HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

garmaine

2,787 karma · joined November 23, 2017

submissionscomments
garmaine··on Google Drive of historical footage locked and flagged as terrorist activity
“Free speech” laws only apply to government restrictions on speech.
garmaine··on A Tunguska size burst destroyed Tall el-Hammam, Bronze Age city in Jordan Valley
Given the distribution of land vs. sea, a recorded once per century event is probably once per 25 years or so in actuality (it just usually happens over the ocean).
garmaine··on Arm AArch64 Adds Memcpy() Instructions
RISC-V?
garmaine··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
Guns aren’t as simple as “in case of emergency, push button” and stopping power for handguns is nonexistent.

If you want a defensive weapon that is easy to use and hard to screw up, buy mace. If you want stopping power, buy a taser.

garmaine··on The curious case of fake NASA geniuses
A lot of ITAR-restricted roles require being a US citizen or green card holder.
garmaine··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
No need to speculate, we know that governments had a direct role in this thanks to the Snowden revelations.
garmaine··on Atlassian fired me while I was taking care of my wife who is fighting cancer
California companies and work culture largely discourages taking PTO, so it tends to accrue.
garmaine··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
> The idea that people should not have to give up all of their ability to fight.

Fight...whom? How? A gun is a very blunt instrument. If you want to learn how to defend yourself, take a self-defense class and buy something non-lethal like mace.

Why is a gun necessary for self-defense?

garmaine··on Lunar Crater Radio Telescope on the Far-Side of the Moon (2020)
Look at the DARE mission proposal.
garmaine··on Lunar Crater Radio Telescope on the Far-Side of the Moon (2020)
Pizza-box sized omnidirectional antennas was the plan, I think. A couple of them spread out over a large area like a crater floor. And yes, they were looking at robotic deployment.
garmaine··on Lunar Crater Radio Telescope on the Far-Side of the Moon (2020)
> and there are some wavelengths that simply can't be observed from the earth because of atmospheric interference.

Of particular relevance is the frequency associated with the transition from opaque plasma to neutral matter, which made interstellar space transparent. This coincides with the first stars, and is as close to the Big Bang as we can observe. Cosmologists are very interested in generating a detailed cosmic map at these frequencies, but they are unfortunately blocked by (1) the ionosphere of the Earth's atmosphere, and (2) subject to tons of radio interference. It's like right smack in the middle of the most commonly used frequency bands. Lunar far-side observatories are pretty much the best path towards making these measurements.

garmaine··on Ask HN: If AI can potentially wipe us out, why is there a race to achieve it?
I lost ten years of my life to worrying about AI risk. I try not to be bitter about that as the rationality techniques I learned along the way have helped me immensely. But I do try to caution others who appear to be falling down the same rabbit hole.

It is the AI x-risk crowd that is non-mainstream, so there isn't really an easily accessible collection of opposing viewpoints, because few have bothered to write up their views. The default/null position is that AI, like nearly all other technologies ever, will have a gradual impact on society and will remain subject to human controls. And that's what most people believe, so researchers who don't buy into the x-risk scenario simply dismiss it as they do all crackpot ideas and move on with their lives. (It should be said that Goertzel has written up his response though: http://multiverseaccordingtoben.blogspot.com/2010/10/singula...)

"GPT-3 is AGI" is a bit of a strawman, sorry. I don't think anyone believes that. But GPT-3 is a clear demonstration that networks can be trained on todays hardware to have at least enough encoded information as a human mind, and encoded in such a way as to be generically useful. But GPT-3 is not an agent, obviously. In the mind of its creators however, it ought to be relatively simple (read: a few million dollars and a couple of years) to attach the GPT-3 knowledgebase to the kind of reinforcement learning based agent architecture that DeepMind and OpenAI are independently developing. Do that and you would have an agent-y general, human-level (or better) intelligence.

Am I worried about that? No. Nor are most researchers in the field, for a variety of reasons. Some say it will be so fragile that it will require a symbiotic relationship with its human handlers, and unable to realistically act against us. Others say that its neural network architecture and human training data will make it behave similar enough to its creators in the ways which matter. Others note that initial projects will be so bug-ridden as to be unusable for word domination until decades down the line, and AI defenses will naturally be developed at a similar pace. So AI might become a geopolitical arms race, but not any different than nuclear weapons in that regard.

Those are all viable arguments I've heard, and I'm sure there are others as well. Notably for AI x-risk to be a thing, all of the above arguments have to be flawed. If even one of them is true, AI will not take over the world. So we don't even have to delve deep into each of them to assess that the likely outcome is that AI does not kill us all.

Edit: Also I think you're right that the AlignmentForum crowd doesn't think that "AGI" requires old-fashioned AI techniques instead of neural networks, but rather that they find those techniques easier to analyze and they're taking a maths-heavy approach to friendly-AI. Even Goertzel thinks that a neural-network approach could work; he just thinks (or thought?) that it would take too long to develop. Now it's probably the sunk cost fallacy and pride that keeps him developing OpenCog as an AGI architecture instead, even though the most basic AI-gym bots have surpassed OpenCog in capability.

garmaine··on Ask HN: If AI can potentially wipe us out, why is there a race to achieve it?
Some context on Goertzel that wouldn't show up in the wiki article. Goertzel's belief is/was that one couldn't achieve general / human-levels intelligence by scaling up regular old neural network ideas. He, and some others, believed that while traditional AI techniques were good within confined use cases, writing an intelligence that could apply itself to problem domains far outside of its training set required an explicitly different set of algorithms at the general/meta level.

E.g. I imagine that Goertzel would say that GPT-3 isn't a general intelligence. It's the human engineer that made GPT-3, or which builds applications applying GPT-3 to different domains that is the general intelligence. Yes GPT-3 is generally applicable, but who does the hard work of actually figuring out how to apply it to new setups? THAT is general intelligence, in Goertzel's view.

Back to the timeline, in 2002 Goertzel wanted to focus not on machine learning, which the field of AI was and still is mostly focused on, but rather designing "something" which (in current day terms) knew how to adapt meta-parameters to a particular training data set, and knew how to transfer/apply trained networks to new problem domains. An artificial AI engineer, as it were.

So Goertzel coined/repurposed the term Artificial General Intelligence to mean not just a human-level AI, but rather a meta-AI program that was able to create, on its own, new human-level narrow AI using more traditional techniques. They created a AGI conference to gather researchers interested in these ideas: http://agi-conference.org

Generally speaking AI researchers who believe that scaling up traditional neural-network architectures is sufficient to create a general/human-level intelligence don't use the term AGI. The kind of folks who go to the AGI conference and study large-architecture AIs aiming for an explicit human-level, meta cognition engine do use the term AGI, and use it a lot. LessWrong folks may not hang around AGI conferences, but they do fall in the latter group. The MIRI institute was traditionally fully devoted to studying AGI architectures of their own trade-secret design, not narrow AI techniques (although that has changed a bit with Paul Christiano's work).

So if you use AGI without qualification, my prior is that you're hailing from the latter camp of AGI meta-architecture researchers or the LessWrong-influenced existential risk crowd. In either case it is worth pointing out that you are getting a tinted view of AI risk that is different from what, say, researchers at DeepMind or Facebook largely believe.

garmaine··on Ask HN: If AI can potentially wipe us out, why is there a race to achieve it?
It's not widely used outside of Ben Goertzel et al, and the LessWrong/MIRI community, because these are the only groups which believe there is a significant qualitative difference between "narrow AI" and "general intelligence."

From a pragmatic perspective, DeepMind and OpenAI have demonstrated to pretty good confidence that scaling up so-called "narrow AI" techniques are sufficient to create general intelligences.

That's not to say that there isn't a useful distinction to be made between classical AGI architectures and the neural network based techniques used by most AI groups today. But it's becoming increasingly clear that the specialized AGI techniques are not not required to achieve general intelligence, so neither is it certain that the conclusions reached by analyzing AGI architectures (which has led to existential risk concerns) apply to the sorts of general intelligences actually being worked on today.

But anyway, the word AGI is unfortunately not useful for being clear, because it's not clear whether you mean general/human-level intelligence, or the specific non-neural-network based architectures that Goertzel had in mind when he coined the term.

garmaine··on Ask HN: If AI can potentially wipe us out, why is there a race to achieve it?
The number of people who truly believe that AI has a serious potential to wipe us out is minuscule, and they are mostly not in decision-making positions.

Since you use the term AGI, I suppose you've been exposed to this idea via LessWrong? I'd caution you that they have a very non-mainstream view of AI potential, even by the standards of AI researchers. Their concerns about existential risk stem from simplified mathematical models that have little or nothing to do with how AI actually works, making the conclusions they draw very tenuous.

garmaine··on Phony diagnoses hide high rates of drugging at nursing homes
Yes, I would.
garmaine··on Phony diagnoses hide high rates of drugging at nursing homes
Live in multi-generational family units where the family shares responsibility for (and benefits from) their own elders.
garmaine··on Bush: The sense of unity seen in the US after 9/11 seems distant
Yeah I wonder why. Maybe it had something to do with the needless second war in Iraq you instigated?
garmaine··on Why did the web take over desktop and not mobile?
They’re the same thing. “App” is short for “application”, aka installable software.
garmaine··on Why did the web take over desktop and not mobile?
…did it?

I still use tons of native apps on my laptop, and almost exclusively native apps only on my desktop.

garmaine··on New details on silicon, subatomic particles and possible ‘fifth force’
There is nothing to disappear. There isn’t a fifth force to within experimental precision. TFA is about an increase in that experimental precision which further reduces the possibility (or at least the magnitude) of any yet undiscovered “fifth force.”
garmaine··on New horizons for SPJ
At the same time, leaving after 23 years for a reason other than retirement suggests something changed.

I have no insight into the company as you do, but that is the first impression I’d get from the circumstances. People don’t stay at a company for 23 years only to jump ship for the same reasons early-career people jump around.

garmaine··on No One Ever Saw the Snow Cruiser Again (2019)
That’s the Holocene calendar, not the Long Now date writing tradition.
garmaine··on Tripwire CEO out after tweeting support of Texas abortion law
Conflicted as I want to downvote you for not contributing to the conversation, but want to upvote you for finally using “hateful” correctly…

I assume that was the sarcastic point you were making?

garmaine··on Tripwire CEO out after tweeting support of Texas abortion law
Stating a political preference is not hateful to anyone. Let’s not lessen the meaning of the word “hate.”
garmaine··on Tripwire CEO out after tweeting support of Texas abortion law
They make ultra violent gratuitous video games. Not to be too gendered, but I don’t think women make up half of their user base.

(Also, not all women are pro-choice.)

garmaine··on Tripwire CEO out after tweeting support of Texas abortion law
Let’s not abuse words.

Here is the tweet:

> Proud of #USSupremeCourt affirming the Texas law banning abortion for babies with a heartbeat. As an entertainer I don’t get political often. Yet with so many vocal peers on the other side of this issue, I felt it was important to go on the record as a pro-life game developer.

Where is the hate?

garmaine··on Rust programs written entirely in Rust
Seriously, why is it there? What purpose does it serve?
garmaine··on Tripwire CEO out after tweeting support of Texas abortion law
Ridiculous. Stating a political opinion on your personal social network account shouldn’t cause you to lose your job.
garmaine··on Ask HN: Using Ed25519 Keys for user authentication
> Users may register for accounts and provide their public Ed25519 keys. Later, when they wish to login, they sign the string "login" (with their private key), base64 encode the result of that and provide it to the server. The server then verifies the signature using their public key. If it verifies, then the user gets a session.

How is this not just a more complicated password?

Usually these sorts of protocols have some sort of challenge for the client to sign, making the login one-time and checking that the user actually has the private key.

← PreviousPage 12 of 34Next →