HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

fortzi

150 karma · joined September 5, 2017

submissionscomments
fortzi··on A single firm is behind OpenAI, Anthropic, and Meta hacking scandals
Revised title: Provider of AI agent eval tooling has a badly configured sandbox

Sub title: Which was used by AI agent providers

But instead you get foil hat folks theorizing about foreign intelligence veterans in ties with their government scheming to look stupid.

fortzi··on A single firm is behind OpenAI, Anthropic, and Meta hacking scandals
> Companies started by Unit 8200 members always have mysterious exploits

You seem to know very few companies started by ex 8200 members to make such a bold statement.

fortzi··on A single firm is behind OpenAI, Anthropic, and Meta hacking scandals
It would be naive to think that someone is doing this “to” those companies. They are not children, and they know exactly what they’re doing. They’ve repeatedly used the strategy of telling everyone how their models are too powerful to release to the public, shortly before launch. This is just another flavor of the same thing.
fortzi··on How much oil-market buffer is left?
Countries don’t have egos, they have interests. In this case, deglobalization (to an extent) and China
fortzi··on How much oil-market buffer is left?
Israel this Israel that... Not a word about how the US is in this adventure to get a grip on oil and gas shipments to China. This is just another move in the bigger play of curtailing China’s influence.

Another’s benefit to the US is that many consumers of Arab oil now has to sign years long contracts to buy oil from the US.

But sure, it’s Israel.

Edit: see US’s recent moves in the straight of Malaka and Gibraltar.

fortzi··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
> In some sense, all programming is boilerplate expansion because computers have (until now) been unable to be programmed with anything approaching natural language.

Maybe sometimes, but not always. When you need to actually render the thing you have all kinds of micro decisions, like where to put the square, what color, how fast it spins, etc.

You might not care about the details, but maybe you do. If it spins at 10000 rpm, will you care then?

Natural language, and human communication in general, is ambiguous, and coding is in great part about disambiguation.

Sure, you can use English to disambiguate as much as needed, but wouldn’t you then end up with some yaml-like spec that wasn’t much easier to create in the first place?

fortzi··on It’s so hard to finish an idea that is not yours and is just suggested by AI
I’m sure there are many of those, but like everything, there are tiers. I’m sure we’ll get something similar in SWE, but my hope is that you’ll still be able to choose to be a high tier engineer if you wanted to
fortzi··on Debian votes to allow "responsible use of generative AI"
I may be mistaking, but I doubt it digs through thinking tokens of previous runs, not to mention previous sessions
fortzi··on Debian votes to allow "responsible use of generative AI"
People, sometimes weirdly called by their animal name, humans, do have memories of their thought process. We can reach back to those memories to explain why we made a decision. Sometimes we don’t remember and speculate instead. Most of the time we can tell the difference
fortzi··on Debian votes to allow "responsible use of generative AI"
In my experience it’s impossible to foresee all the micro decisions that reality will demand. IMO it’s one reason to not use waterfall, which is very similar to what you described
fortzi··on Debian votes to allow "responsible use of generative AI"
Claude won’t tell you why it did something. Instead, it will generate a probable explanation. The two are very different
fortzi··on It’s so hard to finish an idea that is not yours and is just suggested by AI
What are you there for then?
fortzi··on It’s so hard to finish an idea that is not yours and is just suggested by AI
You really put my thoughts into words, thank you!
fortzi··on It’s so hard to finish an idea that is not yours and is just suggested by AI
Yes you can. Sometimes it’ll find them, sometimes it won’t.

I find myself having to use Claude to untangle its own mess piece by piece, a as it charged full steam ahead with the design we made together. However, not everything can be foreseen in a design, unless you go full waterfall. Sometimes I find myself in front of a mountain of bad abstractions stemming from a subtle oversight in the design. Before AI coding, I would find details while coding and catch them in time before they became sinful abominations

fortzi··on It’s so hard to finish an idea that is not yours and is just suggested by AI
Are you working on complex systems that serve many users in production? Do you actually save time?
fortzi··on It’s so hard to finish an idea that is not yours and is just suggested by AI
As a developer you are more akin to a car mechanic, who’s still expected to know how the engine works even a century after it was invented, rather than a driver, who is just the user in this parallel.
fortzi··on It's not empowering to hand off the details
Your vouching for centralization of knowledge, and even understanding, which I think is a very bad idea. It’s not like the rest of us are becoming specialized at something else - knowledge, in the broad sense, is the foundation of all skills. Without it we have nothing to contribute
fortzi··on The room the economy can't see
What's happens to the price of construction when the state suddenly commissions millions of homes?
fortzi··on MiMo-v2.5-Pro-UltraSpeed: 1T model with 1000 tokens per second
For the West
fortzi··on Can the stockmarket swallow Anthropic, SpaceX and OpenAI?
> ... prolonged Gulf conflict that at this point seems to serve no point whatsoever for anyone except perhaps Israel.

Dominating most of global oil and gas traffic is indeed very much a point that the US is trying to serve, albeit with arguable success. The same reasoning explains other crazy adventures like Venezuela and Greenland, as well as other more diplomatic endeavors in Panama, Gibraltar and the strait of Malaka.

The notion that the mighty US is going through all this for the sake of another country is bonkers.

fortzi··on Project Glasswing: An Initial Update
> Progress on software security used to be limited by how quickly we could find new vulnerabilities

And so was malicious vulnerability research.

fortzi··on Claude Design
I agree with all of that.

However, that’s not to say that many designer jobs will be going away, simply because for many cases, cost beats quality. We’ll just have more things with a much lower quality.

You can compare it with mass manufacturing. While some things are better had than not, even with low quality, we’d probably be better off with some things made to last, in lower quantity. But for 99% of the population, e.g. low quality clothing is the norm.

fortzi··on Claude Design
I don’t know.

With the core programming skills atrophying, who’s going to have the skills to audit AI’s work?

fortzi··on Claude Design
> this won't replace Figma or designers

If every designer takes less time to do their job, you need less designers. There’s no getting around that simple math.

fortzi··on Labor market impacts of AI: A new measure and early evidence
Can you give an example of how such a redesigned process might look like?
fortzi··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
I don't watch, I talk to real people who are first hand witnesses. Second, Israel doesn't own any media empire, what exactly do you mean? Third, Hamas doesn't need to dismantle any media organization, they got Qatar with their own world wide media empire of AlJazeera.
fortzi··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
These populists, so called leaders, don't represent everyone and are hated by many. In war everyone loses, and you seem to ignore the fact that there are two sides here. Normative people don't wake up in the morning wanting to murder children for fun. Your cartoonish image of Israelis as some kind of horned monsters is ridiculous.
fortzi··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
Ok, so the Iranian regime itself published this news? And you don’t even question it?

Seems like we’re on such polar ends, there’s no hope in discussion.

fortzi··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
No, the condemnation is real…
fortzi··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
No, these things do not constitute a genocide. Genocide is the purposeful extermination of a people. What you’re describing are other alleged war crimes. While it’s a catchy and horrifying word that’s very useful against Israel, it’s dishonest to use it in this case.

All the things you described are indeed horrifying on their own, and I believe there are cases where Israeli forces did some of these things unjustifiably.

You must be asking yourself what the hell could be justified. Well, I’ve heard first accounts of kids being sent first as scouts in the battlefield, into a kill box, trying to pinpoint Israeli forces. Once the scout goes back and reports on the force’s location, an accurate barrage of RPGs will be shot at them. You can’t go into the kill box to stop them by arresting them. What would you have done? I do not envy the person that has to make that call, they are now scarred for life.

Justified? No? You pick between the life of that kid and the lives of the people under your command. Both choices are bad, this isn’t Hollywood.

Most of what you watch is edited purposefully and doesn’t give you any context for the purpose of recruiting the public opinion. It’s working amazingly.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →