HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gaelian

604 karma · joined October 1, 2010

I'm Gaelian Ditchburn, geek, developer, consultant, musician. I come from the land down under.

http://blog.binarybalance.com.au/

gaelian.ditchburn at that web based email service starting with "g".

submissionscomments
gaelian··on Wozniak calls for open Apple
> Apple's biggest strength to me is timing and execution. They didn't invent the tablet, but they made it better and at a time when more people were ready for it.

Kind of the similar to what happened with their implementation of the mouse and the MP3 player, they didn't invent these things, but they improved upon them or made them more accessible to consumers at the right time. But I am really keen to see if Apple can continue this pattern without Jobs at the helm.

gaelian··on London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic Committee's favor
That poster could have come straight out of Alan Moore's "V for Vendetta".

England prevails!

gaelian··on Internet anemia in Australia
It does seem that if you're looking for the best coverage in regional areas, Telstra is pretty much the only show in town. But regional isn't that important to me and I've been traumatised by Telstra in the past so just want nothing to do with them anymore. :)

Optus 3G coverage can be pretty crappy for my particular circumstances, but 3G is more or less available where I most often need it, so I have no major complaints.

gaelian··on How text editing on the iPad should be
I'd love to know if you're correct on this. Because if you are, then the OP has a flair for subtle, yet relevant visual cues that borders on the precient.
gaelian··on Apple responds to NYT: "We're among top payers of U.S. income tax"
> To be more concrete: you can't build a socioeconomic infrastructure on top of capitalism. You have to do it the other way around.

Well said. I have never really understood why so many people seem to think it has to be all or nothing when it comes to privatisation. Can't things be taken on a case by case basis? When I hear news about the US health care system, I often shake my head in disbelief.

Contrary to apparently popular belief, anything other than full-tilt, "privitise all the things" does not necessarily equal communism.

gaelian··on Make Your Email Hacker Proof
Not that anyone should need further convincing, but just in case here's another data point drawn from my own experience:

http://blog.binarybalance.com.au/2012/03/11/a-wakeup-call-fr...

gaelian··on What Will Replace The Internet? (2000)
I wonder if ultra-realistic VR would be easier or harder to achieve than colonizing the sea.
gaelian··on V for Vendetta and the Rise of Anonymous - by Alan Moore
Apologies for the super-late reply. Wasn't notifo'd of your comment for some weird reason.

For the better most definitely, and when Moore could still be considered as part of the comic industry. I don't think this has really been the case for a long time now.

I agree with toyg's comment that the industry is in its current state because they don't have enough Moores and Ellises and Gaimans. I'm also very fond of Garth Ennis' and Glenn Fabry's work. It's interesting to note that all these guys and more are considered part of the 'British Invasion'[1] and without them, the US comic industry would be in far worse shape than it is.

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Invasion_(comics)

gaelian··on V for Vendetta and the Rise of Anonymous - by Alan Moore
I don't think it's overstating things to say that Moore's influence changed the face of the comic industry forever (no pun intended). The man is a true visionary, pushing the boundary of whatever medium he chooses. I look forward to reading his novels.

Here is another good and recent interview:

http://www.honestpublishing.com/news/honest-alan-moore-inter...

gaelian··on Star Trek as a purely symbolic artifact of past times
Duly noted. :)

I guess getting back to my actual point though, if an entrenched and perennial favourite like Baseball can topple in this version of our future, then conceivably just about anything else can too.

gaelian··on Star Trek as a purely symbolic artifact of past times
As good guesses as any. I remember my feeling when I watched the episode in question was that the decline of Baseball was not due to the rise of another sport, but I don't have any source on this and I don't think this was ever explicitly stated. From memory, the reason was chalked down to something non-specific like people becoming interested in 'other things'. It's been a long time since I watched this stuff.

And people's attention spans seem better in the future if anything, don't they?

gaelian··on Star Trek as a purely symbolic artifact of past times
> I would posit that the world of Star Trek eliminates the alienation of everyday life on Earth that leads one to social networking in the first place.

This kind of discussion always makes me think of how in the Star Trek universe, Baseball is no longer a professional sport, the final World Series being played in 2042[1] due to a lack of interest from the public.

So what kind of social changes could possibly have the by-product of turning Baseball into a niche, amateur sport? I don't know, but I'd wager the changes would have to be pretty sweeping. And from there, would it be such a leap to think that perhaps similar sweeping changes might also massively alter the trajectory of social media and/or other apparently 'too big to fail' juggernauts in this fictionalised and hypothetical future?

Disclaimer: I'm not a rabid trekker trying to retcon so that my fondly remembered childhood reality can remain intact. I just like to think about this stuff sometimes because I was/am just a trekker.

1. http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Baseball

gaelian··on Our startup analyzed the debate last week. What do you think?
Really don't see why steve8918's comment was downvoted.

On a Win 7 machine, running Chrome 16.0.912.75, the font would appear to be a legitimate problem. Were this a page that I had put together, I'd want to know about it.

gaelian··on No longer loving Google
I upvoted this post not because it really brings anything new to the list of grievances against Google, but because I feel its important that the existing grievances not be forgotten.

Also, this is one of the few places on the web where I am sure people from Google frequent. Perhaps I'm being overly optimistic and naive, but if highlighting posts like these help to shift Google back even just a little towards "Don't be evil" then it was worth my upvote.

gaelian··on Anonymous strikes back: takes down DoJ, Universal, RIAA and MPAA sites
> This would be more interesting if it was something that affected those groups. Those groups live in different media, not online. If their cable streams were hacked, billboards, advertising, commercials were compromised, it would truly taking the 'fight' to their door.

But that would probably entail doing something more than loading up LOIC...

gaelian··on How to get hired (or, 'The silly story of interviewing in the valley')
I was talking to a friend of mine about just this issue recently. He and I have been on both sides of the interview table at different times. I have gotten interviewees to solve toy programming problems and I've asked them the funny little logic problems, just as I have been asked the same sort of things in the past. But eventually I too came to the realisation that these kinds of things had little if any real significance to the work that the interviewee was going to be doing. Is it usually going to be the case that the guy you hire will have to write his code with unusual speed, under the pressure of three or more people looking over his shoulder and judging his answer, without the benefit of Internet access or Intellisense or what have you?

My approach is to throw out the whiteboard coding and logic questions whenever I can and to look for examples of a prospective employee's real world work, namely contributions to open source (e.g. GitHub makes this easier) and if not that, then perhaps they can directly provide me with private real world examples of code they've written.

I realise that not everyone will necessarily be able to provide such examples of real world work and yes, looking over someone's pre-existing project will probably take more time than seeing if they can reverse a string. But maybe this is also part of the problem: hiring practices in some places have gotten lazy.

I can't think of a way to entirely, in 100% of cases get rid of FizzBuzz, and the guy who has to escape the fire spreading from one side of the island etc. but I really wish I could, because it just doesn't feel right.

gaelian··on Visualize Success if You Want to Fail
So despite the oversimplified title, the value of this article for me lies in the last two paragraphs; which speak to me off a balance between practicing 'critical visualization' when we need to achieve and 'positive fantasy mode' when we need to reduce stress and anxiety. Both of these activities being useful to success.

I sometimes wonder why some people tend to feel the need to come down hard on one extreme or the other of an issue when so often in my experience the optimal path tends to be the middle road. I think it's because extremes are easier to grasp and seem more definite, more solid. But I also think this can be an indication of lazy thinking and should be called out more often.

gaelian··on Teaching Good Sex
My partner of nearly 10 years is German and while I do feel that I've had a fairly long history of exposure to their culture through her, nor can I say that I am able to speak authoritatively on all Germans or all stratas of their culture. Certainly Germany and wider Europe are not made up of people who have an entirely homogenous attitude towards sexuality. And as you would of course know, it's not like you can just walk naked through any street in Berlin without causing a fuss. But having lived in Germany, I'm sure you understand the subtle difference in the European attitude that I'm trying to illustrate.

I think you're putting the horse before the cart. I'm pretty sceptical that anyone is 'fundamentally wired' any differently from anyone else. We're all products of our society and even if a certain set of social conventions are deeply baked into the history of a particular culture, that shouldn't mean that said social conventions should be mistaken for some form of innate attribute or that they cannot be re-examined if they are found to be detrimental. I'm not implying that this is necessarily what you meant, I'm just pointing out that its a slippery slope from 'fundamentally wired for X' to 'can't change X'.

gaelian··on Teaching Good Sex
Here's a couple of articles on the Netherlands and Sweden:

http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/408927_5 http://www.usnews.com/usnews/news/articles/070318/26sex.htm

The original link of this thread, which talks about the sex ed classes of a Mr Al Vernacchio, does strike me as a pretty detailed example of the kind of model that some European countries are practicing.

And I'll finish with another example from my own experience that illustrates the wider difference in attitude that I alluded to: I visited Germany about 6 or so years ago. One day we went to an area near Potsdam, I think it was Wannsee. This area has a lot of beautiful old architecture and park land and people can swim in some of these parks because they back onto a lake but this area is still very much a developed part of the Berlin/Potsdam area.

We went there with a small group of people, got lake-side and people started taking their clothes off to swim naked in the lake. This was a group of male and female people, almost none of which were in any kind of intimate relationship with each other. And in the middle of the day, with streets nearby and many people walking around the park and surrounding area. It wasn't specifically designated as a nude swimming area, it was just a swimming area and some people swam nude, some didn't and neither caused any issues for anyone.

This is one example that I noticed while in Europe but there were more of these situations where nudity or sex were treated in just a very mature and reasonable way. Not as something that should be shunned and feared out of some kind of puritan obsession with the subject; which in its self I think is fuelled by deeply unsatisfied sexual desires.

gaelian··on WhiteHouse.gov petition to stop E-Parasite/SOPA
"This Section of our site is currently undergoing maintenance We appreciate your patience while we make some improvements Please check back shortly"

Page under heavy load?

gaelian··on Teaching Good Sex
Very much agreed. But I also think we're looking at the problem in a somewhat more isolated context than would be required to effect true improvement. By which I mean, if we are to achieve a safe, controlled environment to have open and honest communication about sex that includes some mature guidance, then a more systemic change in English speaking society as a whole is required. So rather than changes being effected at school, or at home, or somewhere else, I would suggest that change is needed at school and at home and in a wider sense across society.

Looking to existing attitudes and models in Europe might be a good starting point. Because what they do (especially the Scandinavians) works a hell of a lot better than what we do ("we" being English speaking people in general terms).

gaelian··on Teaching Good Sex
> The fully generalizable things you can teach would be communication, consent, and respect.

Agreed. But this is rather a different kettle of fish to what it appears the grandparent comment was suggesting.

> People would think they're dirty perverts for coming up with something that isn't in the standardized curriculum.

Exactly my concern. There's enough of this going on already without unwittingly enshrining it in some form of sanctioned sex education curriculum.

gaelian··on Teaching Good Sex
I find myself somewhat agreeing with the general sentiment of your final paragraph. But "I think it's about time we standardized it" is really rubbing me the wrong way (honestly, not pun initially intended). Either you don't mean that how it sounds or you are massively underestimating the variety of sexual activities that humans engage in and enjoy.

Just with the examples you give (common erogenous zones, sensing feedback, appropriate pressure) there are massive differences between what one person might find enjoyable compared to another. Can you expand on what you would have in mind?

gaelian··on How to work from home without going insane (purple monkey dishwasher)
I have experimented with Pomodoro, but for me it was actually more because I thought it might be a good way for me to remember to take breaks. I don't usually have the problem of not being able to sustain focus for long periods. Sometimes I do but more often than not, my problem is forgetting to take breaks, a habbit which - as I get older - I'm finding my body less forgiving of.

Whenever I read about people having trouble maintaining focus or I see people around me with the same issue, I wonder what it is about my life experience that may have made the difference. There's a few things that spring out to me:

  1. I was introduced to meditation at a young age
  2. I spent a lot of my youth playing pen and paper based RPGs
  3. I spent a lot of my youth reading novels when I wasn't playing pen and paper RPGs
  4. I spent a lot of my youth painting miniatures for table-top war games and playing said war games when I wasn't reading or playing pen and paper RPGs
A common thread I can see through all these activites is that one is using one's mind, one's imagination, more so than having images and entertainment thrust at you by a monitor or TV.

I believe these activities assisted in cultivating an improved ability to focus generally, and particularly to focus on tasks that are not immediately accessible. This focus has served me well in my professional life.

gaelian··on PHP needs to die. What will replace it?
Well said. Your second paragraph expands well on what I was thinking when I said we forget that beginners have a different idea of what 'trivial' means. The MVC concept (for example) might be trivial to those who get it, but it's likely seen as undesired friction by the beginner, while simultaneously being a good next step for them to acclimatise to should they be wishing to progress. Something that better facilitates this - or things like it - than what we currently have would be great.
gaelian··on PHP needs to die. What will replace it?
It really depends on the beginner I guess. It seems like what kemayo is saying is that there are beginner programmers and then there are people who don't want to be a programmer at all really, but might like the idea of having a dynamic year string printed in the footer of their page.

Those of us who have been working with computers for a long time - particularly those of us who write code - too easily forget what it's like to be that true beginner and often have a very different idea of what 'trivial' means compared to the beginner. What might barely be a speed bump for us can often be an insurmountable obstacle for them and I really wish I was better at remembering this more often.

gaelian··on Rails is not MVC
> It is awkward because Javascript is asynchronous and you want to make sure the user interaction stays responsive without devolving into spaghetti.

This is exactly the feeling I've been getting recently as I foray into writing my first Chrome extension. The asynchronous nature of XHR is ending up making my code a little more spaghetti-like that I would prefer. Would you happen to have any recommended resources for possible approaches to addressing this issue?

gaelian··on Google Chrome’s amazing growth spurt. The top web browser by June 2012?
My experience so far has shown that if you're looking for an exact one-to-one duplication of the FF experience, then yeah, Chrome's not there yet and possibly never will be.

Coming from FF I had this funny moment when I opened up the Chrome preferences menu and it opened in a tab, just like a web page (I assume because it is just a web page) and I thought "huh, that feels a little strange..." then I opened up some extension's options page and it was just a web page too and I thought "Actually, preferences and options as just plain web pages is really cool and intuitive after getting over the subtle shock of them not being in those little pop-up dialogs." It unifies things nicely and this approach is one of the reasons why extension development in Chrome can be made so intuitive for people already experienced with web technologies.

Regarding the slow performance of FF lately: I remember some months ago I had this situation where I was trying to debug a JS powered upload progress bar I was working on which relied on AJAX calls to update the length of the bar and it just wasn't updating or it would update once, then nothing until the very end when it would shoot to 100%. Watching in Firebug, AJAX calls were being made but seemingly nothing was coming back. I was stumped, I tried everything I could think of, until by chance I tried turning Firebug off and bam! My upload progress bar started working perfectly. JS in Firefox with Firebug on top of it was slow enough that the multiple AJAX calls needed by the upload progress bar weren't working properly anymore. Looking back, I think that day the seed was planted for my move to Chrome.

gaelian··on Google Chrome’s amazing growth spurt. The top web browser by June 2012?
I felt the same way as you. But a few weeks ago I moved to trialing Chrome as both my development and everyday browser. After close to 4 weeks now of trialing Chrome, I'm 99% certain that I won't be going back to FF for development and certainly not for everyday web browsing. I've now installed a total of 10 extensions into Chrome that well enough duplicate everything I had in FF (supporting my web dev and typical browsing activities). And bear in mind this is from a guy who has used FF for many years and was really looking for any excuse not to make the switch. But I gave it a chance and am actually quite surprised that Chrome has won me over.

The clincher for me was looking at Chrome extension development. The extension system for Chrome seems really accessible and well thought out and I feel like I could make some Chrome extensions for myself without really any hassle at all. In contrast, I have been told by acquaintances who have made FF add-ons that FF add-on development can be quite an unpleasant experience.

gaelian··on How I've started to contribute to open source
> It's funny. It really took me committing something to some open project to realize that all those programmers out there are actually all people like me.

My experience has been very similar. It's like I knew this intellectually, but it took me actually contributing to really internalise, get over the apprehension and realise that we are all just people.

Your comment also makes me think about all those years ago when I started commenting on online forums and how intimidating yet exciting it was for me to do so, even under a pseudonym. Putting one's self out there to strangers online as so many routinely do nowadays was not something that came naturally to me. It certainly seems to be coming more naturally to many of the younger generations now though.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →