HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ghufran_syed

2,751 karma · joined August 15, 2014

Apprentice mathematician, programmer, Emergency Medicine doctor in the SF Bay area.

Feel free to get in touch for any reason at all, it's always nice to chat to people first_name.last_name @ gmail.com

meet.hn/city/us-Los-Angeles

Socials:

- linkedin.com/in/ghufransyed

Interests:

Books, Education, Entrepreneurship, Healthcare, Hiking, Mentorship, Outdoor Activities, Science, Space Tech, Startups

---

submissionscomments
ghufran_syed··on The “success isn't based on hard work” crowd
As argued in the article - would you suggest that the life of that single mother would not get worse if she stopped working so hard? If we define success as some arbitrary amount of money, we can make the correlation between hard work and success “tenuous” just by making the amount of money defining success to be high enough.
ghufran_syed··on Doge Branded as Ponzi by Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis President
What evidence is there for widespread “nazi sympathies”? As opposed to tiny numbers of idiots?

https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/all-amer...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neo-Nazism

ghufran_syed··on I wrote a children's book / illustrated guide to Apache Kafka
This is fabulous!

Is there a typo at https://www.gentlydownthe.stream/#/22 ?

Current version: "First, they dropped large stones into the river, splitting each topic into a smaller number of streams, or Partitions."

I know nothing about Kafka, but I think maybe this should be: "First, they dropped large stones into the river, splitting each topic into a number of smaller streams, or Partitions."

(my emphasis for both versions) "

ghufran_syed··on David Dushman, last surviving Auschwitz liberator, dies aged 98
Wouldn’t bombing the camp kill the prisoners? Or are you suggesting that they could have successfully bombed and “incapacitated” the camp without killing the prisoners? How exactly?
ghufran_syed··on Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing protection expires in June
With that kind of thinking, we can soon make sure the person with 5 houses has much fewer houses, possibly 0? The problem with redistribution is that eventually you run out of other people’s money.
ghufran_syed··on Immediate skin-to-skin contact with unstable newborns improves survival chances
Thats fair, I didn’t pick up on your use of the word “elective”. But vaginal births have twice the incidence of urinary stress incontinence, overactive bladder and pelvic organ prolapse. There is also a risk of tearing of the vagina, and even tears that extend into the anus [2]. If I could choose a surgery that would prevent tearing of my genitalia, at the cost of money pain and possibly other complications somewhere away from my genitalia, I might well choose that - one might even say that a woman should have the right to choose.

It seems weird that we think that the WHO, an organization run mostly by men [3] would somehow know the “correct” rate at which women should risk urinary incontinence and genital injuries - why wouldn’t we let the patients decide with the assistance of their doctors?

[1] https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2718794 [2] https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/labor-and-deliv... [3] https://apps.who.int/gb/gov/en/composition-of-the-board_en.h...

ghufran_syed··on Immediate skin-to-skin contact with unstable newborns improves survival chances
The case linked below started off with an attempt at a normal vaginal delivery. Based on your comment, you might think it admirable that the doctors didn't consider doing a c-section and continued to try vaginal deliver for around 60 hours - but then had to do a c-section and the baby had severe brain injury.

"Specifically, the family alleged the hospital did not properly estimate the weight of the fetus, even though the ultrasound estimate was more than the average weight. The family also asserted that the hospital failed in assessing the safety of vaginal delivery, which constituted malpractice. Finally, the family claimed the hospital did not recognize the deteriorating fetal heart rate pattern, which showed decelerations and a rising baseline. The family stated that if the hospital and its staff adhered to the appropriate standard of care, the infant’s injuries could have been prevented.

Through careful monitoring, the physicians would have noted that delivery via cesarean section was viable — and, in fact, the most appropriate option. This is reinforced because despite the administration of labor-inducing drugs, delivery had not occurred after 60 hours. This timing should have concerned the physicians and care providers, and they should have re-evaluated their initial course of treatment. Absent any evidence indicating otherwise, the abnormal 60-hour labor period could easily have injured the fetus. Whether the physicians acted negligently while monitoring the fetus’ heart rate would likely have been a significant material issue in this case. However, the family presented strong evidence that the care providers were negligent based on the totality of the circumstances and obvious disregard of cause for concern."

It's easy to have opinions when you don't have responsibility for people's lives.

https://www.reliasmedia.com/articles/145690-birth-injury-lit...

ghufran_syed··on LA pays $2600 per homeless tent, per month
Partly because of the rise in legally mandated standards - in california there are laws stating the minimum area of housing for a family of a given size which is way higher than the minimum that people would settle for if the price was correspondingly lower - most poorer people including me earlier in life would prefer to pay half or 1/3 the amount for half or 1/3 the space. The aim of the minimum is sometimes stated as “we don’t want people to live in slums”…and the result is that people either commute up to 2 hours each way, break the law, or end up on the street
ghufran_syed··on Solved by 1440p HiDPI: MacBook Pro 16“ is hot and noisy with an external monitor
I personally like posthaven, if you don’t mind paying $5 / month and you want it to stay up “forever” :) Otherwise github pages is probably the way to go
ghufran_syed··on Woke at Work: Why tech firms are trying to run away from politics and failing
presumably you would also be ok with getting paid less money in exchange for more political freedoms at work?
ghufran_syed··on Woke at Work: Why tech firms are trying to run away from politics and failing
It’s too early yet to see whether the whole episode at basecamp was net positive or negative for the company.
ghufran_syed··on San Francisco’s Shoplifting Surge
>Once shops start closing down, people will ask and complain why stores don’t exist in their neighborhoods, or they’re too expensive but low quality.

And the answer by the people who implemented this policy will, no doubt, be “institutional racism” by walgreens…

ghufran_syed··on Robinhood’s big gamble
Seemed to work well for Vanguard: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Vanguard_Group
ghufran_syed··on Launch HN: Moonshot Brands (YC W21) – We buy and grow e-commerce companies
Berkshire hathaway used to do a lot of this. Also, if the sellers want to retain upside, they can accept some portion of the purchase in stock from Moonshot
ghufran_syed··on Launch HN: UPchieve (YC W21 Nonprofit) – Live tutoring for low-income students
I signed up, went through the training and did my first tutoring session, ended up being 2.5 hours! Some feedback: Some of the subject quizzes have errors (lack of parens in a math question, diagram now showing up) - it would be good to have a "report this question" to report bugs in these pages as you go through, rather than having to remember and post a bug report later

For the upchieve101 quiz - some of the questions weren't covered in the training (or I missed it e.g. what subjects do students want most help with?).

The implicit bias stuff was annoying - I agree with the idea, but there is little evidence it makes any difference to behavior: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-problem-with-...

Having to implicitly agree with ideas like "being colorblind is racism" (paraphrasing) was almost enough to put me off continuing - and being told that it was a sign of white racism when I'm a brown immigrant was a little weird and suggested some unhelpful assumptions on the part of the material's author(s)

It was nice to help a student, and I think they learned a lot during the session, but I was surprised how weird it felt not having any audio interaction. Everything took much longer than it would have otherwise.

I understand the need for student safety, but not knowing anything about a student, and knowing I would never know how this student would do in future was also demotivating, it felt like taking part in "mechanical turk for tutoring". I'll try a few more times, maybe I'll get used to it. But rich kids somehow manage to stay safe with online tutors with audio and video, seems a shame to give the poor kids a crappy version of the same thing.

ghufran_syed··on Launch HN: UPchieve (YC W21 Nonprofit) – Live tutoring for low-income students
I note that the student sign-up uses zip-code to try and classify low-income students. I live in the low-income part of a rich city (Menlo Park), and the whole city just has one zip code. This would exclude a lot of the low-income students who live in my neighborhood. I used to be a volunteer tutor with the local boys and girls clubs of America (bgca.org) chapter and the students who would attend there were exactly the demographic you’re targeting. I know you partner with some schools, but you might want to also consider using organizations like bgca as an alternative way of identifying these kids. You probably don’t want to go to the schools in this area and have them stigmatize the low income students by presenting the app as being just “for the poor kids”
ghufran_syed··on Launch HN: UPchieve (YC W21 Nonprofit) – Live tutoring for low-income students
That would be true if the advice was for an individual - when your organization is serving children, you have a responsibility to them and their parents to minimize the risk, which is small but non-trivial
ghufran_syed··on When Stockton gave people cash, they got jobs
I have personally spoken with 3 business owners who have work, would like to hire back their old workers, but those workers won’t come back because they would lose money by working.

Regarding the study you quoted, the authors note: “ One should be cautious with a causal interpretation, however, because we also find evidence that those collecting UI benefits may differ from those who do not collect benefits along unobservable dimensions. Specifically, those who receive UI benefits tend to have had higher-paying jobs than those who never apply for benefits, suggesting that they may be higher-skilled workers, on average.”

[Edit - my concern with UBI is that if a majority can continually vote for a rise in the UBI, by increasingly taxing a rich minority, eventually those tax levels will get to the point where less is produced. Even if people choose not to work if it pays more than working (my belief based on limited local experience - I certainly wouldn’t go to work if it paid less than staying at home!), it’s not relevant to UBI which is unchanged whether you work or not]

ghufran_syed··on Launch HN: UPchieve (YC W21 Nonprofit) – Live tutoring for low-income students
If you are already keeping the chat logs, maybe you could figure out a way to record the whole session including the whiteboard sessions? Then if you can figure out a way to tag the session’s content appropriately, you would pretty quickly end up with a searchable library of tutoring sessions available on the site (wouldn’t be hard to anonymize them to protect the student and tutor’s privacy). Then you could use the students and volunteers to filter them for quality by making them available in the app / on the site by upvoting etc. That way you would leverage your expensive resource (volunteers) and provide another way for students to benefit if they aren’t in a position to do an interactive tutoring session e.g. on the bus, too noisy at home etc - many low income students have no quiet place at home to do this kind of session because there are just too many people sharing the space.

Getting back to the safety aspect - people are less likely to test the boundaries of your safety rules if they know these (anonymized) sessions will be seen by many other people, and this would massively increase the number of eyeballs for each session further increasing the detection rate of any remaining bad behavior

[Edit - you could also use these recorded sessions to help volunteers get better at teaching, you could get an expert to put together small videos on improving teaching technique with positive and negative anonymized examples from the sessions, then make them available to the volunteer tutors. That could be another low cost and scalable way to reward the tutors - most people who teach would like to get better at it!]

ghufran_syed··on Launch HN: UPchieve (YC W21 Nonprofit) – Live tutoring for low-income students
I think that’s a feature, not a bug - part of the reason I’d like to tutor high school calculus students is so I have an excuse to revise that stuff again - I finished an MS in math and statistics last year, but it’s probably been 8 years since I last did high school / freshman calculus :)
ghufran_syed··on Launch HN: UPchieve (YC W21 Nonprofit) – Live tutoring for low-income students
This looks great, thanks for building this!

The problem of how to get revenue, not just donations for something like this is an interesting one. One idea it might be worth exploring is charging colleges in order for them to be able to contact students through the site as part of their efforts to increase diversity (It would need to be opt-in for the students, to maintain their privacy). If you can keep students on the platform through college, you could do the same for employers looking to increase diversity in hiring - maybe the way to do that is encourage students to “graduate” to being volunteers on the platform when they finish high school? Then the (college) students would get the benefit of support and outreach from employers for internships during college, as well as the psychological and learning benefits of tutoring others who are a few years behind them.

I think it would also be interesting to consider making some kind of private social network for your student “alumni” - having a peer group can be super helpful for low-income students in college, so this would hopefully keep them involved with upchieve, make them more likely to succeed in college, and hopefully let you charge companies looking to recruit them.

Happy to chat about this or any other crazy ideas, contact details in my profile

ghufran_syed··on Evidence from leaked account data on how elites use offshore banking [pdf]
I pay more now because of the SALT cap, but I still support the idea - why should residents of low tax states subsidize residents of high tax states, all other things being equal?
ghufran_syed··on In the Name of Equity, California Will Discourage Students Gifted at Math
I’m currently reading “Surely you’re joking, Mr Feynman”, and this reminds me of his experience in high school where the teacher thought he talked too much and was too noisy because he was bored - so he gave him a copy of “Advanced calculus” by Woods to work through during class time and told him he wasn’t allowed to speak in class until he was done with it. He clearly found that a valuable experience.
ghufran_syed··on Peloton recalling all treadmills after reports of injuries, one death
hundreds of people who didn’t work at tesla were also “sickened by the disease” - was there a difference in the rate of infection between tesla workers and other people in the community?
ghufran_syed··on Google is saving $1B per year as a result of employees working from home
and if inflation is under 2% and the city always increases by the maximum of 2%, then eventually the value of the property tax paid will be infinite, right? How is that analysis useful?
ghufran_syed··on Lambda School agrees to end deceptive educational financing practices
what’s wrong with that? is it better that people can’t develop their human capital, or is it better if people have a variety of ways to finance education to develop their human capital? The status quo is government student loans to finance education, which are generally NOT dischargeable in bankruptcy, AND must still be paid even if if you didn’t graduate, or get a good job afterwards? Isn’t the income-share agreement at least “less bad”? I’d be interested to hear your thoughts on how better to address the problem? If the government was involved, I personally think the best way would be a graduate tax of x%
ghufran_syed··on Apple sued for terminating account with $25k worth of apps and videos
I believe you have to put aside some portion of the cost of the item as a liability. So say you sold a $100 item that cost $70 and the average cost of providing warranty service per item is calculated to be $10. Then you would have to set aside $10 of the $100 as a liability.
ghufran_syed··on UK court clears post office staff convicted due to ‘corrupt data’
doesn’t each side call it’s own expert witnesses? and cross-examine the other sides expert witnesses? Doesn’t seem like it would be hard for the defense’s expert witness to show the possibility of bugs?
ghufran_syed··on Small cities in America’s Mountain West are booming
“fallacy”? Or just an edge case? Are you really claiming that increased electricity prices wouldn’t increase supply of electricity in the long-run?
ghufran_syed··on How fit can you get from just walking?
that’s correct!
← PreviousPage 13 of 29Next →