HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

george_morgan

339 karma · joined April 14, 2009

submissionscomments
george_morgan··on Contacts in the Browser
This seems similar in aims to the Firefox fork Flock, not sure if Flock is still in active development though. It also seems very “un-Firefox” considering Firefox (Phoenix…) began as a slimmed down Mozilla/Netscape Suite.

Maybe short sighted of me, but I don’t really like my web browser to do much more than “browse”. Email, contacts, news readers etc. all feel much nicer as their own dedicated applications. Chances are I’ll come to eat these words within 10 years, though.

Feels like Mozilla are floundering a little on ways to innovate in the browser space. Google really shook things up by improving the core browser technology, rather than adding loads of end-user oriented features. Essentially the same thinking that lead to Firefox originally.

george_morgan··on Facebook Threatens Greasemonkey Script Writer
I’m sure most people support your sentiments, but self-conciously shoe horning Niemöller & Orwell into your arguments like that comes across a bit over the top.

Tone it down, less preaching more conversational. You’ll get a better response and promote better discussions.

george_morgan··on Kurt Vonnegut: I want to share with you something I’ve learned.
Related, Vonnegut on drama: http://sivers.org/drama (more graph sketches!)
george_morgan··on Arial Font is Bullshit
"Helvetica is the font for the rich and wealthy; Arial is the same for the rest of us.”

I find this an intriguing proposition, considering that Helvetica was born out of the modernist movement and it’s democratic ideals whilst Arial was the commission of Microsoft, the personification of capitalism. Pretty sure there’s a liberal arts essay in the making right there.

george_morgan··on Arial Font is Bullshit
Arial seems to have been designed as a regressive version of Helvetica, it’s like an interim step between Akzidenz and Helvetica. Non-parallel terminals being the most distinctive, also the influence of the Akzidenz cap R can be seen.

In this respect, it’s like an early design which would have been discarded in the development of Helvetica. Conceptually, designing something in such a regressive manner seems to go against the spirit of progression the modernist design of Helvetica implies.

george_morgan··on Arial Font is Bullshit
Although proportionally spaced electronic typewriters were fairly common place before the Mac. A little myth making by Mr Jobs I think.
george_morgan··on Arial Font is Bullshit
I own a digitisation of Unica, acquired many moons ago. It is rather nice. There’s not much more to say, I’m mostly just showing off.
george_morgan··on Arial Font is Bullshit
And on the opposite end of the spectrum, you apparently lack the time for vowels.
george_morgan··on X.org lost $5000 from their Paypal account
Thank you for trying to protect us mere human beings from ourselves.
george_morgan··on WWI Ship Camouflage
More on this from Tate Etc. magazine: http://www.tate.org.uk/tateetc/issue4/camouflage.htm
george_morgan··on Official reasons why Adobe doesn't open-source Flash
It doesn't surprise me you were a management consultant. You're getting downvotes for repeating simplistic abstracts, without suggesting anything close to a reasonable course of action.

"How do we fix this problem?" "Well, all problems can be fixed by fixing the problem." "Ok, so how do we do that?" "Simple, fix the problem." "Right."

george_morgan··on Steve Jobs and the Economics of Elitism
I realise this, it just seemed odd in the context of it being Apple and the exact same references given.
george_morgan··on Steve Jobs and the Economics of Elitism
Did anyone notice the mention of the “auteur model of innovation,” attributed to “John Kao, a consultant to corporations and governments on innovation” which sounds an awful lot like John Gruber's auteur theory of design: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xk3UcgbbmxQ

The article even used the same examples as Gruber, hm.

george_morgan··on Top 6 Web Browsers You Probably Haven’t Heard Of
I found an old Phoenix (ver 0.1) binary a while back, super small and snappy. Didn't even have Add-on support then.
george_morgan··on [dead]
I don't think this ridiculous self-referential trolling has any place on HN.
george_morgan··on Chinese web pirates steal design
I'm more surprised this is being reported by the BBC than anything. What makes this case any more notable than countless other web-design piracy cases? Is it the Chinese angle?
george_morgan··on Why I Stopped Throwing Out Junk Mail
I think it was David Ogilvy who said anyone who wanted to write advertising copy should spend a year working in direct response marketing. Same principle.
george_morgan··on Schopenhauer - On thinking for oneself
Schopenhauer also wrote some cracking stuff on women: http://www.heretical.com/miscella/onwomen.html
george_morgan··on Creativity is Not Design - Design Test 2
Lots of evidence of Bauhaus quasi-mystic ideas in this test, talking about the 'energy' of a composition, 'visual influence'. All ideas rooted in early 20th century abstract expression, which I suppose are now widely accepted but are by no means the universal truths they were presented as.

Some mid-century rational design thrown in for good measure, swiss grid systems etc. which are under going something of a renaissance through their recent discovery by web designers, but they also aren't a universal panacea for design ills. You need only look as far as Jan Tschichold's (a prominent exponent of modern typography) return to traditional typographic forms in his later career for evidence of this.

I don't doubt his assertation that there are a lot of incompetent charlatans in graphic and web design, but I do think his view that modern design educators are failing their students is probably due to many of them having moved on from the Bauhaus/Swiss modernism touch points he seems so firmly attached to.

george_morgan··on How Well Do You Understand Design?
"Overconfident journeyman" sums up a lot of the web design bloggers. There is a nice quote about the difference between "men who understand everything and appreciate nothing", which seems relevant here in the sense the author appears to understand 'art' but not fully appreciate it's nuances, shown by his very rote-style.
george_morgan··on Thousands call for Turing apology
Cringe.
george_morgan··on UK Pirate Party registered as politcal party
I always assumed the 'Hacker' in Hacker News was there to gently stigmatise the site, to avoid it going to way of sites like Digg.
george_morgan··on Less, a leaner CSS
This would be more of an issue if it was a consumer service/product. I'm going to give web developers the benefit of the doubt and say they'll probably find this if they're looking for it.
george_morgan··on Why "next-gen games" went gray, brown, and grey.
This is something the industrial designer Ross Lovegrove has been exploring for a while, here's the obligatory TED link: http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/ross_lovegrove_shares_org...

He talks about early modernist design being dictated by the machining processes of the time, lathes and extrusion etc. producing the characteristic geometric work.

Tangentially linked to the OP...

george_morgan··on [dead]
This is another crackpot, pseudo-scientific, poorly referenced, neo-luddite revisionist mess of untested hypothesis and outright speculation which is sure to find it's way back to my email inbox one day after being forwarded from a second cousins best friend.
george_morgan··on Ask HN: Review my website
Being hot is, however, a valid criterion for judging 'hot tweeters', which is what the site appears to be attempting.

It would be a 'misjustice' if they were being called the best/most amusing/interesting/insightful users, but were still only ranked on their pictures.

As it stands, it's shallow but no great injustice.

george_morgan··on How to Spot Quality within Web Design: Examples & Tips
Grid systems are a staple of tool in print graphic design, but only seem to have been picked up by the web design community in the last year or so.

It seems there is a lot of misunderstanding, grid systems are an invisible structure for laying out content with some consistency. Every newspaper, magazine, book or poster you see is usually designed to a grid of some description.

What we're seeing at the moment is a lot of web design taking the idea of the grid very literally, applying it in a very self conscious way, treating the grid as an aesthetic afterthought rather than as a functional underlying system.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3