HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ghufran_syed

2,751 karma · joined August 15, 2014

Apprentice mathematician, programmer, Emergency Medicine doctor in the SF Bay area.

Feel free to get in touch for any reason at all, it's always nice to chat to people first_name.last_name @ gmail.com

meet.hn/city/us-Los-Angeles

Socials:

- linkedin.com/in/ghufransyed

Interests:

Books, Education, Entrepreneurship, Healthcare, Hiking, Mentorship, Outdoor Activities, Science, Space Tech, Startups

---

submissionscomments
ghufran_syed··on NYC mental health response teams show better results than police
“inherently racist”?

Inherent: “existing in something as a permanent, essential, or characteristic attribute.”

Once you define something as “racist”, then it’s not hard to conclude it’s “racist”. Sounds a lot like the christian doctrine of “original sin”:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Original_sin

“Is it your assertion that only white people contain original sin?” - yup, both sentences seem equally meaningful IMO.

ghufran_syed··on NYC mental health response teams show better results than police
You mean it could be a “fallacy of composition” - if you provided some evidence for the claim that a group of likely non-racist individuals are nevertheless racist as a group - whatever that means.
ghufran_syed··on We’d rather have the iceberg than the ship
Property tax payment is very easy in the US, because it is usually done as part of your regular mortgage payment - people still dislike paying it.

The IRS is also a lot more helpful than commonly advertised - I once had a several thousand dollar expense reimbursement from work that my employer wrongly classified a miscellaneous untaxed payment to me. They didn’t attach any penalties, just sent a letter essentially saying “we think you forgot to include this in your income for YEAR, we think you owe $X + $Y interest.”(and the interest amount was very reasonable, like 3-4%)

I just emailed them a copy of the receipts and email I had sent to my employer when claiming reimbursement, and noted that I had not claimed those expenses on my tax return, if I had done , then it would have exactly matched the tax owed.

They replied a few weeks later telling me thanks and that I owed nothing extra.

I do worry about arbitrary abuse of government power in the US, particularly against those guilty of WRONGTHINK, but my personal experience was exactly what I would hope for as a citizen, professional, clear and timely.

I still would still like taxes to be lower - but if you told me I had to make a mandatory charitable donation of the same amount every year to a real charity, I would be fine with that. So in my case at least, it’s that I expect the unionized middle class government workers to get most of the benefit of my extra tax, not the poorest people in society who need it most (and who are usually presented as the need for such increased taxes)

ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: Recommendations for Home Solar Install?
Hmm, seems weird that the price per watt doesn’t seem to have dropped since then, unless we got a really good deal..?

https://news.energysage.com/how-much-does-the-average-solar-...

ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: Recommendations for Home Solar Install?
I got mine installed in northern california in 2019, I would have liked to go with Tesla but they were too expensive at the time. When I looked again last year, they actually looked a lot cheaper than everyone else. I think we paid $2.75 / watt. We used energysage to get and compare quotes, and there is a lot of other useful advice on that site.

In Cali there was also some issue that the rebates for each Tesla powerwall were somehow distributed per company. So if we bought the Powerwall directly from Tesla, we wouldn’t have got a rebate because they had run out, but other installers could still supply the rebate.

The Tesla software to monitor the solar generation, battery use and home energy usage is really nice, certainly much better than the “enphase” software that came with the solar panels and inverters.

ghufran_syed··on Man dies of a heart attack after minors swatted him over his rare Twitter handle
perhaps you could describe that “fundamental difference”???
ghufran_syed··on China unveils 600 kph maglev train
“capable of reaching 600 kph”

So I take that to mean it has never actually done it, but it “could”? Before getting excited about this, maybe we should wait until the system, including the track, is actually built? Or at least a test track with curves etc.

I am not shocked this came from chinese state media originally, it comes across as a press release.

ghufran_syed··on Time to assume that health research is fraudulent until proven otherwise?
I think this is a fabulous idea and this kind of sensible approach to regulation could be applied in many different areas, increasing personal freedom without excessively increasing risk and third-party costs. For example, in finance, maybe the default could be that only fixed rate mortgages can be sold, but if you take and pass a rigorous exam and indemnify the government from any claims if you end up losing your house, then you can be sold an adjustable rate or interest-only mortgage. Maybe you could have default speed limits as we do now, but if you take an exam +/- agree to telemetry in your vehicle, you can go faster than the speed limits as long as it’s safe.

Particularly for my low-income patients who end up coming into the ER for a refill (or a complication of having ran out of their meds), I’ll often write a 3 month supply and 3 refills, so giving them one year of access to their meds without needing a doctor. I still strongly encourage them to get a primary doctor and see that doctor in order to get help with their medical conditions, but the idea that we should effectively coerce patients into seeing a doctor by withholding life-saving medications (“it’s for their own good!!!”) seems grossly unethical to me, and doesn’t take into account the problems poorer people have in getting good affordable healthcare. But I’m pretty sure my position is an outlier among emergency medicine docs.

ghufran_syed··on Time to assume that health research is fraudulent until proven otherwise?
that’s not true in developing countries. Vitamins and “over the counter” (OTC) medicines definitely work - the regulators need to decide the relative risk and benefit of allowing OTC access. As a physician, my personal view is that we should allow more people access to more medicines that are currently prescription-only in the US, but there are always going to be some medicines where the risk of harm is high enough that having a licensed doctor be the gatekeeper is overall beneficial for society. So while I might draw the dividing line in a different place, I think the concept of controlling access to certain medications is sound
ghufran_syed··on Cryptocurrency is like taking the worst parts of today's capitalist system
Some links would be useful btw, "US Coupon Bureau" is not any kind of US official organization, just another crypto startup. And their own website has their name listed as "The Coupon Bureau".

I had to dig a little, but the "NHS vaccine temperature tracking" does at least have a CNBC article about it: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/19/uk-hospitals-use-blockchain-...

ghufran_syed··on Cryptocurrency is like taking the worst parts of today's capitalist system
How do you judge if something is an "exciting development" if you "don't have the resources to vet anything"? Wouldn't making such a judgement imply that you thought it could be useful? Or is "usefulness" not required for such crypto "exciting developments"? I think that may be the point the GP is making...
ghufran_syed··on My take on the study from MIT that predicts “societal collapse”
Why is the "hardness" of the work the key criteria? If you compare "value to society based on peoples willingness to pay", then the ratio of that between a billionaire and the median person probably is 8000x - the founders that become billionaires usually capture only a tiny fraction of the value they create, but we tend to take that value for granted and it's hard to measure. So we only see the billions of dollars they have, not the 10s or 100's of billions of dollars of value they create.
ghufran_syed··on Police destroy Bitcoin miners with steamroller in Malaysia
I think they also said that they knock down houses that have illegal electricity connections to steal electricity - this punishment is probably just the equivalent
ghufran_syed··on Tesla is offering a $1500 upgrade for early cars to support “full self-driving”
Right, Tesla could have the same economic effect by requiring a minimum 2 year contract for the monthly FSD with "free" FSD chip upgrade - I suspect that wouldn't make people feel any better about the situation
ghufran_syed··on Master’s degrees are the second biggest scam in higher education?
You’re assuming that getting the doctorate actually increased people’s skills that are economically useful - this book suggests otherwise:

https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/lsereviewofbooks/2018/05/30/book-rev...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_Against_Education

ghufran_syed··on Master’s degrees are the second biggest scam in higher education?
It sounds like you’re saying that places with less government involvement have less healthcare inflation - isn’t what the comment you are replying to is arguing?
ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: Should I sell my house to fund my startup? Anyone with the same story?
totally agree - I fell into this trap before of mistaking “customers think it’s a good idea” for “customers will pay”

This video from yc explains how most of our conversations with (potential) users are at best useless and at worse misleading, and how to do it better. Based on the book, “The mom test”

https://www.ycombinator.com/library/6g-how-to-talk-to-users

ghufran_syed··on My take on the study from MIT that predicts “societal collapse”
Why do you have to adapt each plant for its location? or just find a suitable location and build a bunch of such plants and transmit the power to where it’s used.

Buildings are also “adapted for each location”, but there is still an entire corpus of standardized techniques to do that that massively reduces costs compared to literally solving the problem from scratch at each site.

And why is it the case that “we don’t have the skilled people to do that”? If people value it, they’ll pay for it- and people can learn new skills in response to market need / pay - there is no predetermined number of “ad-tech software engineers” for example, they were “created” by the people themselves responding to market forces (pay)

ghufran_syed··on My take on the study from MIT that predicts “societal collapse”
The problem is defining “greed”.

It feels like when I want more stuff per unit time/effort, I’m just “trying to support my family and build a better life for my children”. But when other people do the same, it’s “greedy”. Is there any definition of “greedy” we could use for the purposes of this discussion that would apply yo all humans equally?

ghufran_syed··on How to unlearn a disease
“People who experience a single random seizure, for instance, are 50 times more likely to become epileptic than someone who has never had one”

Given that epilepsy is diagnosed and treated based on the presence of recurrent seizures, this seems like a tautology - the set of “at least one seizure” contains the set of “at least two seizures”

Like saying “playing at least one game of basketball was associated with a greatly increased chance of playing more than one basketball game in a lifetime, compared to those who had never played”

ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: 30 years old with no career
I took a long time figuring out what I wanted to do, and I found the following books useful: “What color is your parachute?” by richard bolles “What should I do with my life?” by Po Bronson (who also had trouble deciding what he wanted to do…) “The seven habits of highly effective people” by Steven Covey - the title made me cringe but a friend recommended it to me and I found it very useful YMMV
ghufran_syed··on Shorting Bitcoin
As long as it's only a small percentage of their portfolio, seems safe enough. The max loss is the put premium. Are you getting it mixed up with selling puts, where your losses are unlimited?
ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: How to learn how to sell?
I really like this book “resistance is useless” by an English author, Geoff Birch: https://www.geoffburch.com/?page_id=56 I thinks it’s a sensible common sense approach to learning how to sell
ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: What's your experience working for a YC backed startup?
high pay is opposite to low pay… bureaucratic is opposite to flat… sincere is opposite to charlatan… liberal is opposite to…”racist”?

It sounds like your definition of “racist” is “disagrees with me politically”? Do you think such a definition helps victims of “old-fashioned” racism where people treat you worse because of your skin color?

ghufran_syed··on The “success isn't based on hard work” crowd
Wanting to help the poor with other people's money doesn't seem particularly virtuous, compared to, say, spending one's own time or money. Deciding arbitrarily that the amount of wealth we have is nice but not excessive, but the amount of wealth those evil rich people have is excessive seems rather self-serving. Particularly when "rich" is always conveniently defined as "more money than I have"
ghufran_syed··on Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank
You realize that when forming a company, the number of shares you issue is arbitrary, right? If three founders each put in $1 capital, and each get 1 share, then the price per share is $1. If instead the founders get 1 million shares each, then each share is worth 1 millionth of a dollar. What economic difference does it make?

Or are you claiming that on the day that he paid $0.001 per share, someone else paid more per share? If that didn't happen, there is NO WAY to determine after the fact what the “true” market value was on that date.

ghufran_syed··on Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank
“ buy a stake in a startup that has a good chance of one day exploding in value.”

the propublica people must be rich, if they can reliably identify these kind of startups - everything is easy in hindsight. They also missed the bit where thiel paid tax on the $2000, that he invested. The whole idea of retirement accounts is that you either pay the tax at the beginning, or you pay at the end.

ghufran_syed··on The “success isn't based on hard work” crowd
That person still had to earn the money for the lottery ticket, and do the work of buying the tickets. If you discount all the necessary steps except the final random payoff, it’s easy to “prove” that hard work was not required for a given person’s success
ghufran_syed··on The “success isn't based on hard work” crowd
Having a home is better (more successful) than being homeless. Having children to care for and who (hopefully) love you is better (more successful) than not having those things. Both of those things might be at risk if she didn’t work hard.

I think your example says more about your own values rather about society in general

ghufran_syed··on The “success isn't based on hard work” crowd
Surely the distribution matters too? Even if it is possible to be successful through luck alone, is that necessarily imply that most people are no worse off if they don’t work hard?
← PreviousPage 12 of 29Next →