HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

geezerjay

3,623 karma · joined July 17, 2016

submissionscomments
geezerjay··on I don't want to be a full-fullstack developer
HR drones focus on qualifications because it frees them from the responsibility of actually having to evaluate and corroborate that a candidate is competent in a field.
geezerjay··on The shittiest project I ever worked on (2013)
> The key lesson here, I think, is not “corporations are stupid,” but that “corporations are too complex for linear requirements-gathering to in many cases support.”

This comment should be featured higher in a discussion. The "stupid" label is thrown rather fast although more often than not the problem lies in how critics fail to understand the problem and, more importantly, the restrictions applied to the decision-making process. Therefore critics base their view on their personal and very over-simplified and under-informed view of the problem, don't understand how an outcome is a valid and reasonable solution, and instead of assuming that they have limited information and understanding... They instead assume they have perfect information and complete insight into a problem and therefore any outcome they didn't approve or understand can only mean stupidity.

geezerjay··on The shittiest project I ever worked on (2013)
> which in many ways makes me think about the fact that a lot of it is not far from privatized basic income.

Research grants also fit that description quite nicely.

geezerjay··on The shittiest project I ever worked on (2013)
> Ugh. Reading stuff like this gets me deeply sad; what could have been done with that money and time instead?

You're assuming that an organization can whip out the best proposal possible at a moment's notice, which is highly unlikely. What you perceive as waste is simply development costs, without which the organization could not come up with the most competitive option possible.

Complaining that having different teams working internally on a product is wasteful is just like complaining that a sports team that hiring backup players and running development league teams is wasteful.

geezerjay··on The Huawei Disaster Reveals Google’s Iron Grip on Android
It seems you've missed the point.

Additinally, the Apple whataboutism is a non-sequitur that adds zero to the discussion.

geezerjay··on The Huawei Disaster Reveals Google’s Iron Grip on Android
>You can trivially install Google play store and services on 98% of the non-licensed phones in China.

You mean Google's own Google Play store?

Sounds like Google is in control of that one as well.

geezerjay··on Near-duplicate features of C++ (2017)
Qt code uses 'new' extensively because Qt components take ownership of components and manage memory allocation automatically.
geezerjay··on Near-duplicate features of C++ (2017)
> Now you aren't even supposed to do `new`, but rather std::shared_ptr<...> or std::unique_ptr<...> (as appropriate).

Apples and oranges. Smart pointers are wrappers over raw pointers. They extend functionality, but are not the same.

> Except that you generally create them with std::make_shared() and std::make_unique()

Again, apples and oranges. You're confusing factory functions that wrap memory allocation for convenience with actual memory allocation.

At most you could only complain that those factory methods duplicate the role of constructors, which would be silly.

> And then you have the fun of passing those to a function. Do you pass by value (shared_ptr) or by reference (I believe you do not) or pass a naked pointer (when you need to pass a unique_ptr to a function that uses, but does not modify or cache the pointer, if I remember correctly).

There is no duplication in your examples. You are just unaware of how those functionalities are used.

geezerjay··on Almost 40% of Americans Would Struggle to Cover a $400 Emergency
> For me, having to put it on a credit card is effectively not being able to cover it,

That may be your personal opinion but that contrasts with both the facts and pushes a narrative that doesn't fit reality. For example, I routinely charge unexpected expenses on a credit card although I am more than capable of easily covering them with my savings. I'm sure thay the sheer convenience of charging expenses on a CC drives the decisions of regular CC users, specially as some CC plans charge 0% interests under some conditions.

geezerjay··on Elon Musk’s Boring Company lands $48.7M contract for underground “people mover”
It should also be noted that london's postal service also deployed 2ft-wide tunnels to cart mail through the city, which was launched in the late 1920s.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Post_Office_Railway

geezerjay··on Elon Musk’s Boring Company lands $48.7M contract for underground “people mover”
IIRC TBC never announced any "fantastic new tech", in spite of the marketing effort. It seems they have COTS tunneling equipment, a knack for ignoring basic establish practices, and a enthusiastic PR team.
geezerjay··on PEP 594 – Removing dead batteries from Python's standard library
> A much older example: The C standard library includes a function that's very narrowly useful for copying strings into fixed width buffers with no terminator, called strncpy()

Arguably, what makes C the perfect example is not necessarily its standard library functions per se but the language's official string data type.

geezerjay··on Teen shot herself with gunshot through mouth while hands cuffed behind back
> This, to me, is one of the primary tenants of what is evil about naziism, or tyranny, or whatever you call it.

One of the biggest disservice that has been made towards humanity is the fabrication of this notion that evil totalitarian regimes such as Nazi Germany or Communist Russia are exceptional events created by exceptional individuals who are extraoedinarily evil up to a supernatural/cartoonish level. This fabricated sense of exceptionalisn leads people to believe that thesr massive levels of cruelty are impossible to reproduce, thus there is no likelihood that our little world could ever descend into that state of affairs, even when we repeatedly see cases where police forces assassinate citizens with complete impunity.

geezerjay··on Why I’m rewriting my SaaS
> If you're building something that's going to get a predictable load of 10k QPS and is only going to read from a DB and return some data it might be a good idea to break that out, run that in a serverless configuration, etc.

Serverless costs you money. Running a low-volume db in the same VM you serve the site and the web api costs you zero.

geezerjay··on Ask HN: How to performance test React webapps for rendering speed regressions?
Don't mind the downvotes. Thank you for taking the time to post such an insightful post.
geezerjay··on Ecuador has begun giving the US some of Julian Assange’s possessions
It is quite clear that political asylums are political, thus they depend on the political will of those who hold power in a specific moment in time.
geezerjay··on Ecuador has begun giving the US some of Julian Assange’s possessions
> Watching the video is enough to dispel that.

Doesn't the video show a group of gunmen who the camera guy was following around?

geezerjay··on American life is improving for the lowest paid
You personally chose to use "people on HN" as your barometer. So, if you failed to see the point you tried to make then you're the only one to blame here.
geezerjay··on New $14 esp32 VGA/mouse/keyboard/VT100 computer capable of running micropython
> No, having fun is not about on-paper specs.

Actually, it is. Specs dictate the potential uses of a device, and a more expensive but less capable option simply means users have to pay more to be able to achieve less.

In this case one option appears to be outclassed im every criteria. If these technical aspects weren't relevant then the specs wouldn't have been presented as the device's selling point.

geezerjay··on New $14 esp32 VGA/mouse/keyboard/VT100 computer capable of running micropython
> It's a fun hobbyist computer, not a technical shootout.

It is obviously a technical shootout. Time and money are a finite commodity and having to spend more on a less capable device that takes more work to get up and running is not a good way to invest our resources.

geezerjay··on New $14 esp32 VGA/mouse/keyboard/VT100 computer capable of running micropython
Aren't OrangePi Zero devboards more bang for the buck?

Edit: why are you downvoting a honest question?

geezerjay··on Standards.REST: A Collection of HTTP/REST API Standards and Specs
> Hmmm... not to be a curmudgeon, but will this help much? Or like what is the intended purpose of this, awareness?

What's the difference? Developers can only leverage existing technology if they are aware they exist, and unfortunately specs such as the "home document for HTTP APIs" draft aren't publicized that often, so developers tend to waste time reinventing the wheel.

> Additionally, this would be more useful it contained (I didn’t see any from my phone) links to example implementations or discussions about the RFC.

Typically specs already include examples. For example, picking up again the "home document for HTTP APIs" draft, section 2 starts off with a clear example of such a document.

geezerjay··on Standards.REST: A Collection of HTTP/REST API Standards and Specs
> No HATEOAS? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HATEOAS

HATEOAS is not a standard nora specification. It's a basic part of the REST architecture style.

> "When designing a hypermedia API [per HATEOAS standards], you're really designing for a client that does not, and will never, exist."

I don't believe this is factual or even conceivable. Arguably, OData speficies a standard that designs clients and servers that are full-on REST (per HATEOAS standards) and it does exist and is used in the wild for some years now.

Additionally, there are other standards and specs that do help to implement full-on REST, such as HAL or JSON-LD.

geezerjay··on Being a PhD student shouldn’t be bad for your health
Not the OP but the straw that broke the back of my PhD's camel was an exchange with my supervisor that went something like this:

Supervisor: I need to improve my metrics and you only published a paper last year. You owe me 3 papers in the next 6 months.

Me: How am I going to write 3 papers?

Supervisor: You figure it out.

Me: What topic should I write about?

Supervisor: That's your job.

geezerjay··on Uber Drivers Are Contractors, Not Employees, Labor Board Says
> The important benefits of having a job as opposed to gigging can be summarized as "the employer should not have complete power over the employee".

That's also a big fat red herring.

The clients of a service are not employers of the contractor, and just because a contractor decides to invest some of his time to provide a service through ads posted on a job board that connects clients and service providers it does not mean that the job board suddenly becomes an employer.

geezerjay··on To Message Bus or Not: Distributed Systems Design (2017)
> The problem nowadays is that people don't want to learn the proven stuff. People want to learn the new hip framework. Learning Kubernetes and React.js is much more fun than learning how actual routing in TCP/IP works, right?

That's an awfully short-sighted comparison.

There are far more job offers for deploying and managing systems with kubernetes and to develop front-ends with React than there are for developing TCP/IP infrastructure. It's fun to earn a living and enjoy the priviledges of having a high salary, and the odds you get that by studying solved problems that nowadays just work are not that high.

geezerjay··on Use links not keys to represent relationships in APIs
In REST you do not need URI templates. You discover the invoice collection endpoint through the root endpoint, and once you have a ID you can, say, query the invoice collection endpoint to get to the invoice.
geezerjay··on To Message Bus or Not: Distributed Systems Design (2017)
> If you have a mix of pub-sub, work queues and request-response, it could simplify your dependencies perhaps.

That's a good point. Indeed if the project is already rolling with a message bus then it wouldn't make much sense to increase complexity just to use a specific message exchange pattern.

geezerjay··on To Message Bus or Not: Distributed Systems Design (2017)
> To attempt to define it, I would say architecture has far more to do with _where_ I draw bounded context lines than how or what tools I use to do so.

Your definition makes no sense at all. There is no distinction. Architecture specifies which components comprise the system, their interfaces, their responsibilities, and how components are expected to interact with each other. You pick certain tools because they are expected to handle certain responsibilities, because they implement certain interfaces, and because they support or enable certain types of interactions. There is no distinction.

geezerjay··on To Message Bus or Not: Distributed Systems Design (2017)
> I recommend looking at a standard messaging protocol like AMQP 1.0, which will allow you to implement the request-response pattern in an efficient manner without message brokers.

Honest question: if the goal is to implement the request/response pattern then why should anyone adopt AMQP instead of plain REST/RPC-over-HTTP?

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →