HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gambling8nt

310 karma · joined May 2, 2007

submissionscomments
gambling8nt··on RIP, Tim Russert
Clinton's concession was not simply damaging because it wasn't hacker news--stories of that nature threaten hacker news as a whole.

(1) A story about Clinton's concession contains no information content. Everyone at all tracking politics knew it was coming, and anyone who cared about when it happened could have predicted the timing reasonably well in advance. Tim Russert dying is a story with no hacker news content, but it is at least some information--I sincerely doubt anyone was predicting Russert's imminent demise.

(2) A story about Clinton conceding is divisive to the community. It brings up a topic of discussion unrelated to the topic that brings this community together, and, given the tendency of some people to downvote in order to indicate disagreement, ultimately increases the homogeneity of the viewpoints expressed here. Most people do not find Russert's death nearly as divisive. Regardless of what you think of the quality of Russert's interviews, historical trends tend to indicate that he will be replaced by someone worse at it.

(3) A story about Clinton's concession reminds everyone of how Reddit came to be what it is. This sort of story is relatively benign in this respect.

(4) The story about Clinton conceding--if it had been popular--brings the baggage of continual political stories in its wake. If every time a major media figure dies there is a single HN story about it, HN is not incredibly damaged by this.

gambling8nt··on "The singularity is a religious rather than a scientific vision"
Specific claims with specific dates are falsifiable, but saying that there will be a singularity in the next 40 years is insufficiently specific (without carefully defining the term singularity, which very few singularitarians do), and proponents of such claims have a tendency to push back their prediction dates as the time when those predictions will need to come true approaches (AI, flying cars, the end of the world, etc.). It is the lack of specificity, both in the conditions of falsehood and in the time frame, that renders the singularitarians' claims as unscientific.
gambling8nt··on "The singularity is a religious rather than a scientific vision"
Perhaps not, but the absence of falsifiable claims means that this case isn't scientific.
gambling8nt··on Is EF the New IQ?
Like IQ, EF is creating a self-fulfilling prophecy with regard to success and failure. IQ was used to justify the failure of some students relative to others--so the students with a reason why they were allowed to fail did so, and the teachers paid more attention to the students expected to succeed, so that they did so.

EF, being a measure of "mental discipline" (read: obedience + creativity) separates the students that teachers typically like to teach from those that teachers typically do not. But the students that teachers like to teach are the ones that they focus on, so those students do well academically. Presto--instant self-fulfilling prediction.

Of course, this implies no correlation at all with what it takes to do well outside of these sorts of environments.

gambling8nt··on Ask YC: Math problems
If you are looking for a physical book, try Problem Solving Strategies (http://www.amazon.com/Problem-Solving-Strategies-Problem-Boo...) or Problem Solving Through Problems (http://www.amazon.com/Problem-Solving-Through-Problems-Larso...).
gambling8nt··on Post your proofs: Given five points on a sphere, four of them lie on a closed hemisphere.
Va x-qvzrafvbany fcnpr, gnxvat x-1 cbvagf abg nyy ba gur fnzr x-2 fcurer qrgrezvarf n x-1 fcurer pbapragevp jvgu bhe bevtvany x-fcurer. Fhpu n x-1 fcurer qvivqrf bhe bevtvany x-fcurer vagb gjb x-urzvfcurerf (vs lbh qba'g oryvrir guvf, fvzcyl er-bevrag lbhe onfvf fb gung bar qverpgvba vf begubtbany gb gur x-1 fcurer; gur gjb x urzvfcurerf ner gura gur cbvagf ba gur x-fcurer jurer guvf pbbeqvangr vf abaartngvir, naq gur cbvagf ba gur x-fcurer jurer guvf pbbeqvangr vf abacbfvgvir. Ohg gura vs jr jnag y cbvagf va bhe x-urzvfcurer, jr pna thnenagrr gurve cerfrapr vs jr unir 2(y-(x-1)-1 = 2y-2x+1 cbvagf yrsg. Ohg guvf vf gur fnzr nf fgnegvat jvgu 2y-x cbvagf ba gur fhesnpr bs gur fcurer va x-qvzrafvbany fcnpr, fb gung vf gur zvavzhz ahzore jr arrq gb thnenagrr (hfvat guvf nethzrag) y bs gurz ba n pybfrq x-qvzrafvbany urzvfcurer. Abgr gung guvf erfhyg zngpurf gung bs gur 3-qvzrafvbany pnfr.

Gur vagrerfgvat cneg bs guvf erfhyg vf abg qverpgyl jung vg fnlf, ohg jung vg fnlf nobhg fcnprf jr pna rzorq va gur fhesnpr bs n x-qvzrafvbany fcurer...gung 2y-x cbvagf va fhpu n fcnpr ner pbirerq ol gur cer-vzntr (haqre gur rzorqqvat) bs n urzvfcurer--sbe rzorqqvatf jvgu avpr-ybbxvat cer-vzntrf bs urzvfcurerf, guvf pbhyq pbaprvinoyl npghnyyl or n hfrshy erfhyg.

Edit: Vs lbh pna'g pubbfr fhpu n frg bs x-1 cbvagf, gura nyy lbhe cbvagf snyy ba gur fnzr x-2 fcurer, juvpu pna or rkgraqrq gb n x-1 fcurer gung vf hfrq nf n obhaqnel orgjrra gjb x-urzvfcurerf; nyy lbhe cbvagf ner ba gur obhaqnel bs obgu.

gambling8nt··on Post your proofs: Given five points on a sphere, four of them lie on a closed hemisphere.
12 questions, not 10, and this one seems relatively easy; I immediately saw the construction for andrewf's answer, which is actually the same as cperciva's answer because gur cynar cnffvat guebhtu gjb cbvagf naq gur pragre bs gur fcurer zrrgf gur fcurer ng gur terng pvepyr bs naqerjs'f pbafgehpgvba.
← PreviousPage 5 of 5