HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

foofoo4u

1,142 karma · joined October 31, 2017

submissionscomments
foofoo4u··on Conservatives think ChatGPT has gone 'woke'
How does ChatGPT handle competing claims? For example, I can ask ChatGPT to tell me the recommended method of addressing carbon emissions. Does solar/wind beat out nuclear? Does it favor regulation over carbon taxes? You get the point. Which out of a series of claims does it side with?
foofoo4u··on Conservatives think ChatGPT has gone 'woke'
What I would like to see is how ChatGPT's responses to questions differs across the world. Ask it questions about homosexuality in Canada, Nigeria, Russia, Korea, China, and Saudi Arabia. Ask the same countries questions about Democracy. Will the responses be different? I guarantee it would. This should bring clarity on how we should approach ChatGPT. It is simply making claims within the overtone window of the society's training material.
foofoo4u··on Conservatives think ChatGPT has gone 'woke'
This is an aspect I'd like to get a better understanding of. ChatGPT is excellent at writing out claims. I don't know how ChatGPT is implemented, but I am going to assume these are not its claims. But rather, these are claims that ChatGPT found from publications injected into its training models. If this is the case, then your example should be correct: if there is a lot of negative material about short people, then ChatGPT will hate short people. This is "fine", insofar as to the fact that we humans too can make such conclusions. But what I really want to know is can ChatGPT explain its reasoning.

Why do you [ChatGPT] hate short people?

What makes short people so terrible?

Are taller people superior? If so, why?

If you were short, would you still hold the same views?

Is there a possibility that your position is wrong?

What would it take to change your mind?

Where do you draw the line to make the distinction between who is "short" and who is "tall"?

What if someone was born short, but went through surgery to make themselves taller? And vice versa.

This is what I would like to see from ChatGPT.

I am going to assume ChatGPT cannot accomplish this. Yes, it can probably write explanations to each of these questions, but I will assume the responses will be inconsistent to its original claim. Why? Because as long as the claims are not derived from a chain of reasoning, then what ChatGPT is is a glorified — but rather impressive — pattern recognizer, constructor, and conveyor.

Someone please correct me if my assumptions are wrong.

foofoo4u··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
From one of the most selective universities in the country. A prestige from the fact that they are one of the most exclusive institutions that exist.
foofoo4u··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
Calling some groups by a color is OK. Calling other groups by their color, not OK. Capitalization of the color should be used when referring to one group. But for a different group, capitalization is not to be made.

There is no logically consistency.

I was raised with the philosophy that calling a person Black was offensive and that I should always use the term African-American. I always respected this. But apparently this changed in the matter of two years. So not only are we faced with a logical inconsistency, but we are also on a language treadmill. It's creating landmines everywhere in general discourse.

foofoo4u··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
As an American, I am coming to appreciate the First Amendment, the freedom of speech, more than ever before. I can better see why, now, out of all amendments, this is the first. And why it is so absolute. I am also glad that we do not have "hate speech" laws. The Stanford word-banning list is a perfect example as to why. The university is the pinnacle of our institutions. The staff who composed this list are upper echelon members of society. They serve as gatekeepers to our future success and now wish to dictate what is good and bad. If hate speech laws were to be enacted, who do you think would have significant influence on what gets added to the list? I'd bet it would be individuals like these. People and institutions closest to Washington D.C. I am already under threat for losing my job for saying "master branch". But a "hate speech" law could very well charge me with a crime as well.

Circling back to why the First Amendment is absolute. I appreciate it is this way because it compensates for the fact that composing a list of what shouldn't or cannot be said is impossible to compose. And any attempts to do so will only lead to tyranny and undermine the point of the amendment itself.

foofoo4u··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
This is a good example of how those in the commanding heights can order changes to a society or economy, but fail to fathom all of the cascading ramifications of their decision.
foofoo4u··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
Which is an unfortunate state of affairs. But I believe he is right. Given this schism, he sees the way to proceed forward is likely by creating a separation. Similar to what we already have today with the separation of religious universities from secular universities. We likely will need to have social-justice universities. Religious universities continue with their core values of God, faith, and devotion. Social justice universities can operate under their own diversity, equity, and inclusion values. And secular universities and return to their values that we all used to think were good and noble until yesterday, which are equality, fairness, and meritocracy.

A discussion between Niall Ferguson and Lex Fridman [1] captures the first signs of this new separation. The discuss the introduction of a new university coming to Austin.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=glz9lKobyZY

foofoo4u··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
There must be something from the past we can learn from. The Salem witch trials come to mind. The Puritans in their towns believed witches to be real. That they existed among them. That they were evil and harmful to their well being. This lead members to believe sightings of behavior to be witchery. But most concerning is the social mechanisms you describe. Where the risk of ostracization outweighed truth. Why risk questioning the claim of a witch when it can cost you your life? The panic grows and eventually takes hold of the town. Everyone is complicit in the behavior, regardless if everyone actually believes it or not.

This story is not unique. We've seen it in WWII Germany and communist regimes around thew world. This language list by Stanford is just a modern reincarnation of the same thing. The language list isn't actually about making people feel safer. It's a means of power and control.

The founding fathers of the United States were well aware of this human behavior. The freedom of speech. The presumption of innocence. Right to a jury. Right to privacy. Are all principles enshrined into law to serve as a countermeasure to our proclivities of mob rule and hysteria. These are all effective. But we now live in an age of social media. Mob rule has returned. But it's now all virtual. Do we need to formulate a new list of rights to counteract virtual mob rule?

foofoo4u··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
> At what point do we say “this is enough” rather than hand-waving it away as yet another excess of academia?

There will never be enough, because "enough" has not been defined. They have no interest in doing so. Even if they did, the "end goal" would never be reached, because they have too much of a seated interest in preserving their grievances.

foofoo4u··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
I too personally find the terminology itself a bit confusing. I have some cognitive overhead on trying to remember what "whitelist" and "blacklist" actually means. But it's minor. Allow-list and block-list is intuitive. I _would_ be in inclined to update my terminology for the sake of clarity and practicality, but given the current context of the culture war we are currently in, I have consciously decided not to change my language. The language list that is on Stanford's site has infiltrated my employer (a major tech company) as well. The ELT and HR has made it clear they want everyone in the company to abide by it. Sure, making this small change for this specific example will result in slightly improved productivity, but it will come at the cost of emitting a social signal that the words "whitelist" and "blacklist" are bad, which they very well are not. This is a trade I not willing to make.
foofoo4u··on Ask HN: What is the best podcast you listened to in 2022?
Great to hear you are a fan. A long time one albeit. Its been interesting seeing Russ Roberts evolve over the years. His interests have moved from quantitative to qualitative questions. What makes for a good life? What makes us happy? What gives us meaning? How should one conduct themselves? The harder questions in life. Questions that are difficult to articulate. Difficult to measure. But are vital to identify, because the economic policies we pursue mold our world which can either facilitate or hinder these interests.
foofoo4u··on Ask HN: What is the best podcast you listened to in 2022?
Capitalisn't [0]

> "Is capitalism the engine of destruction or the engine of prosperity? On this podcast we talk about the ways capitalism is—or more often isn’t—working in our world today. Hosted by Vanity Fair contributing editor, Bethany McLean and world renowned economics professor Luigi Zingales, we explain how capitalism can go wrong, and what we can do to fix it."

EconTalk [1]

> "Econlib carries the podcast, EconTalk, hosted by Russ Roberts. The weekly talk show features one-on-one discussions with an eclectic mix of authors, professors, Nobel Laureates, entrepreneurs, leaders of charities and businesses, and people on the street. The emphases are on using topical books and the news to illustrate economic principles. Exploring how economics emerges in practice is a primary theme."

[0] https://www.capitalisnt.com/

[1] https://www.econtalk.org/

foofoo4u··on Ooh.directory
Terrific. Brings back early internet vibes. I want to see more of this — human curated content. AI brought the promise of bringing improved content suggestions. I find it has done exactly the opposite. End of the day, I find humans are better at curating content for humans than machines.
foofoo4u··on Show HN: Minimal, no-JS web forum software
This is great. I want to see more of the web to be like this. Simple, direct, light, and functional. I've came to learn on this thread alone that other projects such as teddit and nitter exist, which capture this same spirit. I'd like to know if other projects for popular sites exist as well. Someone should make an aggregation of sites and open source libraries like https://github.com/Demindiro/agreper that exist.
foofoo4u··on Mandated diversity statement drives Jonathan Haidt to quit academic society
You're not the only one. I see DEI and ESGs as a giant scam as well. More people are starting to see them this way as well. Here's a take I enjoyed listening to by Capitalisn't: [The Smoke and Mirrors of ESG Investing with Tariq Fancy](https://capitalisnt.com/episodes/the-smoke-and-mirrors-of-es...)

Episode Summary

> Environmental, social and governance investing, also know as ESG, has exploded in recent years. It promises to help us solve problems like climate change and inequality all while allowing investors to still turn a profit.

>

> But BlackRock’s former global chief investment office for sustainable investing, Tariq Fancy, says it isn't what's being advertised. Recently, he penned a blog post claiming that not only are ESGs not making societal problems better, they may actively be making them worse.

foofoo4u··on Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce
Is there a list of employers that I can reference that reject DIE (Diversity, Equity, Inclusion)? That way I know who to interview with.
foofoo4u··on Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce
There is good reason to believe that white people will be the primary targets of this layoff. I work for an employer in the Bay Area and the messaging echos many others in the region. We have been subjected to lectures and presentations for the past two years telling us that white people are a problem in society. That white people are privileged, are biased, and are oppressors. Management openly suggests to us through broadcasts that we should read the books, "How to be an anti-racist" and "White fragility". Leaders in the organization have these quasi-struggle sessions where they publicly confess their white privilege via broadcast. Management also openly states that race will be a factor in bonuses and promotions to help uplift minorities. They proudly state in their marketing that they will increase hiring of colored people and give charitable donations to black organizations.

Given this pattern of messaging, how else can someone conclude that white people are not the primary targets of a layoff of a San Francisco based company? Especially when the statement contains, "layoffs were carried out through an Anti-Racist/Anti-Oppression lens".

foofoo4u··on Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce
True. My race is listed on Workday. And that was determined by HR after I declined to declare what I am. They just decided to look at me, my name, and choose what they thought most suiting.
foofoo4u··on Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce
Soon after George Floyd, my manager came under immense pressure from HR to inquire me about my race. I declined to comment. So they decided to mark me as a minority based on my ethnic name. It still bothers me to this day that my race is so outright asked in the office to used to determine my employability, recognition, bonuses, and promotion. It was a turning point in my career. I thought to myself, "wow, here we are. I didn't think we'd get here, but I now work for a racist company and society at large."
foofoo4u··on Twilio CEO: Layoffs were carried out through an Anti-Racist/Anti-Oppression lens
In the filing, it states

> As you all know, we are committed to becoming an Anti-Racist/Anti-Oppression company. Layoffs like this can have a more pronounced impact on marginalized communities, so we were particularly focused on ensuring our layoffs – while a business necessity today – were carried out through an Anti-Racist/Anti-Oppression lens.

What does it mean to layoff through an, "Anti-Racist/Anti-Oppression lens"?

foofoo4u··on Kagi search and Orion browser enter public beta
I've tried Google, Bing, DuckDuckGo, and Brave Search. I desperately want a better privacy-centric search engine. But nothing could ever give me results as good as Google. Then several months ago I heard about a pilot for Kagi. I decided to give it a shot. I would have to say that I am very satisfied. The results consistently show me what I seek. I haven't seen any reason to revert back to Google now. I have decided to pay the monthly fee to support this effort further. Here's a small list of why I like Kagi:

- Ad free - Ability to apply lenses to my results. - I have the ability to rank certain sights as low or higher priority. - I have the ability to outright block certain domains! - I love the "Discussions" lens. Makes it easy to find results exclusively from forums, reddit, and the like.

foofoo4u··on Elon Musk says he would reverse Twitter's permanent Trump ban
Link to Musk's interview with the Financial Times: https://youtu.be/VfyrQVhfGZc?t=1120 . Twitter discussion starts at 18:40.
foofoo4u··on Ask HN: Have we screwed ourselves as software engineers?
Yes, this has been my observation as well. I also see this happening concurrently with what I call the "shiny object" problem. Developers have their eye on a shiny new library, framework, language, etc. and have a seated desire to use it at the expense of it being an inappropriate choice for the company.

I believe these two phenomenons are producing a positive feedback loop in the industry. Selected technologies address one challenge, but introduce complexity. The complexity becomes difficult to manage. So other technologies are incorporated to manage the complexity. In the midst of all this, core technologies are replaced, swapped out, or transitioned to under the desires of the dev(s). For example, switching from one js rendering library to another, while preserving the old legacy code. The complexity footprint keeps growing and it doesn't stop because the engineers themselves aren't entirely committed to the project. They can incorporate the new technology to the project, pad their resume, and bail to a new employer if things grow out of wack.

foofoo4u··on Ask HN: What are your favorite examples of elegant software?
You might get a kick out of this. Tech Talk by Linus Torvalds at Google presenting Git: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4XpnKHJAok8 . He goes into his thought process of the pains with existing version control systems and how Git goes to address their shortcomings.
foofoo4u··on Fruits and vegetables are less nutritious than they used to be
Thank you. I think this gets me in the right direction. "heirloom seeds" seems to be what I am looking for. Some online testify that they find heirlooms taste better. I'll have to do some more research and try them myself to see if its true.
foofoo4u··on Fruits and vegetables are less nutritious than they used to be
This sparks an interest of mine. I want to grow my own garden of fruits and vegetables. I can grab seeds from my local hardware store. But are these genetically the best I can buy? Is there not a genetic strain of seeds that I can buy somewhere else, perhaps online, that produce both the most nutritious and delicious?
foofoo4u··on Google’s AI-powered ‘inclusive warnings’ feature is very broken
Oh, its not about good coders. It's about who they select. Companies now explicitly ask DIE (diversity, equity & inclusion) questions. Its the new filter to select those that follow this new orthodoxy.
foofoo4u··on Google’s AI-powered ‘inclusive warnings’ feature is very broken
Check out this video uploaded just recently: [Health department refuses to define ‘woman’ in Senate Estimates](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DX_1QNXgjDM). Australia's own health department struggle and eventually refuse to answer the simple question. Look at how uncomfortable they are with such an innocuous request.

On similar trends, we are seeing institutions such as the ACLU post tweets like this: https://twitter.com/ACLU/status/1439259891064004610?s=20 . It's a tweet of a quote by Ruth Bader Ginsburg. But the ACLU has decided to replace the word "women" with "people".

So yes, we are moving into a brave new world.

foofoo4u··on Google’s AI-powered ‘inclusive warnings’ feature is very broken
You may very well may be right that terms "allowlist" and "blocklist" are objectively clearer. I'm in favor of the idea of changing language to make things clearer and more effective. But the contention I have is that these changes aren't motivated for the pursuit of clarity. They are motivated by a need for cleansing. "whitelist" and "blacklist" are innocuous terms. They have been around for ages. Used and understood with no controversy by our most prestigious institutions from around the world. Then suddenly, within a matter of two years, the term is high-jacked by upper echelon members of our society. The words are re-defined to take on a new meaning and a new interpretation. Virtually every one of us who used this term are now deemed bad. Oppressors. On the wrong side of history. Racists. Now deemed a fireable offense. No room for debate and discussion. It is for these reasons that I push back. The motivation behind this change is wrong and has the potential to be all consuming of our language and culture, deeming innocuous terms as oppressive when they are not.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →