HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

georgespencer

3,777 karma · joined August 30, 2011

quick to temper (expectations)
submissionscomments
georgespencer··on Go or Rust? Just Listen to the Bots
> Why do so many go devs feel the need to make statements like this

This is a common conceit when writing for the sort of audience who might, for example, nitpick something as utterly uncontroversial as an author's disclaimer acknowledging common criticisms of a language they enjoy working with.

tl;dr: Literally because of people like you :)

georgespencer··on Go or Rust? Just Listen to the Bots
Obligatory link to Eternal September: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
georgespencer··on My Apple Vision Pro Nightmare
I'm sure the author has sincere concerns. I found the sweeping generalisations tough to read:

> [Vision Pro is] an extremely alarming harbinger of how tech giants are going to know even more about our private lives and radically reshape our communities once again.

Given that the author appears to think of himself as a victim, utterly powerless to resist:

> Vision Pro isn't for creating content. It isn't for interacting with the world. It isn't even for walking around your own apartment. At best, at its core, it's yet another way for us to zone out and watch ever higher and higher definition TV and movies. I've never in my adult life vegged out as much as I did during my time with the Vision Pro.

Anecdotally, I find that negative reviews of Vision Pro have tended towards emphatic "this sucks for everyone" rhetoric. Positive reviews, including those from folks using the device as their daily driver now, acknowledge its limitations and rough edges.

> In the end, I followed the path of so many other Vision Pro early adopters and became an early returner.

Vision Pro return rates are estimated at 1%.[^1] It figures: this is an early adopter product. The author of this post had a bad time with it and seems to be desperately reaching to draw generalisable conclusions, rather than sticking to his own subjective experience.

Then again, his three bylines for Business Insider are: "My Apple Vision Pro Nightmare", "Weight wasn't the only thing I lost when I took a weight-loss drug", in which he cheerfully manages to find the L in "I've lost more than 40 pounds, started running again — finishing my first half marathon since Covid-19 started — and my cholesterol and blood pressure are the healthiest they've ever been. I've been freed from a growing list of medications doctors warned I might be shackled to for the rest of my life," and the feel-good hit of last summer, "The looming addiction crisis being fueled by AI".

I suspect the author would be far happier with a Linux machine he can gloat about not using very often. (Of course he tells us he doesn't have a TV in his apartment, lmao.)

[^1]: https://medium.com/@mingchikuo/vision-pro更新-美國市場需求已大幅放緩-全球發佈...

georgespencer··on Martin Scorsese's secret life as an obsessive VHS archivist
Context: https://www.vulture.com/article/tim-heidecker-and-gregg-turk...
georgespencer··on MM1: Methods, Analysis and Insights from Multimodal LLM Pre-training
Same transition some years ago. Siri is noticeably much, much worse to me. Borderline hopeless on a mixture of HomePod + HomePod Mini hardware.
georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
In criminal law this sort of nonsense is explicitly inadmissible in court. It's why during the OJ Simpson criminal trial it was not possible for the defense to do anything more than point out inconsistencies with the chain of evidence: they could not say that it pointed to or was in any way evidence of a conspiracy. (In other words: you can't just say "it could be something else" because that's facile, easy to do, and has no means of disproof. So fucking prove it would be a useful rule to adopt.)

Anyway, I'll be more charitable since this isn't court and you aren't a lawyer, but the substance of my point remains: even the circumstantial evidence does not appear to support murder. Certainly if it were murder it would be revenge, given that the whistle was blown five years ago, and the whistleblower will have provided sworn affidavits and is unlikely to be the difference between conviction and freedom for any individual.

Moreover your insinuation of "a low-level VP" worrying about the testimony seems be totally euphemistic. Do you have any evidence that any one individual or number of individuals might be facing jail time as a result of the whistleblower's testimony, and could somehow avoid it without their direct testimony under cross-examination?

I'm glad you've moved away from the insinuation that it might be a shareholder somehow taking it out on the guy for no reason, at least. Now you have all of your work ahead of you to explain how and why a Boeing executive would be motivated to murder someone five years after the fact when the damage is very probably already done.

> And so statistically

Suspect what you're about to say is going to be nothing to do with statistics

> this seems a lot more likely than this otherwise stable person

Just so we're clear, you think that this…

"A Boeing executive committed or arranged a premeditated murder in public in broad daylight, five years after the fact, and made it look like suicide."

…is more probable than this…

"A whistleblower killed himself."

Let's simplify it a bit: given 100 cases of whistleblowing, do you think you would see greater incidence of murder/violence perpetrated on the whistleblower, or greater incidence of the whistleblowers experiencing meaningfully deterioration of mental health?

What about this one[^1]? Murder as well? What about Ian Gibbons? Elizabeth Holmes presumably killed him?

[^1]: https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article259213078.html

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
> Amongst culture.

I don't know what this means.

> Doesn't matter that you don't agree.

It is fundamental to this discussion that the narrative you describe is fringe (credible polling puts it at around 30% uptake) and directly contradicted by both the evidence and conclusions reached by the institutions required to evaluate said evidence (DOJ, FBI).

It is a narrative in the same way as flat earthism or QAnon are narratives. We should be careful to not imply equivalence ("both sides"-ing) to the situation: there is reality, and then there is a group of people who either do not possess the facts (many people in this thread, for example), or are unfortunately not capable of grasping them for whatever reason.

> Clinton's BJ was in popular culture before the conviction.

Clinton was credibly and publicly accused by an individual, and had a long history of such accusations.

> Pointing to a legal case is moving the goalpost.

My point is that there is no equivalence between Clinton and Epstein, but I don't think you were drawing any really, you were just saying (I think?) that they were both narratives that took hold prior to the facts being established and conclusions reached.

> It is not and does not.

Just sit down and try to write the narrative of what happened and you might see what I mean:

1. Was it the guards, or a professional assassin?

2. If guards: how were they identified? Who put them on the right shift at the right time? Who else helped? How did the benefactor of the scheme know that the guards wouldn't grass on the approach? How did the benefactor of the scheme find the guards and approach them? When the guards walked into the room, how did they restrain Epstein without injuring him or leaving behind any DNA evidence? Did they tie the bedsheets together before or after the murder? How would they be remunerated given the scrutiny on them and their associates from the FBI? Why would they admit to falsifying logs and draw more attention to themselves rather than engineering an excuse less likely to draw huge scrutiny?

3. If professional assassin: how did they get in without being seen on the security cameras monitoring the single point of entrance/egress from Epstein's block? How did they get into the prison through multiple layers of security? Were the guards also paid off? How did the assassin restrain him without injuring him or themselves? Why would you go to the trouble of infiltrating a prison - which is after all an axiomatically hard thing to do – when the guy had already tried to hang himself weeks earlier?

4. General: why do you discount the conclusions of the DOJ psychologist who reviewed Epstein's prison records and evaluations and concluded that it was suicide? Why would a shadowy figure trying to kill Epstein not simply pressure him from the outside by threatening his family (given that they apparently have the capacity to infiltrate a prison facility utterly unnoticed)? Why would you conclude that Epstein's first suicide attempt was sincere but his second was not? Why would you leave it until after he was suicidal and by all accounts uncooperative with the authorities to kill him rather than killing him at a time when it was both easier to achieve and less clear that he would not cooperate? Why do you think the FBI found no cause for suspicion in the testimony of the guards, if you think they did it or were in the loop?

People who spout conspiratorial nonsense with conviction and a poor grasp of the facts / ability to reason are the very reason conspiracy theories propagate. You might be a brilliant mind in other areas, but you should know that to the 70% of the population who do not believe that Epstein was murdered, you are in broadly the same bucket as someone who believes they saw Elvis alive in Hawaii a few weeks ago.

georgespencer··on Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right
This is a keen insight I had not until now appreciated. Thank you.
georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
> attempted a grammatical correction on

Very relaxed about informal grammar, the point is that this:

"Certus found that of those who believed Epstein to be murdered…"

is materially different to

"Certus found that of those who identify as [political party]…"

You didn't repeat the numbers and I didn't check, so I'll take you at your word that this is not the segmentation Certus meant :)

(See how easy it is to change your perspective to accommodate reality?!)

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
I will be explicit: if, after reading the DOJ report and reviewing the facts of the case, you believe that Epstein was murdered, then your critical thinking is sub-normal. An average police officer would grok this.

If a powerful individual had:

1. Much to lose in the event of Epstein cooperating (he wasn't), and,

2. The means to arrange a complex assassination (in a prison, in solitary confinement, and -- I repeat that this is a matter of fact for which you have zero repudiation -- without being seen by the security cameras which were active and monitoring the entrance to Epstein's block from the communal entrance), and,

3. The public knowledge that Epstein had weeks earlier attempted to commit suicide (I literally cannot believe I'm having to enumerate this)…

… why wouldn't you simply pressure Epstein to commit suicide and obviate the insane risk of detection or mishap in a scheme to murder him that would, at a minimum, require either the cooperation of multiple heretofore uncontrolled/unknown operatives within the prison, in addition to the brokering and lifting being done by a proxy (i.e.: at least 3 people, probably closer to 5-10, all of whom would be highly brittle points of failure both during and after the operation)?

Or find a way to provide him with the mysterious extra bed sheets[^1] if he were intending on doing it anyway? You know, perhaps on an unmonitored telephone call[^2] made to his "mother" (dead for years) immediately prior to the suicide?

Sorry, but yes you are dumb if you think Epstein was murdered in prison. You are knowingly taking a position unsupported by fact, considered and rejected by thousands of more qualified investigators from across the judiciary, and the best you can appear to do is accuse me of not being gentle in my treatment of your utterly inane conjecture.

You are leaping to the most exciting conclusion and rejecting the myriad simpler ones supported by the overwhelming evidence. Each of the following is inescapably a simpler and more likely explanation for his death than him being murdered:

1) He succeeded in his second attempt at suicide due to deteriorated mental health,

2) He succeeded in his second attempt at suicide due to his fear of being mistreated or murdered by an inmate (he's a pedophile in prison etc.),

3) He succeeded in his second attempt at suicide due to his fear of being murdered by a guard in the employ of people he might betray,

4) He succeeded in his second attempt at suicide due to his fear of loved ones being murdered at the behest of people he might betray,

5) He succeeded in his second attempt at suicide due to being provided the means by guards operating at the behest of people he might betray,

6) He succeeded in his second attempt at suicide due to befriending a guard who took pity on him or to whom he promised or arranged financial reward himself (yes, it's more likely Epstein was motivated to essentially pay for his own suicide than someone murdered him in his prison cell, sigh),

7) He succeeded in his second attempt at suicide because he was pressured by external forces capable of harming those he loved.

It's just staggering that you cannot evaluate this properly. I don't want to be unkind, I'm sure you're very smart and a lovely person, but I would encourage you to discuss this with any lawyer, prosecutor, or investigator you might have access to and go through the facts line by line. You should absolutely be alarmed that you are out of step with so many informed individuals on this, even before considering people like me who are simply 50th percentile with logic.

[^1]: https://news.bloomberglaw.com/white-collar-and-criminal-law/...

[^2]: https://www.businessinsider.com/jail-officials-jeffrey-epste...

georgespencer··on Sweden Is a NATO Member
> or remain there.

Whilst I'm impressed with the speed of your climbdown, you have now broadened your definition of "installed" to the point where it is utterly meaningless.

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
It isn't interesting or useful because conspiracists fail to interpret "don't know" or "unsure" appropriately given the context of polling. It doesn't mean "I have reviewed the facts and I am undecided".

> Certus poll found that over 30% each of Democrats, Independents and Republicans believed it to be murder.

I believe the Certus poll found that of those who believed him to be murdered, that was the split along political lines.

> That is not a tiny fringe as you claimed it to be.

Three in ten is a tiny minority – winning a vote with 70% would be considered a landslide – but you're right it's a scarily high number of loudmouthed imbeciles.

The good news is that you don't have to worry! Adults are in charge! Hundreds of thousands of smart, capable people are employed to investigate things like this, and will cheerfully tell you that it's far more likely that the unmonitored and illicit phone call made by Epstein directly before his suicide was him being told to have another go or risk the lives of friends or loved ones. (What with that being fucking orders of magnitude easier to do than having a hitman break into solitary confinement in a prison.)

> just as was your unnecessary projection of opinion of using an Insider poll.

Business Insider is right up there with Yahoo Answers for robust, disinterested polling data.

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
And would make the two guards who admitted falsifying reports… the worst patsies in history? And presumably the FBI and DOJ are in on it too? And the camera footage showing nobody entered his block is fake too?

It's so achingly dumb. HN has a really awful conspiratorial leaning these days, it's completely baffling to me.

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
> evidence of a suicide is virtually nonexistent

1. Epstein was found hanged in his cell

2. Video footage from the communal area an assassin would have to use for entrance/egress was analyzed by the FBI and showed nobody entering his block

3. There is video footage of his first suicide attempt on July 23rd, a few weeks before he was found hanging in his cell[^1]

4. An investigation by the FBI, and an autopsy performed by a coroner, concluded that the death was a suicide.

Now you go. Tell me what evidence you have of murder. Address all of my points. Read the DOJ report.

[^1]: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/20/video-of-jeffrey-epstein-jai...

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
> Insider poll

Sorry but lol at Insider being your source for robust polling of the American zeitgeist. In 2019 Certus put the figure of Americans believing he was murdered at 35%, with the remainder believing it to be suicide or "don't know".

"Don't know" is the critical thing here: there aren't too many more crazy conspiracists who could be shown the overwhelming evidence of suicide and conclude that it was murder.

And, of course, irrespective: literally any thinking person who can read the DOJ report will immediately conclude that it's suicide. It's just inarguable (hence the arguments in this thread being mainly "b-b-b-b-but shadowy cabal of powerful people!!!1" and not anything to do with, for example, Epstein already having attempted suicide once, or the camera footage showing nobody entering his block, etc.

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
> It's a narrative of the popular culture

Amongst idiots.

> eg Clinton's bj in the whitehouse

A thing which happened, was admitted by Clinton, and proved by DNA evidence.

Epstein's suicide is different because the evidence overwhelmingly points to suicide, and people are either ignorant or unable to think logically.

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
> It's easy when your world view hinges on the fact that responsible adults are running the world.

Or when you look at the reams of evidence supporting a verdict of suicide and the other side has conspiratorial non-arguments like this.

If any of you get selected for jury duty I would encourage you to please show an adult this thread so you can be recused on grounds of mental incapacity.

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
> And the cameras just happened to be out of order when he chose to kill himself of course.

I know you think this is really brilliant invective, but it just reveals that you don't know what you're talking about.

Epstein was being monitored by guards and cameras in part because he had already tried to kill himself once. (I suppose you don't dispute that?)

The cameras you're referring to are the specific cameras with his cell door in their FOV. MCC New York had a history of such lapses, and the cameras were seized and analysed by the FBI. No evidence was found of anything other than the US prison system being shitty.

But more importantly there were functioning cameras showing the entrance to Epstein's block from the accessible communal area an assassin would have used for entrance/egress. From the DOJ report:

> Thus, anyone entering or attempting to enter Epstein’s SHU tier from the SHU common area would have been picked up by that video camera.

No such person was seen.

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
Yes with their stock at a near record low for the decade, now is certainly the time for Boeing's largest shareholders (Vanguard and Blackrock) to take decisive action by inexplicably murdering someone five years too late to make a difference, and who - if left alive - could have potentially been the single most effective means for the shareholders to take revenge on the executives responsible for the company's demise. Jesus christ.
georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
If you believe Epstein was murdered you are in a tiny, tiny, tiny minority of very gullible or very simple minded people. Upon a cursory review of both the facts of the matter and the very best arguments conspiracists can copy and paste, it is self-evident that he killed himself.
georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
> fowl play

It's "foul" play.

> Sure, it's nowhere near "beyond a reasonable doubt"

To the extent that I do not think it would even be admissible in court in many (all?) states. Hearsay, not under oath, not cross-examinable. Just as possible she misunderstood the dark joke of an obviously suicidal and self-reflective man as people like you and me at Boeing literally arranged to have someone killed lmao.

I can basically only think of more plausible explanations: coincidental victim of murder, suicidal due to stress of whistle-blowing, witness misheard, witness misunderstood, witness made it up…

I can really hear the bottom of the barrel being scraped around here lately.

georgespencer··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
It's far more likely that he simply changed his mind after making the statement attributed to him than it is Boeing would arrange for him to be murdered five years after the fact.
georgespencer··on Sweden Is a NATO Member
> US is largest contributor to IMF it would be a joke to suggest their opinion has no sway.

Russia was pursuing this strategy prior to IMF involvement. The membership of the IMF was supportive of the strategy. The United States' Treasury Department did not intervene. Tell me again how this had anything to do with Putin? You make it sound as if the US was providing weapons to Putin or something.

> Saddam in Iraq

I think you have some reading to do if you believe the United States "installed" Saddam. It was the Ba’athists.

georgespencer··on Sweden Is a NATO Member
> No. The economic shock therapy.

Ah, so you mean the United States' inaction in providing aid to Russia after Yeltsin and the IMF began to aggressively reform Russia's economy?

Your logic is that the United States installed Putin by not interfering more?

> You know. It would be fine if it was a few times thing. But US has a long history of putting dictators into power, calling them allies, then turning against them and invading/killing them. Which only seems to benefit the military and cause chaos everywhere else.

It's notable that your own cartoonish straw man bears no resemblance whatsoever to the specific case you're trying to illustrate, unless I'm missing the part where the US installed Putin, allied with him, and then invaded/killed him.

How many dictators has the United States installed, allied with, and then invaded or killed in your lifetime?

georgespencer··on Sweden Is a NATO Member
> We should thank people that put him there. Checks notes - The United States. Huh?!

There's nothing inherently wrong with an administration exercising soft power to help a favoured politician in another country – even if they sometimes turn out to be dictators – but in this instance I think it's disingenuous to suggest that the United States "put [Putin into power]", assuming you're referring to the United States' inaction after the FSB apartment bombings?

> Wait. Putin got voted person of the year 2007?

Time's Person of the Year Award is specifically scoped to not be an endorsement or celebration of the winner. Think of it more as a measure of outsized impact on the world in a given year.

georgespencer··on Sora: Creating video from text
I'm on the very cusp of this, you helped me realize. Thanks.
georgespencer··on Launch HN: Zenfetch (YC W23) – Turn notes/browser history into an AI assistant
Would love to try this (have a less sophisticated pre-LLM approach running locally), and also use Safari as my main browser. Instant paying customer for Safari, right here.

Also find myself having a pretty severe allergic reaction to websites (Gem is a recent example) roadblocking anything but Chrome (seemingly both because of their web app literally not functioning properly in Safari, and their browser extension being Chrome-only):

a) essentially forcing me to use Chrome for one task, whilst deal with password management in two places, etc., and

b) giving me the nagging worry that the design of the app or extension might contravene some non-technical standard imposed by Apple which Google does not honor…

georgespencer··on Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday
You think his short to medium term plan is to raise $7tn to build dozens of fabs?
georgespencer··on Are we making the best notion open source alternative?
Not sure I follow… does someone (me? Another poster?) say that Confluence is better?
georgespencer··on Are we making the best notion open source alternative?
Excited to try this!

A few years ago someone gave me the excellent advice that I should stop saying “no” to fractional roles I was unenthusiastic about, and instead price them accordingly.

The first thing I did was to stipulate a $500 daily surcharge for any gigs expecting me to use Notion.

I won’t recapitulate the miserable design of Notion’s janky non-native desktop app for macOS, but just this week, my calendar (cron) asked me to “refresh to update the app”.

After that it asked me to restart the app.

After that it had disappeared from my dock, and apparently my entire Mac.

Turns out Notion acquired it, and thought the best way to tell me was to use the update to silently update the app, install a new binary (???) and delete the old one.

Except it crashed half way through, so I had no idea.

Everything those people touch—from “the concept of an enumerated list” to “a popular indie calendar”—seems to be rushed in execution and badly designed from the start.

← PreviousPage 2 of 27Next →