HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

geographomics

1,052 karma · joined August 17, 2014

25db6c1376d93247b27c430492fd49@gmail.com
submissionscomments
geographomics··on Why are we obsessed with the Nazis?
Also the UK still invokes compulsory sterilisation, there was a case this past week: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-31128969
geographomics··on UK to allow babies from three people
This paper from 2011 has a nice comparison of the two methods, there's pros and cons for both: [1]

According to the HFEA [2], the research group in Newcastle (who wrote the above paper) has been testing the two methods against each other - no decision yet as to the best for treatment, though.

[1] http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/content/20/R2/R168.full#sec-5

[2] Section 3.4.4 of http://www.hfea.gov.uk/docs/Third_Mitochondrial_replacement_...

geographomics··on UK to allow babies from three people
That's not the problem - if such a technique worked (it's been attempted in mice [1,2]), two males could produce XX or XY offspring, as you get X sperms and Y sperms. The restriction would be on two females, they could only combine to make XX.

[1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/6722870

[2] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4123998/

geographomics··on UK to allow babies from three people
I think "three people" is okay as it correctly gets across how many contributors there are of genetic and other biological material.

Some other sources have been referring to "three-parent babies" though, which doesn't seem right, as the mitochondrial donor has no maternal role or rights to the baby.

geographomics··on UK to allow babies from three people
No I think we're both correct - sorry, I didn't explain myself properly! I agree with you that it was definitely still banned for implantation.

But by having that clause about mitochondrial disease in, it enabled researchers to investigate (and the the HFE Authority to permit research on) human mitochondrial transfer techniques in vitro by explicitly pointing out the possibility of a future redefinition.

EDIT: this explains it much better than I'm trying to - http://www.hfea.gov.uk/mitochondrial-disease-new-research.ht...

geographomics··on UK to allow babies from three people
Perhaps I'm reading this incorrectly, but as far I can see it was implicitly banned in the 1990 Act by section 3(3d). And then section 3ZA(5) as introduced in 2008 enabled the development of oocyte or embryo-modifying technologies to prevent mitochondrial disease.
geographomics··on UK to allow babies from three people
Yes, it was explicitly banned in 1990, with the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act. In 2008 the government modified the act to allow mitochondrial transfer under future regulations, which enabled such research to take place on human tissue [1].

[1] Section 4 of http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukdsi/2015/9780111125816/pdfs/...

geographomics··on Ask HN: How do I secure a personal journal?
No, just encrypting the data. Anything more would have seemed excessive for my use case.
geographomics··on 2015: The Year of the OpenBSD Desktop
Starting a sentence with "so" (or any other conjunction) is a valid stylistic preference.
geographomics··on Thepiratebay.se is back online
That's true. But to clarify, I wasn't making any claim about the ethics of piracy, just the motivation behind doing it.
geographomics··on Thepiratebay.se is back online
> Well, it is [selfish]. Just like any form of protest.

Not always - for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Apartheid_Movement#A_cons...

geographomics··on Thepiratebay.se is back online
The blank media levy may well be unfair, but I don't see how enabling or engaging in widespread piracy helps fight against that. It probably does the opposite, given the rationale behind such taxes.
geographomics··on Thepiratebay.se is back online
Pirating movies, music, software and so on strikes me as a mostly selfish act, and only loosely related to being anti-government due to there being laws against stealing (in the copyright infringement sense).

Also I don't really see the distinction between watching football, and watching whatever movie one has pirated via sites such as TPB.

geographomics··on Ask HN: How do I secure a personal journal?
I'd also like to add that if fountain pens are too much of a hassle, it's worth trying out some of the nicer ballpoint type pens. Rather than settling for a cheap, scratchy biro or whatever. Personally I find these to be very nice indeed: https://www.google.com/search?q=UB-157
geographomics··on Ask HN: How do I secure a personal journal?
I used to keep a diary this way, and eventually decided on using an encrypted Word document. The encryption in Office used to be very weak in early versions, but it's much better these days.

In recent versions of Office (from 2007 onwards, using the DOCX format), by default it uses AES in CBC mode, with an SHA-1 based key derivation function [1].

So with a sufficiently complex password your documents will be resistant to cracking. But of course you are still vulnerable to keyloggers and the like.

[1] https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/office/cc313071(v=o...

geographomics··on Signing in to websites with SSH
> We introduced the notion of a session where we already had one, in the form of TLS sessions.

But that would only apply to HTTPS. An extension to HTTP itself was necessary so state could be maintained for both HTTP and HTTPS. Especially in the mid-1990s (the era when cookies and HTTPS were introduced) when acquiring a CA-signed certificate was cumbersome and expensive.

geographomics··on Signing in to websites with SSH
How is this better than using cookies? I don't really see the advantage of moving session identification down a layer.
geographomics··on A Heroin Dealer Tells the Silk Road Jury What It Was Like to Sell Drugs Online
> Drug usage is a personal decision and it's none of state's business.

I agree with this up to the point where drug use becomes drug addiction. Of course this doesn't happen to everyone who uses drugs recreationally, but if it does, then it's not so much a decision but a relentless compulsion that thoroughly decimates one's freedom to choose.

Whether it's the state's business or not, I suppose that depends on whether one feels the state has some responsibility towards the mental and physical health of its citizens. I'm very much in favour of harm reduction programmes for drug addicts, rather than the prevailing trend of terribly harsh punishment. Some may feel that this sort of thing is too paternalistic and interfering but it's certainly better than imprisonment.

geographomics··on A Heroin Dealer Tells the Silk Road Jury What It Was Like to Sell Drugs Online
Your 23% statistic is very revealing; in recent years there's been a lot of research into the underlying neurobiology of addiction. Turns out that addicts are often quite predisposed to getting addicted, either through genetics (such as variants in the components of neurotransmitter systems) or their early environment. And through long-term changes in the brain from substance abuse - as an example, over-consuming alcohol over time can damage the frontal cortex, impairing decision-making, including deciding to stop drinking, so you end up with this feedback loop of sorts.

I find it very unfortunate that society hasn't caught up with this way of thinking and mostly still regards addiction as a moral vice, rather than a lifelong illness.

geographomics··on A Heroin Dealer Tells the Silk Road Jury What It Was Like to Sell Drugs Online
In support of what you're saying: many countries (but not the US) take a less punitive approach, preferring to focus on harm reduction.

For example in the UK, needle exchanges - places where you can get clean needles and other paraphenalia - have been well established since the late 1980s to help protect people who inject drugs against the infection risks of needle sharing. It's been credited with greatly reducing the prevalence of HIV and hepatitis viruses amongst that population.

Similarly, heroin addicts are often prescribed synthetic opiates such as methadone and buprenorphine, to prevent their reliance on dealers. This doesn't much reduce deaths from overdose, but does seem to prevent societal harm. Indeed if you are charged with theft or robbery and it turns out that it was to help feed your opiate addiction, it's not uncommon for the judge to offer access to a treatment programme in lieu of a custodial sentence.

There is however a problem with user compliance. Some recent research over the past decade or so has been in 'contingency management', where addicts are offered financial rewards to attend or comply with such treatments. It's very controversial and so far has had mixed results, but the idea is that the overall cost to the state will be reduced, in that a small 'bribe' can put people on the right path, hopefully leading to feeling more intrinsically rewarded by the success of the treatment, and that is less expensive than medical treatment later on.

But despite all this, as you imply, it does need the political will behind it to have any good effect.

geographomics··on One Week of Harassment on Twitter
Talking about unsavoury experiences is a very valuable method of dealing with them.

Perhaps what you really meant was, shut up and take the abuse quietly? Not a very helpful suggestion.

geographomics··on One Week of Harassment on Twitter
I don't think it's fair to equate the barrage of foul insults Anita is receiving, with her simply saying: look at what I have to put up with.

At most, this is a semi-circle of hatred. The other half of the circle being a mixture of disclosure and, I imagine, catharsis.

geographomics··on One Week of Harassment on Twitter
Twitter is mostly public, so it is really a case of self-shaming on the part of the abusive commenters.
geographomics··on Holy Shit, I Interviewed the President
I don't know how widespread this opinion is, but I certainly wouldn't want to be. If some work I'd created became immensely popular then that would be fine, but putting myself out there to relentless, intrusive scrutiny sounds hellish.
geographomics··on Graydon Hoare on Rust 1.0.0-alpha
Didn't he step down voluntarily?[1] Or is there some back story to this that is not general knowledge?

[1] https://mail.mozilla.org/pipermail/rust-dev/2013-August/0054...

geographomics··on Feds found Silk Road 2 servers after a six-month attack on Tor?
We know that a global adversary exists, and that Tor is vulnerable to certain types of attacks by such an adversary (e.g. [1,2]). Given that the list of relays is public by design, that their (albeit encrypted) communication can be monitored by the adversary, that popular hidden services will be moving a significant amount of traffic to and from a single static IP address in a manner modifiable by any user of it, and that there are known methods of disrupting hidden services to effect a global change in this [3] - it follows that such hidden services are rather more vulnerable to deanonymisation, compared to most other users. Seems like running one is an incredibly risky thing to be doing.

[1] http://cryptome.org/2013/08/tor-users-routed.pdf

[2] https://mice.cs.columbia.edu/getTechreport.php?techreportID=...

[3] http://donncha.is/2013/05/trawling-tor-hidden-services/

geographomics··on Students Against Mass Surveillance on Campus
I don't think you've made a strong case for mass surveillance having a significant effect of self-censorship.

The study you cited [1] is an interesting read, but its applicability to mass surveillance is questionable. Being informed that your opinions on a specific topic - of which you are acutely aware are being immediately recorded - will definitely be reported to the police, is not the same as the more vague notion of some unknown entity recording and possibly analysing your everyday words. There may be a perceptual difference between personal surveillance and mass surveillance, which is not addressed in that study. As an analogy, consider the ubiquitous, largely unnoticed CCTV coverage in urban areas, versus the acutely uncomfortable feeling of being followed down the street - the two perceptions are quite different.

That survey of writers linked by Schneier [2] describes its limitations - namely, that it is not really representative of all writers, only those that self-selected (from an email sent to them on the topic of government surveillance) to answer the survey, and that the sample sizes are relatively small. Also, the writers surveyed are all affiliated with the organisation conducting the survey, an advocacy group for freedom of expression. This may well bias the results towards that group rather than writers in general. Indeed, the report authors explicitly state: "the findings cannot be generalized to represent all writers in any given region or level of freedom."

Another point specific to students is that, if they choose to pursue an academic career, it necessitates publishing research to a wide audience (wider than their professional colleagues, at least). Surveillance involves the intrusion of privacy, but publication is essentially the opposite of privacy, so how can it be negatively affected by surveillance, and mass surveillance in particular?

[1] http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?Location=U2&doc=GetTRDo...

[2] http://www.pen.org/sites/default/files/Global%20Chilling_01-...

geographomics··on Students Against Mass Surveillance on Campus
> The ability of students to learn and grow is severely hampered when governments monitor our communications and social media activity.

Is there any evidence of this? Why would monitoring students' social media activity and emails negatively affect their ability to learn?

geographomics··on Why Men Love War (1984)
I'm not sure why you're being downvoted as man's apparent propensity for war is a very curious question. Expert opinions seem quite divided on whether it has biological roots or if is a cultural artefact.

Some interesting reading on the matter:

http://discovermagazine.com/2012/jun/07-is-war-inevitable-by...

http://discovermagazine.com/2012/jun/02-no-war-is-not-inevit...

http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/2014/09/17/n...

geographomics··on Charlie Hebdo: first cover since terror attack depicts prophet Muhammad
Of course, just stop replying.
← PreviousPage 6 of 10Next →