HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gherkin0

1,087 karma · joined June 4, 2015

submissionscomments
gherkin0··on Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces Energy
It's related to the parent's points by a misunderstanding.
gherkin0··on Sci-Hub Is Blowing Up the Academic Publishing Industry
I don't think that would accomplish much. People would just delete the 9 papers that they don't care about rather than maintain them as clutter. And even if everyone did keep the extra files, would use would they be? It would be impossibly difficult to reconstruct the archive from them.

It would probably be better to break down the torrents into smaller, more coherent, and organized collections that contain all associated metadata (e.g. a collection of biology papers from a certain time-span or set of publications). That way you might incentivize people to maintain smaller personal-use archives that could be recombined back into the whole, if the need arises.

You could perhaps even build a system that could automatically generate, publish, and consume torrents with a particular (metadata + content) layout, but that's not restricted to a particular set of torrents. Then it could just consume certain topics from a feed of new torrents, from various sources, on the Pirate Bay.

gherkin0··on Sci-Hub Is Blowing Up the Academic Publishing Industry
> What's wrong with setting up a mirror at archive.org? After all, they /are/ a library, so they get some immunity from copyright. Or can we not do that?

Pretty sure no-one gets "immunity from copyright," at list not to the point where they could mirror Sci-hub with impunity (at least no on in the US). I'd very surprised if archive.org did not respond to DMCA take-down requests, etc.

gherkin0··on Entrpreneurship Means I Give Up
> Even the modern replacement careers- nursing schools, medical schools, which, contrary to the American legend, are calibrated to turn out very few brilliant practitioners in favor of a large, reliable number of perfectly adequate practitioners and a vanishingly small number of screwups- are becoming more lottery-like. Specifically, the ratio of medical school “slots” to the number of residencies waiting for those students once they graduate is going way up… but I digress.

Wut? I'm pretty sure the AMA would never let Med school seats exceed the number of residency positions.

gherkin0··on Entrpreneurship Means I Give Up
Honestly, while that's a good suggestion, I think it's only part of the answer:

1) Trees used to be a lot more abundant before fossil fuels were a big a thing, but now people are using the land the trees would need for other things (e.g. farming, cities) that are unlikely to be displaced.

2) At some point organic carbon sinks will hit equilibrium as the organisms that compose them start to die and decompose.

gherkin0··on All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020
> Recently Elsevier contracted top logicians to produce a Handbook in the History of Logic. It runs to 11 volumes, each volume north of $300. So folks, if you want to get acquainted with the complete history of what is supposed to be a formalisation of rational thought it can be yours for $3,300 or thereabouts.

Unless you're leaving out important details, that strikes me as a completely reasonable and uncontroversial thing for Elsevier to do. If they're going privately fund the creation of an original specialist work, I think they can charge whatever they want for it. That's worlds away from how they they've subverted the primary scientific publishing process for private profit.

gherkin0··on Feds spend billions to run museum-ready computer systems
Honestly, I don't see good solution to this until the rate of technological change really slows down. It seems like your options are to either pay to periodically re-engineer every system or pay to maintain obsolete hardware.
gherkin0··on Tesla Tests Self-Driving Functions with Secret Updates to Its Customers’ Cars
Plus they can scold you if they catch you tinkering with your car.

On the plus side: they're watching you. On the negative side: they're watching you.

gherkin0··on Return of incandescent light bulbs as MIT makes them more efficient than LEDs
It's ironic that the factories that make incandescent bulbs are being shut down.
gherkin0··on The Secret of Billions
> There is nothing that says the feds can't pursue bad cases

It's unfortunate that there isn't something that says that.

gherkin0··on The college debt crisis is worse than it seems
> Ban education discrimination against job applicants. (Except for jobs which require certification).

All that will do is create a regime of required certifications that people will need to get a job, and it will probably greatly reduce (individual) employment flexibility. Employers need some way of judging applicants ability, and it's my understanding that explicit aptitude tests have basically been banned, employers have to use education as a proxy.

> put lower boundaries on what % of tuition goes towards instruction. Most tuition funds do not go towards education, and there is a lot of pressure for universities to spend them on building Potemkin villages.

I think this is a much more reasonable suggestion. Cut out all the extra costs and make college a spartan environment focused on learning.

gherkin0··on When does moderation become censorship?
It's still censorship, even if it's within their legal rights as owners to do it.
gherkin0··on When does moderation become censorship?
I think you have a point if you're talking about a personal website, but I think things get a whole lot blurrier when you're dealing with places that are communities, have an ethos of free expression, or have taken on the characteristics of public forums. I think it's an oversimplification to view those solely through the private property lens.
gherkin0··on When does moderation become censorship?
I think that's incorrectly narrowing the concept of "censorship" to mean only "government censorship," when other kinds exist (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_censorship).
gherkin0··on What Disturbed Me About the Facebook Meeting
Can you really make much of a statement about the modern "progressive movement" by talking about Theodore Roosevelt? While they both used the "progressive" label and perhaps one descended from the other, there's about 100 years of significant social and political change between them.
gherkin0··on New Bloomberg Terminal Keyboard
Oh, I'm not criticizing that interest. It has a legitimate and practical basis given the amount of time programmers spend using keyboards and how integral they are to the performance of their job.
gherkin0··on New Bloomberg Terminal Keyboard
> These keyboards are ergonomically awful: an undifferentiated mass of completely flat buttons, with crappy keyswitches.

You'd think they could splurge a little on keyswitches given that it costs $20k a year to use one (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloomberg_Terminal).

Though it was kinda funny watching the guy in the video hunting-and-pecking on a 80s chiclet keyboard that could've come from a TRS-80.

gherkin0··on New Bloomberg Terminal Keyboard
> This keyboard has been out for ages, unless I am missing something here?

Not everyone works in finance and/or is familiar with Bloomberg terminals (like me). I think this is pretty interesting since Bloomberg, unlike most application developers, has taken their UX to the point where they're building application-specific hardware (though I understand a lot of that is basically legacy inertia).

Also, programmers seem to be far more interested in keyboards as a subject that most people.

I also thought the B-unit is interesting, it's different than any other authentication device I've used.

http://www.bbhub.io/professional/sites/4/2015/03/b-unit_3_us...

gherkin0··on Fitbit Acquires Coin
I just use mine for loyalty cards and magstripe gift cards (so they don't collect dust because I don't want a fat wallet). Might be worth a try if you haven't tried it for anything.
gherkin0··on Fitbit Acquires Coin
Got any loyalty cards or gift cards? That's what I used mine for.
gherkin0··on Fitbit Acquires Coin
Honestly, I just used mine for gift/loyalty cards. Never loaded a real credit card to it.
gherkin0··on Fitbit Acquires Coin
Well, that's just great. I was an original backer and got a Coin 1.0. They kept saying they'd ship me a Coin 2.0 due to the problems with the 1.0, but I never got it. Now it appears all mention of that has been scrubbed from their website.

It is kind of humorous that their website now as a big "Sold Out" banner right at the top next to this announcement.

gherkin0··on Why U.S. Infrastructure Costs So Much
Did you reply to the wrong post?
gherkin0··on SpareOne: Emergency mobile phone powered by AA batteries
A USB battery seems far more useful than some special-purpose device that runs off of AAs. Due to their versatility, I'd probably get way more value out of it than something with a 15 year shelf life that I never use.
gherkin0··on Apple stops support for WebObjects
Not to mention one that non-developers already know and are productive in.
gherkin0··on A Eukaryote Without a Mitochondrial Organelle
Free-radicals?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-radical_theory_of_aging#M...

gherkin0··on A Eukaryote Without a Mitochondrial Organelle
IIRC, mitochondria are only used for aerobic respiration (which requires oxygen). So there might be a chance for such an organism to have survived an an anaerobic/oxygen-free environment.
gherkin0··on Russian Insider Says State-Run Doping Fueled Olympic Gold
> I would be surprised to learn that USOC isn't doing the same thing.

Does the US government care enough about its Olympic performance to coordinate systematic cheating like this?

Winning at sports is cool, but my impression is that authoritarian governments care much more about it (as a matter of national prestige) than non-authoritarian governments do.

gherkin0··on World of VNC
I like this one:

https://worldofvnc.net/browse.php?id=2677

It looks like the LCD display of some embedded system, something I would have never expected to see over VNC.

gherkin0··on Understanding the bin, sbin, usr/bin , usr/sbin split (2010)
> If yes, the device can never be trusted second-hand - the OS might have been modified to secretly accept more keys.

That's always going to be a risk with second-hand devices (or even new devices). Who knows what kind sneaky things someone did to a device that they had long-term access to. You can never really totally trust something that you didn't build yourself from the ground up, so you always have to accept some level of risk.

That UI solution was just a random idea, I'm sure there are better ones. Like you said, it's a Hard Problem.

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →