HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

george_ciobanu

220 karma · joined December 6, 2010

submissionscomments
george_ciobanu··on It's Time for a DevTools for Designers
Also check out bubble.is
george_ciobanu··on China Busts a $3B Underground Bank
True there’s no right to a market. At the end of the day they can impose any rules they like and it’s up to companies to accept them or not.

But don’t make China look like a sad puppy who needs help. It’s a ferocious tiger (good for them) whose economic and military prominence would scare me and everyone who likes free speech and non authoritarian rule.

george_ciobanu··on China Busts a $3B Underground Bank
Leaving history aside (do we really want to apply 16th century economics rules today? No) your statement that any country would do the same thing is untrue in many ways. There are IP laws that protect a comoany's right to keep its secrets and extract value out of them for a number of years. That's a bit too long in some cases but this is what makes modern economy possible. A company invests tons of money in R&D and then gets it back through patents they can protect.

For a government to extort companies to give up their IP is to steal, no mincing words.

Especially if the companies and people given access to the information extracted are close to the government, it's just another tool for them to control the economic environment with politics.

To claim this is some Robin Hood scheme that will bring equality in the world is to say stealing from rich countries is ok and we should do it more, companies be damned. It's essentially an extreme firm of communism and as someone who lived in that system for a while and is has first hand experience of how frustrating corrupted governments are to doing business, I can point at virtually all attempts to make it work and we can all see how they failed.

Chins wants to be competitive at someone else's R&D expense.

Edit: China improving is terrifying would you like to have that political system in your country? If yes most of would would rather have freedom of speech which btw allows us to have this conversation without fearing a knock on the door and prison for life.

george_ciobanu··on Structor – React UI Builder
Check out Bubble at bubble.is
george_ciobanu··on What Is Life? (1944) [pdf]
I flirted with this idea for a long time after hearing it and wanted to like it but in hindsight it's pretty easy to prove it wrong.

Yes entropy creates pressure on life and has a hand in pretty much everything, but Earth has an abundance of free (Gibbs) energy that insulates it and creates a new kind of environment and conditions.

It's like saying that hunger drives social complexity. It's part of it but it doesn't drive it.

Yes you could apply Newtonian physics to everyday social encounters and structures but they're way too broad and generic to derive meaning conclusions at the interpersonal level.

george_ciobanu··on Smarter speed bump using non-Newtonian liquid
Did nobody notice the lady at 00:40 and the bizarre gestures she is asked to do during the demonstration?
george_ciobanu··on The Matasano Crypto Challenges (2013)
Favorite part:

"One final observation. Crypto is like catnip for programmers. It is hard to keep us away from it, because it's challenging and fun to play with. And programmers respond very badly to the insinuation that they're not clever enough to do something. We see the F-16 just sitting there, keys in the ignition, no one watching, lights blinking, ladder extended. And some infosec nerd is telling us we're can't climb in there, even though we just want to taxi around a little and we've totally read the manual."

george_ciobanu··on Is the open office layout dead?
See Joel Spolski's floor design.
george_ciobanu··on The Strange Disappearance of Cooperation in America (2013)
The weight shifts but the overall value stays relatively constant: Quebecers give less than most Americans to homeless people because there are lots more social programs in place. Overalk, those in need get roughly the same amount of support.
george_ciobanu··on Why I Choose Delphi
Bubble.is is Delphi for the web, but better.
george_ciobanu··on How Aging Research Is Changing Our Lives
https://www.elysiumhealth.com/

Also see Peter Thiel's work on blood change.

george_ciobanu··on Ableton Live Redesign
"This is my unsolicited redesign of the Ableton Live. I did this to showcase my design skills to peers working at Ableton, where I would love to work as a designer."
george_ciobanu··on A Startup Making Paper Out of Stone, Not Trees
Trees aside, this is not a new concept, stone paper notebooks have been around for a while. The ones I had wrote incredibly smooth and I loved every one of them. I think Walgreens still carries a small one.

https://www.walgreens.com/store/c/oxford-stone-paper-note-bo...

george_ciobanu··on Hiring without whiteboards
One more thing: the interview process is as much about assessing team dynamics as skill/ability. I wouldn't hire Linus at my own company because he's kind of an asshole. I could be wrong but this is the perception I have from interviews etc. I love his work but can't say I'd like to work on a team that shares his style. It's important to stress that I never talked to him I just saw some interviews. His emails actually seem very reasonable and thoughtful, and he comes across as a regular person.
george_ciobanu··on Hiring without whiteboards
I agree with your general approach to a more holistic interview process. I haven't thought too much about the weights so can't comment there.

I'm pretty sure the weights vary depending on roles: interviewing a tech lead for ML requires deep experience in That field and will have more of those questions than basic CS algs. Or at least a higher weight than it would in a fresh graduate.

It's not my place to judge the average ability of Google engineers. I'd guess it's a normal curve somewhat skewed to the right since the bar is really high. In my limited experience they're on par with top silicon valley engineers but have a different profile than startup ones due to self-selection.

The point of many interviews is to reduce false positives, both for skill and professionalism. It works amazingly well. Every single person I talk to has something interesting to say and is at the very least competent at what they are doing. Not everyone feels brilliant but everyone does seem bright. And I'm not drinking the cool aid.

Hiring good people is easy if you just test for skills. It's much harder to make sure someone is a genuine person, or at least not an asshole. Google does a tremendous job here and I worked at enough startups and a few large companies to know how incredibly difficult that is.

That other companies failed trying to do this can be because of many reasons, from bad engineers to start with, lack of resources, mistakes in assessing ability or rush to get devs on the team asap. Again, not my place to comment.

Every company asking its employees to interview prospects implicitly assumed they are good, or at least competent. If they don't, they have a bigger problem to start with.

If they hired someone they already think they are good, right? And if they ask them to interview someone else they think they are able to judge, or don't understand that logic (In which case they have even bigger problems).

How does a mediocre engineer fail a stellar one? If the candidate is really better than the interviewer, won't they be able to solve anything they ask them to?

I think the reason multiple interviewers ask CS questions is to avoid the issue you mentioned earlier: asking one question the candidate just so happens to know really well. Random sampling should solve it.

I interviewed at Palantir a long time ago and was asked super hard CS questions over the phone and in the first rounds and I killed it. The last round I was tired because I hadn't slept well and tanked one problem. Just one, everything else I had solved really well. Yes I thought it was silly to reject me and wish they had given me another shot. If you are at Palantir and are asked to interview someone, think they are bad, and they get hired, it's demoralizing - you just wasted your time and the company doesn't value your opinion. Sure, you could have a score and average things but again, firing is way way worse than saying no to a good candidate who just had one bad question. And everyone I interviewed with was legit. (I had another series with them later, for a different role and got an offer :-) )

I agree that weights could be adjusted but 1. How do you know that would yield better results? (Show me the data - I don't think anyone has it) and 2. It can also be a cultural choice to bias more towards CS skills vs design or whatever else. Perhaps the company has great design patterns and can teach those skills v effectively. I'm not saying it's true, just an example. If you had a company and ran the interview process your way, I promise there will be someone just like you who vehemently disagrees with your weights :-). But if you could prove that process A vs B yields better outcomes, most companies would definitely follow suit (if they pay attention, are good at adjusting their processes etc).

I don't actually know how they read packets, I just know they work really hard to avoid false positives, and I wholeheartedly agree.

Btw I was rejected by Google twice before - resilience is part of the game ;-)

george_ciobanu··on Hiring without whiteboards
That's nice of you to say, though I'm not sure I earned your compliment.

Re experience - yes, if you're interviewing for someone with deep Java or ML knowledge certainly make sure the interviewer can assess that.

Logic puzzles are not perfect - I used to be really good at solving them and if I ever have to interview on them again, I'd definitely have to practice first, to get up to speed. But I do think that being able to solve them is a meta skill. If you get really good it entails that you are good at reasoning and solving complex problems, or at least a specific class. If you are good with trees you'll likely be able to answer a trie question. It doesn't mean you're just good at that, but that you can apply knowledge to new problems - which is exactly why you are hired. An equivalent real question I got in Java was how to access a private member of a class. If I knew the answer it would mean I have some random bit of trivia in my head. If I solve it using Java knowledge it means I can apply my domain expertise in a new way - that's compelling proof of problem solving skills. If I ask why would you want to do that, it indicates reflective and critical thinking skills.

A seasoned engineer in ML or Java should, imho also be able to solve puzzles. They are, in many ways, better proof of abstract thinking abilities and problem solving skills than specific knowledge. But I agree they are both important - if I want to build a search engine I prefer to have a seasoned ElasticSearch lady lead the project than an equally smart person with no background.

Re your friend, if it helps, I interviewed at a lot of companies and probably failed about 70% of interviews in the first week or two. I got much better after a few weeks, which proves your point that interviewing is also a skill. And I mean for both tech and behavior questions. That's normal, I think.

Re Google, while I don't represent the company, there are public statements that they'd rather have a false negative rate rather than false positives. It's better to say no to a great applicant (politely) than yes to a bad one. If you've ever had to let someone go, or deal with a bad team member, you know what I'm talking about. Of course there's the occasional interviewer who asks a silly question or gets something wrong. Do you never make mistakes? It's impossible to ensure everything goes perfectly in such a large company, but I can tell you, as someone who works here, that people try really hard to do a good job at it, and leave everyone with a good impression. It's the rational thing to do: if you treat people poorly 1. You're and asshole and 2. They'll hate you. Nobody likes assholes especially at Google, and I can share that I haven't met one yet. That's pretty amazing given the size. Thanks for engaging in this discussion, I really enjoy it.

george_ciobanu··on Hiring without whiteboards
Like I said I speak for myself not Google.

They're both valuable, perhaps for different types of work.

A balanced tree does not tell me much about a person's knowledge but how they are able to apply and learn CS concepts does. Deep knowledge of a problem domain is valuable, but also highly perishable - the world changes fast and good engineers need to learn and adapt. Furthermore, if a candidate speaks about a domain they have deep expertise in, we have two more problems: 1. The interviewer might not know enough about the field to assess the candidate. (Generic CS algs and data structures are a good common denominator). 2. A candidate's knowledge about a field doesn't tell me how good they are at reasoning. They may have spent 5 years doing that one thing - that's enough time to learn almost anything in a limited domain - say OS schedulers.

How would you structure an interview process?

george_ciobanu··on Hiring without whiteboards
Of course computer architecture, compiler knowledge etc is valuable and part of the interview process. I was referring to the general process of evaluating- - thus the question was focused on methods not content.

Additionally, explaining how a system works is valuable, and I captured it when mentioned communication abilities.

george_ciobanu··on Hiring without whiteboards
Disclaimer: I work at Google but in no way do I represent my employer's views. These are all my personal opinions.

I interned successfully at FB, Microsoft and Google as a SWE in 2008-2010 and interviewed with a lot of other tech companies (not always but often successfully). Like you, I tend to freeze up in a whiteboard situation, and have most of my life, going back to college and prior (I studied in Romania where at the time you had to stand up and answer questions and use a whiteboard to answer them). I find that a few things help:

1. Practice practice practice. Simulate the interview with a few friends multiple times. It gets easier no matter how shy you are.

2. Smart interviewers and companies open with easy, friendly questions that put the interviewee at ease. It's a sign they understand this is stressful for everyone, no matter how confident, knowledgeable and smart they are.

While these interviews aren't perfect, with the right attitude they are helpful: it shows how the person thinks through a problem and communicates their ideas, and how they "work together" with the interviewer.

These are important skills that are important for all people regardless of their title.

I also believe a solid CS foundation is important even if coding is mostly putting things together. A systematic, mathematical understanding of complexity of Algorithms and Data Structures shows in one's everyday decisions.

There are only a few valid alternatives in my mind: 1. Take-home project work More realistic assessment of how effective a person is. Really good simulation of that, but no signal about their collaboration style, interpersonal dynamics etc. 2. On-site trial for a week or two This is probably the best way to assess someone's ability - internships and residencies are as close to real life as one can get. It's hard for people who already have a job, and expensive for a company to do. Simpler proxies/filters are needed.

Am I missing any other ways to assess candidates?

george_ciobanu··on Tips to Improve Your Mental Math Ability
Laziness? I didn't like remembering to carry when multiplying 45x16 so I did 40x16 + 5x16 - easy to add two numbers in your head, hard to remember two shifted partial results (the way it's done on paper). Different media require different methods. 45x 16 on paper: 270+ 45 It's easy to see here but in your head you have to remember that 45 is shifted left when added to 270. Visually it makes sense but otherwise hard. Breaking things into multiplications by 10, five or other easy substeps is recursive and easy to trace back up.

Truth is I don't know how I came up with it, I think I was just lazy.

george_ciobanu··on How Uber Used Secret “Greyball” Tool to Deceive Authorities Worldwide
Values can be nuanced. Yes to free market but guess what, it occasionally needs checks and balances because while it works for a particular company it might bring society as a whole down. Infrastructure like roads and electricity should not be controlled by a company because it's supposed to benefit everyone.

Let's talk about Uber. Say they survive this situation and thrive as a business, taking over the global cab market. Imagine they also perfect self-driving cars and next month they fire all the drivers. Suddenly you have a company of ~10,000 people getting all the money from all rides around the world. And most of the money goes to the executives and a few thousand shareholders.

You now have a group of millions of people unable to make a living, and support their families. Apply this to all jobs that require mostly drivers (trucking, busses etc) and we just destroyed ~10 million jobs (including supporting infrastructure) in the US alone.

These people need to make a living - if Uber ends up paying super low tax (compared to what it displaces) we have a huge number of people making no money and a few getting all of it.

Civil unrest follows naturally (in one form or another) and you end up with either 1. Segmented civilization with a few people defending their wealth with hired guns 2. Social reform - guaranteed basic income for a while, but long term? 3. Revolution where the mob takes over and the outcome is anyone's guess - an extreme form of socialism?

It's not just about values, a lot of it is about long-term thinking.

Which of the three outcomes is better may be a question of values - is it better that a few people do super well and everyone else suffers, or most do pretty well?

Without some social stability and wellness companies cannot function - people need money to pay with, and without jobs there's not much money to go around.

george_ciobanu··on Google Goes Public with Unpatched Microsoft Edge and IE Vulnerability
"Project Zero's disclosure deadline policy has been in place since the formation of our team earlier in 2014. It's the result of many years of careful consideration and industry-wide discussions about vulnerability remediation. Security researchers have been using roughly the same disclosure principles for the past 13 years (since the introduction of "Responsible Disclosure" in 2001), and we think that our disclosure principles need to evolve with the changing infosec ecosystem. In other words, as threats change, so should our disclosure policy.

On balance, Project Zero believes that disclosure deadlines are currently the optimal approach for user security - it allows software vendors a fair and reasonable length of time to exercise their vulnerability management process, while also respecting the rights of users to learn and understand the risks they face. By removing the ability of a vendor to withhold the details of security issues indefinitely, we give users the opportunity to react to vulnerabilities in a timely manner, and to exercise their power as a customer to request an expedited vendor response."

From https://www.engadget.com/2015/01/02/google-posts-unpatched-m...

george_ciobanu··on Will Democracy Survive Big Data and Artificial Intelligence?
I agree with you on the first points. We don't know how soon computers will match us in intelligence and they're still underpowered but 2 things might accelerate their rise: 1. GPU computing. Much more similar to the brain. 2. IoT - it might bring computers the senses humans have today. A self-correcting ML system with access to broad sensors, huge computing resources and the Internet is starting to look surprisingly similar to our abilities and data access.
george_ciobanu··on Mathematicians becoming data scientists
A lot of these "arcane" topics have long-term horizons. Agree with everything else but the whole point of research is to probe the space of possibilities (theoretical and practical) to find major ideas. Most of them fail but that's part of the exploratory process - it's expected.
george_ciobanu··on Tips to Improve Your Mental Math Ability
I'm a bit surprised - I do almost all these things in my head anyway, never thought them as tricks just that I'm weird and cannot model school methods like others do. (Not trying to brag)
george_ciobanu··on Ask HN: What're the best-designed things you've ever used?
A dishwasher that only had one button: start. A dry cleaning service where they just told me to come back next day after 5p and never asked me how I want my shirts, what kind of treatment etc. For contrast most places ask several questions that I never know the answer to. The best UI is no UI.
george_ciobanu··on As Leaks Multiply, Fears of a ‘Deep State’ in America
There's a darker explanation than the two suggested already: that Russia actually controls people high in the administration (possibly more than one, including Trump) and intelligence agencies are fighting them.
george_ciobanu··on Reflecting on one very, very strange year at Uber
Susan, thank you for sharing and please accept a virtual hug to help you shake the experience. I'm amazed you were this patient with such ridiculous behavior.
george_ciobanu··on Let’s not demonize driving, just stop subsidizing it
Interstate roads and highways are also critical elements of national security - they act as the internet for transportation (by providing multiple redundant routes that can be easily patched, unlike railways)
george_ciobanu··on Understanding Agent Cooperation
"Scarce resources cause competition" and "Scarce but close to impossible to catch on own resources cause cooperation". Is that really a discovery worth publishing?
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →