HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

forum_ghost

91 karma · joined February 27, 2022

submissionscomments
forum_ghost··on California aims to slash insulin prices
>This should not happen by the argument you keep repeating.

you do not understand how the industry works. salaries are high because the supply is constrained.

supply is capped. by residency availability.

doctors, like many others, don't want to live in some areas, and supply ends up being unevenly distributed.

In any major US metro, you can see a cardiologist TOMORROW. Don't even have to be a millionaire.

https://www.merritthawkins.com/uploadedFiles/MerrittHawkins/...

Let me guess, next will be "but muh AVERAGES"?

You can remain average. Best of luck.

forum_ghost··on California aims to slash insulin prices
It’s always been a business.

Even in formerly communist countries bribes got you better access.

As soon as you can figure out how to prevent people trying to leverage every resource they have and try to outcompete others to avoid death, let us know. you might get a Nobel.

forum_ghost··on California aims to slash insulin prices
Anyone who keeps talking about averages or statistical outcomes does not understand the first thing about medicine: there is no averages.

Because of deep sub-specialization you only have an agglomeration of outliers that are really good at what they do, and then the plankton, just like in every profession.

You can either have someone that knows exactly what he’s doing, or someone who rarely does it. A large part of medicine is guesswork, and you want someone who’s seen enough to be doing the guessing.

There is no shortage of physicians if you have the money. You can see the absolute best physician of your choice literally tomorrow if you have enough money to name a hospital wing. They’ll just see you while they eat their lunch, or come in an hour earlier.

The shortage you are talking about, is a shortage of competent, qualified saints willing to forego compensation after spending a decade in training to treat the poor.

If your expectation is that the top talent should for peanuts - do you really think there can be no shortages? You are literally asking for saints and miracles.

P.S. >there's more to life than just strictly salary. Things like retirement benefits, socialized healthcare, safety nets etc all contribute to reasons why this occurs.

$2-3 million/year solve all of the above. There is more to life, but 90% of every graduating class are there for money, nothing less.

forum_ghost··on California aims to slash insulin prices
You get paid what you can negotiate, not what you deserve.

Any politician that would propose serious enough cuts to physicians pay would suddenly find that their own GP has dropped him, and his oncologist forgot how treat the politician’s cancer. Sounds extreme? Happened several times in the US.

If they’d succeeded, you’d just have waves of immigration to richer countries that can pay higher, called brain drain. The US has the financial resources to attract the best talent. Not just salaries, but resources mean you get to work on things you find interesting, and ignore things you don’t.

Regarding “best”. I never said all US physicians are “best”.

What I said was, that because of higher pay, the best talent can be appropriately rewarded in the US.

How many public single payer systems can afford a physician that bills $10 million per year? More common than you think in the US.

They are most certainly outliers, and not the average physicians.

The issue is that due to super-specialization game that is medicine, anyone sufficiently experienced is going to be an outlier. Once it comes to something more involved than simple fracture, you want someone who does nothing but works on the specific issue you have, and preferably nothing else.

Real example: triple board certified (max fax, ent, trauma) surgeon Kasey Li in the US bills something like 100k per operation. Top talent from Hollywood and top Silicon Valley execs go to him. you’ve seen his work multiple times on several personalities.

There is literally not a single surgeon in Australia that is equally as well trained and as experienced as Li. He only works in one area and one issue only.

He pioneered an entire new field, changed numerous lives, including some execs that frequent this board, lol.

Who are you to decide how much he charges? You not even qualified to assess any his work to begin with, maybe 5-10 people in the world are.

forum_ghost··on California aims to slash insulin prices
What exists in Australia is exactly what the US has: private payers that get preferential access, and then Medicare for the poor/everyone else. People avoiding appointments they cannot afford. Psi service refusing to take Medicare patients. Unavailable pharmaceuticals in Australia that one can easily access in the US. You even have US-style HMOs.

It’s just a US-lite system compared to Canada (which like Cuba outlaws private healthcare, but has a grey healthcare market because the public system is broke), and NHS(which is broke like Canada, but at least you can pay private).

1) Patients avoiding appointments due to costs, just like the US:

“Almost impossible to get bulk billed’: patients avoid seeing doctors due to out-of-pocket costs”

https://amp.theguardian.com/australia-news/2022/may/12/almos... Private healthcare is better in Australia:

2) Private healthcare where cash suddenly trumps virtue-signalling on the internet.

Paying cash money? Jump the queue! The poor can languish and die while on waitlists.

“Public patients requiring elective surgery for cancer, heart conditions and other serious health issues face longer waiting times than their privately insured counterparts in public hospitals, according to a new report. ”

https://thenewdaily.com.au/life/wellbeing/2017/12/06/private...

3) Refusal of public patients.

In some cases, physicians don’t even take any Medicare patients -at all-.

Let’s take a rather relevant specialty for this thread, psychiatry:

“Psychiatry costs in particular are prohibitive. One reader reported paying $300 for 20 minutes with a psychiatrist, while another said they paid $900 for the first session and $500 for subsequent sessions. Another reader said her one-hour psychiatry session cost $435, and the Medicare rebate “didn’t even cover half”. Another reader, Jamie, said she had paid $220 and received $76 back from Medicare, but that her initial appointment was $600.”

Congrats! You are paying American rates! Good job Australia!

https://amp.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/apr/19/like-...

My goodness, isn’t this a huge surprise! Highly trained people want to get paid even in Australia, news at 11. Who could’ve guessed.

Money talks. It’s that simple. Why is that so hard to accept?

Engineers used to move to Bay Area to get the best possible salaries, but we should suppress doctors who even as much attempt to move overseas for bigger pay checks, lol?

forum_ghost··on California aims to slash insulin prices
Every country can grant compulsory licenses.

India does that a lot, and supplies the entire developing world with medicines.

Canada doesn’t have that much leverage. It often receives brand medications much later, and some cases medications aren’t marketed in Canada.

Try to buy Nuvigil in Canada, let us know how that leverage worked out for this drug.

forum_ghost··on California aims to slash insulin prices
What you are writing about is aspirational utopian fantasy.

What I wrote is harsh reality informed by two decades of being elbow deep in bodily fluids.

You may not like it, but you aren’t getting the best physician just because you developed some far out ideas how the best talent in the world must fix your problems.

Guess what, physicians are free people too, even free to refuse any patient for any reason.

They just want top dollar, and move where the pay is best, that’s all.

You wouldn’t move for a 10x higher salary? You would deny everything that would bring to your family?

forum_ghost··on California aims to slash insulin prices
Medicine, first and foremost, is a BUSINESS.

It is also a game of super-sub-specialization. The entire field. There essentially numerous subspecialties within each specialty.

Some surgeons do nothing but the same apnea surgery 5 times a day. Some oncologists do nothing but specific neuroendocrine cancers all day. Some diagnosticians are good for a specific area of their field - and utterly useless elsewhere, because they just couldn’t care less and want to work on what they find interesting. Just like anyone else.

If you want to see someone who actually knows what they are doing, sees the same exact issue you are having 10 times per day instead of once per decade, you WILL travel. Of course, you can always settle for the clueless doctor nearby who will do the bare minimum, or maybe even nothing.

Remember: patient outcomes are not part of the standard of care. There are no real incentives to do better than bare minimum, as a physician.

Sometimes the talent is in Switzerland. Sometimes Germany. Korea has some leading talents in niche areas.

It just so happens that the US pays the best, and just like engineers who can write their ticket that move to Bay Area, so do the physicians that move to the US.

Real life example: many neonatal surgeons only begin practising on their own, independently, in literally their late 30s, if not 40s. In training until then, whew. Slightly different than picking up a new JavaScript framework.

Would you seek to maximise your income if you had to study for 20 years after high school?

Neonatal surgery is often $1-2 million per surgery. There are only a handful of such centres. Only some of them operated on a specific condition more than 10 times.

The same really goes for anything else from diagnostic to operators. Even in the US, you’d often have to travel out of state if you want to get a proper opinion. Easier with imaging or biopsies because these can be mailed. Tons of people travel for surgeries. 250k Canadians every year travel to the US to get care they cannot get on time (or at all) at home. I’ve seen it all, even Saudis flying over for dental work.

Next time you see your doctor ask them who would they pick for their surgery: someone who does the procedure 100x per year, or someone who maybe does 1-2 cases per year. Then guess where the most super-specialized talent can maximise their income. Probably not the remote Australia with a population of ~10% of the US.

US simply has the best talent. If you can afford it.

As for Canada/NHS/Australia being better - that’s just laughable. Canada is actually dead last among top 10 richest countries, and happens to have the second highest drug prices after Switzerland. Also has as many beds per capita as Mexico. You’d be better off going literally anywhere else.

Mayo at Rochester has a larger diagnostic antibody library than anything in those three countries combined, and can arrive at your diagnosis within two days instead of two decades. Guess where your tertiary centre in Canada/Aus/Uk often mails your blood work and biopsies once they are at the end of the rope?

That’s right. USA.

forum_ghost··on What a gas stove ban means for restaurants
the famous french restaurants are cooking on electric, really?
forum_ghost··on WhatsApp threatened to leave the Netherlands due to controversial backdoor law
- 1A was written to make sure citizens beliefs, ideas and thoughts cannot be suppressed and controlled by the state.

- 2A was written to allow citizens possess the same tools as any other powerful imperial force of the day.

How is any of these concepts outdated?

You really think people who drafted those wrote them specifically about the tech of the day, and were smart enough to form a great nation, but too dumb to anticipate advances in technology, and were illiterate w.r.t history of civilizations and how technology advanced through the ages?

>fully semi-automatic

OK. You likely never held a gun in your hands. Makes sense.

Reminder: The nation with oldest gun culture in the world, Czech Republic, issued guns like candy to everyone that asked after Soviets pulled out in 1991. There were only two periods in Czechia that had prohibitions on gun ownership: 1. Occupation by Soviets. 2. Occupation by Germans. For the other 500 years Czechs owned and carried weapons, and still remain the only shall issue country in Europe, with rights secured by the constitution to carry and to use of deadly force in self defence.

(FYI: Gun homicides rates in Czechia are on par with much vaunted entirely gunless Asia.)

Afghans fought off the US with nothing but goats and AKs, while hiding in caves.

Seems these things are still quite relevant in 1991 and 2021.

forum_ghost··on In a small trial, drugs seemed to rejuvenate the body’s ‘epigenetic clock’ (2019)
> throwing an entire gas station into the fire?

Why? Longer span can also mean longer healthspan.

forum_ghost··on WhatsApp threatened to leave the Netherlands due to controversial backdoor law
>outdated constitutional rights

? surely you are joking?

forum_ghost··on WhatsApp threatened to leave the Netherlands due to controversial backdoor law
I'd be very surprised any serious criminals use anything from webstores in the first place. maybe some low level foot soldiers at most.
forum_ghost··on WhatsApp threatened to leave the Netherlands due to controversial backdoor law
afaik they only have key disclosure. which you can reveal yourself on clientside?

afaik they dont have a backdoor law? can you point to a link? tia

forum_ghost··on What a gas stove ban means for restaurants
Fossil fuel again is a misdirection. Neonics, BPA, DDT and all sorts of other fun stuff would exist without fossil fuels.

Semiconductor manufacturing gaves is few superfund sites in the US. Nothing to do with fossil fuels either.

The big problem is total lack of liability.

You can dump millions of actual toxins and poison literally billions and no jail time for anyone involved, not even a token patsy.

forum_ghost··on What a gas stove ban means for restaurants
European restaurants (in any EU country, even Germany) absolutely do use gas, and it's fairly common.

Depending on the restaurant, i'd go as far as to say "all" of them use it. At least the ones worth mentioning. Heating up hotdogs can probably done one something other than gas.

Fewer natgas stover in Germany, more in Italy. Netherlands has like 92% of households hooked up to natural gas. Restaurants are mostly gas or induction.

forum_ghost··on What a gas stove ban means for restaurants
Populations of insects have collapsed, fish stocks have collapsed, biosphere is polluted by millions of tons of forever chemicals dumped into the Pacific ever year. Chemicals that keep accumulating in every life form.

Earlier puberty in girls by several years, lower testosterone in men by more than 50% in two generation. Intersex fish. Some species are even reproducing asexually which for some was thought impossible.

This is NOW. TODAY.

CO2 has become such a convenient misdirection device that the industry uses to keep your attention away from rather current things that can very well implode life as we know it well before any "climate problems" actually become disruptive as these all other pollutants are today.

Why else do you think Exxon is rated 100% ESG compliant? Yes! They bought some credits or whatever, but still dump a few million tons of actual pollutants that destroy life TODAY.

Just keep everyone spinning on the carbon hamster wheels.

It's the green way.

forum_ghost··on Tech experts urge Washington to resist crypto industry’s influence
Do tell: how do you think these standards are established? By performing surveys or some other democratic/rule of law/other ritual?

FATF is an unelected, undemocratic body, where you have absolute monarchies like Saudi Arabia and authoritarian states like Russia audit the free/democratic/morebuzzwords West.

I can only imagine you think voting matters too.

It doesn’t, never did.

forum_ghost··on Tech experts urge Washington to resist crypto industry’s influence
> Anonymous billions are all fun and games until the second plane hits the tower.

What? security services can only spy on money, but just can’t do their main job of preventing attacks by humans?

Maybe we should hire a competent replacement for that job then.

forum_ghost··on Tech experts urge Washington to resist crypto industry’s influence
Do you think Germany should use more cash or less?
forum_ghost··on Elon Musk Tesla email: Remote work is no longer acceptable
The same works in person too.

You make your own “serendipity”.

Some just win a small lottery at times, and don’t even realize it.

forum_ghost··on Tech experts urge Washington to resist crypto industry’s influence
You are not aware at all how Cyprus went down, are you?

The banking holiday was declared in Cyprus, banks and ATMs shutodnw, everyone local is locked out completely, meanwhile deposits were drained by the rich international depositors thru oversease branches that remained open.

Why do you love defending the indefensible so much? Take the L and move on.

forum_ghost··on Tech experts urge Washington to resist crypto industry’s influence
wasn't early internet a massive rise in complexity? and it came with a ton of fraud too?
forum_ghost··on Tech experts urge Washington to resist crypto industry’s influence
Here is what a fairly prominent member of the global community of technologists, DHH, who is a known Bitcoin-sceptic thinks now:

https://world.hey.com/dhh/i-was-wrong-we-need-crypto-587ccb0...

forum_ghost··on Tech experts urge Washington to resist crypto industry’s influence
> Do Germans or Italians want different anti-money laundering standards, for example?

Yes. Germany is the highest user of cash in G-7 and has radically different views on privacy from other G-7/G-20 country, doesn't even have a centralized citizen register.

They have very little in common with Italy on many aspects, and certainly standards would vary as well.

But what does it matter? You think supra-national organizations actually care what some little people think?

forum_ghost··on Tech experts urge Washington to resist crypto industry’s influence
can you find people in Cyprus that were enthusiastic about losing money so that the government can pay bankers' gambling debts?

a 2-3 verified examples will suffice, tia.

forum_ghost··on Elon Musk Tesla email: Remote work is no longer acceptable
>I wouldn’t be where I am if remote work was the norm

why not? It's probably just as likely you wouldn't be where you are if your several pivotal points in life went only slightly different.

forum_ghost··on Elon Musk Tesla email: Remote work is no longer acceptable
Indeed.

Why shouldn't there be a binding UN convention that enforces work from home where possible to save us from climate change?

forum_ghost··on I'm retiring from the engineering profession
>at least it has some urban core

why do they need to exist?

they are even harder to maintain than suburbs, have you not noticed the meter thick layer of dirt in the NYC subway?

forum_ghost··on Lia DiBello on the Mental Model of Business Expertise
No tldr?
← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →