HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gaelian

604 karma · joined October 1, 2010

I'm Gaelian Ditchburn, geek, developer, consultant, musician. I come from the land down under.

http://blog.binarybalance.com.au/

gaelian.ditchburn at that web based email service starting with "g".

submissionscomments
gaelian··on Lisp has too many parentheses...
dictionary.com seems to think you're kind of both right[1].

[1] http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/dorsal

gaelian··on Learn Python The Hard Way Now For Sale
For what it's worth, my vote would be for Learn C The Hard Way. Not having learned C in any formal setting and coming from a background of mainly interpreted languages, I've found it quite difficult to determine reliable, up to date resources for learning C. It's not that there's none around obviously, it's just hard to know which stuff to go with and hard to find something in between complete n00b and full master, which is what I'd be hoping for.
gaelian··on Web page assignment leads to cease and desist letter.
I would actually have found the C&D letter more convincing if it hadn't been so well written.

Still funny though.

gaelian··on New Look at Mystery Flashes Reported by Astronauts
Sorry about that. It was new to me and I my eye slipped right past the little date there.
gaelian··on Single input login form
I suspect 3rd party password managers and such similar features native to browsers would not cope well with this single input login form.

I also wonder about the accessibility issues that would be inherent. JS would seem to be a large part of getting this solution to function and that can be an issue for screen reader users for example.

My instinctual reaction is to think that this is a solution that causes more problems than it solves. But none the less, I like it when people challenge the status quo and propose something new. Sometimes it pays off, sometimes it doesn't but if no one ever did this, where would we be?

gaelian··on Ask HN: What's the deal with Steve Ballmer?
Stimulants?
gaelian··on How serial #s on Nazi tanks gave the Allies a big strategic advantage
For RoR, you can override to_param on the model in question, something like:

  class User < ActiveRecord::Base
    def to_param
      self.login
    end
    ...
  end
Assuming self.login is reliably unique. Although I've found this can still have some follow on effects that could need to be handled in a situation similar to the above. There are also some heavier weight, more feature filled options of course.
gaelian··on Mac OS X.7 "Lion" preview
I can indeed understand your sentiment also. Hence my description of my behavior bordering on something close to OCD. I think I get that "feeling of clutter" a lot more easily than many people :P

For whatever reason though, I guess I don't really reinstall apps very often. Once I decide to remove something, it's almost always after pondering the issue for a little while and making a decision that I very rarely go back on. The only time I can remember reinstalling something on my Mac was Filezilla. I got myself a new FTP client, removed Filezilla as I didn't think I'd be using it anymore and then found out that my new FTP client had a bug that prevented proper connectivity via FTPS. So I went back to Filezilla and as luck would have it, Filezilla's preferences are stored in ~/.filezilla and they were all still there (because I didn't know about this directory). That was a small time saver.

I suspect a great deal of my attitude towards being (likely overly) careful about what I install/uninstall and what's left behind afterwards comes from my many years as a Windows user. I remember it even took me a while to figure out that you can usually just drag stuff to the Applications folder to install on a Mac, I kept thinking to myself "I'm missing something, it can't be this simple..."

gaelian··on Mac OS X.7 "Lion" preview
I've been using Hazel with OS X for a while now to further facilitate my bordering on obsessive compulsive desire to keep my machine clean. Hazel takes care of preference files etc. that can be left over after trashing a piece of software on OS X.

I still remember the moment it dawned on me that my new Mac didn't have a registry, I think I almost shed a tear of joy.

gaelian··on The reverse job applicant
My two cents would be that it's almost always somewhere in between the two extremes you describe.

Certainly having experience with OO in one language will be an advantage when it comes to picking up another OO language but yeah, you're not 100% there. I would posit that you're more than 50% there, though (with this particular example). Understanding the OO concept is more important than the syntax.

You know what I find onerous when I think about learning a new language? It's not so much picking up the new syntax because a lot of the time I find that I can do that pretty quickly (at least if the paradigm between old and new language is not too disparate). It's picking up the ecosystem around the language:

How do I deploy an application written in language X? How do I package code written in language X (e.g. Ruby gems, Python eggs or whatever)? Which unit testing frameworks do I learn? What IDEs or text editors are usually used with language X? Documentation conventions and related software (e.g. rdoc)? What community resources are valuable, trustworthy and stable? etc.

When I first started learning Ruby (along with Rails, some years ago now) my web development experience mostly consisted of LAMP and ASP.Net. Deploying Rails apps seemed like such a massive hassle compared to PHP. Part of this was that Ruby as a web dev language was much newer than PHP and was still settling in, parts of it really were a hassle. But I came to realise that a big reason for the difference was that the two communities were conceptually coming at the issue of deployment from very different perspectives and a lot of the differences I was seeing were no accident, and not so difficult to grok when you understand the motivation behind them.

A lot of non-programmers don't get that there is usually a fair amount of transferable knowledge when it comes to picking up a new language that utilises similar concepts to one you already know. But I can also understand that some (probably most) employers want their staff to "hit the ground running" and may be looking for people with a very specific skill set.

Putting myself in the position of an employer and knowing what I do, I'd rather hire Person A that's obviously enthusiastic about learning new stuff, who's maybe contributed to something open source that can be reviewed, and who surely has some background knowledge that they can build on but who may not necessarily have language X listed on their resume, over Person B who does have language X on his resume but that's all they've really got. It would be good if more recruitment firms and HR departments started to realise that having the right acronym/keyword listed on your resume doesn't actually mean much on its own.

gaelian··on Steve Ballmer E-mail to Employees on Ray Ozzie Transition
"... Ray has played a critical role in helping us to assume the leadership position in the cloud ..."

Emphasis mine. Does this have any basis in fact?

gaelian··on Story behind the 'Do you use your real identity on Hacker News?' poll
Repost of my reply:

@Jacques: the last thing I was expecting in response to my post was a near incoherent rant from a disgruntled HN user. But yes, I'm glad that Mr Anonymous was able to so deftly demonstrate the downside of online anonymity and thereby reinforce the conclusion of my post. I don't think I've personally had any direct contact with you before now and I did not really have any preconceived opinion of you or your contributions to HN. But if it's between even handed and civil comments or over the top bitter trolling with a side of character assassination, that's not a hard choice.

gaelian··on Gap says it will keep classic logo
In that case, couldn't we just do away with domians and stick to IP addresses then? At least sans IP scarcity issues. :P
gaelian··on Should I take a Help Desk Job?
After some years of working in "enterprisey" environments, I've recently starting a partial transition into something a little more freelance and self determined. Always glad to hear from people who are on the same wave length. :)
gaelian··on Should I take a Help Desk Job?
Like you, I decided to get into IT kind of late. My first position in the IT industry was help desk support for a local and quite successful ISP. We did both sales and tech support. It was a very busy job with high call volumes, lots of shift work and the shortest legally required break times. Coincidentally enough, I also had a long commute to this job, though it was < 2 hours. After about three months I found a new position working in web design/development which was more like what I was wanting to do. This was lucky because shortly after I left, the local ISP was sold and everyone was told they could relocate across the country or lose their job.

I learned a lot from working help desk and don't regret doing the job at all, if nothing else, it was good to have something other than study on my resume. But I could tell even after three months I was already starting to burn out and was getting a bit sick of being treated more like a resource than a human being. In my experience, help desk workers tend to be treated as being pretty expendable and easily replaceable, whether this is actually the case or not.

My advice would be if you need a job now or feel that you might benefit from the experience of working a "real" job (assuming this is your first foray into a professional position), then take this help desk job. If you don't need a job now or don't feel the experience of this job would be helpful, don't take it. But either way keep looking for something that's more inline with what you're really after.

gaelian··on To truly become rich, you need to stop acting like it
My wife is involved in the wedding industry. Both she and I have commented at various times that if people invested less in their wedding day and more in their ongoing relationship after the day, they'd often be better off.
gaelian··on ATM Fraud at Aldi: Terminals modified in manufacturer's factory.
Had an experience with 3-D Secure just last week:

* SO asks me to buy some printer ink for her at a particular online store that sells such things, SO gives me her Visa card.

* I do the deed and while I'm checking out online I come to a page that tells me it has been detected that I am a part of the "Verified by Visa" program and that I will be redirected to a page to facilitate said verification by Visa.

* I'm redirected to a page that by the URL and branding I assume is owned by the bank that provides the merchant facilities for the ink cartridge website. This page partially loads but then dies because my NoScript Firefox add-on disallows the JS on the page. I'm left looking at a button that says something like "Click to enter your password" but due to JS being disabled, it does nothing when you click on it and even if it did, I would not know what password to enter. I do some Googling on Verified by Visa and how it might relate to our particular bank, but find very little other than pages filled with sales-speak on how Verified by Visa makes things more secure.

* Conversation ensues: Me: "Do you have a password for your Visa card?" SO: "Password? I have a pin number..." Me: "No I think it's different to your pin number" SO: "I have no idea what you're talking about." Temperature starts to rise as it's late and it's been a long day. Conversation escalates but is defused just in time before it goes nuclear.

* I enable JS, the page then reloads and errors out because now it's been detected that I've done something out of the ordinary flow and it's all bets off. I get back to the original ink cartridge website to find my shopping cart empty.

* I select all the products I want to purchase once more and not realising at this stage what Verified by Visa actually is and my tired and befuddled mind already convinced that the bank has enrolled my SO in some added security scheme and that she's forgotten that they gave her a password, I try using my own MasterCard to pay and find out that actually I hit the same thing, only with MasterCard it's called MasterCard SecureCode. Fortunately, Since I enabled JS last time, I get through it this time, interestingly without having to enter any password, even though the explanatory text on the page still tells me I will need to. This is lucky because I have no password for my MasterCard either.

* The next day, SO goes to the bank, the person behind the counter has no idea what Verified by Visa or MasterCard SecureCode actually is. They tell her they do not supply passwords for credit cards. SO calls me and asks me to explain what happened to the person at the bank, more frustration ensues. SO eventually finds someone at the bank who knows vaguely what she's talking about and he tells her that they don't supply passwords for credit cards, but that you should be able to set one up through the checkout process of this random, not particularly trusted website that she buys printer cartridges from.

* I do more research and find out that yes, this is all in fact 3-D Secure under different names and I now have a rough idea of what the deal actually is.

I'm going to have to put some of the blame for this whole cluster fuck onto myself because I'm meant to know about this stuff, I'm paranoid enough to be using NoScript and that night was not my most blindingly brilliant moment of deductive reasoning in general. But none the less, this was without a doubt the worst experience of eCommerce that I have had in all the years I have been buying stuff off the Internet. Regardless of the merit of 3-D Secure it's self, if this is the current state of its implementation then yeah, no thanks.

gaelian··on 82% aren’t passionate about their work
That post sounds kind of bitter, maybe a bad day? In any case, it's possible to be passionate while not being flaky or unreliable. In my world at least, passion is what keeps me paying attention to the details, coming in to work on time and interested in what I'm doing.

I guess my definition of "passion" is quite different to that used by this person.

← PreviousPage 6 of 6