HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

garden_hermit

299 karma · joined August 24, 2020

submissionscomments
garden_hermit··on No evidence that chance meetings in office boosts innovation
I wonder how this scales to a level of a city. Large cities tend to have larger innovation, which is partially attributed to the ease at which ideas can move between companies through job changes, serendipitious encounters, and a build-up of local business infrastructure.

Would these sorts of agglomerative effects still occur in cities, if remote work is the norm and people don't have to be so concentrated? Or might these effects be amplified at the national level, because people can communicate more freely? I'm interested to see how this plays out over the next years.

garden_hermit··on Japan's government plans to encourage 4-day workweek, but experts split
"encourage"
garden_hermit··on 4-day workweeks can boost happiness and productivity
I think the idea is that a 4-day workweek would come along with a broader cultural shift.

Imagine a world where Saturday was a workday, it shouldn't be hard as this was the case for many only a few generations ago.

We could say that it is expected that you will not only work 48hrs/6 days a week, but probably 70, 80, 90 hours likely 7 days a week!

Fortunately, a cultural shift occurred along the way, and the work week is now commonly accepted to be 5 days. Expectations of clients, managers, and employees are based around this standard.

So why can't the standard change again? Why couldn't a broad cultural shift occur in which expectations are better managed towards the productivity of a 4-day work week?

garden_hermit··on How TV dramas informed and misinformed perceptions of the war on drugs
Andy Warhol and a million graphic designers might disagree :)

I maintain that art affects society. Scorsese makes Taxi Driver, some crazy guy watches it, decides to shoot Ronald Reagan to impress Jody Foster. Would crazy guy have done the same thing regardless of the movie? Maybe. Would he have done it on the same day, at the same time, in the exact same way? Probably not.

The world where Scorsese chose to make Taxi Driver is different than the one where the movie never existed; maybe the difference is trivial, but -some- effect is there. The remaining question is the extent of that effect.

The fact that when I imagine a cop, I imagine "Bad Boys" and "Law and Order", even when I haven't watched these shows for over a decade, is a testament to art's effects. Maybe this image was born out of the crime waves of the 70s-80s, but the image persists, affecting how people feel on topics of policing.

garden_hermit··on How TV dramas informed and misinformed perceptions of the war on drugs
Doesn't the historic sucess of political propaganda, and the marketing successes of companies like Coca-Cola, illustrate the power of art to influence society, to some extent?

And it doesn't have to be an either or. They can both mutually shape each other.

garden_hermit··on Experts Weigh in on Pentagon UFO Report
I like to imagine that if aliens have visited us, its for a kind of tourism or safari. Us seeing them is the pilot (some underpaid, overworked tour guide) making a mistake.
garden_hermit··on Amazon executives are worried they'll run out of people to employ
Ideally, robots doing all of our work should be utopian, leaving humans free to pursue other interests. Unfortunately, the current structure of society instead makes this dystopian.
garden_hermit··on Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Carbon Energy (2020)
I think the problem is that doing it right requires "putting in the effort".

Unless there is a 100% idiot-proof reactor is made, mistakes and crises will still happen, maybe less often, but still sometimes, and it will kill the PR of nuclear.

garden_hermit··on Beyond Meat’s Beyond Burger life cycle assessment (2018)
What the OP is talking about mostly is factory farming, where cows will likely not eat very much grass, and where animals will not be free to graze.

I think most people would agree that traditional livestock farming is a much better system, ethically and environmentally, but it would struggle to meet global demand.

garden_hermit··on The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology
Is there any evidence that these paths are being cut? Mod communities for video games seem like they are thriving. Look at the sheer array of Minecraft mods, or mods for nearly any popular game on Steam.

Combine this with popular and easy game making software like RPGMaker, or even the ease that someone can set up a basic game on Unity. Beyond this, there are programs like Scratch and Processing that allow for fun and relatively easy computational tinkering.

I doubt the natural paths of curiosity have shrunk, though they may look different. Rather, the number of people using computers has massively increased, and the number of computer "tinkerers" is just a smaller proportion of people of the larger whole.

garden_hermit··on Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]
I was still under the assumption of Curiosity's 7 minutes! Thanks for letting me know
garden_hermit··on Perseverance Rover lands on Mars [video]
Watching these is always a stressful experience, I can't imagine what it would be like sitting in that room, praying that the object you spend years of work on is able to land by itself 7 light-minutes away.

I'm looking forward to what Perseverance will teach us.

garden_hermit··on Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRNA vaccines
I see no evidence that China has organized around long-term discovery or technical brilliance. They have many scientists, and relative advantages in certain fields, but their system of science still has major structure issues.

For example, one aspect of Chinese science policy is paying scientists based on the impact factor of their published papers. This, however, has lead to a much larger issue of "salami-slicing"/"least-publishable unit" publications aimed at passing the minimum bar of a "good enough" journal rather than contributing to science. Another issue—these payouts are only given to certain authors of the paper, which can lead to issues and controversies over authorship position. These are issues in the U.S. and Europe, but less severe, and not incentivized with cash payments.

China does not have some secret sauce that makes them better at discovery or technical brilliance. If anything their policies are organized towards maximizing prestige. Whether large-scale competence follows prestige, we will have to wait to see.

garden_hermit··on Teaching Students How to Cheat During the Pandemic
the article also says that one student was asked to turn their back to the camera, which would further confound cheating via teleprompter
garden_hermit··on Thinking too much can be bad for you (2012)
"Tacit knowledge" I think captures what you are talking about. Its the knowledge embedded in our bodies and automatic responses. Most commonly this can refer to mechanical tasks, like when you go on autopilot while driving.

It can also be used to describe mental tasks and ways of thinking. An engineer has tacit knowledge that shapes their natural way of thinking and intuition. A novelist, a nurse, or a tailor, in contrast, will have very different mental structures.

garden_hermit··on Parable of the Butler: A science-fiction pioneer finds posthumous fame
I mean, the "is it real or not" is the point of the show :)

The second season is...different. I loved the first season, but had more difficulty with the second. Its not bad, and offers -a few- answers, but if you don't like the unexplained/mysterious aspects of the first season, definintely skip the second.

garden_hermit··on Parable of the Butler: A science-fiction pioneer finds posthumous fame
I think its a different kind of representation. "The Expanse" book series, for instance, also features this sort of "UN" representation of many people form many kinds of ethnic background, and this is really great! However, the experiences of these characters is divorced from those of many non-white people living in the U.S. (this will of course all vary by the country of the audience). There is also a matter of who is the main or POV character, and who are secondary characters.

Butler, however, offers a different kind of representation. For one, her main protagonists are black. And, at least in the parable books, she focuses on a near future where the experiences of the black protagonists would be more familiar to black readers. Third, these are black characters written by a black women, who can draw on her own experience to more effectively capture and communicate the experiences of black women.

Representation in sci-fi is tricky, because once you start getting too far away from the current time period, you start to lose out a lot of the cultural experiences that people can relate to. N.K. Jemisin's "The Broken Earth" series does a decent job of capturing the experiences of non-white people living in the U.S. in a deep and thoughtful way, while maintaining an abstract fantasy/sci-fi setting.

garden_hermit··on How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler
> People will praise the Arab Spring organizing on Twitter without considering the implications for the events at the Capital on Jan 6th.

The reason why someone might hold these competing beliefs is simple: they strongly value democratic institutions. Violence, in the name of promoting democratic institutions, and ideally expanding human rights, is justifiable. Violence in the name of authoritarian insurrection is not.

Now, of course this gets really tricky, because many people on Parler, and in the capitol riots, fully believed that they were protecting democracy from massive voter-fraud. No clear answer to address that issue, but it is something that democratic societies will need to reckon with. How does one preserve democratic ideals (including promoting free speech, to whatever extent possible), while still maintaining a healthy society that doesn't tear itself apart?

garden_hermit··on Facebook Admits It Was Used to Incite Violence in Myanmar (2018)
Ideally, the definition of hate will result from a complex negotiation between stakeholders in society, just as we draw a line on who counts as an "adult", what counts as "self defense", and what counts as "libel".

The definition will be less than ideal, open to abuse, and problematic, but having it is better than not, just as having a definition of "adult", "self defense", and "libel" are better than not having them.

garden_hermit··on Big Tech is the new deep state
I mean, if ever there were an exception to free speech absolutism, now is the time—the more we learn about the capitol insurrection, the more we realize just how close we came (literally seconds) to a massacre on the senate floor, egged on by the president, and planned openly on these platforms.

Its possible to have a discussion about the power of big tech, about their anti-competitive behavior, and lack of democratic oversight, but perhaps those issues should be discussed separately from banning Trump and kicking Parler—which seem like good choices on the part of the companies, even though it was done far too late.

garden_hermit··on Peer-reviewed papers are getting increasingly boring
These kinds of things exist, though the rate that they are adopted varies widely.

In Psychology, for instance, there was discussion back in 2015 about per-registration in the field [1]. Since then, tools and repositories have been created to help facilitate per-registration [2].

But again, they are not universally adopted. Some of this is probably generational—academia is quite conservative, and doesn't change quickly. A new generation will likely use these tools more. Other times, fields are more insular than others, and so such tools will take some time to diffuse into their community. In the meantime though, things have improved, even if only somewhat, across the sciences.

[1] https://www.apa.org/science/about/psa/2015/08/pre-registrati... [2] https://www.cos.io/initiatives/prereg

garden_hermit··on Peer-reviewed papers are getting increasingly boring
My doctoral degree has required training in both Computer Science and Social Science, and regularly interact with both communities. Drawing on this, I feel that this comment is unnecessarily partisan and divisive.

> 2) Mentioning the replication crisis in social science gets a lot of the social science academics observably upset and defensive.

The replication crisis is widely discussed in social sciences. Nearly every major social science journal will have at least one, likely many, editorials and articles on the crisis tailored to their field. Maybe this is explicitely a Management Studies thing? The field is relatively small and insular, and so cannot be generalized to wider social science. And are your experiences drawon from the community as a whole, or the faculty in your department?

> 3) I have enjoyed my time spent with CS academics a lot more, luckily have some interaction even now - the ones I have spoken to seem to lack the ego-driven blind spots the social scientists exhibit. The CS group seems to have a lot more fun with their research.

Maybe this is just the local community of wherever you studied? I've met equal parts ego-driven and chill people in both CS and Social Science. A major concept in most social science fields is sampling—I'd urge you to consider how representative the people you are talking to actually are, and how your sample might be biased from the global population. My prior is that there would be little difference in personality, in aggregate, between the fields.

> I.e. I have observed that even when a manager or leader wants to hire developers, social science damaged managers and HR will actively sabotage these efforts because they are still, fundamentally, driven by Taylorist, control fetish concepts (which they refuse to accept)

I mean, that's one possibility. The other is that hiring people is difficult and expensive, and that credentials are a quick and useful, if flawed, method of sorting through the pile.

And are most HR people really trained in Management? I honestly don't know, but I doubt that the typical Psychology or Sociology major, for instance, is going to know of, remember, or consider using Taylorist management theory.

It definitely seems that you enjoyed your time in CS more than your time in Management. That's great! CS is an important field with lots of cool people. But generalizing this preference into a wider philosophy that privileges CS at the expense of (all?) social sciences is silly.

garden_hermit··on Peer-reviewed papers are getting increasingly boring
Many novel funding approaches have been proposed in an attempt to free scientists from the endless grant-> public-> grant cycle.

One is to accept only mini grant proposals, say 10 pages at most, and screen these to meet some minimum threshold, say, aiming for the top 20th percentile. Then a random subset of these get funded. This helps diversify the funding somewhat, and hopefully catch more "risky, but interesting" projects.

Another approach has been universal funding. The most basic is "everyone gets X research dollars", and any additional funding would require submitting grants on top of that. More complex schemes propose "everyone gets 2X dollars, but they must donate X to other researchers", which allows some people to accumulate the funds necessary to conduct big, expensive work. But all of these proposals aim to minimize grant writing and review, and hopefully to diversify the kinds of work being done.

Longer windows of evaluation could also be useful. Big interesting ideas take time to develop and support, but the competitive academic environment demands quick evaluations, which make ot difficult to sustain long projects. Evaluating a research project after 5 years, instead of 1 or 2, could help alleviate some of the pressure on researchers so they can pursue longer agendas.

Every researcher can come up with their pet theory and solution. Ultimately, I think that all of these approaches, and many others, have merit. But we need to experiment with different policies to see what works.

garden_hermit··on Peer-reviewed papers are getting increasingly boring
There is a lot of caution in research funding. Some research is considered "safe", whereas others risky. IN a properly balanced portfolio, perhaps 80% of funding should go to safe work and the remaining 20% to more risky, but potentially high-reward studies. However this isn't how funding agencies usually operate.

At least in the context of the U.S. government, funding agencies are terrified of being seen as "wasting" funding, because that is a sure way to have funding cut by congress. The "Golden Fleece" awards, a congressman's attack on perceived frivolous spending, have routinely been targeted at specific research funded by the NSF and have helped make the agency afraid of being attacked by congress.

garden_hermit··on Peer-reviewed papers are getting increasingly boring
This is whats done in science evaluation—the H-index for instance is built from a combination of publication and citation counts. Similarly, journal prestige is quantified using the Journal Impact Factor, which aggregates the average number of citation a paper in the journal receives.

As you speculate, these can also be gamed. Authors will cite themselves more to inflate their citations, or form citation carters with other authors to cite each other's work. Similarly, journals have been known to coerce authors to cite other works in the venue, in order to inflate their impact factor. Beyond these, there are issues with comparing citations across disciplines, article type, and other contexts.

> Eventually, pubs are going to start rejecting valid papers for being too incremental.

Many of hte most prestigious journals, such as Science, Nature, and Cell, already do this. However newer Mega-journals, like PLoS, have had explicitly the opposite policy, and state that they accept anything that is "sound science", no matter the size of its contribution; they have however become more selective over time.

garden_hermit··on Why are boys academically underperforming? [audio]
Very true. "Egalitarian" here is highly relative. Schools now are certainly more egalitarian than they were a few centuries ago (when barely anyone could even attend!) but they are still a long way off.

I'm optimistic that we will eventually reach a fully egalitarian future, but pessimistic at how much work is left to do.

garden_hermit··on Why are boys academically underperforming? [audio]
There is also a different between "explicit" and "implicit" safe spaces for different groups. Its just that they are only ever "marked" with a demographic identifier if they are for a non-dominant group. I.e., "Comic Book Shops" are geared towards (historically, typically) white boys, but "Black comic book shops" and "Girl comic book shops" also exist. We notice these, because they are marked as such, because they run counter the norm. What we don't always notice is that the unmarked "Comic Book Shop" is already geared towards a particular demographic—white men.

Basically, different safe spaces exist for different demographics, but are only marked for certain groups.

garden_hermit··on Why are boys academically underperforming? [audio]
It could very well be that women have had the potential to outperform men in academic tasks since Socrates, but never had the chance until widespread and egalitarian schooling.
garden_hermit··on Tech elites leaving San Francisco threaten Silicon Valley's supremacy
> There was no inherent "supremacy", just one created by a bunch of companies being together.

That is why they have supremacy, though. Agglomeration effects are a big deal. Its why New York has remained a center of trade and finance for centuries, and why Detroit remains a hub for the automotive industry despite the city's bankruptcy.

No matter what brought the companies there in the first place, just "being together" is a huge deal and is hard to replicate elsewhere. We will see if tech will be an exception, but my prior is that proximity is important, even with WFH, and that Silicon Valley will remain the national center of tech companies.

garden_hermit··on How I read books: a guide on how to learn
Building on this advice, I highy recommend the essay titled "How to Read a Book" by Paul Edwards:

https://pne.people.si.umich.edu/PDF/howtoread.pdf

Edwards is an academic historian of science who write incredibly long and dense books drawing on hundreds of sources. If anyone knows how to read, its him, and his advice was truly useful for my own reading.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →