HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ggchappell

2,759 karma · joined February 27, 2009

Glenn G. Chappell

I'm a C.S. prof. at the University of Alaska. If you want contact info, Google finds me pretty easily.

submissionscomments
ggchappell··on Ask HN: The Internet is getting lame. What's next?
> ... I never get into the depth of conversation I once did. That's something lost.

Others have given some good answers, but I think there is another factor: the way discussions are organized.

In a typical BBS, or on UseNet in days of old, a thread was linear, identified only by its subject line. Multiple people could stay with a thread for a relatively long time and have an extended discussion.

Today, most online forum software (HN, Reddit, etc.) displays threads as trees. Each reply begins a new subthread. As a result, a conversion involving more than 2 people will rarely be linear, and a reply 2 or 3 or 4 levels in will be read by almost no one.

But the solution is not to move back to linear threads. Those were abandoned for a good reason: they do not scale. Six active posters might be able to have a reasonable linear discussion. 100 cannot. Linear threads are also much easier for one poster to hijack. Among 6 people, there is a decent chance that none of them is a jerk. Among 100 people, the chance is pretty much zero. So the thread gets filled with troll posts. Conclusion: tree-shaped discussions, along with voting, are what prevents us from being drowned in troll posts & flamewars.

So, what is the solution? I don't know. It's an interesting problem to consider.

ggchappell··on Why Blogging Died
> In preface, when I say blogging is dead, I am referring to blogging in the niches I am most familiar with and active in ; other niches may be different, ....

I wonder what niches are being referred to here. It never occurred to me that blogging might be "dead". It sure doesn't look dead to me. But then I guess I'm interested in different niches.

ggchappell··on Ask HN: Why can't we delete our accounts or remove old posts?
Editing and deleting an HN comment can be done within a limited time (an hour?) after the comment is created. After that it does not seem to be possible -- at least for me.
ggchappell··on Search and Rescue for Sale
> Then the avalanches started: one, two, three. They were aerosol avalanches—wind-driven thin layers of snow.

TIL that there are aerosol avalanches. It seems to be a difficult topic to learn more about. The search hits I get are articles that assume you know about aerosol avalanches, while general articles on avalanches do not mention the aerosol kind. An "aerosol avalanches for complete morons" would be nice. Regardless, it's an interesting concept.

ggchappell··on The Genesis of the Gang (1899)
Whoa! This is interesting, but reading it is work.

> Apart from its religious aspect, seen from the angle of the community's interest wholly, the matter is of the gravest import.

And most of the sentences are like that. Is this really what the people of 1899 considered to be effective communication? Or is it more a kind of poetry-in-prose-form that one was supposed to skim in order to pick up some sort of vague gist?

ggchappell··on Death of a Diploma Mill: University of Phoenix Going Down in Flames?
REPLY-AS-EDIT. Well, they're not. Really. They are accredited by the Higher Learning Commission, indicating that they meet U.S. Dept. of Education standards.

Having been through several similar accreditations at my own school (I'm a C.S. professor at a more traditional university), I can say with some confidence that the accreditation process is not a joke.

So, lots of accusations are made against U. of P. I don't know which of these might be true. Maybe U. of P. is a collection of lying, manipulative thieves who eat babies for breakfast; I couldn't say. But they do not give away meaningless diplomas to whomever is willing to pay the fees.

ggchappell··on Young Men in Shorts (2004)
An apt comment. I wish I had seen it before I started the post. I had read good fraction of this essay before I had the slightest idea what it was supposed to be all about.
ggchappell··on Functional Fixedness
Interesting.

I wonder if this phenomenon might at least partially explain the repeated misguided calls we see for encryption software to have back doors for law-enforcement use. Roughly speaking, people might be thinking that such a back door would not be used for nefarious purposes, because that is not what it is for.

ggchappell··on Death of a Diploma Mill: University of Phoenix Going Down in Flames?
The U of P may have some serious problems, but they are certainly not a diploma mill.
ggchappell··on Three things that make CEOs stupid
A worthwhile little post. However:

> The truth is the final and most endemic problem. Employees incorrectly (in many cases) believe that the boss doesn't want to hear from them, doesn't want constructive feedback.

This needs to be thought through a bit more.

A blunt, honest comment to ones boss is often the kind of thing that has a small upside in the best case, and a large downside in the worst case. Why take a nearly pointless risk? What the boss thinks he "wants" is hardly relevant.

ggchappell··on Faster than Bresenham's Algorithm? (2009)
Ah, that's an interesting idea.

We might say that Bresenham's Algorithm is not really about drawing lines; it's about doing a best-possible discrete approximation to linear interpolation, using integer arithmetic.

And since we can easily[1] change that line to any conic section we want, we should be able to use a variation on B's Alg. to do a perspective-correct interpolation, right?

Sounds good to me. However, as perhaps you were, I'm too lazy[2] right now to work out the details. :-)

--------

[1] For certain values of "easy".

[2] Or perhaps "too busy". That sounds a bit better, doesn't it?

ggchappell··on I can tolerate anything except the outgroup (2014)
Fantasic article! Lots of interesting thoughts.

Rather lengthy, though, isn't it? I feel that, lurking somewhere in this enormous stream-of-consciousness essay, there is a post about 1/2 the length that could become a truly classic blog post.

ggchappell··on SL-1: The only fatal nuclear reactor accident in US history
> You're not going to make any headway here, this is a very pro-nuclear crowd.

One hopes that "pro-nuclear" people (or pro-anything people) are still capable of being intellectually honest and admitting the existence of evidence on both sides of an issue -- despite having concluded that one side is the better one.

Not that HN is a paragon of virtue in this regard, but it's certainly better than most internet forums.

ggchappell··on How two bored 1970s housewives helped create the PC industry
> What made Apple SO different from all the others that failed?

Others have given decent answers, but, honestly, I don't think Apple was all that different. As you noted, "... even then, just barely."

We tend to think of Apple rather differently, today. But remember that Apple wasn't really such a big deal 20 years ago. The Apple that just barely made it through the 1980s and the Apple that reworked NeXTSTEP into OS X, brought out the iPhone, etc., are rather different beasts. They share a name and some corporate infrastructure, but not a lot else, really.

ggchappell··on Is the average sinuosity of the world's rivers equal to pi?
The Lukuga -- #40 on the list.

I suspect there is an error in the data. The project lists the Lukuga River as being 1904 km long. But Wikipedia[1] only has 320 km, which would give it a much more ordinary sinuosity of 1.27.

For a river that might actually have a very high sinuosity, take a look at the Fraser River -- #20 on the list, with sinuosity listed as 5.12.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lukuga_River

ggchappell··on Users Rationally Rejecting Security Advice (2009)
Okay, now I'm wondering about something.

A point that Bruce has harped on for years is that the law often creates the wrong incentives for security policies. In particular, in the U.S., the downside of what we call "identity theft" often falls squarely on the consumer, while the security policies for the banking industry are designed by banks. Thus the policy makers may not have to live with the downsides of their own policies.

I'm guessing that the incentives created by the law for banking security are rather different in Singapore -- maybe not ideal, but certainly different.

Can you (or anyone else) comment knowledgeably on this?

ggchappell··on TPP Leak Reveals Take-Down Measures Softened – But DRM Rules Remain Harsh
> Can we just have a breakdown of companies who played a large part in the TPP formation so we can boycott them?

Unfortunately, it isn't that simple. We need to know what each company was pushing for. For example, maybe the TPP turns out to be not quite as awful as it might have been, because Company X wouldn't stand for the awful stuff. We really don't want to boycott them in that case.

The big problem here is not the companies, anyway. It's the government. Companies are private entities. They can only be expected to push their own interests. But the government is supposed to represent the people. Theoretically, the government is what keeps private companies from running amok. When it fails to do so, we need to hold the government accountable. When it does just the opposite, and enshrines companies' unreasonable demands into law, then we have a serious problem.

ggchappell··on Ask HN: What to do if your open source project becomes famous?
> How do you sell ads on open source code?

The code just shows ads. Users are free to get rid of them, but you hope they don't; perhaps you encourage them not to. (Note: webpages are often the same way; users can run AdBlock if they want.) If advertisers pay only for click-throughs to their site, then they know they're not getting ripped off.

> I know about ubuntu and firefox but was wondering if there are startups doing open source work and generating revenue.

Well, you said "famous". Once you're famous, you're often not a start-up any more. In any case, I can't think of any, but then I'm not really into the start-up scene.

ggchappell··on Ask HN: What to do if your open source project becomes famous?
> If your open source project becomes famous could you earn a living out of it?

Yes, it is possible. It is perhaps a bit unlikely, though.

You would need some way to get money out of a product that is being given away. Selling advertising is one model. Charging for support is another.

> Do you know any examples of a project that became famous or most used and is hiring a team of devs to work on it.

Certainly. You probably know about them, too: Firefox, Red Hat, Ubuntu, ....

ggchappell··on Facebook’s Piracy Problem
> That would be, on the whole, a net gain for the public domain.

Now that is an interesting thought. Let Disney have Mickey Mouse forever, in exchange for lots of recent stuff.

However, I'm not sure it would work. Say I'm an artist. I know that my heirs will have to right to control my works until doomsday if I assign the authorship to a corporation. So I form a trust for that purpose. This sounds like a simple thing to do. It is also very reasonable, from my POV; I'm providing for my children. And if it were commonly done, then it would negate the benefits of this change in the law.

ggchappell··on “Hong Kong is not China” illustrations cause controversy online
> ... I realized it was a veiled reference to the Tiananmen Square massacre, which is known as the June 4th incident in China (literally, "six four incident").

Ah, thanks for the explanation.

ggchappell··on How technology could kill the art of lying
> Admitting you were wrong makes you look incompetent.

It certainly makes you feel like you look incompetent. I wonder how much it makes others judge you as incompetent. Perhaps this issue has been researched? (I'm guessing that it might matter a great deal how one was wrong; there are different ways to be wrong, and different levels of wrongness.)

ggchappell··on Mapping the U.S. By Property Value Instead of Land Area
Interesting.

BTW, there is a glitch in the animation. One city -- Lincoln, Nebraska, I think -- does not expand smoothly.

ggchappell··on Facebook’s Piracy Problem
> A radical idea: Maybe our model of intellectual property is wrong, or outdated.

Honestly, that's not really radical. It seems to be pretty clear to anyone who knows anything about computers. There may be flaws your other thoughts, as other commenters have suggested, but not with the first one.

The big problem -- in the U.S. anyway -- is that there are huge companies with a vested interest in maintaining something like the late-ish 20th century copyright regime. These make campaign contributions to lawmakers, who pass laws in their favor, which allow them to continue making money, which they contribute to lawmakers, etc. It appears to me that little is going to change until that cycle is broken.

ggchappell··on Recombine to avoid naming when naming is hard
There are some good thoughts here, but it isn't all quite coherent yet. So, to add my 2 cents:

There are basically two reasons to name things.

1. Because something is lacking in either the syntax of our PL or our skill in coding, so that we end up giving something a name, when it does not really need one.

2. As a handle on some abstraction, indicating what it is for.

When #1 is the issue, names are best avoided. When #2 is the issue, names are a Good Thing, but a poorly chosen name can be very harmful.

ggchappell··on 'Sin free Facebook' attracts thousands
Are there good reasons to think that this is supposed to be serious? It all looks very tongue-in-cheek to me.
ggchappell··on Same-Sex Marriage Is a Right, Supreme Court Rules
Correct me if I'm misunderstanding things, but your comment suggests that you think marriage started as a religious thing and then later became a legal matter.

This is not the case, at least in western/european culture. In fact, the reverse is true. Marriage was not thought of as a religious institution until pretty late in the game -- certainly not until after 1000. (For example, marriage was not declared a sacrament until the Council of Trent in the 1500s.)

ggchappell··on Poll: Should conferences allow talks by those whose politics they don't support?
I find the statements far too vague to vote on. When I vote on conferences should (not) am I voting on what I think conferences ought to be allowed to do, what I expect them to do (lest they be considered substandard), or what they ought to be required to do?

(I would also note that there are many kinds of conferences. It seems that plenty of posters here feel they know exactly what category you are referring to. But I, for one, do not.)

ggchappell··on Fear of Macros
> By saying metaprogramming is an anti-pattern, we're saying that us lowly programmers ought not to put on our language designer hat and let the professionals take care of it.

I don't agree.

For example, most of us here would probably classify manual memory management as an anti-pattern. We're capable of doing it; we do it when we must. But we recognize that, most of the time, it's a bad idea.

Perhaps vinceguidry is saying something similar about metaprogramming.

ggchappell··on Unix is not an acceptable Unix
> You can’t write a function that returns a list of files because the shell doesn’t know what a “list” is, doesn’t know what “files” are, and couldn’t tell you the difference between a “function” and a “program” if its life depended on it.

Could it be that what this article is really groping towards is Perl? I mean Perl not as it has become, but as it was -- Perl 4 perhaps: basically the capabilities of the shell, augmented with a couple of data structures. So there are strings, lists, hashes, and functions, and that's pretty much it.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →