HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gambling8nt

310 karma · joined May 2, 2007

submissionscomments
gambling8nt··on 19 year old from Florida commits suicide on Justin.tv
"Once you're broadcasting the fact that you're thinking about suicide on the net, it's only a matter of time."

Do you really think that every time someone talks about suicide on the internet that they are actually serious? Or even most of the time? Certainly I agree that a better support structure is needed, but talking about suicide on the internet may not necessarily be as much of a warning sign as you seem to think (a study on this would probably be reasonably insightful to the matter).

gambling8nt··on 19 year old from Florida commits suicide on Justin.tv
That doesn't necessarily make it any more real to the viewers. Do you feel personally connected with celebrities you see on television?
gambling8nt··on 19 year old from Florida commits suicide on Justin.tv
If someone hangs themselves from the tree in my front yard, is there an element of fault with me for supplying the tree?

Any effort to shift blame onto j.tv for this is little more than an over-reaction caused by a state of grief...while it is certainly understandable, it is equally indefensible.

gambling8nt··on Video Game Helps Math Students Vanquish an Archfiend - Algebra
The pace of such games is too low to be interesting or effective.

Also, students of this age will be more inclined to guess if you include any sort of graphical cues at all.

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
In spring of 2005 I did a back of the envelope calculation on the total cost to produce the mass of carbon nanotubes needed for an elevator with cross-section of 1 cm^2 using the methods available then and got a result of about 1.25 quadrillion dollars--a sum truly large enough to be meaningless. It appears there have been several significant advances since then, including the revision of the intended cross-sectional area downward, and improvements in the production costs.

And my estimate on costs was precisely in the vein of "next year make an elevator"--I do not doubt that there will be a space elevator long before the next 50 years pass, I merely doubt that $700b is sufficient that a feasible short term effort could be made.

A lunar elevator, while a nice proof of concept for a terrestrial space elevator, has two major problems: (1) There isn't really a point; the moon's gravity well is too weak for it to be worth it to construct an elevator any time soon. (2) Getting the material there without an existing terrestrial space elevator (and possibly even with one) is a prohibitively expensive exercise.

Research into the construction of a space elevator is a worthwhile pursuit likely to result in many useful technological advances. But $700b is not enough to construct one in the short term from existing technology, and is too much to be usefully applied to further research.

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
Or, for other means of comparison, $700b is about:

87 next generation aircraft carriers (or about 155 current-generation aircraft carriers)

500 stealth bombers (or 5000 stealth fighters)

10 years of federal education spending in the US

1.1% of the worldwide annual GDP

2/5 of the combined net worth of the 100 wealthiest people (or, if you prefer, 12 times the net worth of Bill Gates, or about 1/6 of the combined net worth of the 1000 wealthiest people)

23 times the total annual income tax collected from the lower 50% of filers with positive adjusted gross income in 2006 (see http://www.taxfoundation.org/news/show/250.html)

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
On the contrary; an incompetent leader is easier to manipulate, and therefore more likely to be favored by whatever secondary powers arise as the fascist nation stagnates.
gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
The problem with estimating the net worth of the Catholic church is that an overwhelmingly large fraction of its wealth is in buildings (the many churches it owns throughout the world), real estate (the land those churches are built on, plus the Vatican), and art. That said, this article (http://www.zenit.org/article-1900?l=english) gives some indication of the magnitude of their income/expenditures.

Note: Most of the figures in the attached article are in lire, with a conversion rate of 2000 lire to 1$US--the annual in and outflow of the Catholic church is on the order of hundreds of millions of $US; it is only their total assets that are on the order of trillions.

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
Family size for $50k to qualify under the federally mandated definition of poverty is 12.

In fact, $50k is approximately the median household income (for 2007), with mean household sizes in that income bracket at about 2.6.

gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
$700b is almost certainly insufficient to do this; the Catholic church has around 4 times this amount by itself (most of it is illiquid, though--a large fraction is in real estate).
gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
Spoiler Alert: If you wait long enough, all fascist countries are eventually run by retards.
gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
The only one of these you could afford for $700b is Equatorial Guinea... :P
gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
With a $700b loan, it wouldn't exactly be failing any more...that's sort of the point of this whole exercise.
gambling8nt··on Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
$700 b is not nearly enough to make a space elevator with existing technology; you're off by about a factor of 1000.

Of course, if you're willing to wait ten years for the cost to produce carbon nanotubes to drop...

gambling8nt··on Einstein versus Peer Review...
"It is well known" is shorthand for "I don't want to bother figuring out the correct original reference for it", not "the average layperson knows this".
gambling8nt··on Have idea, need coder (comic)
It's 99% making something people want; the sorts of projects in question are rarely something anyone actually wants.
gambling8nt··on Smart-people traps
I don't agree that whenever there is a power imbalance, one side will get "fucked over". Indeed, the whole idea of having a market is that people are mostly equal in terms of power (read Hobbes' Leviathan). It's only when power imbalances are so gross that they're obvious that one side is guaranteed to get "fucked over".
gambling8nt··on What a Space Shuttle launch looks like from a plane [video]
Spacecraft launches are much more impressive when viewed up close (2ish miles away) and in person. No video can do justice to the feeling of the wave of heat washing past you after ignition, or to the incredible sense of scale and speed involved.
gambling8nt··on How your behaviour can change your children’s DNA
It directly affects his social conditioning, which in turn affects the lifestyle advice he imparts to his descendants.
gambling8nt··on How your behaviour can change your children’s DNA
None of the phenomena referenced in this article are particularly new; all are well explained by fetal hormonal effects and social conditioning, without reference to epigenetics.
gambling8nt··on In the Basement of the Ivory Tower
That is because, unlike most authors, Tolkien was actually trying to put symbolism into his work--he wasn't trying to just write a novel; he was telling an epic. Being a linguist, he recognized that, in the many retellings of an epic, small embellishments are added in order to provide side stories and submorals.
gambling8nt··on Play this game for 20 minutes - learn about concurrency
You need both blocks down there.
gambling8nt··on Ask cperciva: Are great mathematicians born or made?
I don't agree with your choice of cutoff age--certainly it is correct that the historical figures who had made the largest contributions to the field of mathematics have done so while quite young--indeed, the prime ages for developing new mathematics seem historically to be between 17 and 23--but there is nothing to suggest predestination regarding the matter at age 5. Also, given the level of specialization involved with some open problems (and the overwhelmingly large amount of data involved in all of mathematics), it is certainly possible that someone deeply specializing in an aspect of mathematics not "popular" at the time could make a non-negligible contribution to mathematics even if they started late in life, and were less "smart" than their "prodigy" peers.

If you start mathematics late in life, you are extraordinarily unlikely to find your name on a list with names like Gauss, Newton, and Archimedes. Nor will you likely reach any sort of par with Euler, Hilbert, or Russell. Indeed, even the levels of Conway, Shannon, and Wiles are probably unattainable. But math is a huge field now, and there are parts of it that most young mathematicians find boring, or simply aren't exposed to. If you find some such part that you like, you can probably make some progress.

gambling8nt··on Join NASA return to the moon
I would say that this isn't really hacker news...but it's actually a fairly clever social hack to try to calculate how many people are interested in NASA's return to the moon.

EDIT: It would be nice if the input form were a secure page though.

gambling8nt··on The Disadvantages of an Elite Education
The ability to do these sorts of competitions is a learned skill like any other. Certainly, it is a learned skill that has some relation to research ability within mathematics, but neither tests, nor grades, nor classes are the be-all or end-all of skill measurement tools. If you can solve half the questions, you have enough logical ability to accomplish anything short of beating cperciva at a math competition. The true mark of skill is to go use that to create something new--anything else is just practice.
gambling8nt··on Confirmed: Ice on Mars. News broken by Twitter.
Blown out from the bottom of a trench? Without the trench getting filled in?
gambling8nt··on June 19, 240 B.C.: The Earth Is Round, and It's This Big
He came much later; in particular, he lived shortly after Archimedes, whose existence doubtless steals much of his thunder.
gambling8nt··on June 19, 240 B.C.: The Earth Is Round, and It's This Big
Actually, Aristarchus, a contemporary of Eratosthenes (slightly earlier in fact) determined the ratio distance to the sun/distance to the moon to be about 20 (actual answer is about 390), and that the distance to the moon was about 20 Earth radii (although Archimedes credited him with an approximation closer to 80 Earth radii; the actual value is about 60). This would have validated any assumption about the sun being far enough away to generate essentially parallel rays.

Incidentally, the fact that the world was round was probably already known by Eratosthenes' time, since the Greek society was essentially a group of seafarers, and when you watch a ship go out to sea, in addition to appearing smaller as it gets further away, it also appears to sink downwards. They would doubtless have noticed this, and concluded that the Earth was probably round.

gambling8nt··on Firefox 3 smart bar is just too smart
His problem is that he has to go through a lot more effort because under FF2, etc., he only had to type a few letters from the beginning of the URL in order to get where he was going.
gambling8nt··on "The singularity is a religious rather than a scientific vision"
The Turing Test is not an element of the singularity--it pre-exists the idea of the singularity by a sizable margin, and was an effort to define the idea of artificial intelligence. I would certainly encourage people who wish to believe in the coming singularity to set similar concrete goals for their vision of the future. But, even then, the idea of the singularity will not be science--although the specific, falsifiable claims might be.

Claims made in 1994 that the internet would change the world were not science (although some specific claims might have been)--this does not make them useless or wrong. It isn't a scientific claim that the Mona Lisa is a good painting, or that dogs are loyal. But most people would agree with both of these statements.

Most predictions (ignoring those of incredibly limited scope) about the future are unscientific. This, by itself, does not make them false. But trying to pretend to be science is rarely a good sign.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →