HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gamerdonkey

340 karma · joined October 3, 2013

submissionscomments
gamerdonkey··on Rat Park drug experiment cartoon
The two followup studies do disagree with the original Rat Park experiment, but I think you inadvertently misrepresent their results by cutting off your quote mid-sentence.

> The results of earlier research, indicating rats housed in a quasinatural colony drank significantly less sucrose-morphine than rats isolated in standard laboratory cages, could not be replicated, as the consumption of sucrose-morphine by the isolated animals in the present two studies was reduced. [emphasis added]

Without that last bit, the reader is left with the impression that all rats were highly addicted regardless of their environment, but the results were the opposite. All rats were less addicted than expected, regardless of their environment. Again, you're correct that the updated studies refute the original, but I feel like that distinction is important in a discussion that centers around addiction more than just the Rat Park experiment.

Additionally, the abstract notes that the latest studies may have been biased by a strain of rats that is less prone to addiction that those used by the Rat Park study. You noted in another reply that this indicates genetics play more of a role in addiction than environment, but this also calls into question any inferences about human addiction that are based on rat studies which do not include an analysis of the specimens' genetic predisposition toward addiction.

Finally, research that supports the result of the Rat Park does exist [1]. Studies have found isolated mice are less resistant to addiction compared to those living in stimulating and social environments [2][3]. Another study found that rats isolated in key parts of their development are more prone to alcohol and amphetamine addiction in adulthood [4]. Based on the latter example, the effects of environment on addiction may be more nuanced that the Rat Park experiment would suggest.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park#Related_research

[2] http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0014488607...

[3] http://www.jneurosci.org/content/23/35/10999.full

[4] http://www.utexas.edu/news/2013/01/23/socially-isolated-rats...

gamerdonkey··on Oracle wins Android-Java copyright appeal
Days like this are when I really miss Groklaw. I refuse to click on a link to FOSSPatents, and I don't have another reliable source for tech-legal news.
gamerdonkey··on World’s Largest Solar Array Set to Crank Out 290 Megawatts of Sunshine Power
I meant that the examples benefit oil, gas, and nuclear overwhelmingly as opposed to the renewable sectors in the report. I'm sorry if that wasn't clear.

Obviously, a program that applies to all companies will see more expenditures for the oil and gas companies because they exist in a larger and more established industry. That is still tax-payer money being spent to encourage growth in that sector, and much less, comparatively speaking, is being spent in those sectors than on renewables.

Thus, I find it a little disingenuous to roll out that 10x factor which ignores a lot of subsidization for an industry which many would argue doesn't need much more encouragement.

gamerdonkey··on World’s Largest Solar Array Set to Crank Out 290 Megawatts of Sunshine Power
Renewable energy sources are seeing tons of direct subsidies. However, quoting those numbers in a discussion like this can be a little misleading because of the disclaimer on page ix of that report titled "Not All Subsidies Impacting the Energy Sector Are Included in this Report"

> This report only includes subsidies meeting the following criteria: they are provided by the federal government, they provide a financial benefit with an identifiable FY 2010 federal budget impact, and, they are specifically targeted at energy. These criteria, particularly the energy-specific requirement, exclude some subsidies that benefit the energy sector. Some of the subsidies excluded from this analysis are discussed below.

The examples that they list overwhelmingly benefit oil, gas, and nuclear energy sectors.

gamerdonkey··on Gimli Glider
Hoods blockage up is a comparatively common event in rally races. I've read that many teams specifically design the hood to leave a large gap if it flips up, thus allowing the driver to continue down the stage. This happened to a top driver at the latest Sno*Drift rally here in the US, and the video is pretty fun to watch.

http://youtu.be/c3fkwl2we14?t=7m18s

gamerdonkey··on Gimli Glider
While I feel that US driver education and testing has many faults, I don't want everyone to have the impression that the test is as simple as 'What does a STOP sign mean?'. Hyperbole is good for humor but can be misguiding in a discussion about actual solutions.

While it has been some time since my driver's test, I remember somewhat complicated questions about right-of-way, dealing with vehicle problems, handling adverse driving conditions, and responding to potential accident situations. Of course, part of the problem I have with our driver education system is how much it varies among the states. Most of what is shared deals with the operations of highway driving, while I think there needs to be more requirements for overall safe driving.

Also, I was a little incredulous at first that 80 mph is the answer for 'poor' conditions. But, I suppose I have driven on 80 mph interstates here under extremely heavy rain while everyone maintained the speed limit. I suppose it's just one of those things where we have a different sense of scale.

gamerdonkey··on John Carmack's former employer claims he stole tech for Oculus VR when he left
I agree that Carmack probably didn't not sign one. But they are very common among companies in the tech sector and they can be just as horrible as you imagine.
gamerdonkey··on John Carmack's former employer claims he stole tech for Oculus VR when he left
> Unless recreating non-patented work from memory is actually forbidden? That would be horrible.

Here lies the black magic of the Non-Compete Agreement.

gamerdonkey··on Hackers Can Mess With Traffic Lights to Jam Roads and Reroute Cars
In the US, these are certainly real. Apparently, some did use strobe lights to signal the traffic lights.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_signal_preemption

I vaguely have memories of the state legislator having to pass new laws after the devices were installed because it was not technically illegal to have the emitter in your vehicle.

gamerdonkey··on The Hackaday Prize
I certainly understand the concern, but I think the timeframe of this contest will serve to mitigate the problem. Three months is, in my opinion, long enough for a motivated participant to come up with an entry that could easily compete with a multi-year project.

Additionally, the openness encouraged by the competition (as a judging criteria) will allow the community time to scrutinize entries and call out any that appear to be 'cheating'.

gamerdonkey··on How to exploit home routers for anonymity
Hopefully, by making this kind of exploitation common knowledge for the more tech-oriented crowd, we will be able to bring about change in the companies that manufacture the devices. You're right that the vast majority of people do not realize why they need to secure their infrastructure and would not know how to do it if they did. For that kind of person, the default needs to change to something more secure.

This kind of "change through widespread knowledge of exploitation" strategy saw some success in changing the default encryption schemes of WiFi routers. So, we're already kind of in the same area.

gamerdonkey··on Chris Anderson on drones and open source hardware
Having heard some talks from 3D Robotics people and followed them online, I get the sense that they (officially, as an organization) accept the clones as competition and simply try to continue innovating to stay ahead of the game. That sentiment is exemplified in this blog post: http://www.adafruit.com/blog/2011/05/19/cloned-open-source-h...

That being said, I think it is natural for there to be some animosity towards the clones on a more individual basis, especially in a situation where community members and employees feel that they are expected to provide support for the clones.

gamerdonkey··on The inventor of everything
They actually do get a mention in the article.

  The venture capitalists who’ve sunk tens of millions into
  Cheiky’s startups have a lot to lose if his suspect science
  is discovered — exposing Cheiky might stop him from raising
  money again, but it would also tarnish their reputations.
  None of the firms who backed Cheiky would speak with The
  Verge about him on the record, but several shared negative
  impressions on background. Unlike many serial entrepreneurs,
  who return to previous investors for favorable terms,
  Cheiky’s last three startups all have a very different set
  of backers.
Seems they're just playing the same game.
gamerdonkey··on Shutting down Ubuntu One file services
Canonical does seem to have more trouble finding reliable revenue streams. This is probably due to their focus on more end-user-oriented support and features. Among the Linux distro 'major players', though, they're kind of the odd ones out. RedHat and SUSE have been doing pretty well for themselves.

http://www.networkworld.com/community/blog/linux-profitabili...

gamerdonkey··on More News Is Being Written By Robots
I actually don't think our opinions differ that much. I just have trouble expressing my ideas. You seem to have hit it on the nose with your last statement. I am more optimistic that these scripts will be used to generate breaking news that doesn't (yet) require much human analysis, just information that must be quickly disseminated in a readable format (such as an earthquake's geophysical qualities). This would hopefully leave more resources that would allow more rigorous journalism (such as analysis of the effects of and response to an earthquake) to thrive in the future just as deficiently as now.

The word count was intended to display just how little information might be conveyed in fifty words. The inclusion of my comment's word count was simply to make the comment self-referential. Both can be safely ignored.

gamerdonkey··on More News Is Being Written By Robots
I would argue that there are several logical problems with a jump from 'earthquake report' to 'news leak' or 'declaration of war'. Using only fifty words for an earthquake report implies that there was no explanation or analysis to be made of its effects. Most leaks and war declarations tend to require much more information to be covered completely, and I would not expect to find any that are fifty words or less.

For a sense of scale, your comment was 188 words. My comment is 88 words.

gamerdonkey··on Press Conference in Brazil to Announce Discovery in Outer Solar System
I agree. I get an amazing thrill from learning even some small new fact about our solar system. However, I'd argue that you don't have to wait until you have kids to get current on science. Maintaining general knowledge about the world around us is beneficial to everyone, and I believe that recognizing how much of a universe there is beyond our existence can help keep things in perspective.

And with all the Internet, Wikipedia, and several prominent science-oriented television shows today, keeping up is easier than ever.

gamerdonkey··on It Is Time For Basic Income
Oddly, you've also just summed up the reasons behind many of our copyright and patent issues.
gamerdonkey··on Journal pulls paper due to “legal context” created by climate contrarians
Are you suggesting that these psychologists are conspiring with climate scientists to influence the debate?
gamerdonkey··on Journal pulls paper due to “legal context” created by climate contrarians
I agree, the paper itself was not about climate science. It was published by psychologists, so I wouldn't expect it to be. However, the intent did not seem to be about marginalizing people. It was a scientific study of the psychological phenomena that exist around conspiracy theories, including the reaction of a study about conspiracy theorists that involves further conspiracy theories.

Also, I'm not sure how defamation laws would come into play. By all accounts listed, the scientific basis behind the paper was sound, so no libel or falsehoods to speak of. It seems more likely that the potential costs of defending against legal action is enough of a threat to warrant the removal of an academic paper.

gamerdonkey··on Working shorter hours may also be good for your health
Possibly because you work so much.
gamerdonkey··on 95% of climate models agree: the observations must be wrong
The problem with this article is how the author frames the entire debate around this one measure of climate change, as though this is the only possible observation of climate change.

The issue of human contribution to climate change is much more complicated than that. This is an interesting contribution to the discussion, but it shouldn't be the only piece of information we go from.

gamerdonkey··on Curse Of The Gifted (2000)
> I know. That's the trouble with talking about growing up or being highly intelligent, you end up sounding like a narcissistic prick.

You've framed this incorrectly. The reason you ended up sounding like a narcissistic prick is because you were being a narcissistic prick. Perhaps you were just reducing his point to something a little too trivially simple.

There's nothing wrong with saying things like "I've tested in the top 1-2% of dozens of aptitude and intelligence tests". That doesn't sound narcissistic. Making the unsubstantiated claim that you are so smart that the problems of 'normal' people are trivially simple to solve and shall be disregarded is narcissistic. Especially when, once called out on that claim, you respond with an example fit perfectly to your honestly very narrow solution and cover every other scenario with an aloof "well, some problems do get complex".

Honestly, it sounds like jakobe was dead on. If the world seems so simple to you, you're probably not looking close enough. If you really are so good at coming up with solutions to the problems of the world, I hope you're spending your time improving it for yourself and those around you in truly substantial ways.

gamerdonkey··on The Day We Do Nothing Of Consequence
Oh good, the UPDATE brought some helpful advice to the original article.

> So if you're expecting me to tell you what to do, here you go: develop a strategy that is in line with your beliefs and goals, and share it with others.

If only The Day We Fight Back people were doing that. Like, if they had found a piece of legislation that worked toward their goals, come up with ways to improve it further, developed a strategy to support that legislation, and then embarked on a widescale sharing campaign, maybe they could get something done.

gamerdonkey··on Money for Nothing
Depending on the size of the dataset, you may have been providing a valuable service to those on dialup (however unwittingly). I remember how even a download of 50-100MB would take dedication to keep everyone off the phone for hours and pray that there were no interruptions upstream. Paying $10-15 for a guaranteed CD of what I wanted would have been well within reason.
gamerdonkey··on Your code may be elegant, but mine works
I'm honestly sorry I gave that a pageview.

It's an article chock full of caveats (Best practices vary wildly across the board, except for the ones any decent programmer obviously knows.), straw-men (Someone spending a week to implement caching on a 20-row table probably wasn't crafting elegant code anyway.), and contrived anecdotal examples (Christmas apps must be out by Christmas. My God, what a breakthrough. Most projects are not nearly this straightforward.).

gamerdonkey··on Wealth does not make you smarter
I disagree with this sentiment, but you could not have stated it more perfectly.
gamerdonkey··on Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize
I agree that it is a fairly large difference in number, but I still think that trumpeting on about it distracts from the primary discussion.

At best, this is all speculation. 7-8 years is the time before Chelsea Manning becomes eligible for parole. Whether or not she is actually released will depend on a number of factors, including the political climate at the time. We'll only really find out around 2021.

Finally, and this is something I touched on in my first comment, even 7 years in a federal prison is nothing to sneeze at. A non-trivial amount of time spent on federal probation after release isn't exactly going to be a cakewalk, either. And this is all on top of the time already spent in the military justice system, including almost a year of solitary confinement. Basically, I'm just asking that we don't downplay what must be an awful experience simply because our justice system has wiggle room.

gamerdonkey··on Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel peace prize
I hate that this nitpicking has become the standard response whenever someone is facing a prison sentence. It utterly belittles the hardship that people like Pfc. Manning actually face, even if it is for 7-8 years in the end.

Additionally, the parole or probation that she faces even after release are still punishment. It's not as though the troubles are suddenly over.

Treating the issue in this way makes it sound like the judge announced the 35 year sentence, slammed a gavel, then looked over to Manning with a wink and a whimsical smile. That's not what happened. 35 years was the sentence, and that is what you should expect to hear in relation to the case, even if it can be reduced with work on the part of the defendant.

gamerdonkey··on Keepod Unite: $7 PC to bridge the digital divide
I think you're right to be critical. This doesn't seem like a perfect idea. Still, some counters to your points:

1. CD's would probably be more inexpensive to produce, but they are much more vulnerable to damage and destruction. Additionally, with a USB drive, the user can save data that will persist from computer to computer, which makes the idea more tolerant to the use of unreliable recycled computers. Hosting a cloud OS would introduce a pretty major dependency on network connectivity, which I can understand them trying to avoid when their focus seems to be on developing nations.

2. That can be expensive, but you might be surprised how many recycled electronics simply end up in these developing countries. These costs might also be why the price of "just a live USB drive" is as high as $7.

3. Again, the USB drive itself probably won't cost $7, so that supporting infrastructure might be included in that price. Unfortunately, it will be up to those running this campaign to provide full answers on that. I'll admit that I'm just speculating myself.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →