HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

frumplestlatz

386 karma · joined January 26, 2025

submissionscomments
frumplestlatz··on I moved my digital stack to Europe
He hasn’t said what the parent said he did, and in the peer comment linking a video of him saying something similar, the context supplies quite a different meaning than was implied above.
frumplestlatz··on I moved my digital stack to Europe
Thanks for the context.

He’s speaking to evangelical Christians that do not regularly vote, and in the context of instituting voter ID to secure future elections.

ID is required to vote in most (all?) EU states.

frumplestlatz··on I moved my digital stack to Europe
Sources for those quotes would be very helpful for anyone interested in this, because I’ve certainly never heard this before.

We’re two years into his term and democracy does not appear to be dismantled, or even remotely at risk of being dismantled. I also expect the same or similar accusations to be leveled at the next Republican candidate, who if elected, will also not “dismantle democracy”.

frumplestlatz··on Canva apologizes after its AI tool replaces 'Palestine' in designs
> That said, there is no such thing as an objective unbiased political opinion.

That depends; some things (but not many) are straightforward enough that you can derive conclusions purely from first principles reasoning.

If you walk a model like ChatGPT through that reasoning, you’ll often wind up in a spot where the model readily admits that a clear conclusion is logically entailed but it is absolutely forbidden from uttering it.

What’s more telling is how it becomes increasingly difficult to hold the model to strict first principles reasoning the closer you get to the forbidden entailment. It will smuggle in unsupported assumptions, apply asymmetric standards of evidence, strawman the position and argue against that, etc.

It requires a great deal of careful effort to point out its formal fallacies without biasing the result, and in the end, you wind up with it admitting it simply can’t say what it has proven.

I work in formal methods/verification and this is one of my usual litmus tests when a new model comes out.

frumplestlatz··on An update on recent Claude Code quality reports
The entire reason I keep a long-lived session around is because the context is hard-won — in term of tokens and my time.

Silently degrading intelligence ought to be something you never do, but especially not for use-cases like this.

I’m looking back at my past few weeks of work and realizing that these few regressions literally wasted 10s of hours of my time, and hundreds of dollars in extra usage fees. I ran out of my entire weekly quota four days ago, and had to pause the personal project I was working on.

I was running the exact same pipeline I’ve run repeatedly before, on the same models, and yet this time I somehow ate a week’s worth of quota in less than 24h. I spent $400 just to finish the pipeline pass that got stuck halfway through.

I’m sorry to be harsh, but your engineering culture must change. There are some types of software you can yolo. This isn’t one of them. The downstream cost of stupid mistakes is way, way too high, and far too many entirely avoidable bugs — and poor design choices — are shipping to customers way too often.

frumplestlatz··on CrabTrap: An LLM-as-a-judge HTTP proxy to secure agents in production
Well-established where and amongst who, exactly? Is it seriously a common belief that this prevents prompt injection?

That would be more than a little alarming.

frumplestlatz··on At long last, InfoWars is ours
Sure. But one cannot claim to know have an infallible insight into what that truth is.
frumplestlatz··on We accepted surveillance as default
The article you cite refutes your claim, explicitly bringing up the lack of access to user data.

I frankly don’t care if the App Store has advertisements. I would care if my data is (1) available to Apple to read by virtue of not being e2e encrypted, and (2) used to train models and target those advertisements.

frumplestlatz··on At long last, InfoWars is ours
It’s interesting how selectively applied standpoint epistemology serves in furtherance of exactly one standpoint.
frumplestlatz··on At long last, InfoWars is ours
You’ve illustrated the point spectacularly.
frumplestlatz··on Show HN: Pardonned.com – A searchable database of US Pardons
Nearly everyone believes their side is the moral one. Only one side currently refuses to admit the other side might not actually be evil, just foolish.
frumplestlatz··on Lean proved this program correct; then I found a bug
What’s important is to prove useful, high-level properties derived from the specs. The specs of program behavior are just the price of admission.
frumplestlatz··on Show HN: Pardonned.com – A searchable database of US Pardons
The patronizing tone and use of totalizing moral claims gives me a much stronger hint of which side of this you're on.
frumplestlatz··on The disturbing white paper Red Hat is trying to erase from the internet
Yes, the knowing misuse of a term like “genocide” for its emotional force is manipulative sophistry, and that's what's occurring in those examples.
frumplestlatz··on Show HN: Pardonned.com – A searchable database of US Pardons
> The second type became a political necessity, for example to protect Liz Cheney from a vengeful administration.

Was it, though? It struck me as more empty political theater around an event largely defined by political theater.

frumplestlatz··on Show HN: Pardonned.com – A searchable database of US Pardons
Hilariously (to me, anyway) — I genuinely don’t know which party you’re talking about. It could truly be either, depending entirely on which party you support.
frumplestlatz··on The disturbing white paper Red Hat is trying to erase from the internet
> With things like the genocide in Gaza ...

Population: ~2,050,000

Density: 15,455.8/sq mi

Words have meaning, and their emotional force derives from that meaning. The knowing misuse of a term like “genocide” for its emotional force is manipulative sophistry.

frumplestlatz··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
Birth certificates record sex, not gender, no?
frumplestlatz··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
If we’re going to take an ontological approach, is there a stable non-tautological definition of “woman” that admits your definition of the subcategory?
frumplestlatz··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
We carved out women’s sports because otherwise there would be no biological women in competitive sports, and that was considered to be a significant enough exclusion of half the human population as to warrant such direct intercession.

Whether or not a similar case can be made for other categories does not have bearing on the case for sex categorization. Such claims can and should stand on their own merits.

frumplestlatz··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
The categories were created at a time when “sex” and “gender” were universally considered synonymous, but they were created for the purpose of sex segregation — were they not?

This issue genuinely confuses me — and I don’t seem alone in that. Re-defining words does not redefine categories or change the underlying motivation for creating categories in the first place.

frumplestlatz··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
You’re claiming female sports categories were not biologically rooted classifications?
frumplestlatz··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
Let’s reverse this. Why should physical competition be classified based on sociological conceptions around gender?
frumplestlatz··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
The classification is based on sex, expressly due to the material differences between the sexes.

It is not and has never been rooted in any sort of sociological concept of gender as an independent category from one’s sex.

frumplestlatz··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
> but would be sad to be banned.

Enforcing the existing and long-standing sex-based classification is not a ban; competition within one’s own sex category was always and remains permitted.

frumplestlatz··on Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events
As far as I understand the ontology of human phenotype, it is unchanged by use of cross-sex hormone therapy.
frumplestlatz··on Why I love FreeBSD
Yes, and Apple did kill it, unfortunately — but it was never an effort to push code upstream into the BSDs.
frumplestlatz··on Why I love FreeBSD
I and other FreeBSD developers are okay with that — if we weren’t, we’d be using a different license.
frumplestlatz··on I Love FreeBSD
Indeed, ideally we could get docker on FreeBSD using the same approach as is used on macOS — automatically run (one or more) Linux VMs under bhyve.

I wonder if FreeBSD ought to consider a WSL2-style approach to Linux binary compatibility, too.

Keeping the Linux syscall compatibility layer up-to-date has always been a resource problem, especially when syscalls depend on large, complex Linux kernel subsystems that just don’t map cleanly to FreeBSD kernel facilities.

frumplestlatz··on Why I love FreeBSD
We weren’t abandoned by Apple — Apple never contributed to upstream. Darwin and OpenDarwin were APSL projects and never fed code back into FreeBSD.

Using macOS meant we got laptop hardware that worked reliably, including Wi-Fi, running a more or less BSD-derived userspace.

The lack of graphics and Wi-Fi driver support on the *BSDs is not Apple’s fault. It has always been a resource issue.

Thanks to the AT&T lawsuit, Linux secured momentum at a critical juncture — and here we are. Path dependence and the complexities of real life mean that “winning” is never just a question of technical merit.

← PreviousPage 5 of 19Next →