HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gghhzzgghhzz

238 karma · joined January 19, 2014

submissionscomments
gghhzzgghhzz··on UK bank fined £49M over IT system meltdown
It's not really the quantity of data that is important in migrations like this.

It's what is and isn't in the data - often a lot of junk in my experience if the source system is a legacy system that has evolved

what meaning that data has within a completely different system

what the demands are on the completeness of that data is in the new system

how to deal with exceptions

and whether that data can ever be frozen, or whether it is still online (as in the case of banking transactions)

This is unlikely to be simply a technical problem of ETLing tables, changing date ranges from inclusive to exclusive and mapping some address fields.

Of course the size of the data after a certain point does make a big difference to risk planning and business continuity planning. It's not possible to rollback and try again within the migration window should a catastrophic issue occur, and it's not possible to simply run some bulk updates to fix issues during the go-live validation.

It is noted though in this project that the data migration itself was not found to contribute to the failure.

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
The manifesto in 1983 included unilateral nuclear disarmament, leaving the EEC.

The 2017 / 2019 Corbyn manifesto were more aligned with the SDP-Liberal alliance manifestos of 1983.

Don't take my word for it, here is one of the members of SDP at the time who split from the Labour party because of Foot.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/may/11/leaked...

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
I think you are conflating socialism with statism.

Personally I don't believe Marxism to imply state control, or public ownership to mean state ownership.

I'd also see ownership models to include workers and customers. e.g. as a seasonal reference Building and Loan from It's a Wonderful Life.

Of course not everyone sees it that way.

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
The NHS has been in continuous reform. Thatcher / Blair / Brown / Lansley / Hunt.

Most of these reforms have included injecting private sector and internal markets into the system.

You may agree or disagree with these reforms, but it's difficult to argue that they don't incur overhead. Outsourced contracts need administration, legal frameworks; private parties take profit or else they wouldn't exist.

I'd argue it is likely that most of the extra funding is seeping out through these reforms, plus the legacy of not nationalising the whole health system - GP surgeries, pharmacy, generic drug manufacturing - when the NHS was formed.

I agree with you on the prevention aspect. but my thought is that a more joined up system including GPs, pharmacy and especially social care, would manage a lot of lifestyle related issues much better.

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
You are missing a few things here.

Firstly that involving workers in the ownership and running of a company is a successful model that is working in German for example. Focus on short term shareholder value is not good for employees or the company.

You are posting on a site that has a large percentage of people working in start-ups. Comments like your kind of goes completely against the audience.

Secondary, I've heard McDonnell describe himself as a Marxist. but he is also a politician. Unlike Corbyn he was the one to (incorrectly in my view) seek compromise and common ground with people who were seeking to undermine him. He was the key player in getting Labour to adopt a policy of second referendum, something that an ideological Marxist would certainly not go anywhere near, let alone drive.

There's no actual Marxist I know that would go anywhere near the EU.

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
> What do you call nationalising companies and handing control to the workers? (It's in the manifesto)

There is a confusion here between the situation we have and how we address it.

My water supply - water being that thing that falls from the sky on to the top of my house, and humans die if we don't have any within 3 days - is owned by a Hong Kong investment fund that is incorporated in the Cayman Islands.

If you asked the person on the street then they would say that this ownership model is radical, and public ownership of water is conservative.

However, if you instead ask them to comment on taking water ownership from a private company into the public domain , they'd say that was radical.

The issue is that we've moved so far in terms of financialisation of nearly every aspect of our lives, that any attempt to address that will be seen as radical.

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
he wrote Seventy Two Virgins (the book having a character who loved money, had a hocked nose and jewish name) in 2004. he continuously wrote racist, sexist and homophobic comments in his articles since.

His relationship with Jennifer Arcuri and public spending implications was out before 2019.

It was all out in the public domain.

It was the media's jobs to ignore this and pretend the main issue was one case where Corbyn liked a photo on facebook that he later claimed he hadn't paid enough attention to and apologised for (Johnson has never apologised or been called on to apologise)

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
you should always ask the question. what was it that made it so difficult to elect someone like Corbyn, yet so easy to elect someone like Johnson?

That's the actual interesting question here.

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
The 2017 Corbyn manifesto was praised by Polly Toynbee of all people for goodness sake!

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/may/11/leaked...

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
The policies were popular. 2017 saw the reversal of decline in Labour votes that started under Blair. Labour got more votes than any Blair election other than 1997.

There is a large constituency against the status quo in the UK. We have proof of that in the 2016 Brexit referendum, where 17 million people voted strongly against the establishment line and effectively against an economic model that we had had for 40 years. People voted in part to take back control, and what is nationalisation of basic aspects of our lives like water / housing / energy / drug manufacturing / transport etc if not taking back control?

Since the pandemic, the implementation of a chaotic version of Brexit, and the cost of living crisis. The underlying aspects of the 2017 / 2019 Labour policies are even more starkly relevant. Everything has been laid bare, and for some reason the two main parties are now completely devoid of ideas or vision.

gghhzzgghhzz··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
no it wasn't worse.

There are massive systemic issues in the country. Lack of housing, regional inequality, geographical inequality, falling real terms wages, chronic underfunding of R&D. Basically everything is falling apart. 40 years of financialisation of public services and nearly every aspect of our lives (there's virtually nothing you can do as part of your daily routine that doesn't trigger a transfer of wealth from public or household money to the top). The Brexit vote itself was partially a reaction to these issues.

These things need real solutions and real ideas. Any ideas that even start to address them let alone reverse the issues will look radical, and Labour 2017 / 2019 was barely doing that just offering a mild social democratic platform that would not be out of place in Northern Europe or indeed in the 1983 SDP-Liberal manifesto.

Adding to that we would have had a planned and controlled Brexit, with certain Eu agreements being replaced with equivalent things with different names.

All of this is mostly academic though as the first restrictions in the pandemic would have given the key to removing a Corbyn government by an effective establishment coup.

gghhzzgghhzz··on Maintain a clean architecture in Python with dependency rules
I use it mostly for reverse engineering a model on top of a legacy database when working on projects to clean and migrate that data.

I seen some very legacy database 'designs' and have never failed to model them with a combination of sqlalchemy join mapping, datatype mapping and some object properties in python for cases that are simpler to just express as list comprehensions.

You end up with some data quality rules / Transformation logic you can reasonably share with business users.

On the Load end I normally do that via sql bulk inserts as using an ORM just adds too much overhead and not enough control.

gghhzzgghhzz··on Coinbase sheds 85% of its value this year so far
How can you trade p2p?

How do I find someone to sell me bitcoin without an exchange?

If I do find someone and I send them some money, then who guarantees that they send the bitcoin?

How will day traders deal with the on-chain transaction costs and slow transaction time?

gghhzzgghhzz··on UK food price inflation hit 16.2% in October – cost of food basics surging
if we are heading into a recession, then a public sector spending spree is exactly what we do need.

Households won't spend, private sector won't invest as households are not spending, so if the public sector also stops spending then you go into a much longer and deeper recession.

Money itself for a government with a central bank is just a unit of account. There can't not be enough of it. It's just a way to measure resource distribution.

Wealth on the other hand. There's plenty of that in the UK, but it's increasingly in the hands of a few.

40 years of financilising public services and nearly every aspect of our lives means that household and public spending eventually ends up being concentrated even more in the hands of a few. That's the actual issue with public spending into such an economy, that without an effective tax system (which we don't have), then it makes inequality worse.

Both Tory and Labour are pushing a false narrative, because ultimately they represent those who are doing pretty well out of this deal.

gghhzzgghhzz··on UK food price inflation hit 16.2% in October – cost of food basics surging
There's graph.

QE went from 445bn before Covid to 895bn at end of 2020

https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/monetary-policy/quantitative...

EDIT: also https://neweconomics.org/2021/10/99-5-of-government-covid-de...

gghhzzgghhzz··on UK food price inflation hit 16.2% in October – cost of food basics surging
Tories did end up supporting May's compromise, even some members of the ERG.

It was blocked by Labour and other parties.

It would have been the most practical way forward at the time. It would have been softer and better planned and with a better working relationship with the EU.

It would also have meant that Labour would have been in partial control of parliament for another 3 years as May's majority relied on people who hated her and was never going to last for every vote. Then we would have had another election this year not in 2019.

I honestly don't know what people were thinking at the time. It was obvious that not compromising would end in chaos.

gghhzzgghhzz··on UK food price inflation hit 16.2% in October – cost of food basics surging
Debt being an issue is mostly a self imposed limitation / political tactic.

Parties were saying exactly the same thing about debt in 2010 when debt / GDP ratio was lower in order to win an election and implement austerity.

Covid Debt in the UK was all QE anyway, so is effectively money we owe to ourselves.

I do agree that Truss could have done all the things she wanted to do if she had just been smarter about presentation.

gghhzzgghhzz··on FTX fiasco sparks billions of dollars of outflows from exchanges
I'm not trying to defend them, but if 20% of the customer assets are in SHIB then that should be the pct they are holding in reserve?
gghhzzgghhzz··on Bank of England expects UK to fall into longest ever recession
not sure that there was 700 billion spend during covid.

but there's nothing wrong with pumping money into an economy that you have forcibly restricted (or that is in a recession for that matter)

the issue is that you need to be in control of where it ends up. UK has an extremely financialised economy where nearly everything anyone uses or does flows up to the top. Therefore taxes needed to be increased and targeted on where the money flowed to to avoid even further accumulation of assets by a small pct of the population.

gghhzzgghhzz··on Bank of England expects UK to fall into longest ever recession
Biggest ever investigation by the Information Commission. No CA were not involved.

If you understood the political situation at the time, then it was all but obvious there would be a massive anti-establishment vote, facebook ads or not.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/oct/07/cambridge-an...

gghhzzgghhzz··on Bank of England expects UK to fall into longest ever recession
"They are completely unable to sell bonds now. At this point, they are being forced to buy their bonds in order to keep the market for their bonds from total collapse."

This isn't true though. there is still large over-subscription on guilt auctions. https://www.dmo.gov.uk/data/pdfdatareport?reportCode=D2.1A

interest rates are higher that is true.

yes there was a period of buying guilts, but Bank of England has reversed this now and is going through policy (incorrect in my opinion) of quantitive tightening and selling what it 'bought' during QE https://www.ft.com/content/64e5dcdd-42a8-4013-a3bd-75a62cf8e...

gghhzzgghhzz··on Bank of England expects UK to fall into longest ever recession
"Remember when they were considering a Norway-like agreement? Or perhaps like Switzerland? "

The self-interested groups who were trying to deny that the vote had happened were some of the loudest voices against any sort of soft Brexit. therefore all but guaranteeing chaotic Brexit.

Look at the indicative votes in early 2019 at a time when the government was paralysed and desperate to get any way out. Those voting against single market / customs union were nationalists, green, change uk and right wing labour MPs.

https://ig.ft.com/brexit-second-round-indicative-votes/

gghhzzgghhzz··on GDPR for Developers by Example
Establishment companies are always writing new systems or rewriting systems. They will be easy competition if they don't.
gghhzzgghhzz··on GDPR for Developers by Example
agree with this. If done well, then this has all sorts of secondary benefits. better engineered systems, more agility through implicit fire breaks, stronger devops processes, faster backups etc.

I don't think GDPR should have been enforced on existing systems as in many cases it became a tick box exercise. Best practice and certification for new development would have made more sense.

gghhzzgghhzz··on Increased Subscription Pricing for IDEs, .NET Tools, and the All Products Pack
Prices are not rising because people have too much money and are over purchasing food and energy just to show off to their neighbours.

If that were the case then there are things that would work. Increase taxes on income, unearned income, wealth and excess profits to take money out of the economy (MMT theory would support this if the issue was genuinely too much money) Introduce price controls and rationing on food and basic services including energy and housing to stop profiteering.

gghhzzgghhzz··on The Case for a Confederal Europe
There's no power behind any of these ideas. Anything business related has the power of capital behind it, even the regulations and standards - some of the admittedly good - are the basic requirements of a taming a market to make it functional. Without a shared demos then there is no democratic mandate for them either.

The massive tragedy of the EU is that they have spent 20 years or more dealing with the inbuilt contradictions of their single currency and self-imposed restrictions of their monetary policy. All of which has the effect of constraining public spending. When the 20 years could have been spent on a serious move to a green economy. It was culturally, socially and economically (having a tradition of social democracy which requires public spending) the place where this could have really taken off. Yet navel gazing, and now paying the geo-political price.

gghhzzgghhzz··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
US has some of the highest levels of comparative inequality in the world. There are also areas that have been depopulated and others where basic services cannot keep up with the population (housing for example).

but that aside, the US has broad political integration and economic integration and has a single demos. The EU is trying to impose economic integration without political integration (or at least without being honest with the scope of political integration) and that will never work. You can't have freedom of movement of goods, services, capital and labour over unequal economies without seriously compensating for it, both 'sides' of the transactions are damaged. Plus it doesn't have a single demos and I don't see how you can magic one into being.

a more apt comparison would be to look at NAFTA. It increased trade, but at great overall cost to both sides.

gghhzzgghhzz··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
I think we should all have a healthy scepticism for leaders and politicians. We do tend to have that for those in Westminster.

The idea that politicians in Brussels don't have vested interests, are not the result of heavy lobbying, are not seeking re-election, are not corruptible or of questionable moral standing is rather dangerous. There seems to be a heavy degree of Blue-Washing. Take a politician like Donald Tusk for example, someone who would be in the fringes of the socially conservative right in the UK, yet is venerated during the Brexit discussions. Or Micheal Barnier, again venerated amongst so called liberals in the UK, yet now calling for an immigration ban in France.

On the economic side. Yes everything is very convoluted and remote for a reason. Power structures always get taken over by the interests of capital. The idea that the EU / Euro / European central bank is any different is again rather dangerous. This is an institution with economic interests written into its constitution. The goal here is to drive down the costs of labour added with the maybe unintended or maybe intended consequence that the EU has spend 20 years dealing with the contradictions and artificial constraints on public spending of a currency that it has created, when it could have been using that time and effort to do something transformational, especially in the direction of green technology and energy.

gghhzzgghhzz··on Scotland starts renewed case for independence
As a Welsh secessionist, I can't for the life of me square the idea of wanting to leave union that for all its massive faults is at least something you can understand and engage with, to replace that by joining a union that is distant, more artificial and certainly more vague and impenetrable to the common person.

Why would you leave economic and political dominance by Westminster with no control over the economics of your borders (the capital flows, the tax loopholes, the destabilising and exploitative 'investment', the primacy of trade which leads to the all encompassing trade for trade's sake, the depopulation of youth) to instead give that control up to Frankfurt and Brussels?

I think we (Scotland, and Wales) should define what we want to do first and why and where we want to go / want to be. Then in some cases trade agreements will be useful to promote these goals. but they have to be tightly controlled and compensated for.

gghhzzgghhzz··on Vangelis has died
poor example compared to his lifetime of work, but this was a beautiful advert

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EsyyJaX0j3Y

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →