HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

finder83

471 karma · joined October 13, 2011

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/finder; my proof: https://keybase.io/finder/sigs/fSPF_LrUf1_rF9MuAwNM6rQvSfSMmOwuCh7UAGv5pQw ]
submissionscomments
finder83··on Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her consent
Thanks for correcting me, I was completely off on that! I realized after your post that I was thinking of transubstantiation instead of sacrament/ordinance. I'm Baptist and both in the 1689 confession [1] and the baptist faith and message 2000 [2] it's considered an ordinance, so most southern baptist churches to my knowledge consider it an ordinance, even those that are reformed-leaning. There are also other non-mainline denominations, probably mostly non-reformed, where it's usually an ordinance, such as Pentecostalism.

My confusion was that I was equating transubstantiation with it being a sacrament...so to my knowledge only Anglicans have preserved full transubstantiation (with others having some mixture of Christ being present)

[1] https://www.arbca.com/1689-chapter30 [2] https://bfm.sbc.net/bfm2000/#vii

I think it's safe to say that in almost all protestant denominations, the Eucharist is not a means of salvation though. I would hope that all would say salvation is through grace alone through faith alone. Let me know if you disagree though, I'd be curious of exceptions.

finder83··on Woman ‘dehumanised’ by viral TikTok filmed without her consent
There may be some overlap in some denominations I'm not aware of, but as far as the Eucharist is concerned, it's largely only a Catholic thing. In Catholicism, the first Eucharist has a particular significance as Christ/the Spirit dwelling within you. In Protestantism, it's only an ordinance, so is only a representation/ritual/tradition. There is often a component of confessing sins privately before partaking though, but the "Lord's Supper" (as it's called by most protestant denominations) is not a means of grace or sacrament in most protestant denominations. By "means of grace", I mean that taking the Lord's Supper does not lead to salvation or impart God's grace or anything else. It's purely symbolic in probably 95% of Protestantism. In the other 5% of orthodox Protestantism, it's not just symbolic, but is not a means of salvation/grace. In Catholicism (to my understanding of not being Catholic but studying it in a protestant seminary), it is considered a means of grace and imparts some form or measure of grace for salvation.

In all of Christianity though, there is an understanding that our sin is a failure to live up to God's holiness and standards, and that in Protestantism one of the pillars (5 solas) is that it is only through his grace, mercy, and love for us that Jesus came to die, and that our salvation is due to his grace alone and not something individually inherent in ourselves that makes us worthy.

I'm hedging all of that with the fact that there's a lot of religions/denominations/cults that call themselves "Christian", and many believe very different things.

finder83··on How I clean my glasses
Longer hair I find adds a lot to glasses getting dirty, also windy conditions with dirt blowing in the air
finder83··on Plasticity Is CAD for Artists
That was exactly my thought. I've tried to use fusion/freecad/etc for woodworking, but this looks amazing for it. But I'd like to set some basic dimensional parameters
finder83··on Epic Games acquires Bandcamp
This is my guess as well. Pretty much every Epic acquisition is for Unreal.
finder83··on AirPods don't “just work”
That's all part of the Airpods experience for me. Randomly have to reinsert into the case to get both earbuds working, devices I've connected to won't work if I've connected more devices, if I reboot from Linux to windows I have to drop them and re-pair them (I assume they pair based on a device id?), sometimes they don't charge but it's impossible to tell because when I open them it just shows yellow. Maybe it's because I have the first gen and no apple devices, but I really don't care for them.

My wife's soundcores work great.

My Bose over-ear are a much better experience.

finder83··on Fans pour funding into ‘The Chosen’
Agreed! Matthew is such a great character. I relate a lot with him too. I get the same feeling watching the character as I do reading the book of Matthew, which makes me appreciate the gospel even more.
finder83··on Movie dialogue has gotten more difficult to understand
Tenet was just unintelligible; we ended up just turning it off. It had nothing to do with masks (we couldn't understand the non-masked sections either). It was purely sound mixing and a bad call from Nolan.

I won't be seeing another Nolan film until he changes his mind on the importance of voice quality, as I like to enjoy movies and not strain to have any idea what is going on. His choices in sound quality and mixing completely breaks any sense of immersion for me...if they were outstanding plot-wise I would possibly struggle through. But without that sense of immersion, they're just not worth watching imho, as his films are all about the immersion factor.

finder83··on Why Lisp?
The repl in Common Lisp is a persistent image that's actually running the program you're working on. You can inject functions, packages, change packages, debug, etc, all directly from the environment running the web server without restarting. It's more interactive development combined with hot reloading as opposed to a repl from other languages (though it does have a repl as well)
finder83··on Why Lisp?
I feel like if you considered an average developer most people are writing API-like services that talk to a database and a few various APIs, payments, email, notification services, etc. ML is kind of a niche area where Python definitely excels and almost stands alone, but web frameworks are a dime a dozen, and every language pretty much has a postgres or mongo client.

"Much of anything complex" probably wouldn't hold true for most developers...I mean, it's all complex given technology, but 99% glue code that can be written in anything. That's generally true for me at least.

I have been bitten by lack of libraries for things like Cassandra in the past and switched languages because of it, but that's the exception and not the norm for me, and you really have to choose the right language for some projects. Or have some kind of architecture where you can have different parts in different languages.

finder83··on Write thin to write fast
I have an irrational hatred of columns. My master's degree reading includes many articles in journals that use columns, and pieces from the 1800s which are in columns, and I almost always feel anxiety with opening them for the first time. I felt that same anxiety for this website.

I think part of the reason is that actually scrolling a page with columns is a pain if you are zoomed in to make the text legible. You can't just scroll one direction on a tablet, you have to scroll down then back up and slightly over, scroll down again, then back up, etc. Sometimes you lose your place and have to zoom out to find what column you were previously on. Even then if I have the choice between a print book with columns and without (such as the Bible), I will always choose without.

finder83··on Making Emacs Popular Again (2020)
I do need to try nvim again, I'm sure there's a lot of new amazing plugins.
finder83··on Making Emacs Popular Again (2020)
I use Emacs (with Evil) daily, and despite having tried to move to other editors I'm locked into Emacs. Not so much because of the functionality of Emacs itself but because of plugins...

First, Emacs has the best Vim compatibility I've seen outside of Vim itself. Visual Studio is probably "good enough" for me on this with the vim plugin, but that 5% difference in compatibility makes a difference in practice.

But the largest reason I can't get away from Emacs is Ivy/Counsel. Being able to fuzzy search on the current file or entire project, see results, jump around to each one to see context, make changes to the results in an occur buffer to selectively mass edit search results...all of that I just haven't found a replacement for. Search/replace just doesn't cut it.

So effectively if I move to another editor, my code navigation time increases by 5-10x. Things like better autocomplete might fill that gap, but just even understanding how things go together is so much more difficult when you're fighting with your editor.

Add on other things like org-roam, buffer fuzzy searching in Ivy, fasd tie-in, the customization options, etc, and Emacs is just an amazing experience. There are definitely things I would change, like inline debugging (which I use VS Code for instead), setting up languages and autocomplete, etc. Getting things just right takes a long time for a new language.

finder83··on Show HN: I built a CNC-machine from scratch, using 40x 3D-printed parts
I read it as "40 individual 3D printed parts."
finder83··on Differences with other Lisps
All of the features mentioned seemed to be in favor of Clojure, like it doesn't mention the lack of CLOS and conditions/restarts, which were both major eye openers for me in learning Common Lisp. Just a personal point, I much prefer macros in CL as well.

There are parts of Clojure I like, such as the data structures and de-structuring. Maybe it was primarily the JVM, but I just couldn't get into Clojure...it doesn't give the same feeling as working in CL. I really wanted to like it though.

I do wish that someone would take some of the modern data structure ideas and backport them to Common Lisp (as a new lisp obviously). The historical cruft in lisp and lack a strong modern standard library are major reasons I don't play with it day-to-day.

finder83··on Node-RED: Low-code programming for event-driven applications
I didn't dislike node red, but it didn't really fit my use case well. I wanted to use it as a REST service to write APIs for clients to use to generate reports from our various databases. Basically a low-code data pipeline from cassandra, mongo, sql, etc. It worked...but things like switching git branches while keeping things running, updating the service, aggregating results, etc, were difficult. More difficult than just writing the code.

I wrote one then never used it again opting for node instances inside of our Kubernetes cluster instead.

finder83··on Hardened wood as a renewable alternative to steel and plastic
Looks like giant plywood. I'm actually really curious how it handles moisture content changes. Does it crack and is it dimensionally as stable as plywood?
finder83··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
This is precisely why I wish more manufacturers would start adding physical keyboards again...at least 60% of my phone use involves writing. I still hate touch-screen keyboards, and am easily twice as slow as I used to be on physical ones.

If someone would come out with a smaller phone with decent battery life, a processor that's not underpowered, physical keyboard, a headphone jack, and mediocre camera, I'd definitely jump on it. Almost the entirety of this press release is camera based, which I just don't care about that much...but maybe I'm not the target market.

finder83··on Mezzano on Librebooted ThinkPads
This looks really cool! May have to try it in a virtualbox or something.

Does anyone know of anything similar to this, but in an image like Pharo/smalltalk has? Would love a fully interactive Common Lisp environment, built in debugger, window system, etc (that's open source)

finder83··on Mozilla to put ads in Firefox address bar suggestions
Also owned now by a China-based company and closed source
finder83··on How Doctors die. It’s not like the rest of us (2016)
Well, I'm a protestant so there might be a different belief system in the Catholic church. "Grace by faith alone", which is the basis of what I commented above is a reformation doctrine and is mostly a protestant thing (some Catholics I have met believe it, but officially not the Roman Catholic Church), and penitence is entirely a Catholic thing, and was a primary cause of the reformation.

There are actually a LOT of different belief systems within Christianity and the related cults surrounding it, so you can't entirely sum them up by saying "Christianity". How I would respond to anyone stating that suffering is required to pay for sins is that it is un-Biblical and they've warped the message of Jesus, and are adding to/complicating the gospel.

This is possible in the Catholic church because edicts of the Pope and Councils have had equal (or at least near equal, I'm not a Catholic historian or theologian) weight with scripture, which of course have no weight at all to Protestantism as the Pope is just another person. Mother Theresa and penitents have such a drastically different belief system, that while I would not go so far as to call them non-Christian as I think only God alone determines that, I would say that their teachings are not the same religion as mine. Saints again are a purely Catholic thing, so to me and other protestants, Mother Theresa is just another person, and "Saint" is a worthless designation from the Catholic Church. In addition, individual adherents of what is classified as "Christian" can teach and believe (or fail in their belief) of the core doctrines and cease to become what I would consider Christian, despite doing things in the name of Christ. The church during the time of Paul's letters and Acts were dealing with the same thing, people using the name of Christ who were not what Luke or Paul considered Christians.

It sounds like a no-true-Scottsman argument, and perhaps it is, but the argument that I'm making is that you are lumping billions of people together, when #1 they don't lump themselves together (Catholics have considered protestants and the reformers heretics as well), and #2 they believe and practice drastically different things. You will likely hear Protestants hedge when asked if Roman Catholics are Christian, and the reason is because on an individual basis, there are Christians within the Roman Catholic church. But what they teach is not what we consider the Christian gospel.

finder83··on How Doctors die. It’s not like the rest of us (2016)
Are you saying that "suffering erases sin" is Jesus' final message?

The Christian message is that there's nothing we can do in our own power to erase sin, including suffering, hence the need for Jesus in the first place.

Death in Christianity is the final release from sin and its consequences, e.g. suffering, and into eternal joy...and being released of the weight of the consequences of sin eternally is supposed to bring joy and love in this life.

So I have no idea what you're talking about.

finder83··on Apple banned a pay equity Slack channel
Not that I agree with the move, but is that really surprising?

Creating a false sense of camaraderie and family creates a culture where people are interested in working and are positive toward the company. It increases productivity, makes people work more hours, and probably increases tenure.

Talking about pay equity leads to dissatisfaction and likely loss of profits as people look for more money, or for different jobs. It's not in the company's best interests.

Remember, HR is not there primarily for your benefit as an employee. I would say the same about company chat.

finder83··on Mob justice is trampling democratic discourse
That's a great quote. For me, it usually ends up that I need to just be silent and ask questions. And yet more and more, people are forcing an opinion, essentially taking the "If you're not with us, you're against us" stance, regardless of if I agree or disagree or how much I validate their own thought process.

Just pondering, why are people not allowed to keep their opinions to themselves now, especially if they are doing so to be kind to the other person? My own opinion is often that the reality of people and situations is nuanced, and blanket policies don't work at all levels. But even that is an unacceptable position in peoples' eyes.

finder83··on Stop Waiting for Godot
This guy has some fantastic videos on architecture in Godot. It takes a little more work to go from simple->complex, like using the event system properly, global scripts, etc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRHN_WEulLc

finder83··on Julia and the Reincarnation of Lisp (2020)
One other large issue is that less popular languages (CL, Scheme, Smalltalk, etc) sometimes just don't have the library you need or the libraries are immature and not fully developed.

Database adapters for something like SQL Server is a great example. Most languages have a Postgres library, but sometimes the business requires a SQL Server connection...it's rarely been by choice that I've wanted to use it, but by necessity.

Another is Salesforce...I don't know anyone who would voluntarily want to work with Salesforce, but more and more it's often a requirement to have a working soap library, Salesforce client, etc. Sure, you could write your own...but I can't think of something less interesting to do in development, when you could just switch languages and integrate directly without having to write a lot of glue code.

I do feel like I get more done in Common Lisp when the language 100% hits my use case, but it seems invariable that my use case involves external services I didn't plan on that have to be re-implemented or a work around/microservice written for them in a different language.

finder83··on Kinda a Big Announcement
I wish I could say my experience matched yours, but SO is an extremely frustrating place for many of my errors and problems. I don't think it made programming worse, it did make it better...but it's far from a panacea, and often a question has answers that are so outdated that the solutions no longer work, the solutions aren't complete or have bugs, or it's close to my error but not the same error, or a different solution. I'd say that's my experience about 1/2 the time I use SO.

I picked up a book last month to learn Clojure...how does SO help to learn a language start to finish? I don't even typically refer to SO for syntax questions, I'm sure it has that information but it doesn't seem like a very convenient place to index it. But maybe that's my subset of languages...

I probably end up on stack overflow a few times a week, and it is helpful...but I'd be fine without it if Google would just return better results.

finder83··on Puresql – A yesql inspired Node SQL library
Not the author, just thought this was an interesting library. I've used similar libraries in Clojure and CL (such as yesql) and really enjoy the step away from ORMs, but also having queries in a centralized place with parameters. This library looks well done, I haven't used it in any projects yet.
finder83··on Girls perform better academically in almost all countries (2015)
Sure, but to me that's on a different spectrum/axis from being independent thinkers. Both extremes on the axis of being a good citizen or being a conspiracy theorist are still following group think. But that is a concern as well, honestly if my kids are anything like me though they'll be skeptical of anything, particularly anything suddenly popular or extreme.
finder83··on Girls perform better academically in almost all countries (2015)
Agreed entirely. The goals of our factory system education are not in the best interest of the individuals participating. We home school largely for that reason...I want my children, both our boy and girls, to have individual creative thought, to explore the world, to rough-house, and to not just be a "good citizen" of society. Good citizens rarely make the world a better place.

I want them to challenge, think, be introduced to the complexity and darkness of history, be able to creatively write and imagine, and to not fall in line with whatever the societal expectations and agendas are for the week.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →