HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gamerdonkey

340 karma · joined October 3, 2013

submissionscomments
gamerdonkey··on The Palantir app helping ICE raids in Minneapolis
My bad. Thanks for clarifying.
gamerdonkey··on The Palantir app helping ICE raids in Minneapolis
Ah, my bad. That does seem to lower the stakes a bit.
gamerdonkey··on The Palantir app helping ICE raids in Minneapolis
> As an example: a an African American janitor in our kids' school voted republican in 2024 for the first time in his life, because the park in his Brooklyn neighborhood has become a shanty town and he can't work out there.

Okay, first off, I am just very confused by this sentence. How is the "shanty town" preventing him from working? Does he work from his home in Brooklyn? Is the school located in the park? Does he want to work in the park but is force to work at the school? I know this isn't the most important part, but I haven't been able to parse the story. Edit: others explained that this is "work out" there, and not related to being a janitor. Thanks. I feel the rest still stands.

Further, I don't understand how what is happening is supposed to solve the "underlying issue". How does 3000 federal agents breaking windows and shoving people in Minneapolis help a Brooklyn community poor enough to become a shanty town? It would be like if I, in my job, had an backend outage on our website, and I went to the design team and began berating them while I fixed a couple UI issues. Sure, I might solve some real problems, and it could feel good in some cathartic way (especially if I've had unanswered complaints for years). But I wouldn't call it "fixing the underlying issues".

I believe it is most likely that the people who still support this style of enforcement have been hurt much like you, some acutely but many just slowly over time, and have bought into the idea that some "other" is at fault. And they want to see that "other" dealt with in some way, any way. Even if it means people get hurt, because they themselves have been hurt. So why not the "other"?

But I don't believe a shanty town in the most populous city what is supposed to be the richest and most prosperous country on Earth is caused by the poorest few percent of people living here. I don't think an illegal immigrant in Minneapolis is at fault, even if they have a "criminal background" (insidious phrasing that inflates numbers by lumping in people who may have paid their debt to society). I don't want to see people hurt.

gamerdonkey··on My article on why AI is great (or terrible) or how to use it
The gambling analogy has been brought up before.

https://pivot-to-ai.com/2025/06/05/generative-ai-runs-on-gam...

gamerdonkey··on 2025 Was Another Exceptionally Hot Year
I have many questions about your methodology:

- How many stations were you left with?

- Did that number decline over time (as you excluded replacement stations)?

- What was your scale?

- Are you willing to share your results?

- How is this still the top comment after 30 minutes?

But your comment touches on a common misconception, which is that heat islands must be excluded to accurately measure the overall temperature. You refer to the idea as "heat-producing objects", but I would argue that a parking lot is more of a heat reflecting object. More to the point, even heat islands must be considered as part of the worldwide climate, simply because they are part of this wide world. Their heat does not simply disappear (I hope you agree that would violate physics).

Imagine we want to measure the average temperature inside a single 30-foot by 10-foot room during winter. We have two probes: one near a burning fireplace on one end of the room, and one near a window on the other. If we excluded data from one probe or the other, do you believe we would get an accurate average reading?

Of course, when scientists are calculating a global temperature, they have to handle special cases in the data (like heat islands). This has been known for some time, and you can read more about it here: https://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/07/no-ma...

I fear that I've spent too much time responding to this, but I wanted to take it on in earnest.

gamerdonkey··on 2025 Was Another Exceptionally Hot Year
Basically every country has been conducting a massive geoengineering project in the open for the past decades by releasing billions of tonnes of CO2 (and other greenhouse gasses) into the atmosphere. We've been able to detect that, yes.
gamerdonkey··on Hi, it's me, Wikipedia, and I am ready for your apology
Do you happen to remember any of the articles where you performed this experiment? I ask because specifically around 5 years ago, I know there were a number of cartoons where the creators intentionally wrote characters with queer representation in mind (She-Ra is the first to come to mind). So, if the sections you were removing had been properly cited and relevant to the actual series, then the removal for being "nothing more than attempts to use those articles to push a 'queer' viewpoint on the subject matter" probably did not represent a neutral viewpoint.

Of course, this depends on you opening up your research to some peer review.

gamerdonkey··on Hi, it's me, Wikipedia, and I am ready for your apology
Did you fix them?
gamerdonkey··on You are the scariest monster in the woods
Those are examples that are discussed in the article, yes.
gamerdonkey··on Discord says 70k users may have had their government IDs leaked in breach
Everyone, please, don't fight.

It's both.

The companies wouldn't have this specific data if it wasn't for the age verification laws. Companies also work to amass as much private data as possible about their users without any influence from government and are often not good stewards of it.

Let's also not forget that companies like Discord often support and work with governments on these kind of laws because they prefer a consolidated regulatory structure and it has the added benefit of making life more difficult for smaller competitors that may enter the space.

gamerdonkey··on AirPods live translation blocked for EU users with EU Apple accounts
They are complying in the same way that the rich kid who keeps getting called out for using his hands on the football (soccer) field complies with the rules by taking his ball and going home.
gamerdonkey··on Open Source is one person
I didn't see it explicitly stated, but I think it supports the "overworked" part of this statement:

> Open source, the thing that drives the world, the thing Harvard says has an economic value of 8.8 trillion dollars (also a big number). Most of it is one person. And I can promise you not one of those single person projects have the proper amount of resources they need. If you want to talk about possible risks to your supply chain, a single maintainer that’s grossly underpaid and overworked. That’s the risk. The country they are from is irrelevant.

gamerdonkey··on In a first, Google has released data on how much energy an AI prompt uses
I don't know why, but it always irks me when a corporation puts out a document like this cosplaying as peer-reviewed research, and they don't bother to put in even a lip-service "conflict of interest" disclosure. I should expect it at this point.
gamerdonkey··on Retro gaming YouTuber Once Were Nerd sued and raided by the Italian government
I'm pretty sure the post you're replying to was referring to "legit ways" as in the purchase would be actually from the current rights holder. Buying on the secondary market comes with its own problems:

1. The people who made-- er, own the rights to the game get no financial benefit. Functionally, what is the difference to EA if I download a copy of NFS: Underground, or if I buy a copy from some rando on eBay? Yes, the courts care, but it's not exactly like I'm supporting the artists.

2. You are not guaranteed a legitimate copy. eBay sellers will ship duplicated discs all the time, whether contemporary copies or ones made recently to meet the demands of retro gaming. Can you claim you got duped and offload your moral responsibility to the seller? Maybe. But you could still be a pirate.

3. Copyright law is complicated, and you might still be pirating if you do get a legitimate copy. The arcade cabinet is a great example. Did the seller own it outright, or was it on a lease that got abandoned when the game was no longer profitable? In the latter case, your purchase would not be covered by the US first-sale doctrine. So you could spend £4095 and then may as well hoist the jolly roger.

4. The used game market is a long-standing problem currently being solved by games publishers. It will not be long before there are no old CDs of retro games available because they never existed in the first place.

I've just always been weirded out when people hold up gray market purchases of used media as some paradigm of moral responsibility. It's like a financial transaction with the transfer of physical media is some magical incantation that erases all questions of ownership.

gamerdonkey··on The Monster Inside ChatGPT
Ooh, fun metaphor!

Mirrors are not entirely passive objects. Tinting, fog, and scratches affect the quality of their reflection. They can be tilted and turned to reflect a different angle of ourselves or another object entirely. Depending on their shape, they can present a near-perfect image, a distorted view, or they can focus light into a destructive point of intense energy.

gamerdonkey··on FICO to incorporate buy-now-pay-later loans into credit scores
The current default is that missing a rent payment can harm your credit score, but paying on time will never improve it.

https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/can-late-rent-pa...

This benefits the landlords for the reasons you outlined, and tenants must interact with the credit industry through additional (often predatory) means in order to build a credit history that may allow them to buy their own home. Further, landlords have an incentive against providing this positive feedback, as doing so makes it more likely that tenants would exit a relationship that is profitable to the landlord.

gamerdonkey··on On loyalty to Your Employer
> And most people I know and see do drop work for family and friends ever so often as much their situation permits.

Your experiences today may well be the result of this idea becoming more and more pervasive over the past 30 or so years, and the resulting reduction in employee loyalty to their employers.

gamerdonkey··on Master the Art of the Product Manager 'No'
I expect anyone within earshot who cares about me to put me down if I ever used any of these phrases in a serious context.
gamerdonkey··on Scientific American's departing editor and the politicization of science
> There was never any scientific basis for that belief.

This is an incorrect statement that can be fixed with minutes of research.

https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.0610941104 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00916...

One might argue about the quality of the research or point out contradicting studies, but saying there was zero basis is flat-out false.

Adding that the idea was "made up" is a great example of bending the idea of science to prop up a point.

gamerdonkey··on Trucks Are Killing Us
This system sounds an awful lot like the freight rail system. That seems like it would be easier to automate, too.
gamerdonkey··on How Beats Tricks You into Thinking It Makes a Premium Product
Depends heavily on your peers.
gamerdonkey··on How I became a drug cheat athlete to test the system
I think we can get a fair idea of what would happen by looking at the two unrestricted auto racing divisions: Group B and Can-Am.

Group B was a basically unrestricted class in the World Rally Championship. This series was initially very well received by fans, and the manufacturers produced cars that are still legendary to this day. However, in only 4 years, costs of remaining competitive ballooned, and the teams with the deepest pockets were the teams that could dominate. Sadly, the entire class of cars was banned after a series of accidents caused many competitor and spectator casualties. I don't believe this would be the result of unrestricted Olympians, as few events pose a direct risk of grave injury to athletes or fans.

Can-Am, on the other hand, lasted some 8 years in its unrestricted form. Unlike rally, it was run on closed race courses, so safety was easier to keep in check than on the winding rural roads of rally. Like Group B, it started out popular with racing fans, and the unrestricted nature allowed manufacturers and teams to innovate faster and faster. The only restriction was funding. Again, the teams with the deepest pockets began to dominate, and competition suffered because of it. Teams pulled out, and public interest dwindled. The last scheduled race wasn't even run.

gamerdonkey··on Let Snowden Come Home
Sadly, things are not often so cut and dry.

What are you feelings about spying that is ostensibly international but nonetheless collects a potentially large, though unknowable, amount of intimate domestic communication? I ask because that is exactly the kind of thing that happens with the "Foreign Intelligence" programs Snowden leaked.

> [...] Section 702 of FISA Amendments Act of 2008, is labeled "Procedures For Targeting Certain Persons Outside The United States Other Than United States Persons." Going on name alone, that sounds like the opposite of a license for the NSA to collect private messages between Americans.

> Not necessarily.

> [...]

> Through those spying programs, it is possible that American-to-American email could hit an overseas server and be pulled into NSA databases even though those emails are not the target of NSA searches. The law does not prohibit this kind of "incidental" collection of Americans’ communications, as long as it was part of an otherwise valid collection of non-Americans’ information, said Stephen Vladeck, American University national security law professor.

> Government reports, leaks and a scathing 2011 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court opinion offer more proof that the NSA cannot separate out communications between Americans from the emails involving a foreigner. "NSA’s knowing acquisition of tens of thousands of wholly domestic communications through its Upstream collection is a cause of concern for the court," wrote FISC Judge John D. Bates in the declassified opinion.

http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2015/apr/09/...

gamerdonkey··on The Unrealized Horrors of Population Explosion
Not to say that this is concrete evidence or to lend any credence to The Limits of Growth predictions, but there are at least some concerns about overfishing the oceans and a possible collapse there.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/10/29/j...

gamerdonkey··on Why are interest rates so low?
I would say that outright dismissing any concept is not an answer.

I do have a problem with equating greed to innovation and cultural growth. Greed, in economic terms, optimizes only for the accumulation of wealth. Many technological and cultural advances would do nothing to amass wealth and would be missing in a society focused solely on economic growth.

gamerdonkey··on Pulling the Curtain on Airport Security [pdf]
Unfortunately, studies have found that police homicides are under-reported to the FBI's national database.

http://www.npr.org/2014/08/21/342228794/ferguson-turns-lens-...

gamerdonkey··on Judge Sentenced to 28 Years for Selling Kids to the Prison System (2013)
Yeah, I thought the post you replied to was confusing profit guarantees, but apparently not.

http://truth-out.org/buzzflash/commentary/prison-populations...

http://www.inthepublicinterest.org/sites/default/files/Crimi...

gamerdonkey··on Tech Blogger Tries To Cancel Comcast Service, Hilarity Ensues
Maybe Ryan read down to 9 b (3):

"you may terminate this Agreement for any reason at any time by notifying Comcast in one of three ways: [...] (3) call our customer service line during normal business hours"

gamerdonkey··on Anti-Tesla sentiment and the death of optimism
Unfortunately, I don't have time for a more detailed response. http://shrinkthatfootprint.com/electric-cars-green
gamerdonkey··on Raptor robot runs at 28.58 mph, faster than any human [video]
I'm going to reply to your comment, as it's currently on top, but several of the top comments have this same sentiment.

I don't think it's fair to criticize this project harshly because the robot has external power and a supporting arm to keep it from damaging itself. The research and development was clearly about the design and actuation of the legs, and the researches have clearly done well on that front. To require them to provide onboard power for a system that they don't even know the requirements for is a little much, in my opinion.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →