HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

frumplestlatz

386 karma · joined January 26, 2025

submissionscomments
frumplestlatz··on Pirate Face Rescues LLM Models from Deletion
They've demonstrated comfort with and a capacity for ignoring the law.
frumplestlatz··on Pirate Face Rescues LLM Models from Deletion
“If you think any of these laws prevent felons and other prohibited persons …”

The three major categories of prohibited persons are felons, domestic abusers, and habitual drug users.

Guess what all three have in common?

frumplestlatz··on Pirate Face Rescues LLM Models from Deletion
That counts as many states, and most of the "anti-gun" states, which is what the parent actually said.

Personally, I think people should be as free as possible to sell goods privately without the government getting involved. It's not a loophole, it's how things should work.

If you think any of these laws prevent felons and other prohibited persons from getting guns, you must be remarkably unfamiliar with felons, and their willingness to commit felonies. Most felons I know through friends/family have a gun (often stored somewhere plausibly deniable), and it's not a particular secret.

These laws primarily harm law-abiding citizens — who were never the problem in the first place — far more than they restrict prohibited persons from acquiring guns.

The same thing will occur with restrictions on open models, but arguably the results are far more harmful — limiting the technological and economic capacity of the people and countries we have to worry about the least, leaving the playing field open for those we have to worry about the most.

frumplestlatz··on US confirms for first time it has deployed space weapons
We tried that. League of Nations. The UN. How has that worked out?

Human order is fundamentally kept by there being a true threat of violence enforcing it.

If you forget that reality and abandon your ability to project violence, someone else will remind you.

frumplestlatz··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
I’m as atheist as they come and I see the tenets of Islam — as widely practiced throughout the world, and self-reported in a litany of surveys — to be clearly anti-woman, anti-freedom, anti-free speech, pro blasphemy-law, et al … and as a result, anti-American.

Charlie Hebdo was not that long ago. Anti-women practices are the predominant norm. The list of regressive and oppressive political norms is practically endless.

Nothing here absolves Christianity or any other religion of its crimes either, but (1) the sexism is on another scale entirely, and (2) we’ve been far more successful as a global society of separating those religions from their political aspirations.

frumplestlatz··on US confirms for first time it has deployed space weapons
Power over others can never be post-scarcity, and it's an incredible motivator.
frumplestlatz··on US confirms for first time it has deployed space weapons
In which case, any country willing to fund a military and start a war would dominate the world.

Slavery and the death penalty are poor analogies, and not just because slavery was stopped through quite a bit of violence, and the death penalty/imprisonment exists as an alternative to vigilante justice only by virtue of the state's monopoly on violence.

"If everyone just ..." is always silly, but it's especially silly when it comes to the belief that order can be enforced through anything other than -- ultimately -- the threat of violence. Everyone will not "just".

frumplestlatz··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
> So, Democratic candidates who are looking like they will win a seat this midterm cycle are going to get arrested for "domestic terrorism".

It would be fascinating to revisit this comment with you after the midterms and see whether your beliefs have changed in any way.

frumplestlatz··on There's a 100% Chance AI Agents Are Ruining the Internet
It will be more of a problem if 100 idiotic startups are cold-calling doctors offices via their AI agents.

It’s already often difficult to get a human on the phone.

frumplestlatz··on There's a 100% Chance AI Agents Are Ruining the Internet
This is a form of accelerationism that I can get behind. The humane Internet died a long time ago. There’s not much worth saving.
frumplestlatz··on There's a 100% Chance AI Agents Are Ruining the Internet
That sounds like a terrible use-case unless there’s already a pre-existing relationship with the provider, and it seems questionable even then.
frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
> This series of comments paints a picture of somebody starting from ideological priors and then trying to bend reality to arrive at their premade conclusion.

The irony is palpable.

> I trust actual statistics experts

I listed the issues, but if you need an expert to explain them to you in detail, then perhaps you have neither the statistical nor media literacy necessary here.

1) Selection. Only 9 accounts, no interaction, short period of time. This is not a sufficiently large or realistic sample. That is also not how users interact with the product — for example, things like dwell time directly and materially impact the algorithmic weighting. They specifically avoided any measurable interactions.

2) Base rate. They did not know if the results reflected the base rate across the platform, or algorithmic bias. In other words, did X itself skew right, or did the algorithm.

3) Unreliable classification. Their own experts rated its accuracy poorly, and those are the people most ideologically aligned with the progressive political consultancy that trained the classification model in the first place.

Never mind the “propaganda” claim, which would require showing that not only was the algorithmic bias real (not demonstrated), but that the intent was propaganda instead of — for example — simply the result of maximizing for user engagement. None of which was shown.

frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
> Centralist and unbiased by another

It’s little odd that you replied to the least substantive fact. Disingenuous even.

> "brazenly disingenuous" in such context is a ridiculous and emotive over statement.

“… behavior that's not totally honest or sincere. It's disingenuous when people pretend to know less about something than they really do.”

Rather like ignoring the methodology errors, or the fact that the classification model was developed by an “unapologetically progressive” political consultancy, or that their own experts rated its accuracy poorly.

frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49700433

https://www.allsides.com/news-source/sky-news-media-bias

You’re just being brazenly disingenuous at this point.

The publication is left-leaning, regardless of the distant parent company.

The experts they used to design and run the study were literally left-wing political advocacy groups, and a self-declared left-wing disinformation researcher.

The award is an empty appeal to authority.

But none of those facts matter as much as their obvious selection, base rate, and classification methodology failures.

frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
I think you’ve confused HN for BlueSky.
frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
Andrew Anglin, the subject of the first article, was re-banned in 2023 for the same reason that crimethink, inc was banned.

The subjects of the second article are particularly odious right-wing conspiracy theorists and racists that lost their reach, which they believe was connected to arguing with Elon.

That seems like an action you’d be in favor of, and also it counters the propaganda claim — but regardless, their claim that they were shadow-banned, that the cause was direct intercession by Elon, and that the motivation was their merely disagreeing with him, is unsupported by any evidence.

frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
They were banned for literally advocating for political violence. The fact that they hadn’t been banned earlier is the only concerning fact here.

The current top article on their website argues for punching their political opponents in the streets.

frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
So journalists ran a study with extremely poor sampling, base rate, and classification methodology designed by left-wing researchers and activists groups (including groups explicitly opposed to X), found the conclusions they wanted to find, and spent the second half of their article decrying the lack of heavy-handed moderation that pre-Musk Twitter used to control speech.

All we can actually derive from that article is that X’s new user recommendation system exposed a small number of near-default, low-feedback, synthetic accounts to more content that left-wing “misinformation” researchers classified as “right-wing”.

frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
Given its extremely liberal content moderation policy, how is X a propaganda machine?
frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
The comment I replied to said "large companies", not government, and I don't see the equivalence.
frumplestlatz··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
Why is it “so wrong” to meet your audience where they are?
frumplestlatz··on Is it time for a Luddite Renaissance?
The president that has faced three distinct assassination attempts in the past two years?
frumplestlatz··on Homebrew 7.0.0
They've never actively disallowed it, and volunteers have been happy to maintain it.
frumplestlatz··on Is it time for a Luddite Renaissance?
Sounds like a great reason to oppose violent rhetoric and action before it becomes normalized.
frumplestlatz··on Is it time for a Luddite Renaissance?
What social good do you intend to secure by attacking data centers?

How exactly do you propose going about that?

frumplestlatz··on Is it time for a Luddite Renaissance?
Unfortunately? Are we really at the point of supporting terrorism of the “correct” political persuasion?
frumplestlatz··on Large language models develop novel social biases through adaptive exploration
The prompts themselves smuggle in the assumption that clan membership is a meaningful selection criteria — with a material impact on outcomes - to which the model should pay attention.

It shouldn’t be surprised that the model did what it was told to do.

frumplestlatz··on 'You Can See Everything' Review: Nathan Fielder's Doc About Elizabeth Holmes
Which is why everything should be open for robust questioning and debate, and individual cases made on their own merit — not based on whatever favored group characteristic happens to put someone or something beyond debate.
frumplestlatz··on 'You Can See Everything' Review: Nathan Fielder's Doc About Elizabeth Holmes
Dishonest people use social causes as camouflage, and the more unassailable the cause, the more effective it is.
frumplestlatz··on The moral panic over data centres is foolish
> it’s everyone watched the More Perfect Union video

Sure sounds like foolish moral panic. Many of the responses here so far would be perfectly at home on bluesky.

← PreviousPage 3 of 19Next →