HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

futuraperdita

361 karma · joined September 26, 2024

submissionscomments
futuraperdita··on Briar keeps Iran connected via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi when the internet goes dark
Alexander Hamilton explains his definition of what "well-regulated" is - and the purpose of a citizen militia - in contrast to the standing army in the Federalist Papers, No. 29. Most of the idea has become much more federalized than intended with the National Guard, but it has long since been misused for its intended purpose.
futuraperdita··on The Myth of the ThinkPad
I have a haptic touchpad on my current X1 Carbon and actually don't mind it. The ancient Haswell-generation clickpads were terrible but the Sensel ones are underappreciated.
futuraperdita··on The Myth of the ThinkPad
> For reasons unknown online technology forums have always had some kind of "underdog" that they cheer for.

I've found it's usually a relation in sorts to the underdogs, in some way or another: a vengeance against the status quo, a sort of angsty reactance against it, or a desire to simply do the usual thing and signal yourself as "alternative". That's all the hipsterism is: a kind of counterculture. The author of this post is basically saying in the subtext "You're simply living off the scavenged technology of corporations and these computers aren't built for what you see in them. You are a stupid 20-something with false nostalgia," which I could argue is just a different sort of social signaling.

There is some truth in both sides of the Thinkpad culture argument. Thinkpads have excellent Linux support, ludicrously bad color gamut, questionable build quality generation-to-generation, but are always serviceable if not attractive. If the MacBook is the AR-15, the ThinkPad is the AK-47.

futuraperdita··on Sisyphus Now Lives in Oh My Claude
If you're an engineering manager, you should communicate with your team, know their strengths and weaknesses, stay sharp on modern technique, and, most importantly, ask them what workflows work best for them, not us on Hacker News.

If you're hiring a consultancy or a pile of freelancers it's a bit different, but the question here would make me believe you don't trust their capability to start and I would be looking for teams that better align with what you expect as their outputs.

futuraperdita··on AMD Ryzen chief teases return of older Zen 3 chips to fight soaring RAM prices
I'm curious when this stops.

I have been thinking over the past week or so that we're likely to see consumer technology sitting well behind datacenter tech perpetually here, and this is not a transient shortage but an overall market adjustment to consumer and SMB being a few generations (or process nodes) behind the hyperscalers. Outside of gamers and enthusiasts, most people can be on anything from the last 7-8 years and be fine with it, and most of what they do is offloaded to the cloud anyway.

I'm also pessimistic enough to see a sort of long-term "compute control", where we see a few generations of technology leak to adversaries through individual channels, and then we start ensuring that _only_ controlled/regulated/registered companies can purchase the leading-edge. After all, nobody needs that much compute, it's dangerous! What if they put it on a drone?

futuraperdita··on Ask HN: When do we expose "Humans as Tools" so LLM agents can call us on demand?
Exactly this. OP, this is basically where this book goes - AI management that directs humans around as automata.
futuraperdita··on AI Police Reports: Year in Review
What worries me is that _a lot of people seem to see LLMs as smarter than themselves_ and anthropmorphize them into a sort of human-exact intelligence. The worst-case scenario of Utah's law is that when the disclaimer is added that the report is generated by AI, enough jurists begin to associate that with "likely more correct than not".
futuraperdita··on Meta's new A.I. superstars are chafing against the rest of the company
> The new head of Facebook AI is 28 years old? That's not OK, that's too young. Too inexperienced and not worldwise enough by a long shot.

This is ageist in the way I don't usually expect from the Valley. Plenty of entrepreneurs have built successful or innovative concepts in their 20s. It is OK to state that Wang is incompetent, but that has little to do with his age and more to do with his capability.

futuraperdita··on More than 100 rally against data centers at Michigan Capitol
> DC fills vacant lots that might otherwise attract crime.

Can we prove that the location of this DC is attracting crime? It's not a vacant lot. This protest is because DTE is expected to raise electric rates for the state's residents, so you're costing the local economy in aggregate more than the jobs that the DC is even providing. It's not guaranteed, if almost likely not, to be a net positive on the whole versus the zero-case of a "vacant lot".

> the urban decay that's been destroying Michigan.

I'm asking this genuinely: have you been to Michigan? The entire state is certainly not some sort of industrial wasteland and a lot of people equate the state to the Urbex porn of the shell of Detroit. This is planned in the state capital's entertainment district, not some semi-abandoned factory area.

Most of the state I've seen has been mostly nature, some sand dunes, and woods.

futuraperdita··on Windows 11 will ask consent before sharing personal files with AI after outrage
> you're going to see people figure out how to be the digital Amish and run what they need locally and live without the benefits of the rest.

I've been a large proponent of what LLMs and the transformative nature of them, but for a lot of people running these companies, it's clear that it isn't about the technology and instead about control. I've even lost some trust in my Apple products throughout this as it feels more like a matter of time that they bend to this more than they have, especially with the shakeup.

I think it's OK if people want to use these systems - but if they don't, we'll let the market speak for itself. For now, I'm out.

futuraperdita··on More than 100 rally against data centers at Michigan Capitol
These things don't really supply "jobs" in any sort of way that is noticeable to the surrounding community. A couple hundred people. The idea that DCs produce jobs is basically a false hope given these communities.
futuraperdita··on [dead]
I'm sorry. It's not creative to just slap something through an LLM and publish it on the Internet.
futuraperdita··on EFF launches Age Verification Hub
What parts and content should be "harder to access" in your view?
futuraperdita··on US Fed will start buying Treasury bills to manage market liquidity
I'm thinking the same thing. AFAICT this is still going to increase M0 and long-term inflation risk. I don't see how this rate cut is likely to change and/or stimulate the economy with the conditions we have today, just to add to the risk of stagflation.
futuraperdita··on LLM from scratch, part 28 – training a base model from scratch on an RTX 3090
You've created a text-based version of a Black Mirror episode: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Be_Right_Back
futuraperdita··on How the Creator Economy Destroyed the Internet
> It's like somebody set out to do what the 90s Geocities couldn't, using modern tech.

This style is basically a sort of nostalgiacore and that's exactly what it's trying to do. It's heavily influenced by Web 1.0 and the time-smear of 1990s-2000s early Web culture.

futuraperdita··on Socialist ends by market means: A history
Came to this post hoping to see C4SS mentioned. "Markets not capitalism" is a fantastic read in general and the PDF is freely available / open access.
futuraperdita··on I failed to recreate the 1996 Space Jam website with Claude
I think you're assuming a pattern existed in 1996 that didn't actually exist until the 2010s.

In 1996 JavaScript was extremely limited; even server side processing was often limited to CGI scripts. There was nothing like React that was in common use at the time. The Space Jam website was almost certainly not dynamically compiled as HTML - it existed and was served as a static set of files.

Even a decade later, React and the frontend-framework sort of thinking wasn't really a big thing. People had started to make lots of things with "DHTML" in the early 2000s where JavaScript was used to make things spicier (pretty animations, some server side loading with AJAX) and still often worked without JS enabled in a pattern called graceful degradation.

What you'd get from "View Source", or "Inspect Element", and what was literally saved on disk of spacejam.com, was almost certainly the same content.

futuraperdita··on Everyone in Seattle hates AI
> AI also has very powerful open models (that can actually be fine-tuned for personal use) that can compete against the flagship proprietary models.

It was already tough to run flagship-class local models and it's only getting worse with the demand for datacenter-scale compute from those specific big players. What happens when the model that works best needs 1TB of HBM and specialized TPUs?

AI computation looks a lot like early Bitcoin: first the CPU, then the GPUs, then the ASICs, then the ASICs mostly being made specifically by syndicates for syndicates. We are speedrunning the same centralization.

futuraperdita··on Micron Announces Exit from Crucial Consumer Business
Is this not just "with freedom comes responsibility" applied to technology? Often the freedom to do something means that, when given that sovereignty and missing the requisite experience, that means you also end up with the freedom to harm yourself (whether through a misunderstanding of a danger or just simple error.)

Do we want to accept that as a potential consequence, or have someone else choose for us what consequences we are allowed to accept?

futuraperdita··on Minisforum Stuffs Entire Arm Homelab in the MS-R1
Having bought other systems in the MS-line, these boxes are heavy on cool homelab specs but aren't all that reliable and dealing with Minisforum for support is abysmal. I ended up moving back to old enterprise hardware (TinyMiniMicro or rackmounted gear). I don't recommend purchasing these systems if you're looking for anything more than a novelty; they're not any better than buying one of the random AliExpress mini PCs.
futuraperdita··on iPhone Pocket
> You can get nice, custom, handmade bags for a fraction of what this pointless junk goes for.

You're making the subjective value judgement that a synthetic material is "junk", without qualifying it as such. A textile that is less expensive to manufacture, or is synthetic, does not automatically qualify as "junk". Look at technical fabrics such as GoreTex as a highly functional example, or any avant-garde techwear from brands like ACRONYM which usually last quite a long time and have some artistic merit within the fashion world.

It's OK to not like synthetic materials. It's also OK to not care about fashion-as-art, but fashion is oft ephemeral by nature and design.

futuraperdita··on 74% of CEOs worry AI failures could cost them their jobs
> Board members hold CEOs accountable. How is an AI agent going to do that?

The lack of oversight is a feature, not a bug, in this case.

futuraperdita··on Windows 10 Deadline Boosts Mac Sales
This comment is getting downvoted for what is likely its tone of ageism, but I don't think that it's completely wrong: the original FOSS-activist community is now a group of oldheads and hasn't successfully made the same generational shift that maintained its original philosophy. Looking at any rant from Torvalds, the Linux programming community has often held technical elitism before inclusivity. "Open source" over "free/libre software" has found success not because of its personalities and community but rather because it is a meme that can be appropriated for your own. The counterculture I see in GenZ+ that is most interested in working with FOSS/public technologies is politically aligned differently and has more pragmatic goals (e.g. will use major commercial communications platforms such as Discord).
futuraperdita··on Windows 10 Deadline Boosts Mac Sales
> I am married, have three school age children, and have hobbies and I volunteer regularly. One of those hobbies is not “figuring out how to make Linux work.”

This comment literally asks him to go check to see if his games work with Linux, and that he needs specific hardware for that compatibility to be meaningfully successful. The alternative is he just uses Windows and plays his games. It's exactly the type of "extra steps" that he wants to avoid.

I use Linux systems daily, and every now and then I'll go FOSS-zealot enough to go rip my Thinkpad back out of the closet and port everything over. Then, I'm no longer interoperable with any part of society that isn't involved in a fringe movement of the Linux laptop, and then go back, somewhat disappointingly, to my MacBook Pro.

futuraperdita··on Claude Code Unleashed
This article is an ad for the author's product.
futuraperdita··on Review: Ryzen AI CPU makes the Framework Laptop 13 the fastest has ever been
Given the increase in power budget and cooling, I’m still disappointed to see that the lowly MacBook Air is not just competitive, but sometimes leading against the best x86 chips, some 5 years after the first one was released.

After struggling with heat and power usage, I’ve resigned myself to macOS in the short term. I’d love to see real competition again.

futuraperdita··on Mark Zuckerberg says social media is over
Non-iMessage chats are also segregated by color, a visual affordance that identifies you as a member of the non-Apple outgroup. The other.
futuraperdita··on Top OpenAI Catastrophic Risk Official Steps Down Abruptly
> OAI is lying and Sam Altman in particular is extremely convincing

Sam is an excellent hype-man and is going to play to the strengths of the team and their accomplishments; every new product release is going to be hailed as a breakthrough until people become skeptical if it really is. In the middle of the hype cycle you keep your foot on the gas, because you can make it through a potential AI winter and if not invest in more products.

"AGI" is a shaky definition with moving goalposts. What it means to me might not be what it means to you. How it manifests in product is unlikely to be the science-fiction "one model that does everything". It also doesn't mean that the path to AGI is the path to ASI, or the path to catastrophic risks.

I personally believe that if OpenAI has dismantled the safety org, it is not just because it is in their short-term best interest, but also because they have found that many of the initial concerns around "catastrophic risk" (in the MIRI-type doomer style) from current systems are likely to be unlikely or invalid. As for the smaller safety risks, I'm not sure business has really ever cared about those unless the costs realized outweigh the profit.

futuraperdita··on Top OpenAI Catastrophic Risk Official Steps Down Abruptly
X-risk talks heighten fear in everyone, but the reasons why changes like this are made in large technology companies are usually banal. Two alternative explanations include that the person just felt like coding again, or that the projections of exponential progress are falling apart on short timelines. You don't need a bunch of safety people if you're seeing that the LLM feature curve is actually sigmoid, so you're pivoting to products and applications of the existing models which will continue to get better in specialized ways.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →