HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

garmaine

2,787 karma · joined November 23, 2017

submissionscomments
garmaine··on Crews are abandoned on ships in record numbers without pay, food or a way home
The same reason you might specify “American South” if it is a crew from Alabama.
garmaine··on Ireland joins OECD International Tax agreement
You need higher karma to vouch for a comment then flag one, apparently.
garmaine··on Long Covid is overblown and often something else, says Oxford professor
Here is a start: https://theguardian.com/money/2019/apr/17/who-owns-england-t...
garmaine··on Intel CEO says AMD’s time is ‘over’
ARM says Intel’s time is ‘over’
garmaine··on Long Covid is overblown and often something else, says Oxford professor
You must not be familiar with the intricacies of UK property ownership. Most desirable properties in London are owned by a small group of aristocratic people who really do just hold property, and things which give them political influence like newspapers. Corporate ownership of buildings is not as prevalent as, say, in New York (except in the family business sort of way).

Part of this is tradition, but also the quirks of UK property law which makes it very hard to trance ownership of property, and so these people who value their privacy prefer property over other more liquid investments they’d have to disclose.

garmaine··on Databases, Types, and the Relational Model: The Third Manifesto [pdf]
I really wish Date had any understanding of modern type theory, since that's the basis of his desired reform of SQL. His typing model is 50 years out of date.
garmaine··on A Fire Upon the Deep by Vernor Vinge (1992)
See the sibling comments... those books are SF thriller junk. Don't let me stop you from reading them if you enjoy that, but their reputation for "deep ideas" is not deserved.
garmaine··on A Fire Upon the Deep by Vernor Vinge (1992)
(minor spoilers for Deepness follow)

When I read Deepness I actually imagined in my head a Studio Ghibli like aesthetic for the spider world chapters. I thought if it were ever adapted into film or TV, it would be essential to display the spider world as the humans listening to their radio broadcasts imagined it, as a playful, colorful, animated world populated by anthropomorphized cartoon spiders. Given the level of technology and political environment, it would feel very similar to the city backdrops of Kiki's Delivery Service or Howl's Moving Castle.

It would also make the reveal at the end when the spiders and humans finally meet all the much more dramatic, as humans land on the planet to find not the cute lovable anime world we'd been watching, but the primordially scary reality of spiders with human-level intelligence.

garmaine··on A Fire Upon the Deep by Vernor Vinge (1992)
Same here. I would have put down and thrown away Deepness if I hadn't read Fire Upon The Deep first and trusted the author. I'm glad I finished it because of the parts about the spiders and Pham Nuwen's past was really interesting. But the "present-day" emergents story line is dark... I did not enjoy reading those parts.
garmaine··on A Fire Upon the Deep by Vernor Vinge (1992)
Also along similar lines is Alastair Reynolds' Diamond Dogs short story.
garmaine··on A Fire Upon the Deep by Vernor Vinge (1992)
That aspect of it destroyed the rereadability of the book for me. I tried reading it again recently because I loved the part of the plot that dealt with the spiders, but I ended up skipping over the chapters with the emergents because I knew where thing were going and didn't want to re-experience it.

Still, that's credit to the author that he was able to write something powerful enough to evoke such a response.

garmaine··on A Fire Upon the Deep by Vernor Vinge (1992)
I think you very much missed the point. The tine packs don't mind read, they have high bandwidth sonic communication and their mind is brought into being through that communication. Much like the same can be said of you, whose brain consists of specialized regions with high-bandwidth communication between them. Individually they're rather dumb dogs, but together they can form a higher intelligence.

It's an extremely interesting way to explore the nature of the mind, and what it means to be a conscious, thinking entity. The super-AI thing is just a thriller plot point to move the story forward, by comparison.

garmaine··on Where do type systems come from? (2017)
I believe it is correct to say there are undecidable theorems in some limited type systems which cannot be proven, but which can be once you extend the type system (e.g. by making it higher-level or dependent).

So in those limited systems we know there are things that are "true" or "false", but which can only be proven when we have a superset of the original tools available.

And by extension, maybe in our more complete type system there are things which can't be proven yet, but could perhaps be if there were better tools available?

Maybe another angle to look at it: one of the things which is difficult to prove is the halting problem. Maybe you can't prove that a given program will terminate. But you could run that program and watch it terminate, and then you'd know it does. In that sense there is a "true" answer, but one which couldn't have been proved in advance from type theory.

But I admit I only have a high-level understanding of these things. Type theory and axiomatic mathematics is something I'd like to know more about.

garmaine··on When users never use the features they asked for
Yeah sounds like the lesson here is that nobody reads the update messages.
garmaine··on Ford workers at 4 new plants won't automatically be UAW members: Here's why
This is what happens when you settle for “electability” as your primary metric in selecting a candidate. You end up with an entrenched establishment, partisan hack that is fully owned by lobbyists.

The administration didn’t even try to hide the blatant favoritism of its policy.

garmaine··on Tesla Sues for Defamation over Social Media Posts
Surely not more litigious than Bezos.
garmaine··on US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho
The anti-nuclear crowd willfully conflates the two.
garmaine··on US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho
Not in 2003.
garmaine··on Stanislav Petrov, Officer Who Helped Avert Nuclear War on Sept. 26, 1983 (2017)
I’m not defending Trump. I’m just saying the nuclear situation wasn’t comparable to Petrov. Accuracy and precision matters.

A general saying he would hypothetically disobey orders is quite different from actually doing so.

garmaine··on Stanislav Petrov, Officer Who Helped Avert Nuclear War on Sept. 26, 1983 (2017)
The situation would be comparable is Trump actually ordered a nuclear assault, but he did not.
garmaine··on Noam Chomsky on the cruelty of American imperialism
That’s how Americans use the term, yes. It’s original meaning (still in partial use by the rest of the world) is shorthand for “liberalism”, which is a well defined political and economic philosophy that is actually somewhat conservative and center-right leaning in modern American political terms.
garmaine··on Thousands of student files lost in error
Exams don’t give the whole picture.
garmaine··on Noam Chomsky on the cruelty of American imperialism
In the USA (re-)definition of the word, yes.
garmaine··on A monk in 14th-century Italy wrote about the Americas
My history may be off, but I believe that the Chinese named their country 中國 because they believed themselves the center of the world. Much like how the Romans named the Mediterranean (which means “middle sea”). The primary meaning of 中 is “middle” and it gains the meaning of “inside” by the geometric implication of the insides of something being that thing’s middle.

中國人 is a specific term of nationality. Likewise with 美國人. But 外國人 is different—it is defined only in relation to something else, as The Other. That’s fine in the context of passport control where your nationality matters, and you need to be in the foreigner line. But it’s not okay when we all live together in the same country, speaking the same language and with our kids in the same class in school, and you still refer to me as The Foreigner. Do you see the difference?

Interestingly, A LOT of mainlanders don’t know to line up in the 外國人 line when they go through Taiwan’s passport control, and they get upset when they are told to switch. It happens literally every time I’m in the airport (at least pre-pandemic). I don’t know if this is a dialectical, cultural, or propaganda problem, but it seems related.

garmaine··on A monk in 14th-century Italy wrote about the Americas
I don’t see that as consistent. The USA isn’t the middle of the world by any measure.
garmaine··on A monk in 14th-century Italy wrote about the Americas
Correct that it is very different in Taiwan.

But generally you're missing the point. (1) 老外 (lao wai) is an intrinsically othering term, and (2) it's generally applied by race rather than by national origin. It doesn't matter what the literal translation is. The point is about how the word is used.

Here in California many Chinese-speaking transplants use the terms 老外 or 外國人 to refer to white Americans. I always correct them when they do--pointing out that they are the foreigners. It comes off as rude, but that's the point! No one likes to be ostracized or grouped based on the color of their skin, and that's precisely what they were doing when they used the term to refer to white people in the first place.

If I move my life to China or Taiwan, how long do I have live there before I am no longer 老外? What about my kids who grow up there, speaking at a native level and calling the country their home. Are they 老外 too?

garmaine··on All businesses will eventually turn into subscriptions
That’s exactly how trade-in works at a dealership though.
garmaine··on Microsoft and an army of tiny telecoms are part of a plan to wire rural America
Is this a job for The Boring Company? Dig a straight hole through bedrock that can be “tapped” from the surface with a precisely positioned narrow drill, but is wide enough for human technicians to traverse in electric golf carts.
garmaine··on Google Drive of historical footage locked and flagged as terrorist activity
What does that mean?
garmaine··on Google Drive of historical footage locked and flagged as terrorist activity
I’m replying to a comment that said, I quote, “but in the US there are free speech laws.”

Given that context, I thought it was clear I was talking about the nature of free speech laws in the USA.

← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →