love to hear about animal behaviour. I don't love to hear the back flips that ignorance masquerading as knowledge makes us do. Eg, the author signs off with: "I would suggest that what makes us unique is that we are mammals—only more so. The mammalian characteristics have been amplified in human beings. This echoes Darwin’s supposition in The Descent of Man that humans differ mentally from animals in degree rather than in kind and that, as Giovanni Boniolo put it, it is only logical to suppose that human behaviour evolved from that of our non-human ancestors. Some people may not like this idea."

If you have to have a theory to explain the world, as if the world can be explained on scientific terms, then the go-to theory is evolution. If you don't agree with this 'science' then the author will get all passive aggressive on you for lack of belief in 'non-human ancestors'. He smugly allows himself to say: "Some people may not like this idea." Unsaid is - 'Those idiots.'

So, the science belief is actually a lever to feel superior, justified and empowered in his ignorance masquerading as knowledge, over those who, in their own ignorance believe in religion, or something other to him. But there is no greater knowledge there. Its ignorance all round.

The article is the sugar, to get you to swallow the pill of an assumed but still unproven belief in evolution.

Skepticism of everything is the answer. Beware of believing anything regards the objective world, that does not match with personal experience.

feralimal··on Deep Frozen Arctic Microbes Are Waking Up
"Rockabye baby, on the tree top..."

Don't worry about me, just getting those microbes back to bed...

feralimal··on I Miss Working from the Office
No offices, everyone work at home - everyone so busy...

And then you look around, what is all this work achieving?

What were we achieving when we worked in the office? Were we doing anything real at all?

feralimal··on Dr. Roger Hodkinson says CV19 response utterly unfounded, despite running tests
It is interesting that - at last - there are a few independent voices speaking up from within the medical profession.

This should also be read - editorial in the BMJ about covid: https://www.bmj.com/content/371/bmj.m4425

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
aaand here's the link, sorry!

editorial in the BMJ about covid: https://www.bmj.com/content/371/bmj.m4425

feralimal··on Dr. Roger Hodkinson says CV19 response utterly unfounded, despite running tests
The doctor is very qualified, educated at Cambridge, Former head of Alberta College of Physicians & Surgeons, now running a lab that undertakes covid testing.

Even so, he is very opposed to the global response. In his opinion this is just a normal flu season. No need to shut the world down.

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
Its so obvious, isn't it? Why hasn't anyone done it? Because that does not suit the agenda.

Because government does not change anything, its just there to pacify the masses. Name one thing that government has done for you, when you voted?

Lobbying is not the answer. You are dealing with a system that has been captured from top to bottom.

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
I've expressed my position. That this is a captured system, owned by large corporations. That education, science, government, media - all of it is captured and bent towards the will of those few who own the large corporations. If you can't see how the world is being co-ordinated now, I don't think you ever will.

If you are a top elite, and own almost everything, even banks, even the Federal Reserve (and it is privately owned btw), so you can print your own money, you have a totally different set of questions. You may well find yourself prepared to ditch an entire industry (oil) for the sake of the greater good. Its really not about the oil industry.

We are globally being transitioned away from cars, etc. We will not own cars in the future. We will have our freedom of movement severely constrained, on account of our 'citizen score' (see present day China). We will not be able to use electricity or water, once our allocated credits are used up. This sounds dystopian, right?

But you will be cheering this on, because you believe what you are told.

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
Science is incredibly easy to cheat. Everyone is silo'd and beholden to funding.

That very few people speak up about it (why would they, when their jobs are at risk) means nothing.

A really good example of someone speaking up, from a 'trusted' organisation, is this editorial in the British Medical Journal.

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
So much trust in the stories you are provided.

Even though it doesn't tally up with what you see.

I see a wonderful world. You see a world that you yourself are killing.

But even accepting the stories, science etc we are given, the top 100 corporations are responsible on their own for 70% of the emissions. Why don't we make this issue completely disappear in the easiest way possible, by banning those corporations only from any polluting? Job done.

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
Its far, far bigger than that.

And you do realise that the BBC was created to be a propaganda delivery vehicle? That you couldn't get a job there unless you had been screened by MI5? That they gave out free TVs to ensure good take up of their propaganda?

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
Climate change and coronavirus are pretexts for the rollout of a technocratic system. They are geopolitical stories to get our buy in to all they have planned for us. This can be seen in the way all our governments are acting in tandem. We have a 'new normal', 'build back better', etc. Klaus Schwab lays out the plans in detail if you want to know what's coming up.

What happened to 3 weeks to flatten the curve? We're 8 months in, and it is clear this is going to continue perpetually, and we are going to be vaccinated twice annually for covid19/20/21 - there is no end to this. And climate change is the 'carrot' - we all want to save the earth! But what if that is a fake story to frame our situation in order for us to subscribe to the plans?

If you try to correlate climate change to personal experience, you will see just how much you are putting trust in organisations that are not there to serve you.

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
No I don't think it means people will suffocate. I'm saying that carbon dioxide should help trees grow. That we have a natural buffer against too much.

Did you know that some farms, pump carbon dioxide into their greenhouses to improve their crop. It seems self-evident that any extra would be mopped up by trees, bushes etc in the wild.

I hear what you are saying about snow and your experience. But you should also ask the older generation what their experience was of the winters there. There may have been times that there wasn't always snow. And unfortunately, I don't think our weather today is entirely natural - that weather modification has been around for a few years now.

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
> From about 3,000 years ago to about 100 years ago, sea levels naturally rose and declined slightly, with little change in the overall trend. Over the past 100 years, global temperatures have risen about 1 degree C (1.8 degrees F), with sea level response to that warming totaling about 160 to 210 mm (with about half of that amount occurring since 1993)

This is hearsay. You were not there 3000 years ago, or even 100 years. You have been told a story and are re-telling it to me. Why should I believe it? I know how people can mislead into lying with statistics, for their work, etc to prepare information that is not accurate. I just don't have any faith in science. (I love the scientific method, but that's a different story, that pales into insignificance when funding is involved.)

> In 2018, the all-species index in the UK, based on the aggregated population trends of 130 breeding species, was 11% below its 1970 value.

We have had industrial farming methods take off at that time, and we do throw some awful stuff on the soil - I'm prepared to believe that this is probably fair data. However, how can I know this is really true?

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
Fair enough. But I don't trust. Can I know?

If I cannot know, I will not trust. To trust would weaken me, and empower those who hide information to hide even more. This is where we are.

I do live in a zero trust world. I trust government and corporations least of all. Individuals I have much more time for.

Although zero trust was disconcerting at first, I also find it liberating. I know that there is lots I do not know. I'm not pretending to myself - holding beliefs as if they were knowledge, because of misplaced trust.

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
Yes. I don't trust the television to present the truth. Perhaps you also know, but 'the science' also tells us there are more polar bears than ever. I don't really trust any of it. Science, media, government - all are long-captured areas that have been bent to manage us for the benefit of those that own the corporations.

On your point about climate - do you really think that the climate should be the same, year after year? I think there are fluctuations. (I also think the weather we have is not entirely natural, but that's a different story.)

On forest fires, these are in fact managed environments. If you don't let the fires burn naturally, and allow matter to build up, eventually you will have a massive conflagration. You can just de-fund the organisations that actively managed those environments, to prepare a fire event.

Additionally, it really doesn't take much to create a fire - just someone to start one - ie this doesn't need to be a natural event. In fact, there were lots of people that were arrested for starting fires on purpose. Bizarrely, lots of them were released! (At least that was the case in Aus.)

You might say 'why would they do that?' Well, my view is that those who govern us want to usher in a technocratic control system, and they need us to accept this. If they say they are going to save us from climate change and killing the world, the psychology is such that most people would willingly sign up. They teach us about climate change in schools, so everyone is on board.

feralimal··on Britain to ban new petrol cars and vans by 2030 on road to net zero emissions
Thanks for those posting data from NASA and NOAA. I know you will think that I'm being outrageous not to trust the data from those organisations, but I don't. I see all - ALL - the organisations as acting in interests that are not mine. I do not want to get into an anarchy conversation, but I think it is self-evident that governmental structures are about control.

What is requested in posting this 'scientific' data, is that I deny the evidence of my own senses.

What I would really like anecdotal evidence, preferably supported by photos. Personally, all the beaches I went to in my youth have water at the same level. I appreciate there is erosion, as there is also the depositing of new material elsewhere.

What can you give personal testimony on?

PS Do you see and accept that when you take the science data on trust, your are actually taking a religious position? The position is that the science is right, even if it doesn't cohere with your own senses. That is faith!

feralimal··on Anarchy
Independent thinking, with no one as an authority over you and what you think, is a required first step.

If you are not able to accept what you see with your own eyes (your experience) and instead accept what others tell you (teachers, TV), you are not in authority of yourself.

feralimal··on Does Apple really log every app you run? A technical look
> But Apple simply has to find a more privacy-aware system designs for this problem which does not leak this kind of data without an opt-in and also does not impact application startup times. (revocation lists?)

The idea that you need apple to certify the developer over the software you run on your phone is nonsense though. You don't do that on your computer, so why do you need to be nannied on your phone?

feralimal··on Oh dear – Elon has 4 Covid tests, 2 positive, 2 negative. Is this science?
Fair point, but he does mention PCR in a later tweet: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1327305722384719872
feralimal··on Oh dear – Elon has 4 Covid tests, 2 positive, 2 negative. Is this science?
I believe Adam Curry on NoAgenda has been discussing how if you ramp up the PCR test cycles to 60, everything returns positive. I think this is what Elon is getting at.
feralimal··on Google knows where we are, and so do advertisers
I think the opposite ie that every nice place in the world is destroyed by a well functioning hierarchy. Say Romania, where you had lots of small agriculture - when they joined the EU, big agra moves in and as part of the agricultural policies, small farms are converted to big ones, that follow the worst agricultural practise. This is by design. Where you had unique expressions, once the system is in place, what you have is well-ordered people and Starbucks. It is based in fear. It is not our natural state.

Hierarchies are not transparent. If you are in a corporation, do you know what you boss is aiming for? What his boss's targets are? None of them are accountable. They would fire others in a sec if it was expedient for them. The system itself, makes people act daily like conmen, thieves. It turns people inside out - to take care of others is to fail financially - look at nursing.

Hopelessly naive is right. I don't care. I only have to answer to myself, and my heart and intuition. I don't want to be a part of the ever-increasing dystopia we are creating for ourselves. I judge for myself what is 'good' and act accordingly. I think that at the end of this experience we judge ourselves and our actions here. Our time here might not be all we experience. (Yes, I think the materialistic expression of our lives is a lie too.) I hope I am able to say I took the time to understand myself, to find out what's right, to have taken some actions in that direction. And I don't mean giving to so-called charitable organisations!

feralimal··on Google knows where we are, and so do advertisers
Those 'backward' countries are hardly untouched by 'democracy' though, are they?

What does it mean that a prison is quiet? Is it that prisoners love their subservience? Or that there are well armed guards. For NZ, it is certainly slave mindedness - the belief is the goodness of government and the Queen is strong.

feralimal··on Google knows where we are, and so do advertisers
I did go from 0-100. Sorry - but I'm glad I caught your interest.

If we were on a desert island, and I were to ask you to give me 40% of your income/produce and take out loans from me to buy your hut and donkey, you would rightly refuse. If I and 5 others where to do the same, you might consent, but you wouldn't think it was right. The system we have though - that no one asked for or signed into - is a system people actually think this is right!! And they will fight to maintain it. It is a slavery system, where because the criminals are so far away, unperceived by most, and tv and schooling (owned by those criminals) tells them it is right, and everyone else is going along with the insanity, well, we say 'I guess that it is right, it's what humans are' etc. Justifying the unjustifiable.

'Self-sovereignty' to me, is being able to say that you are responsible for yourself, and to mean it. Try it in the mirror! If you are unconvinced, you are not sovereign. This is not to say you need to lord it over others - far from it. It's that you treat yourself as an individual, and are responsible for yourself and your actions. You get rid of the cognitive dissonance as you reason things out. But you need to go all the way.

Accepting the authority of any other over your own experience and judgement, is to have made a grave error of personal judgement. (I don't mean refusing to accept the worthy advise of your mechanic over what to do with your car btw.) I mean being told something and ignoring your own reasoning and accepting theirs. To a reasonable person, it should be possible for someone to share evidence and allow you to make up your mind and get your agreement if what is requested is reasonable. If it is unreasonable you should be able to refuse. But our system is entirely unreasonable. If you are in the US, did you agree to the constitution, to be an American citizen? Were you - a free man under God - invited to join this club? The system is about manipulation and covert use of force and fear. It has an appeal - it is comforting (and easier) to think that someone else has this - but in fact, only you do.

'Might makes right' in this system (a system I think it has been in place for 100s of years). At some point those with the might want not to fight, or be hassled, or even known. 'They' set up a system to train those it has subjugated that this situation is right (education). No, education is not about improving those that go through its system - as you may have noticed. It is about making the men that suit the system and play the game.

Individually, people are lovely and cannot conceive of the breadth of the scam and lie that they are living. We are happy joyful creatures, but we have been turned inside out. And the loss of privacy is another example. They cannot conceive that education is 15 years of mind moulding, that the health industry is about making them unwell, that the media is about keeping them uninformed, that science is religion masquerading as reason, etc. But there it is. If you look and do your own research - and you have to do your own research - you will see what I mean.

All the best.

feralimal··on Google knows where we are, and so do advertisers
Did you ever wonder about the discrepancy in tech that occurred at that time the first iPhone appeared? We were all using desktops or fairly clunky laptops. Then, out of nowhere, we have touchscreens, cameras, maps, etc AND the power of a desktop machine, in a device that's 1/20th the size! It was such a staggering leap! I think phones were technology that was so far ahead of what we were prepared for, we had no means of defence.

With regards to the aims of Apple, Google et al - yes I think they wanted to spy on us from the start. It has always been about better governance of the masses. Corporation owners think they own us - everything we are provided with is only done with a view for them to apply greater governance of us. Historically, it would have been expedient to use stories (religions) to do this, then debt, and now technology.

Bringing us to the present, if you ask me, the virus we are apparently experiencing, is just a pretext. It is just another story, that leverages us into a technocracy. They want to boot up a technocratic system that we will all live in from cradle to grave, unaware and unable to do anything about our circumstances. This has been planned since the 1930's - IBM shared work space with Technocracy Inc as it was known then.

We are spending our time online, shopping online, isolated, dependent on corporations for the news, our food, intermediating our experiences, etc. We are sold on the future, Elon's neural lace, augmented reality, smart metering/cities, etc. I'm not joking when I say it seems to me that these plans are so progressed, and everyone is so on board, that the human experiment must surely come to an end soon. It will be a great reset, but we're not going to like it.

PS Here's a good article from 2016: https://www.technocracy.news/global-smart-grid-technocracys-...

feralimal··on Intriguing maps that reveal alternate histories
On maps, I find it surprising and hilarious that the UN has a flat earth map on its logo!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_the_United_Nations

feralimal··on [dead]
Thanks for the update
← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →