1,600 karma · joined May 8, 2011
I don't have enough data to know if I agree with his point (especially since the GHG changes form), but his "long-term" refers to the life cycle of a single cow.
A question for those well-versed in the biomedical and ecological sciences: Could our attempts to eliminate viruses be a bad thing? I wonder about the ripple effects of ecosystems on each other. We do not brag about extinction of any other natural entity.
And, when eradication does not work, when we only hinder the growth of a virus, does the attempt to prevent infection (or any form of "mostly cleaned up" coverage) encourage the development of superviruses by selecting for the strongest in the set, in the same way bacteria do? If not, why?
This line is when I decided this was probably a PR placement. I guess that maybe took me a bit longer than most, but it just feels so stilted.
"We passed our test, but we'd want to pass more." - then why did it 'pass'?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
One should seriously estimate and discuss the environmental implications of such a change before working towards it though, I think.
It might slightly favor HFTs if things do change across those 5 minute downtimes. Otherwise, your orders should be just as valid before the freeze as after, no?
I agree with you mostly - especially on the discussion of what "probable cause" should be defined as and what constitutes a "random" search, as just an example of some of the ethical issues of interest here. That is a debate to have and even one I think this community is well equipped to discuss, but it was not something I was trying to comment on.
I was only making the point that it wasn't fair to jump on the 93% as though it was representative of the problem. I am not taking any ethical or defensive position of drug dogs here.
Even more so, I think that is actually what is happening here. An officer is acting as a tier 1 filter, and then the drug dog is acting as a tier 2 filter, further reducing the number of false positives, which in a "legal and ethical" sense, we generally feel are worse than false negatives.
---
93% alert rate means:
93% = false positive + true positive
7% = true negative + false negative
---
We're given "His success rate was much lower, at 59 percent." Assuming that means that 59% are true positives, we know the false positive rate is 34%.
Without data on how many passengers are carrying drugs, we can't say anything about the rest of that result. A plausible world where the drug dog may be valuable is when he unquestionably rules out that 7% of the population that he doesn't alert on, as in false negative = 0.
I believe the reason this number is so high (59%) is that the officer has already used his suspicion to determine filter out most people. This makes the value of the "ruling out" plausibility even more valuable: the drug dog reduces searches compared to trusting the cop.
Ideally, they'd provide the receiver operating characteristics curve [0] or the confusion matrix [1].
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Receiver_operating_characteris... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confusion_matrix
This shouldn't fail. It resolves to an IP owned by The Coca Cola Corp (not an internal IP)
To really confirm this, try bringing two watches to a watchmaker at different times, one a $5,000 watch and one a $500 watch. Ask what a service costs. The gap tends to exist even if the movements are the same!
1) basically dominates the entire space of statistical analysis
2) was almost entirely irrelevant to the article
...struck me as pretty artificial to me too.