HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gaurav_v

257 karma · joined December 19, 2010

gauravvman at gmail
submissionscomments
gaurav_v··on Creativity requires isolation
Can't playing video games be creative? I haven't played very many, but it always seemed to me that videogames were designed as highly engaging technical challenges, and you could certainly employ some degree of creativity in solving (winning) them. It's arguably not the most productive use of creative juice...
gaurav_v··on Occupy George
It would definitely be a lot easier (and seemingly, effective) if they all just said we want X, where X is some not necessarily even specific reform.

But maybe they just want to say 'we're angry about this rising income inequality and we want someone to do something about it.' I think that's a valid stance to have, and opinion to express. It then falls on the government to either:

1. Do something about income inequality. 2. Explain why they can't or shouldn't or won't.

Failing that either of these things occur, it may inspire someone to run for office with the platform of performing (1) or (2) above. Any of these outcomes seem like a 'successful' outcome of the protest.

gaurav_v··on Occupy George
I agree that the movement lacks a coherent message.

That being said, one of the large issues in play is that people feel slighted by rising income inequality, which they perceive to have arisen out of a sort of government-industry feedback loop. Certainly this is what the printed dollar bills seem to be about.

With regard to your comments about the utility of the protest: I don't think it's a waste in any regard. If you feel something about government (in this country), you have several options: wait for an election and vote, write to your congresspeople, protest, etc. I agree that it's frustratingly difficult to figure out what the movement wants, but (even unaligned) protest is a perfectly legitimate way to express (even general) displeasure with your (perhaps even falsely perceived) current government.

gaurav_v··on Harvey Golub's Response To Warren Buffett
There are a number of huge problems with this argument, but the most important problems are the common ones:

1. There's just so much waste!

The byline reads: "Before you ask for more tax money from me, raise the $2.2 trillion you already collect each year more fairly and spend it more wisely." This is then supported by a few examples which don't address any of the big entitlement programs necessary for nontrivial tax-reform.

2. I pay such a large percent of the taxes!

He draws authority from the fact that "Today, top earners—the 250,000 people who earn $1 million or more—pay 20% of all income taxes, and the 3% who earn more than $200,000 pay almost half. Almost half of all filers pay no income taxes at all. Clearly they earn less and should pay less. But they should pay something and have a stake in our government spending their money too."

This is clearly a less meaningful statistic than percentage of income paid, which was the crux of Buffett's argument. If I posses say, 90% of the assets in some country X, certainly it doesn't make sense for me to yell, 'hey, I pay like, 60% of the taxes in this place, and all of you Xonian slackers in the bottom 5% are skating by on a free ride.' It particularly doesn't make sense if, as he proposes, there is no tax on gifting money to your (grand)children, and so perhaps I just inherited the wealth.

gaurav_v··on A lack of sleep can kill you
That's assuming that you value all years equally, which most people don't.
gaurav_v··on Vandalised home puts pressure on Airbnb
The last line of her most recent blog post pretty much sums up the entire thrust of her story and its problems for Airbnb:

"And for those who have so generously suggested a donation fund be set up to help me recover, I thank you from the bottom of my heart, and suggest that instead, you keep the money and use it to book yourself into a nice, safe hotel room the next time you travel. You’ll be glad you did."

gaurav_v··on Why I read Hacker News even though I understand very little of it
Because they're ... reading it?
gaurav_v··on What really drives the poor
Regarding Gates: A lot of people can afford to go to Harvard given financial aid. I think the more relevant point to his story is that his parents were so wealthy they could send him to an elite private _middle and high school,_ where he had access to a computer.
gaurav_v··on LulzSec Hackers Make Enemies Online
Someone in a previous discussion mentioned that the internet was still very much 'the wild west' with regard to security. I thought it was interesting that the story told here seems like something right out of an old western movie.
gaurav_v··on MIT is a national treasure
This is rare, but not unheard of; I can think of fiveish people off the top of my head that were admitted to MIT and Caltech without a high school diploma. All of the cases I know of are kids who just decided to leave high school without finishing their requirements, and went directly into one of the tech schools a year early.

The blog post mentions that there 'was no place nearby to go to high school.' That's really the issue in play. All of the 'MIT a year early' people I know about made a case to admissions that they had exhausted all of the resources at their schools and the time for MIT was now. The tech schools don't discriminate against lack of opportunity. If you're perceived as not taking all of the opportunities presented to you, though, you're finished. The post mentions that he took some community college classes. This shows a desire to learn and an ability to take advantage of the resources available to him. If he hadn't gotten a high school diploma because he was just too cool to be bothered, I imagine that he would have had more of an uphill battle.

gaurav_v··on Goodbye to academic research
"You hardly have postdoctoral positions in math, physics and social sciences."

I don't know anything about the social sciences. In physics, I know that postdocs are absolutely necessary and expected, to the same degree that they are in the life sciences.

Mathematics is a little different. There are a very small minority of prodigy-types that go right from graduate school to the tenure track. However, post-doc's are still the norm, although they don't go by the name 'postdoc.' Usually they are pronounced 'visiting assistant professor' or 'instructor.'

Here's an example of a 'postdoc' in mathematics. All of the big universities have them:

http://www.mathjobs.org/jobs/jobs/1815

gaurav_v··on Goodbye to academic research
"Competition for a job in math is way lower than it is for biological sciences."

Actually, the opposite is true, at least in the United States. Many more Biological Science PhDs are granted relative to mathematics, but there is also a lot more funding in the life sciences relative to mathematics.

The mathematics job market is more similar to the notorious humanities market than to the life sciences.

gaurav_v··on Stop trying to make maths "fun" - lessons also for coding?
This "Mathematician's Lament" is (by far) the best critique of the modern mathematics education that I've seen to date:

http://www.maa.org/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf

gaurav_v··on Great Math Books as Recommended by Our Readers
He posts answers to the exercises on his website as the course progresses each year. This year there are no answers because he's not teaching the course; he's on sabbatical.
gaurav_v··on Great Math Books as Recommended by Our Readers
Milne's notes are an awesome resource.
gaurav_v··on Great Math Books as Recommended by Our Readers
I would strongly suggest Jerry Shurman's Calculus and Multivariable Calculus texts, which are available for free on his website: people.reed.edu/~jerry/
gaurav_v··on Lecture notes on Computational Geometry
Some notes on discrete differential geometry:

http://ddg.cs.columbia.edu/

gaurav_v··on And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Patent Trolls
My favorite example of the broken patent system is United States Patent 6368227: Method of swinging on a swing.

Abstract: "A method of swing on a swing is disclosed, in which a user positioned on a standard swing suspended by two chains from a substantially horizontal tree branch induces side to side motion by pulling alternately on one chain and then the other."

Link: http://www.freepatentsonline.com/6368227.html

And some news coverage: http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn2178-boy-takes-swing-a...

gaurav_v··on Mathematics: The Most Misunderstood Subject
I too am super pumped about Lie algebras, and have come up against the issue of how to explain the topic to my less mathematically inclined friends.

You have to start with groups. Group structure is something that's both beautiful and something that can be truly appreciated in a 'cocktail party' setting. And you can't convey anything of substance and true about Lie algebras to someone who doesn't know what a group is.

Then, once your listener is happy and feeling smarter about his new group theory knowledge, you can try to motivate the idea of a Lie algebra however best fits with your research. This way, you are able to tell your listener something comprehensible, and also hint at what else is out there.

At least, I've found that this explanation keeps people pretty happy.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2