HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

fictioncircle

335 karma · joined January 28, 2017

submissionscomments
fictioncircle··on Record low housing inventory is 'freaking us out' says Redfin CEO
Most of which is not true for the average homeowner that isn't investing as they are immune to capital gains and income tax due to the homeowner exclusion.

So they eat ~8% (tops).

Landlords have to buy and hold because they eat the taxes.

Redfin caters primarily to homeowners so you aren't really their target market.

fictioncircle··on Record low housing inventory is 'freaking us out' says Redfin CEO
Its not difficult if you buy something similar size to what you are renting and hold it for 5+ years.

The tax credits, inflation working in your favor (instead of against) alone is generally enough to cover the fee after 5 years.

fictioncircle··on Ask HN: How to leave a startup when you own a third of it?
> I'm leaving a startup I founded due to disagreements over team/strategy. I worked on it for about 16 months.

> Is it reasonable for me to keep 10% of it. - They think it's way too much.

33% over a 48 month vesting schedule is:

16/48*.33 is 11%.

Option A) Ask for 11% of the money raised, 11% of the company, or some combination thereof. (i.e. Keep 5% and sell them 6% for ~$30k)

Option B) Dilute you over time as the company grows.

A is about as low as its reasonable for them to offer you. If they aren't willing to meet that bar, just hold on to the full amount you are entitled until they agree.

fictioncircle··on Nearly 1 in 3 drugs have a significant safety issue after FDA approval
Probably worth keeping in mind that many SSDI requests are denied and the process can take 18 months.

So pretty much everyone needs an 18 months of savings + COBRA costs. Even then its quite likely not enough unfortunately.

fictioncircle··on Nearly 1 in 3 drugs have a significant safety issue after FDA approval
> If an insurance company can "remove" you when you become unhealthy, then they weren't providing insurance in the first place.

Yup, hence Obamacare with mandatory enrollment and the removal of all the tools they used to it. Then people complain about prices going up. :/

fictioncircle··on Nearly 1 in 3 drugs have a significant safety issue after FDA approval
> Insurance companies are the most aligned with your wellness financially. They want as many healthy people to pay in as possible.

That is only true if they are forced to accept people blindly and without screening.

Otherwise, they simply create a screening process centered around removing unhealthy people and preventing unhealthy people from enrolling.

fictioncircle··on Nearly 1 in 3 drugs have a significant safety issue after FDA approval
https://www.bio.org/sites/default/files/Clinical%20Developme...

> A more interesting question would be how many would have a significant safety issue without FDA approval.

tl;dr

> FDA approval (LOA) reveals that only 9.6% (n=9,985) of drug development programs successfully make it to market

The FDA strikes a good balance I think. Its never going to be 100% successful but it does screen out many dangerous drugs.

fictioncircle··on Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclose password to police
> No, it is not.

Then your assertion they are pro-terrorist doesn't make any sense.

Helping to free people who were tortured at some point during their captivity isn't the same as being "pro-terrorist".

Being a civil rights group that opposes mistreatment of prisoners is going to lead to you representing or seeking to free unsavory people on the basis of their mistreatment (rather than their innocence).

fictioncircle··on Basic Income in a Just Society
It's not so ppl can't work. No one wants to live on $10k in the US.

Even LeanFIRE types want $20k/year.

fictioncircle··on Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclose password to police
> It's a lot more than "simply pro-Islam" as you say http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/1098105....

So your argument is torture is OK because they are convicted terrorists?

Or that the US military is pro-Terrorist?

> For example, Cage is animated about the case of Aafia Siddiqui, jailed for 86 years in the US for attempting to murder US officials in Afghanistan and assaulting those who tried to stop her. Siddiqui had wide-ranging links to al-Qaeda and was married to a key plotter behind the 9/11 attacks. At the beginning of her trial she said that jurors should be "subject to genetic testing" to see if they were Zionist or Israeli. She is no terror suspect – her guilt was proved in a court of law. Yet Cage’s profile on Siddiqui – which misses literally all this out – says it has "dedicated itself" to freeing her.

> Aafia Siddiqui and her three children were kidnapped from the streets of Karachi in March 2003. Since then they have been subjected to enforced disappearances, torture and ill-treatment beyond measure. Cageprisoners has dedicated itself to campaigning for Aafia and her family in order to help secure their release and expose those involved in their abuse.

> Others that Cage support include Djamel Beghal, who, following allegations of a plot to blow up the US embassy in Paris, was jailed in France in 2005 for "belonging to a criminal association in relation to preparing an act of terrorism"; and Nizar Trabelsi, convicted in Belgium as part of an al-Qaeda plot to carry out a suicide attack against a military base there holding US soldiers.

> Le Point reported that the Emirati police had been sharing information with the French authorities since the beginning of August 2001. Questions being asked of Beghal confirmed for him that it was the French who were feeding information to the Emirati police during his torture and abuse.

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2010/10/20/al-qaeda-terror-leader-...

> Anwar Al-Awlaki may be the first American on the CIA's kill or capture list, but he was also a lunch guest of military brass at the Pentagon within months of the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks, Fox News has learned.

fictioncircle··on Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclose password to police
> It's worth pointing out that while some outlets (Guardian etc) report it as just another NGO, Cage is an Islamist pressure group.

Alright, so all the Christian pressure groups should get that kind of treatment in your view then?

If not, given CAGE isn't pro-terrorist and is simply pro-Islam, you even pointing that out is...really questionable judgment on your part.

fictioncircle··on Noncompete Clauses: Signing Away the Right to Get a New Job
> Not joking btw. It's rather amazing that employers who expect rational, logical decision making on the job want applicants to suspend their reasoning and good judgment when it comes to negotiating compensation and employment terms.

Which is when you move on to the next employer if at all possible.

fictioncircle··on Why Are Economists Giving Piketty the Cold Shoulder?
> But we don't have a solution to the problem of global capital chasing efficiency globally, and thereby hollowing out the middle of the income distribution in Western economies.

It isn't a solvable problem, honestly, is the big secret no one really wants to admit.

Capitalism, by its nature, is going to chase efficiency globally regardless of what you do to prevent it. Technology, over time, is going to make this worse because it is easier to avoid inconvenient regulations by operating out of "friendly" countries as well as enabling automation that really only leaves "services" that pays very little for many people who used to have better options.

The truth is the Middle Class is going to shrink no matter what you do and you are going to basically end up with a very large gap of people making 6 figures (who can afford to hire people to handle things for them) and less skilled people who will be reduced to jobs servicing them that barely pay above minimum wage.

People don't like "income redistribution" but that is the only way to actually solve the problem long term. It needs to be done in a way that working is still incentived but where those relatively low paying service jobs + the redistribution leaves people with the housing, food, and health care they need.

The reality is, the bottom 50% in most countries need about 20% of the national income to be happy...and in the US they are getting about 12%.

The problem is, right now, that is politically impossible outside of a handful of European countries.

fictioncircle··on Solar Roof
> Houses need roofs that last. Why put a new roof on every 15-20 years if you can put one on that lasts the lifetime of the house?

Please don't seriously suggest Tesla's solar roof will last the lifetime of a house to people.

The real warranty is 30 years for power and weatherization.

Its misleading marketing speak (at best).

https://www.tesla.com/solarroof#order

> Weatherization means that there will be no water leaks or other weather intrusions during the 30 year warranty period that result from our installation.

It will almost certainly require replacing and/or serious repair long before the "lifetime of the house" is up.

fictioncircle··on Strong beliefs, loosely held
Tbpfh, that is only true for people of above average ability to remain calm in the face of failure.

I've seen many, many people make dumb decision after dumb decision despite having all the facts because of emotions.

fictioncircle··on Solar Roof
> EDIT: That's sort of the kicker. A regular roof does not get a 30% federal tax credit (plus possible state incentives), nor does it produce power for 30+ years, nor does it have a lifetime warranty. If you can obtain low cost financing, you almost always come out ahead.

Maximizing retirement savings is still likely more cost effective than this roof for most people and I doubt many people in the US are putting away $24k/year.

The only way I'd see this is as viable is below inflation interest and people showing they can sell the houses for the full value of the Tesla roof.

fictioncircle··on Solar Roof
That sounds about right to me.

A roof that exceeds 10% of the purchase price is likely to push the house outside of the price range of buyers in the target market.

I know a friend of mine (who has a solar system, not quite the same) but basically got almost nothing for it. The aesthetics of a "Solar Roof" is better but I don't see it raising the value of the house by more than 10%.

I used their calculator using the estimates when I had my roof done last time, and it is just not economically feasible.

$60k roof vs. $6k roof.

Net of $12k savings over 30 years.

$60k over 30 years (adjusting for inflation in conservative investments) is easily going to hit $180k.

fictioncircle··on President Trump Dismisses FBI Director Comey
Sorry I quoted the wrong bit. He was actually fired.

> ut the stubborn Republican FBI Director refused to go voluntarily, finally provoking Bill Clinton to telephone Mr. Sessions on July 20, 1993. The President called twice. The first call was to tell the Director he was fired. The second was to tell the Director it was effective immediately. That’s cold, man.

fictioncircle··on President Trump Dismisses FBI Director Comey
He was pressured by Trump partisans in the FBI and elsewhere (in accordance with his obligations) to release that and Obama blocked him from writing an Op-ed about Trump before the election.

I think he genuinely tried to stay neutral but the GOP partisans threatened to leak stuff so he tried to do damage control ineffectually.

http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2017/04/report-obama-re...

> Report: Obama Rejected Comey Op-Ed on Russia’s Election Meddling

http://www.newsweek.com/fbi-reviewing-more-clinton-emails-51...

> The truth is Comey didn’t have a choice. Because the new information followed his sworn testimony about the case, Comey was obligated by Department of Justice rules to keep the relevant committees apprised.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-10-28/leaked-memo-james-c...

> Now, it is the democrats turn to rage at Comey and the FBI, although Comey likely did not have much choice: had he kept the information secret, it certainly would have leaked as we predicted; as such his best recourse was to come clean, although many have speculated about the cryptic nature of the disclosure.

http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/02/james-comey-fbi-direc...

> The story broke in the Daily Mail on September 21, and the F.B.I. seized the laptop on October 3. Within a couple of days, the New York F.B.I. agents, who had a warrant to look only at Weiner-related information, knew there were Clinton e-mails on the laptop, and the prosecutors in D.C. were informed.

> Often, a retired agent says, those in the field are suspicious of Washington. “Dreamland,” they called it in his day, because they believed those who weren’t on the ground investigating cases were clueless. “[Agents] out in the field never want to give a case to D.C., because they believe headquarters is a hindrance to their investigations,” says the agent, who also notes there is a paranoia that politics might interfere at headquarters. New York has an especially dim view of Washington and a reputation for fierce independence. “There is a renegade quality to the New York F.B.I.,” says a former prosecutor, which, he claims, can take the form of agents leaking to the press to advance their own interests or to influence an investigation. “New York leaks like a sieve,” concurs another former prosecutor

> Comey chose Washington because he wanted to be close enough to get daily updates, according to CNN, but he may also have been worried about leaks from New York. A former D.O.J. official says that, as early as 2015, a rumor was floating around that the F.B.I. agents in New York were cracking jokes about seeing Hillary Clinton in handcuffs. “It was widely understood that there was a faction in that office that couldn’t stand her and was out to get her,” this person says.

fictioncircle··on President Trump Dismisses FBI Director Comey
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2016/10/31/1589230/-Only-One-U...

> When Bill Clinton took office in January , 1993, his FBI Director was William S. Sessions, serving an appointment made by Ronald Reagan at the time of the Iran-Contra affair. Making it clear that the new President did not want the Republican FBI Director in his Administration, Clinton’s newly appointed Attorney General, Janet Reno, quietly pressured Mr. Sessions to resign.

fictioncircle··on Wikimedia Foundation spending
I've seen that kind of diaspora before in internet forums and ran some for awhile based on that principle.

It does work more or less in that case. I'm not 1000% sure it'll work with Wikipedia but in the case I was personally involved in it did.

fictioncircle··on Wikimedia Foundation spending
> No one outside of WMF is downloading and storing the dumps they provide to the public?

No one who is actively marketing and encouraging contributions on a scale people are aware of them.

If they existed, you'd have told me who they were. ;)

Simply storing the data isn't enough, you'd need to maintain it and make it publicly available as a mirror of the site and encouraging people to interact so you have a community to work with in the event of Wikipedia's failure.

I guess my point is the OP should be doing that instead of bitching.

fictioncircle··on Wikimedia Foundation spending
> I imagine the cost of the disorganization or loss of volunteer contribution effort in the splintering of WP spinoffs/mirrors is orders of magnitude larger than load offset from mirroring.

I'm sure it would be but at the end of the day I'm not sure that would be, ultimately, bad if a monolithic entity failed because of mismanagement.

Nothing stops them from sharing information/pages or linking to each other.

fictioncircle··on Wikimedia Foundation spending
Frankly, the problem with this Op Ed is there is a very simple solution available to anyone who is concerned about a "doomsday" scenario for Wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Database_download#Wh...

Mirror it and make it available read-only until that day comes as a separate "disaster recovery" organization and raise the minimal funding required for that function (1 employee + 1 dedicated server) would be sufficient to the task. More if you wanted to make it usable but at that point, you aren't really a dumb mirror.

> pages-articles.xml.bz2 – Current revisions only, no talk or user pages; this is probably what you want, and is approximately 13 GB compressed (expands to over 58 GB when uncompressed).

You just need to mirror this regularly and maintain a reasonable depth of the backup. (Say, once a month for the past 12 months)

Then, whenever this terrible event destroys Wikipedia you are on the clear due to you operating under the past licenses for the data and people will need a new place to go if Wikipedia is genuinely destroyed.

fictioncircle··on Wikimedia Foundation spending
The OP is complaining about personnel and fundraising costs rather than actual hosting costs.
fictioncircle··on Wikimedia Foundation spending
> How true are his statements? I seriously don't know enough about the WMF or the fiscal policies in place to make even a guess.

Its true in the sense any forecast is true.

WMF operated in line with its projections, however, so its a question of differing strategic goals b/t the author and the WMF rather than a true "wrong" or "right".

If you FIND for "Planned spending" you'll find a useful table that largely explains the numbers are in line with the planned budgets.

fictioncircle··on [dead]
https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/fbi-hacked-over-8...

Its 2016 news.

fictioncircle··on Thousands of Veterans Want to Learn to Code But Can’t
> Can the applicant draw on knowledge of complexity to distill their Google search? Without that types of test your answer is "hopefully."

It isn't difficult to structure a complex question that requires research and have the answer you claim is impossible to find.

> That's why Google, FB, etc start with whiteboard tests. Anyone can search and implement.

I'm sure that is what you believe but that doesn't make it true.

> 2) and 4) and 5) are strawmen. It is -in fact- possible to understand the fundamentals and look things up.

I've never met an engineer (or any professional implementing complex processes) who simultaneously grasped the fundamentals of all areas where they needed to possess competence from memory. (Yes, that includes myself in case you are wondering.)

fictioncircle··on Handling bot attacks against a Tor hidden service
Owasp presentations, Blackhat presentations, etc. usually give you a general idea of what people are seeing and then you research the specific attack(s) in depth. This isn't the sort of thing you can commit to memory.

https://www.owasp.org/images/c/c9/Benelux_day_20161125_G_Pel...

fictioncircle··on Thousands of Veterans Want to Learn to Code But Can’t
> Exactly my point. Rarely is there one "correct" implementation.

For any given problem asked in such interviews there is certainly one correct implementation and if you believe otherwise you are not providing sufficient information to answer such a question.

> Understanding the choice you make and can support is the point of coding interviews. That's why they're so often done in pseudocode and/or on the whiteboard. > If you can look stuff up you're not demonstrating a knowledge of the fundamentals. If you don't understand complexity and optimization, you will make mistakes even if you can look stuff up later. > That's why these companies do these.

Honestly? This is part of the rant I was trying to avoid.

1) I've met developers that claim SHA-1 is a secure choice in 2017 and make other facepalm worthy claims that 5 minutes of research would have told them was a bad idea.

2) We've fired quite a few people who believe as you do precisely because they are so convinced they understand the fundamentals they don't look things up and make costly mistakes.

3) I've met accountants who can't correctly handle a 4-4-5 calendar that is integral to their jobs without looking things up. Similarly, I've met ones like you that genuinely believe they've memorized the "fundamentals" and repeatedly failed waste thousands of dollars.

4) I honestly believe anyone who refuses to look things up to double check is fundamentally incompetent. We all make mistakes and the only way to appropriately minimize them is to double check (i.e look things up) before hand and have someone else review it afterward.

5) I genuinely do not want to work with anyone who does not do #4. Ever. The sheer number of times they've attempted to shift blame onto other people before they were fired is simply not worth the hassle.

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →