HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gambling8nt

310 karma · joined May 2, 2007

submissionscomments
gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What was your first job?
13; personal tutor for another student at $20/hour.
gambling8nt··on HN: Like playing Go? Review my new site. It was a "weekend hack."
I'd recommend giving a quick overview of the Kyu/Dan ranking system and then asking people in line to estimate their rank if they don't know it.
gambling8nt··on Ever Downloaded a Copyrighted Song? You Owe Infinity Dollars
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strict_liability_(criminal)

For most minor and petty crimes (such as my examples in another comment; parking violations, drunk driving, etc.), mens rea is unneeded (in the US, at any rate). The question of what degree of mens rea is relevant for intellectual property theft is both open and relevant; simply saying that, for example, it should should require mens rea because larceny (theft) does ignores the fundamental differences between the two.

EDIT: Two clarifying points. First, there is legal language describing the mens rea necessary in intellectual property theft; however, there is not a significant body of case law interpreting exactly what it means. Second, the reason that you can't just copy the mens rea of larceny is that intent to commit larceny is the intent to deprive the rightful owner of the object, which is clearly not a factor in intellectual property theft.

gambling8nt··on Ever Downloaded a Copyrighted Song? You Owe Infinity Dollars
Assuming that a defendant must be caught and informed of the loss of their first two strikes (as versus being caught once for a least three instances of the crime, and losing them all at once), such a solution--if enforced effectively enough--is not terribly far from ideal (at least from what should be the RIAA's long term perspective), in that the emotional effect of having been caught twice ought to be a sufficient deterrent for any reasonable individual not to continue to illegally download music. That said, the third strike is still perhaps too stringent to actually be enforced, even as a bandwidth limiter rather than a complete disconnect, and the fear of enforcement is a crucial part of an effective deterrent.

I would be more inclined to suggest limitations on internet usage for 2^N months (or some reasonable facsimile) for an Nth offense.

Of course, any such scheme is dependent upon dramatically better enforcement, in much the same way that, due to ineffective and uneven enforcement, drug laws are not an effective deterrent.

gambling8nt··on Ever Downloaded a Copyrighted Song? You Owe Infinity Dollars
Not every crime requires intent; criminal action can occur purely through negligence--you don't have to have or prove criminal intent to get a ticket for running a stop sign or in order to get a parking ticket.
gambling8nt··on Ever Downloaded a Copyrighted Song? You Owe Infinity Dollars
The trick behind a fair and effective penalty for a crime is that there both has to be a realistic expectation of actual enforcement (there's no way a person can afford to pay $80k for a song unless their last name rhymes with Mates or Muffet, even if caught), and the expected value has to be obviously negative under most circumstances--that is, the probability of being caught times the expense must be much more negative than the value gained by committing the crime.

We can see this principle at work in the fines for things such as littering, illegal parking, and drunk driving. Individual instances of these crimes gain a person a small amount of value; the fines for being caught are around one or two orders of magnitude greater than this (at first--often repeat offenses raise the expense another order of magnitude in the form of either jail time or increased insurance costs), in line with the approximation of being caught a non-negligible fraction of the time.

By comparison, illegal file sharing has a vanishingly small chance of getting your life completely destroyed. The problem with this is two fold. First, it isn't at all calculable what the expected value is; there simply isn't enough data to accurately determine what the probability of getting caught from any single illegal act is. Second, the enforcement rate is sufficiently low that, even if it were reliably calculable, people would not emotionally treat it correctly--the same emotional detachment from strongly negative consequences occurs here as the one that makes people take other sorts of extreme risks such as teenage unprotected sex, extreme sports, and going to war as a foot soldier (note that I am not saying that these always have negative expected value; merely that people are not good at estimating these sorts of risks).

The problem the RIAA faces is that enforcement to the degree necessary for a lower level fine to create sufficiently negative expected value is a practical impossibility; there's no reasonable way to effectively catch and fine even 1% of file-sharers (a rough estimate of what order of magnitude of enforcement is necessary to make people effectively able to gauge the risk--such an enforcement rate would not stop illegal file sharing altogether, but it would at least slow it down, much like my other examples). The only long-term option is to change business models to one less completely invalidated by the advance of technology.

gambling8nt··on How to Retire On $500 Per Month
The biggest problem with the 6% figure is that it ignores inflationary pressure. If you're stuck with extremely low risk investments (as you are once retired), you should really be looking at levels around 1 to 2% over inflation. At 2% over inflation (long term rate around 5%), withdrawing 6% annually (growing the withdrawal amount to keep up with inflation), you'll only last about 20 years, assuming no mishaps. Withdrawing 4%, the commonly recommended value, lasts more like 35 years; the average American retirement isn't that long, but it has a significant increase in expenses at the end.
gambling8nt··on Microsoft appeals to poverty to get people download Internet Explorer 8
I expect they are more afraid of a single individual (or a concerted group of individuals, possibly going by the name "anonymous") downloading N copies for large values of N.
gambling8nt··on Ask HN: Have you ever felt inferior for not being from a name-brand college?
Most of these pro-rated tuition policies are very, very new; until very recently, even students at top schools were expected to take out loans to cover some medium-sized fraction of the tuition costs. By comparison, going to a rather good state school, I got paid a net of around $8k per year to go to college.

The financial equation is different for every person, but the value add of a name-brand school over a state school is typically a hard sell--for a motivated student a decent education is available everywhere.

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: Have you ever felt inferior for not being from a name-brand college?
I wouldn't say I've felt inferior. I've occasionally felt significant regret over my collegiate decision. But then I remember that most such people wind up paying $200k more than I did to go to college. Going to an MIT or Harvard might have gotten me somewhat better connections and opportunities, but it is difficult to see those as adding up to that large of a difference.
gambling8nt··on Google Squared is Live
I'm not sure how this is superior (or how anything along this line would ever make it superior) to getting the information via classical search...particularly since it is readily available, more complete, and more organized via wiki (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ABBA_discography). Can you think of any advantage this has?
gambling8nt··on Google Squared is Live
This doesn't seem to be consistent in the way it is trying to help me; for example, a search for "tympanuchus cupido" (the genus and species name of the greater prairie chicken) returns only phasianidae, the family to which prairie chickens belong. Meanwhile, a search for just "tympanuchus" (the genus, which includes more than just prairie chickens) returns Attwater's Prairie Chicken National Wildlife Refuge, which seems only tangentially related. Terms with multiple meanings (which is precisely what structured search is supposed to help with) don't seem to recognize this multiplicity--consider a search for "peripatetic", which is both the name of a school of ancient Greek philosophy (which is recognized in the results), and a term meaning wandering or itinerant (which is not recognized, even when the search is changed to "peripatetic definition"). Even the most straightforwardly categorical queries don't seem to work that well ("dungeons and dragons classes" returns a list that is neither complete, nor correct). Speaking of neither completeness nor correctness, if you think my query choices were a little too farfetched, consider the query "search engines"--it returns none of bing, Duck Duck Go, and cuil in the first 50 results (although, somewhat entertainingly, Yahoo is the first result and Google is the second).

Is there something I'm missing that this engine actually does well?

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: How to calculate if a box will fit through a hallway with a 90 degree turn
To solve the problem for an object with thickness, imagine shifting the wall on the inside of the turn in by a distance equal to the width of a box (with the corner expanding out to a semicircle), and then consider moving a line segment through the appropriately shrunken hallway.

Note that we're still being possibly inefficient, as we are not using our third available dimension; however, this is only relevant if the box is much longer in one direction than the other two (for example, if you were trying to carry a 2x4 around this corner).

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What do you eat?
7 grams a serving is plenty of protein, as you've suggested.

Recommended daily protein intake depends upon a person's height and gender, as well as a few other factors that tend to have small effects. For most adults, the theoretically ideal amount will fall somewhere around 40 to 50g of protein per day, with less for shorter women and more for taller men. Getting less than this can cause severe problems due to amino acid deficiencies (particularly when you always consume the same general protein source and it doesn't contain significant quantities of one or more of the amino acids you don't produce on your own), as well as muscular atrophy (exacerbated rather than improved by exercise, as an insufficient protein intake will prevent the microtears in your muscles from healing properly). Getting significantly more than this increases stress on your kidneys (although it has not been shown to solely lead to kidney failure) due to the larger quantities of nitrogen present in protein than other forms of food.

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What do you eat?
The key with preparing fish is that, unlike meat, it doesn't change color when it is done. Instead, you want the fish to flake (this verb will make sense if you try it) when you run a fork along it "across the grain". If you aren't confident the first time, use a recipe to get a general sense of how long it should take, and overcook it slightly, then slowly work your way back (on successive attempts) until you reach a point where you are comfortable with how well done it gets.

Once you are used to how the fish cooks, consider different flavorings, such as orange or pineapple juice (pretty much everybody starts with lemon), and onions (many people add black pepper to fish, I personally can't stand the stuff).

Unless you live close to where fish are caught (not just the coast, but particular parts of the coast for different kinds of fish), the only cheap fish available will come in a can. However, if, unlike the OP, you aren't interested in the cheapest healthy food available you can make a decent fish fillet with a little practice.

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What do you eat?
There are three primary aspects of a balanced diet to consider: (1) starches: in my experience, rice is the cheapest per calorie, when purchased in bulk. Other good choices in this category include pasta and barley. (2) vegetables: getting a variety of vegetables is important in one's diet; I typically get frozen, since I can't get to a supermarket often enough to get fresh. Note that vegetables should typically be either green or carrots to qualify; in particular, corn is a starch. (3) protein: your body can't function without consuming several amino acids you don't produce. My typical protein source is cheese, as this is cheaper per serving than meat. Also in this category are beans, soy, and tofu.

A typical meal where I live on the east coast (by which I mean, 80% of my lunches/dinners) consists of: $0.30 to $0.40 of pasta (1/3 to 2/5 of a pound, dry), $1.00 to $1.25 of vegetables (1/2 pound), $0.60 to $0.90 of cheese (2 to 3 servings), and occasionally seasonings.

Add in milk and cereal for breakfasts, plus costs of variations on this theme and occasional extras, and my monthly food budget works out to around $160.

Edited to indicate amounts associated with given costs.

gambling8nt··on [dead]
Jokes add noise, preventing the signal of regular discussion. The limited tolerance of jokes here isn't random, it's an effort to protect the importance and screen real estate of substantive discussion.
gambling8nt··on Obama proposes no capital gains tax on qualified small business stock
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_gains_tax_in_the_United_States

and, more generally en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_gains_tax

Briefly, in the US cap gains are taxed at a special rate separate from regular income; if you hold the associated asset for at least 6 months, this rate only applies to half the capital gains, and if you fall into a low enough income bracket, your rate is significantly reduced.

gambling8nt··on Poll: Male or female?
Part of what makes this sort of thing a touchy subject for so many people is that, in the event of this sort of process being practiced (1) men who aren't selected feel angry about the nature of the process instead of feeling that they need to improve themselves to improve their chances for the next round, and (2) women who are selected are sometimes (often?) demeaned by men as needing additional assistance in order to make the cut (this is contrary to a common view I have encountered; that this sort of thing is fundamentally victimless). People subject to either of these circumstances (or close to such a person) are likely to have strong feelings on this subject.

As to why I personally supplied such a detailed response; it's mostly an opportunity to procrastinate by trying to change some minds regarding an issue important to me instead of working on something I've been avoiding.

gambling8nt··on The Problem With Young Web Entrepreneurs
In addition to typically not commenting without reading the article, comments on HN overwhelmingly take the form of (1) expanding an argument (rare), (2) asking a question (less rare), or (3) expressing reasoned disagreement. Thus, the presence of an interesting article without comments that is at or near the top mostly indicates a reasonable level of agreement between what was written and the people on HN at the time.
gambling8nt··on Poll: Male or female?
Because PG has finite time, there are two fundamental possibilities at work here:

(1) PG can find more "great groups" that he would want to fund than he has the time to work with. This, I expect, is almost certainly the case; PG then has to determine which amongst these groups of founders with whom to work. The question becomes, what function of the group of founders selected should be maximized. If you "give an additional point or two for being female founded" then the function you are optimizing is not just a matter of competence and dedication--either you aren't actually altering your behavior towards female founded groups, or there is some sufficiently pathological example of groups being very similar in which there is a female founded group that is slightly less competent/dedicated than a male only group competing over one remaining slot, and the slot is given to the female group. If no such example ever occurs in practice, then there is no point in giving female founded groups "an additional point or two" since it never altered the decision.

(2) PG has more time available than "great groups" with whom to work. In this case, taking on additional groups simply because they are female-founded, in addition to being discriminatory, seems likely to be a net negative, assuming the original meaning to the term "great groups" was set to be at whatever level is necessary to have positive expected outcome.

Looking at this dichotomy another way, we can think of PG's time as a market resource. In the first case, it is scarce, and should sell to the highest bidders (those with highest expected value, measured as utility for PG). In the second case, it is abundant, and every consumer gets what they need/want. In reality, it is probably either directly scarce (falling into the first category), or made scarce by the presence of other high utility alternatives (e.g., spending time with his family).

In summary, there is no "in addition to" as far as criteria with respect to which you want to maximize. There can only be "instead of", or a (possibly zero) conversion factor.

As a side note, in another comment on this page (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=591537) PG noted that they don't ask the gender of founders when considering funding.

gambling8nt··on Poll: Male or female?
Simultaneous optimization of multiple functions is impossible in the general case. But if there is one function being optimized, then there is some trade-off being made, so that--to some extent--one parameter is being selected for instead of another.
gambling8nt··on Why it's hard to share the wealth
How do you propose we measure "power"?
gambling8nt··on Why it's hard to share the wealth
As a theist I have to disagree with your final point. The presence of order in our universe is very clearly necessary in order for us to be able to question the existence of order. That the weak anthropic principle is and always will be a sufficient explanation of the presence of order does not undermine my personal sense of faith, but nothing about the presence of order supports it.
gambling8nt··on Is Spatial Ability the "Geek Gene"?
I also think in this way; I typically describe it to technically inclined people as being kind of like thinking with a command line interface instead of a GUI, although the metaphor is rather imperfect.

More strangely (to most people with whom I have spoken), I often dream entirely without images--occasionally even as written prose.

Edit: Perhaps interestingly, this does not seem to harm my ability to do spatial inference, but I have essentially no long term image recall.

gambling8nt··on Unskilled and Unaware of It
The real takeaway from this data is not just that the below average half tends to significantly overestimate its abilities (although that is supported), or that the extremely effective tend to underestimate their abilities (also supported), but that, almost completely regardless of skill, people tend to estimate their own abilities to fall within the third quartile. To me, this seems like reasonable evidence for the otherwise anecdotal fact that (at least for some fields) those who are not themselves competent at a subject are poor judges of competency at that subject, since their primary tool for making skill assessments will be to assess the confidence others have in their skills.
gambling8nt··on Hacker News Disease
I think the problem is with the varying interpretations of "rapidly"; going from little or no background to an expert in a field might be "rapidly" done in 10 years if most people take 20.

The problem (which I agree exists) arrives when people fail to realize that even extremely rapid conversion of intelligence to knowledge does not make you an expert in many fields without years of fairly dedicated study.

gambling8nt··on Cash-Strapped State Schools Being Forced to Privatize
You're not considering that they also need to grow the endowment to keep up with inflation; their estimate seems to indicate an expected return of 2% over inflation--a more reasonable projection for long term conservative investment.
gambling8nt··on Ask HN: Why no sense of humor?
Continuing your musical analogy, a "discussion" without disagreement would be like a musical piece in which every instrument played precisely the same notes and every singer sang precisely the same words at the same time. In such a circumstance, the presence of additional people is largely irrelevant.

A sequence of arguments going back and forth between two people, on the other hand, are essentially the back and forth of a duet playing separate themes (that, ideally, mix at the end). While certain sorts of arguments are non- or counter-productive (analogous to internally discordant themes), the possibility of such things occurring does not imply that this mode is not superior to single-view discourse.

The fact that discussions center on points of disagreement is not an accident, and does not imply that there is not agreement regarding most things. Disagreements are simply the portion of a topic around which someone believes that there is more information that an outside observer should consider when formulating their beliefs, whereas when there is agreement no further information is necessary, so there is no value in transmitting more signal.

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: Why no sense of humor?
Coherent discussion IS a sequence of block and attack--thesis and antithesis--ideally (although rarely in practice) ending in some kind of resolution (synthesis). Comprehension without disagreement does not necessitate discussion or further remark; the best sign that you've written something of value that others have comprehended is when a comment is voted up without replies (the upvotes indicate value, and the lack of reply indicates agreement). Any other system would result in the overwhelming additional noise of a cacophony of "I agree"s with possible small variations.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →