The only comment I have is that concentric circles are not the most intuitive way of showing a percentage of a whole. 50% doesn't 'look' like 50%, and looks similar to 30%.
but I'm not sure how else you would do it.
238 karma · joined January 19, 2014
The only comment I have is that concentric circles are not the most intuitive way of showing a percentage of a whole. 50% doesn't 'look' like 50%, and looks similar to 30%.
but I'm not sure how else you would do it.
Hence you have trade agreements and tariffs, tax, environmental regulations etc.
And trade isn't always good. If you are exporting then you are using your own resources (human, minerals, environment) etc to do work for others. This may work for you at an individual level, but it may not work for the country.
Four examples from the UK
1) Welsh Lamb. It is produced at great cost to the hill environment, including habitats and the knock on effects of flooding downstream. It was exported to the EU, while we were importing lamb from New Zealand to eat.
2) Fishing. Many of the fish caught in UK waters were exported because we were not used to eating them, while we were importing fish that we were used to eating. Individual fishermen probably did 'ok' out of this system, the companies above them doing much better. But coastal communities were not thriving, they were categorised as some of the poorest areas in the EU. Fishing didn't contribute to a sustainable environment for coastal communities. Then there is the environment, fishing stocks, discarded fishing gear etc.
3) Cars. This is a bit more difficult to solve, but we seem to spend endless resources in the EU and UK producing as many cars as possible. Despite them barely being used (a car sits idle 97% of the time) other than to financially cripple the owners. A car is very inefficient way to travel in the most populated places in the UK. Yet we have built our services around it, and continue to over produce millions of the things every year. Who is benefiting from this approach, rather than proper investment in a first class public transport system and associated planning system?
4) The drug trade. This is a trade full of highly skilled and resourceful people, it generates billions in complex imports and exports and logistics. This is good trade? No of course not.
but free trade / free movement just papered over the actual issue. You can temporarily use a form of economic imperialism to bring in people to run key services in your country for lower wages, but if won't solve the real issue and won't last forever, because it only 'works' between countries with relative unequal economies. It also does not compensate the donar country for the large issues it creates there.
Key workers are not being paid anywhere near enough to compensate for their importance to the country and to the economy, we are not valuing them no matter where they come from, and we are not training and recruiting enough people locally. Until this changes, then people are not going to come here to work in the NHS, child care etc. Free movement or not.
This issue was coming sooner or later, in some sectors Brexit has highlighted it.
If you want more people to come work here, then support the strikes.
EDIT. in addition, good quality child care should be provided free by the state, it is a massive benefit to the economy and to society. That's another core issue that was never addressed while we were inside the EU, nor is it (yet) being addressed outside it.
It's a very narrow view of wealth flows, looking at the bigger picture then more flows back the other way.
e.g. See the example of Strathclyde Police Training and Recruitment Centre here:
https://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2019/08/16/the-burden-of...
It's not relevant for 2023.
This worship of free trade we had was completely unrestricted. A lot of trade was completely decoupled from any real benefit or political or social project or any environmental concerns. If KPIs from trade and financial services are the main thing that are measured, then you will always end up with trade for trade's sake.
“Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether they could, they didn't stop to think if they should.”
Brexit has delivered an opportunity to assess and understand what we are trading and why.
There are systemic issues that no main stream political project seems capable of addressing, it's pointless to simply remove some trade barriers again to paper things over, and then pat ourselves on the back and pretend they are being solved.
Brexit has exposed some of those issues, and made it clear where the responsibility lies. by exposing them and focusing attention on them it has created a real opportunity to address them, although I imagine that opportunity will be missed.
The main issue is that an every increasing proportion of money spent on services ends up in profits for private companies, and in the administration of that profit and contracts. If money went directly to public sector workers, then the economy would boom.
Sure we can trade a bit more, but when the whole economy is financialised to a massive degree, then any benefits of that trade (if that trade outweighs the negative effects) are funnelled through a long standing system of extracting profit and concentrating wealth.
there's pretty much nothing you can do in your private or public life that doesn't result in a net transfer or wealth from the household, the local economy or from public funds, through a highly complex system of extraction.
So not only has people's purchasing power gone down, because purchasing power is relative to the money you have vs the money others have, but also basic services have just gone away from being free at the point of use. And what is free at the point of use is both low quality (so you are incentivised to pay to get a better service), and is again a black hole of public money being funnelled away thus reducing your purchasing power.
SQL is still dreadful, apart from all the alternatives.
But it will make responsibility clear. Out of the EU, no domestic government can claim plausible deniability on a directive like this, claiming not to support it yet there being nothing they can do about it - while secretly wanting to implement something like that anyway, but without the political fallout.
I'm not sure there we currently have the supply chain, security and ability to deal with geopolitical fallout of using the same fuel for mass domestic use.
During this time then more electricity is imported, a lot of gas is burned, and coal stations are put on standby.
To my knowledge, then no industry needs to shut down .
I wish it was that easy.
I trained hard for a year and barely made it under 24.
I guess it depends on age and if you are carrying around a bit of extra weight.
5K is a wonderful distance though. You can walk it in an hour, walk / jog it in 40, jog it in 30 .. then a whole world of gradual improvements and mind games open up to get you from there to 20 mins.
It's very inclusive of all abilities from walking up to club runners. Plus the weekly routine and encouragement of participating in a unfussy group activity.
Living outside London, there's nothing I can do in my daily life that doesn't result in a net transfer of wealth from my self, or from the public domain, into the private sector and therefore into London.
Every private or public interaction I have has been financialised. be that being forced to keep a car, having children in school, getting sick, renting or owning a house.
I could go to toilet in the middle of the park and that would result in net movement of wealth to London and offshore (someone would be sub-contracted to clean the park).
it is true that 'does / doesn't work' is subjective.
The votes in the 70s / 80s, which were the basis of what we have now were about trade, not peace via trade.
you are referring to 'they' without qualifying 'they'.
Political union was never on a ballot paper in most countries. In the cases it was (Maastricht referendums) then it was not conclusive .
EDIT:
Apologies for being anglocentric, but the Labour (dominant political party in UK at the time) didn't seem to include inter-European aggression in its arguments against a supernational state in 1950
https://www.cvce.eu/en/obj/manifesto_by_the_national_executi...
It does have a single demos, which is something the EU doesn't currently have. People will accept in some way to see federal money directed (or debt guaranteed) at communities they are geographically distant to, yet feel solidarity with in some way.
I personally feel the demos issue is the key rather than the monetary policy.
I'm not sure what the key is here, but maybe it is this.
> Are the countries supposed to split up and go back to competing with each other in an increasingly harsher global market?
countries are still competing with each other inside the trading block, only they have had many of the advantages they used to have available to them - e.g. their currency and central bank, their deficit spending, the ability to control inputs to their economy - taken away.
It's a trade off. It may be right, it may be wrong, but there's a lot of looking at the EU from one perspective only, it's nice to hear other perspectives.
For me, I don't see how a EU that doesn't federalise, i.e. doesn't have a single economic policy, doesn't have a single demos, can survive.
But even then, most of us live in countries that do have a single fiscal policy, a single demos, a freedom of movement of labour, goods, capital etc within our own country; and still it doesn't work without massive compensation to correct the inequalities that it brings. We have domestic governments trying (or most often not trying) and failing to deal with this imbalance even within a country.
I don't see how this will ever be possible at a supernational scale.
the original impetus being to use trade to solve a political problem, but the original impetus was not federalism, although I imagine there were federalists around at the time.
at some point it became about free trade. and then there was a realisation that free trade between unequal economies was not sustainable. And similarly that consumer rights in a world where infrastructure and technology barriers had been removed, were also not sustainable via the protectionism that public ownership and state control provided.
There was then a need to control the excesses of free markets and the four freedoms in general, and the need to liberalise sectors that were not in the private space.
Hence the need for political union.
After that things went very wrong, culminating in what we have today. Russia could have been part of the EU, as was certainly possible especially given the completely new dynamic that existed after the fall of the soviet union. That would truly have been a positive project.
I don't know if we could ever have undone the mistakes that were made from 1991 onwards, plenty of people tried to include Russian nationalism into international politics, but by then it was far too late, we were dealing with a mess that we had created.
For the last 10 years they have done the opposite and tried to legitimise themselves against this bogeyman i.e. implicitly stating that your only alternatives are a socially and economically liberal democracy that seems powerless to address systemic issues, or socially reactionary forces.
But the later keeps becoming more prominent due to the failure of the former.
Point 2 I agree with the sentiment.
I'm not suggesting for one minute that Croatia now is in the same state as Greece was 20 years ago. but improved credit rating based on the idea that the currency is effectively backed by the German and French economy, was one of the reasons for the debt crisis. German and French banks loaned them money that they shouldn't have, knowing that they would get bailed out.
Good luck to them though. It seems to have a similar population size to Scotland, so is interesting in terms of the independence debate in the UK.
When EU countries could have been forging ahead, building on the natural base of social democracy and technological advancement, e.g. to become world leaders in future energy . Instead they have spend 20 years dealing with the internal inconsistencies and self imposed limitations of a single currency without a single fiscal / monetary policy.
I don't see it changing, but who knows.
EDIT. I do wish people would post counterpoint, rather than vote down something that I explicitly stated was my own humble opinion, and indeed ended on a conciliatory sentence. Down votes really should be used for trolling, or off topic to the poster they are replying to, not as a lazy way of replying.