HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

frumplestlatz

386 karma · joined January 26, 2025

submissionscomments
frumplestlatz··on Religious scholars met with Anthropic
Who or what is liable for what a model chooses to do — or not do?
frumplestlatz··on Religious scholars met with Anthropic
Everything you listed is a biological entity with a common evolutionary heritage.

All but one of the things that you listed is just a human being.

Tell me, where is the pain center in a GPU? Where are the nerves? Persistent memory? Any evolutionary reason at all to develop a pain response that in any way mimics ours?

Model weights are not a gestalt biological entity. The things that you listed are not in any way remotely similar to a model.

I would suggest you plug your comment into a model and ask it to critique it — it might help you walk through why your comparison makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. One nice thing about models is that they they don’t get annoyed explaining the obvious, because they’re not conscious entities.

frumplestlatz··on Religious scholars met with Anthropic
Maybe consider the obvious, enormous chasm between everything you just listed and an LLM.
frumplestlatz··on Religious scholars met with Anthropic
What makes this unique is that they’re arguing that it is literally magical. They’re building what they claim is a conscious God while also telling us it will end the world.

The EA folks infesting Anthropic are genuinely cultists … and that is novel and alarming when they’re running a corporation of such size and reach.

frumplestlatz··on Kolibri: A Sovereign Open-Weight Model
I think the simple reality is that if your goal is producing quality work output, you want the smartest possible model available.

What is the upper bound on the value of more intelligence applied to your problem domain?

frumplestlatz··on Meta Uses A.I. Data Centers to Avoid Billions in Federal Taxes
Then it's tax fraud and illegal, not a subsidy. If it's not illegal, then ... it's still not a subsidy.
frumplestlatz··on Meta Uses A.I. Data Centers to Avoid Billions in Federal Taxes
It's literally their money. Not taking other people's money is not a subsidy.

You can argue that they should be paying those taxes under the current law, but it's not a subsidy.

frumplestlatz··on DraftKings is using AI to behaviorally target chronic gamblers
Gambling is extractive by definition, so I’m not particularly convinced that it’s not a problem for most of the people that “enjoy” it.
frumplestlatz··on Booted up in 1993, this server still runs – but not for much longer (2017)
The real marvel is that you tortured both the English language and your readers that much just to describe a UPS swap.
frumplestlatz··on Pacing the Frontier is not the actual goal for AI labs
The US has 14 ballistic missile submarines, and just one of those submarines has sufficient firepower to decimate an entire continent.

… and those submarines only represent about half of our deployed nuclear arsenal.

We only agreed to nuclear arms constraints that left us with civilization-destroying capability, preserved our ability to keep improving and modernizing that arsenal, and locked out non-nuclear powers from development (and didn’t fully succeed at that).

Does that seem like a successful analogous example to you?

If anything, it’s a much better analogy for regulatory capture and incumbent entrenchment, not successful “pacing” of dangerous technology.

frumplestlatz··on Pacing the Frontier is not the actual goal for AI labs
Which is more likely?

1) They genuinely want (and believe it is actually possible to achieve) an international agreement and governing body to “pace” AI development — and believe that governing body will be successful in doing so.

or

2) They see an opportunity for regulatory capture that grants them a stronger incumbent position and control over future AI regulation.

frumplestlatz··on On caring for user data: NeoVim caused Vim undo files to be deleted
Actually calling someone a nazi for opposing mass immigration is certainly a choice, but it's not one we should be rewarding with deference. It carried an implicit threat, and the github issue was a form of triangulation intended to force others to take a position on something they're not party to.

I've never liked DHH, but as far as I can tell, he's neither a white supremacist or a nazi. I'm also not the viewpoint police, and I have zero trust or patience for anyone that tries to be.

frumplestlatz··on Fifteen years later, the Apple Cards origin story
Maybe when I finally retire
frumplestlatz··on Fifteen years later, the Apple Cards origin story
To be fair, he was genuinely a demanding and abrasive personality.

I once saw him absolutely dismantle, over the course of an hour, an intern that made the mistake of asking one stupid question.

frumplestlatz··on Fifteen years later, the Apple Cards origin story
He got away with it because the results were unique and valuable.
frumplestlatz··on U.S. appeals court upholds designation of Anthropic as supply chain risk
That’s literally what they’re doing. That’s what supply chain risk means.

They don’t buy the product, and the product can’t be used in the things they do buy.

frumplestlatz··on U.S. appeals court upholds designation of Anthropic as supply chain risk
You’re still absolutely free to do business with Anthropic.

Our military is simply choosing not to do business with them, or anyone that depends on them.

If you believed in democracy, you wouldn’t be supporting the EA-infected corporation that tried to make our democratic institutions subordinate to their corporate decision making.

frumplestlatz··on U.S. appeals court upholds designation of Anthropic as supply chain risk
Anthropic took the position that our military’s decision making power should be subordinate to Anthropic’s constraints.

Any dependency on a company that thinks they have that moral authority and has the technical means to enforce it is absolutely a risk to the supply chain.

If you want to blame someone or something for this, we should start with Dario and “effective altruism”.

frumplestlatz··on U.S. appeals court upholds designation of Anthropic as supply chain risk
We cannot subordinate our military’s decision making power — in any arena — to a private company.

Our military must also not be dependent on a private company that believes it has the moral prerogative to control our military’s decisions, and would have the technical capability to do so.

frumplestlatz··on U.S. appeals court upholds designation of Anthropic as supply chain risk
There is no available information on the quantity of gold in that base …

… but I sincerely doubt Apple gave a ~$1M “gold bar” to a political leader, in front of cameras, using a patently transparent ploy like “it’s just a detachable base”.

That would be a phenomenally stupid and obvious violation of bribery law.

And if Trump does keep it as a personal gift, it will be included in a financial disclosure report.

frumplestlatz··on The Mafia may be keeping fentanyl out of Italy
You would like to state to be in the business of permitting the sale of cocaine, heroin, methamphetamine, et al?

Or perhaps selling it directly?

Has this ever worked? Do you have any evidence whatsoever that this is a good idea?

frumplestlatz··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
A broken limb, fractured elbow, deep cuts/lacerations/abrasions on my legs, elbow, and arms. I was in pain, my wounds were filled with gravel and dirt, and I just closed my eyes and laid on the floor and disassociated for twelve fucking hours. My girlfriend was losing her shit trying to advocate for me.

Subjectively applied, uncaring triage that leaves people poorly cared for is exactly what happens when you lack sufficient capacity, aren’t paying your staff enough to care, and staff's incentives aren’t sufficiently tied to their outcomes.

My father, an ER doctor in the US, was losing his shit over their quality of care when I FaceTimed him afterwards.

Your lack of compassion is also exactly what produces these kinds of systems. Who cares about the actual outcomes or the affected individuals, as long as your ideological ideals aren’t challenged.

> The second they dispatch an ambulance, you owe them how much exactly these days? $5000?

My insurance covered all of it. The driver’s insurance reimbursed my own.

And even if they hadn’t, I’d rather be in the hole financially than spend 12 hours in pain and have persistent issues caused by free health care doing a hack job putting me back together.

The US healthcare system isn’t perfect, but I’ve got at least another four decades left on this planet, and the cost of US healthcare is nothing compared to the cost of living out those decades in a body that’s not as healthy as possible.

frumplestlatz··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
Sometimes it works — but the overall quality, speed, and care outcomes remain, on average, very poor when compared to the US.

The price is only good if you ignore the outcomes and what you’re paying on the backend through taxes.

frumplestlatz··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
This was at the Ospedale San Carlo di Nancy in Rome.
frumplestlatz··on Once Claude can measure something, it can make it faster
I’ve had the same thing occur five or six times over the past week; they seem to be attempting to prevent anything resembling chain of thought extraction.

Every single time it triggered, it was due to a prompt written by their own model in a dynamic workflow. The self-serving nanny oversight has to go.

The fact that they label model distillation as an “attack” is genuinely hilarious after they “distilled“ their models from all of our work, and continue to do so.

I believe AI is here to stay and an incredibly powerful tool, but these companies, and especially Dario and Altman, are the very last people I want to see in charge of it.

frumplestlatz··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
And in a society that hasn’t made health care profitable (Italy), I waited 12 hours, literally on the floor, with a broken arm and covered in my own blood, before I was seen after a motorcycle accident.

I literally would’ve been better off flying to New York. I still have scars and nerve damage from the incredibly poor care in Italy’s medical system.

In the US, I was rushed into the ER in an ambulance and seen immediately after a car hit me while I was bicycling — and that was just because they were worried about the speed at which the accident occurred. They had me patched up within the hour. I was fine, road rash and sore for a couple weeks.

There’s no silver bullet here, but I’m very sure that healthcare is not a good analogy for nuclear power.

I’m also very sure that anyone that advocates for government healthcare should try actually using it in one of these countries. I hope you enjoy waiting and long-term adverse health effects from poor, delayed, and inaccessible care.

frumplestlatz··on Pirate Face Rescues LLM Models from Deletion
You’re confusing definition with inference.

Of course "a felon has previously committed a felony" is tautological. But "a person who has committed a felony is substantially more likely to commit serious crimes in the future" isn't.

It's a well-established empirical claim, and that's why they're prohibited persons.

As for magically predicting whether someone will become a prohibited person: we can’t, and even if we could, that would mean preemptively restricting a constitutional right.

frumplestlatz··on Meta bans ads for Virginia Woolf play in Spain
I’m not confused, I know exactly where that claim is coming from.

As for the conversation, that claim, and others, are not as self-evident or universally held as was posited.

frumplestlatz··on A restored PDP-11/83 serving this page on 211BSD Unix
Thanks for keeping the spirit of the old internet alive :)

I hope you won’t have to restore it from tape!

frumplestlatz··on Meta bans ads for Virginia Woolf play in Spain
Failure to comply with burdensome regulation in the way that you would prefer does not inherently make it the problem of those you have burdened.
← PreviousPage 2 of 19Next →