HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

fundatus

597 karma · joined January 18, 2021

submissionscomments
fundatus··on Germany’s solar power generation hit record high at weekend
For sure, but the negative prices indicate quite clearly that the storage capacity is way too low (unfortunately). In case our storage capacity would be just right, prices would never be negative.
fundatus··on Germany’s solar power generation hit record high at weekend
Might be true (didn't check the numbers) but German coal/lignite plants (which are the biggest contributors to the German CO2 footprint) will be phased off gradually over the next 7 years. So that will change drastically.

It would probably have been wiser to keep the nuclear shut-off at 2030, but Fukushima changed that and when the energy crisis hit it was already too late to change course.

fundatus··on New insights into why aspirin works so well
> except thousands of common herbal remedies are replaced by patent medicine with legal controls, because $MONEY

Except they are not being replaced? Just like in the good old days™ you can still get out and collect the herbs you're looking for. It's just that nowadays we know that component X of a herbal remedy actually does the job so you just buy that in tablet form (or whatever) instead eating of the whole thing.

fundatus··on Deutschlandticket for regional bus and rail services to be offered for €49/month
Regional trains in Germany are not run for-profit. For each route there is a public tender for subsidies every 10 years or so. Private companies that win these contracts have to fulfill whatever local authorities put into these tenders (like timetables, capacity of trains etc). So your suggestion simply wouldn't work. Instead, your local authorities must improve whatever they require from the companies (and then also increase the subsidy accordingly of course).
fundatus··on The UK is wasting a lot of wind power
Yep, 15 minutes to full load is not uncommon with gas plants.
fundatus··on Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab
that is exactly what i am talking about in my second point?! you‘re at 11.5 GW considering the capacity factor, divide that by 3 (first point) and you’re still above whatever you’ll produce with Hinkley Point C!
fundatus··on Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab
> sure nuclear is very expensive up front, but a nuclear powerplant can run for 100 years while wind and solar had to be completely replaced every 25 years.

Hinkley Point C is currently expected to cost around $31 billion once finished for a measly 3,000 MW.

For that money you could build ~2,300 15MW onshore wind turbines - which would add up to roughly 34,500 MW capacity. So even under the assumptions that

- you have to replace the wind turbines 3x to reach 100 years life span and

- you always have to build more renewables since they don't run at 100% their capacity throughout their lifespan

wind make more sense economically nowadays.

fundatus··on Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab
Yep, and fusion reactors will probably be even more expensive (especially the first ones). Looking at the current prices of renewables, I don't see a market for fusion reactors at all to be honest.

After all we already have a giant fusion reactor just 12 light-minutes away from us! We just have to harvest that energy. The direction were already going (mostly market-driven nowadays actually!) is generation from renewable sources, flexible grids and storage systems to balance everything out.

fundatus··on The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months
So when you said "currently" you actually meant "right at this moment". Because currently (as is "this year") about 50% of Germany's electricity generation comes from renewables.
fundatus··on Migrating 1 terabyte of files from OneDrive to Nextcloud
In case you still want to build it yourself: you can use sshfs to mount a Storage box on your Hetzner server instance.
fundatus··on India follows EU's example in requiring USB-C charging for smart devices
Yeah, but the EU said back then: "You either find a common standard, or we're gonna legislate." Companies didn't want legislation, so most of them complied.
fundatus··on Is Web3 Bullshit? (Transcript)
A regular bank transfer? I know the US doesn't really do that kind of thing, but here in Europe I can send money to another bank account within 10 seconds.[1] And it doesn't even cost me or you anything and all I need is your IBAN.

[1] https://www.europeanpaymentscouncil.eu/what-we-do/sepa-insta...

fundatus··on White House is pushing ahead research to cool Earth by reflecting back sunlight
Nuclear is an energy source of the past. It's too expensive and therefore rejected by the markets. Modern, emmission-free energy-sources like solar or wind (accompanied by storage in homes, districts and some larger-scale storage facilities) became so cheap in the past decade that you can now build more than 10 times the capacity in renewables for the price of a nuclear reactor. It's simple economics why nuclear is dying a slow death.
fundatus··on White House is pushing ahead research to cool Earth by reflecting back sunlight
> It isn't good enough due to variability. We don't have efficient energy storage so that means you have to build massive overcapacity, like 5x as much.

That's a problem already solved: Storage. Germany alone has 3.4 GWh of home-battery storage installed as of today. And it's constantly increasing. Averaged over a year, renewable energy sources operate at about 30% of their capacity. So even in a worst-case scenario with no storage whatsoever you would need to build 3x "overcapacity".

> We should have some renewables but we can't base the entire energy supply on them.

We surely can and will! Mark my words.

fundatus··on Who killed nuclear energy and how to revive it
Hinkley Point C, £23 billion for a measly ~3.000 MW. you could literally build ten+ times the capacity using modern, emission-free alternatives.
fundatus··on Who killed nuclear energy and how to revive it
my point obviously being that this still affects plants, animals and humans in a much larger area than just the surrounding area - which makes the argument "We could have a chernobyl every year for the next hundred years" not very compelling
fundatus··on Who killed nuclear energy and how to revive it
It's literally natural market forces that are "killing" nuclear energy. It's simply too expensive compared to modern, emission-free alternatives.
fundatus··on Who killed nuclear energy and how to revive it
> Nuclear power is cheaper when built in serial production. That's the basic conclusion of any analysis of the history of nuclear power construction. There's nuance as to why, but the basic pattern is that putting an order of 40 steam generators is cheaper than a run of just 4 of them. Similar deal with specialized pumps and other nuclear power components. Suppliers can re-use infrastructure and expertise, and get better deals on input materials by guaranteeing a stable demand.

Unintuitively though, this is incorrect - both for France[1] and the US[2]. Building subsequent versions of the same reactor design increases the cost - instead of it staying the same or going down.

[1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03014...

[2] https://news.mit.edu/2020/reasons-nuclear-overruns-1118

fundatus··on Who killed nuclear energy and how to revive it
After Chernobyl clouds containing radioactive material where blown westwards by the wind and eventually those clouds rained down over parts of Germany. To this day if you go out hunting for example wild boards in those areas they have to be tested for radioactivity before they can be processed further, since their diet mostly consists of mushrooms and plants that contain a lot of Caesium-137 from that rainfall back in 1986.
fundatus··on Who killed nuclear energy and how to revive it
Who Killed Nuclear Energy? The absurd cost to build this technology and the emergence of much more cost-effective and emission-free alternatives. It's as simple as that. It wasn't the tree-huggers or a big conspiracy.
fundatus··on Bob Cassette Rewinder: Hacking Detergent DRM
Same! Also it washes at up to 70°C which you simply can't do when hand washing - but it gives you a much better result with less water usage.
fundatus··on Europe is investing heavily in trains
Not sure about other countries, but Germany's long distance trains are run for-profit. Only commuter trains are subsidized. Tracks are paid for by taxes - but so are streets.
fundatus··on Visa, Mastercard block Russian financial institutions after sanctions
The thing is "neutral state" for Putin means a russian vassal state. So not an option.
fundatus··on Tesla to recall vehicles that may disobey stop signs
Every Pro iPhone has one. So it already got pretty cheap by now. Looking at Mercedes' Level 3 Autopilot tech you can also see how well you can integrate the sensors into the front of a car.
fundatus··on Europe Is Losing Nuclear Power Just When It Needs Energy
Well, might be. The question is though if it's worth a price orders of magnitude higher than competing energy sources. And most countries on this planet seem to have come to the conclusion that it is actually not worth the price. Now I am actually not particularly for or against nuclear power - just making the argument that it's not an economic source of energy anymore.
fundatus··on Europe Is Losing Nuclear Power Just When It Needs Energy
I've compared the build costs of HPC to the build costs of wind turbines. Not total costs.
fundatus··on Europe Is Losing Nuclear Power Just When It Needs Energy
Don't think so. Taking Germany as an example, many people joined these movements after the country was in large parts affected (to this day actually) by the nuclear fallout of the disaster in Chernobyl. So I guess experiencing this first hand made a huge impact for many people. Personally I don't have a very strong opinion on nuclear (neither positive nor negative) but I also believe that you can't simply take these experiences away from people and it would be wrong to invalidate them.
fundatus··on Europe Is Losing Nuclear Power Just When It Needs Energy
Refueling outages last on average for about 2 months every 18-24 months, so it's never been "constantly" really.
fundatus··on Europe Is Losing Nuclear Power Just When It Needs Energy
Let's do some math. You can build a 3 MW wind turbine for around £2 million. Which means you could build around 11,500 wind turbines with the amount of money spent on HPC. Which in turn means a maximum production of 34,500 MW. So even under the assumption that these will run at below 10% of their capacity you're still producing more electricity than HPC. Now in reality this number averages around 30% actually. So the price per MWh is orders of magnitudes lower compared to nuclear.
fundatus··on Europe Is Losing Nuclear Power Just When It Needs Energy
Nuclear is also the most expensive energy source (total cost per MWh). Which is the real reason why "Europe is losing nuclear power".

When finished the UKs Hinkley Point C nuclear plant will probably have cost around £23 billion for ~3.000 MW which is completely insane.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →