HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

feralimal

-15 karma · joined May 9, 2020

submissionscomments
feralimal··on A Stoic Philosopher in a Hanoi Prison: I am the captain of my soul
Ah I see, I said army not navy. Whatevs.
feralimal··on A Stoic Philosopher in a Hanoi Prison: I am the captain of my soul
I've explained one reason, in a comment above, fyi.
feralimal··on A Stoic Philosopher in a Hanoi Prison: I am the captain of my soul
No. Skepticism is refusing to believe in something until it has been shown to be true.

What commonly passes as skepticism is a very tame effort. To say accept 50% of the claims, rather than 100%. You should accept 0% of claims that you have not verified. This is also known as the scientific method. (But don't look to science to be upholding it...)

The elites govern us. They have always governed us. One of the methodologies is that is to sell us on stories from the cradle that allow them to operate in reality, while we are living in unsubstantiated stories.

When we take no action to verify, when we trust our experts, politicians, anyone apart from ourselves, when we accept the authority of another over our own experience, we are badly lost.

Do you recollect when it was going to be 2 weeks to flatten the curve? Do you think the curve will be flattened? Do we need to 'mask harder'? Get vaccinated? Why didn't we have cold vaccines previously? Do we need to isolate healthy people, is that how it works? The contradictions in the current narrative are impossible to resolve if you are a thinking person with authority over your own thinking.

McCain is clearly from the governance clique. His father was an admiral. He then does a dog and pony show in the intimidating country of 'Vietnam', and comes back into governance and plays his role. He is an actor. We get indications of this, eg the broken leg that changes legs! Here's the explanation:

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5113233/John-McCain...

He says:

"Finally on Thursday, McCain himself took to Twitter to put the conspiracy theories to rest. 'My left leg was doing extra work to compensate for the boot, so I'm giving it a break,' the senator tweeted. 'I still hate wearing this boot, but it won't slow us down from frying 7 turkeys today!'"

That explanation explains nothing. NOTHING. But the headline says it "solves the riddle of his moveable leg". Maybe you read it wrong? Perhaps you had better doubt yourself, and trust the experts! And then you have to read a load more soft spin and fluff about how wonderful man, what a wonderful family, etc, etc, and nothing about him being a criminal that should have spent most of his time in jail for being an enemy of humanity - being part of the governance system.

The reality unfortunately is that no one is checking anything, and that people's brains are turned off. Especially well educated brains. They have fully accepted the stories, and are better at filling in the blanks, rather than letting the evidence do the talking.

All the best.

feralimal··on A Stoic Philosopher in a Hanoi Prison: I am the captain of my soul
That's from the article!
feralimal··on Zeptoseconds: New world record in short time measurement
Whereas you believe it to be true.

Even though the odds are on my side. According to science!

feralimal··on A Stoic Philosopher in a Hanoi Prison: I am the captain of my soul
Stoicism, as a philosophy, is indeed personally valuable and an interesting way to view the world.

But no, I have little respect for this eulogy of a vice-admiral in the army. I expect that he is another faker, like John McCain, whose father was a full admiral. Were either of these characters even PoWs? I doubt it.

These people are not to be respected. They are our governors. They tell stories and lies. To manipulate us into thinking we deserve to be governed by them. And they like to portray themselves as heroes to be worshipped. All lies.

If we use some skepticism - which, I know we all profess to do - we don't know that any of this is true! Its not true because it says so in some online source.

All I can see is another soft-sell, soft-spin of some character, that in a more moral dimension, would likely have been sent to life imprisonment for crimes against humanity.

feralimal··on Zeptoseconds: New world record in short time measurement
No, I agree that not all science is not false.

But if you were a betting man, you would bet on this being false, seeing as 70% of studies cannot be reproduced.

And this is a study that no one else can even hope to reproduce. Its just a claim.

And there is the comedy 'gag' of 24-7. Ie, the time they measured was all the the time. Hilarious.

feralimal··on Zeptoseconds: New world record in short time measurement
You should take a look at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why_Most_Published_Research_Fi...
feralimal··on Zeptoseconds: New world record in short time measurement
"They measured how long it takes for a photon to cross a hydrogen molecule: about 247 zeptoseconds for the average bond length of the molecule."

24-7? Say no more.

feralimal··on Cat Gap
"All modern carnivorans, including cats, evolved from miacoids, which existed from approximately 66 to 33 million years ago."

Say no more.

feralimal··on Animation of how bridges were built in Central Europe in the Middle Ages [video]
That's one part of it. But where is this claim even from? Where are the sources?
feralimal··on The two vaccines are called Ambush and Triumph. Are we at war?
These names have a strong militaristic naming.

The first is called 'ambush', to be followed 28 days later by 'triumph'.

Is it surprising to see that the vaccination is taking this sort of warlike approach? Who are we at war with? As the virus can't hear us.... is it the people whom the vaccine is purported to help?

Very odd, no?

feralimal··on Animation of how bridges were built in Central Europe in the Middle Ages [video]
My Czech is not the best, if I'm honest...

So, your reading is that its a hyposthesis by some astronomer. And that someone chronicled the year construction started.

If you are able to provide sources for those, that would be interesting!

Cheers

feralimal··on Animation of how bridges were built in Central Europe in the Middle Ages [video]
In the book, it says:

"Charles BridgeAmong the best-known architectural features of Prague is Charles Bridge (Karl¿v most). Known as PragueBridge until 1870, it spans the Vltava River and the Kampa Island between the Lesser Town and the OldTown. It is one of the oldest stone bridges in Europe and the second oldest in the republic (the oldest inPísek, Bohemia, was built in the thirteenth century).The first bridge crossing the Vltava in Prague was wooden anddated from the tenth century. The Judith stone bridge, built 1158–1160, spanned the river until a disastrous floodwashed it away in 1342. Charles IV commissioned Petr Parlérˇ to erect a new bridge; being somewhat superstitious,the king broke ground for the bridge in 1357 on 9 July at 5:31 A.M., thus creating a date and time that, if given com-pletely in numbers, is a perfect palindrome: 1–3–5–7–9–7–5–3–1.

The sandstone bridge, stretching 516 meters with sixteen arches, was completed in 1402.Thirty statues adorn thebridge (the originals for most are in the Lapidarium of the National Museum). In 1683 Charles Bridge received itsfirst baroque sculpture, that of St. John Nepomuk, the work of Matthias Rauchmüller and Jan Brokoff. The bronzerelief at the base of the statue depicts the false legend that Jan Nepomuk would not tell Václav IV the secrets of thequeen’s confession, so Václav IV had him cast into the Vltava from the bridge (a bronze cross in the bridge parapetmarks the alleged spot). Other baroque masters who sculpted works for the bridge included Ferdinand MaximiliánBrokoff, Michal Josef Brokoff, and Matyá≥Bernard Braun. In the classical era, Josef Max, Emanuel Max, and otherssculpted several statues. Karel Dvorˇák completed the most recent statue, that of the missionaries Cyril and Method-ius, in 1938.

On the Lesser Town side of the bridge are two towers.The first is a remnant of the Judith Bridge that was rebuiltin 1591. The taller Gothic tower was completed in 1464, and a Gothic gateway links the two towers. On the OldTown side of the bridge stands a single Gothic tower decorated with saints, the builders, and skillfully executed rep-resentations of Charles IV and his son,Václav IV. Also embellishing the tower are the coats of arms of the Bohemiankingdom.The roof is the design of Josef Mocker from the late nineteenth century. A portion of the Old Town Towerfacade and the bridge was damaged during a Swedish bombardment in 1648."

Ok - so now, I can see where the wiki claim is from. But, where is this source in the history book from?

My problem is that this is presented as true, but I want to know where the sources are. The book "EASTERN EUROPE" by RICHARD FRUCHT, was written in 2005. Obviously we are not dealing with a primary or secondary source. But what is the source Frucht is using? Is it just a story Frucht or someone else made up? We don't know.

feralimal··on Animation of how bridges were built in Central Europe in the Middle Ages [video]
Actually, if you find a better version of that book than the one on archive.org, you can see this info on page 251. I'm just looking now... Not sure why this isn't found in archive.org's search.
feralimal··on Animation of how bridges were built in Central Europe in the Middle Ages [video]
Nice animation, but I bear in mind that stuff that is presented like this is really just hearsay - we don't really know that it was built as presented. It could well have been built as shown - its a plausible hypothesis. But it is also plausible that the bridges were only built in the 18th century. Or maybe they were built 100's of years earlier.

With any historical claims, we should have access to the source to be able to confirm.

On the wiki page that was posted we read:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Bridge

"Throughout its history, Charles Bridge has suffered several disasters and witnessed many historic events. Czech legend has it that construction began on Charles Bridge at 5:31am on 9 July 1357 with the first stone being laid by Charles IV himself. This exact time was very important to the Holy Roman Emperor because he was a strong believer in numerology and felt that this specific time, which formed a palindrome (1357 9, 7 5:31), was a numerical bridge, and would imbue Charles Bridge with additional strength.[4]"

Where 4 is:

"Frucht, Richard (2005). Eastern Europe : an introduction to the people, lands, and culture. 1. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO. pp. 251. ISBN 9781576078013."

https://archive.org/details/easterneuropeint0000unse/page/25...

When you search that book on archive.org though, there are no references to "1357", "5:31", "numerology". There is a single reference to "numerical" but this relates to 1944.

So we have a paragraph in wiki, that has some very specific information, that it claims is from a book that doesn't seem to contain that info.

This is to say that 'we' don't know anything about this bridge - the sources do not check out.

I was hoping to get a little further than this. I wanted to track the primary or secondary source for this claim about the bridge build date. But I couldn't even get that far.

What should one conclude, when the detailed information being provided does not check (or should that 'Czech') out?

feralimal··on Why are the noses broken on Egyptian statues?
At a glance, the black ones appear to be made of granite - this is very tough! You might wonder how they were ever able to make such perfect representations with very hard material 3000+ years ago. And to then polish them so well that the polish still looks good after all this time, as on the picture at the top of that article.

However (and whenever) they were made, once made, these are hard and most definitely do NOT break accidentally. Well, not so many of them as that, anyway. If it is granite, I think you could drop a statue like that and it would break your wood or marble floor, rather than break off accidentally.

feralimal··on Ask HN: Why are there no open source 2d printers?
Or washing machines, dishwashers, cars or even planes?

I'm afraid the answer is due to the fact that we live under a corporatocracy, and that this is the way things roll round here!

Good luck with anyone who is trying to get a open source version of whatever out there. Unfortunately, for one reason or another, I suspect it won't work out, but I have my fingers crossed for you!

feralimal··on Why are the noses broken on Egyptian statues?
This is something I've noticed on a lot of older statues. Not just Egyptian ones.

This is pretty far from the standard narrative, but I think something happened 300 years ago. A different group moved in, and destroyed the more beautiful creations of the older group. Where there were statues on churches, these were replaced with gargoyles.

I think the nose destruction you raise is a part of that - its a simple way to 'uglify' a thing of beauty. Those Egyptian statues are representation of people that were in perfect proportions and display idealised geometry.

https://www.emotions.64g.ru/prof3/pro04en.htm

So, I think they were beautiful and destroyed intentionally by whoever conquered or moved in over the preceding group.

feralimal··on YouTube bans coronavirus vaccine misinformation
Well done youtube!! About time!

We should realise by now that Google, youtube, facebook and apple really DO have the truth! They studied truth hard, and know it! Why others don't know the truth is their problem.

Its definitely not the case that the FAANG companies are espousing a self-serving opinion, nor that they are driving a politically divisive agenda for their benefit. Its just not that!

So sorry - FAANG have the Truth, and those who get banned deserved it! And if you know what's good for you, you'd better learn the truth too and quick!

feralimal··on PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single terrorist attack
Its only a huge waste of time and money, if you believe the purported justification - that it was to stop terrorist attacks.

If you believe it was part of the new governance apparatus, I think you would consider it an unmitigated success.

feralimal··on German ship completes historic Arctic expedition
I know nothing about climate depot. But I think the studies it is citing are valid, no?
feralimal··on German ship completes historic Arctic expedition
But numbers are increasing!

https://www.climatedepot.com/2019/03/05/study-polar-bear-num...

So, don't worry!

feralimal··on AT&T is selling your phone calls and text messages to marketers, how to opt out
Meta-data isn't count! It isn't really data. It just provides a graph of everyone you interact with. What's the problem?

And anyway, phone companies have to make a buck.. Its not like we're paying them for the service!

feralimal··on Why the Arabic world turned away from science (2011)
That you think that video is proof of water being h2o, says all I need to know about what you think of the scientific method!
feralimal··on Why the Arabic world turned away from science (2011)
Society doesn't have knowledge. Libraries and universities do not have knowledge. Books do not have knowledge. Those are inanimate objects or concepts. They are not living men and women.

The only place knowledge resides in the minds of individual people.

In my view, you are making a category error to subsume your individual understanding, that no one else can access, into some concept called 'society'. There is no hive mind, no borg, no tangible collective consciousness. There are conceptual artefacts we all interact with, and all interpret in similar ways in our individual consciousness. We all know what a 'tree' is for example. These are common linguistic named 'tokens' that we use to interact with others. I say 'tree' and you understand me. But the concept of 'tree' only exists in our minds.

We discuss things in the objective world with others and that use concepts such as 'society' to describe part of that objective world. Our exchange of concepts does not make those concepts real in themselves. They are only real or animated in the mind of an individual - in you or I. They have no life of their own.

To treat 'society' as a real thing - as a sort of ultra-human - is to mistake the map for the terrain. On a map a group of people may be interpreted as a 'collection' or a 'society'. But that is just a concept to navigate the map at a certain resolution. The 'society' concept only resides in the mind of the individual looking at the map - its not actually a real thing. This can be confirmed as other individuals can use a different mental maps to successfully navigate the terrain - eg they may see a collection of individuals as a collection of individuals.

feralimal··on Why the Arabic world turned away from science (2011)
We. The royal 'we'. Did we? What exactly was your part in this? Did we watch it on a video?
feralimal··on Why the Arabic world turned away from science (2011)
Were you born yesterday? :)

Knowledge is certain. If there is a possibility that some claim could be wrong, it is only a hypothesis. And that's perfectly fine. Call that knowledge if you like, but you are over-stating your case. Lying in fact.

The reality is that we have far less knowledge than we think. We may be aware of lots of hypotheses, we can have knowledge of hypotheses. But this is not knowledge of the thing being hypothesised about.

You think you have knowledge when you don't. And I say, if you are unaware of your ignorance, and in fact erroneously believe yourself to be knowledgeable, you are in a state worse than ignorance. You only have beliefs, but you think they are knowledge. This is to say, you are guilty of magical thinking. And that is the essence of religion.

Hence why I say, religion and science are the same thing at core - its all belief. Adherents to each believe they have knowledge, but this belief is without proof. In a way scientists are worse as they are convinced they do have the truth, and are determined to righteously inflict their truths on everyone else! They are far from humble. Its pretty irritating!

All the best.

feralimal··on Why the Arabic world turned away from science (2011)
I watched it.

Issues I have with the video you provided. I can't believe that this passes muster with you as a scientist.

I can't help but notice the gas he creates at first is white in colour. In the second the gas is clear in colour. Both white and colourless gas are the same apparently. The difference in colour is not explained.

In the second experiment, Brian Cox says he is using hydrogen + AIR (not oxygen). Air is apparently 78% nitrogen, 21% oxygen, and argon + trace gases are the rest. This is to say, this is not mixing oxygen + hydrogen. So this experiment is NOT what I was asking evidence of.

Finally, he creates an explosive pop and some condensation appears on the glass jar. Let's accept that this liquid is water. What's to say that the water isn't simply water that was already in vapour form in the air that condensed against the glass?

And why do we need flame to ignite the gases? Is it really true that fire creates water? Is that a joke?

And do we really think that the ratio of 2 particle of hydrogen to 1 of oxygen was met? It was hardly a rigorous measurement, was it?

Overall, no, I did not see and experiment where pure hydrogen and pure oxygen where combined to make water. Do you think you did? To me, its all inference, hearsay and claim.

If this is all the evidence you need, yes, I think your threshold is too low.

feralimal··on Why the Arabic world turned away from science (2011)
Knowledge IS a binary thing.

Either it is coherent with reality or it is not.

← PreviousPage 8 of 14Next →