HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ghufran_syed

2,751 karma · joined August 15, 2014

Apprentice mathematician, programmer, Emergency Medicine doctor in the SF Bay area.

Feel free to get in touch for any reason at all, it's always nice to chat to people first_name.last_name @ gmail.com

meet.hn/city/us-Los-Angeles

Socials:

- linkedin.com/in/ghufransyed

Interests:

Books, Education, Entrepreneurship, Healthcare, Hiking, Mentorship, Outdoor Activities, Science, Space Tech, Startups

---

submissionscomments
ghufran_syed··on Launch HN: Kalshi (YC W19) – A regulated exchange for trading on events
So the guy the administration fired is somehow also the guy to make the current CFTC do what he wants? I’m sure he knows the rules and institutional concerns of the CFTC, but why would he have undue influence over the person who replaced him?
ghufran_syed··on Things I've noticed while visiting the ICU
It’s worth noting that the patient’s condition is not an independent variable with respect to the level of care - the author’s father got moved to step down because they got better…and I’m glad to see that they continued to get better in step down.

A UK judge once talked about balancing the “benefits and burdens of treatment” when making medical decisions, I think that’s a good way to think about it. The benefit of ICU care is less chance of deterioration and death - the burden is the pain, medication effects, discomfort, noise, confusion and many other things described in the article.

It would also be less confusing for the family if the doctors could explain their thought process well, but a) not everybody is good at this, b) not every family member can necessarily even understand or remember this when they are distraught and sleep-deprived, and c) the health system (and patients) don’t want to pay for the time - if they paid double, the doc could spend twice as long with them, as happens with boutique / concierge doctors.

Regarding the ICU doc disregarding the consult recommendations- the ICU described sounds like a “closed “ ICU where the intensivist makes the final decision, vs an “open” icu where a hospitalist will often be the one making the final decision regarding care. Either way, it seems obvious that someone has to coordinate the care and decide what’s important right now and what’s not - there are many tests that a consultant may recommend that won’t improve the chances of the patient improving right now, and can be done later on the med-surg floor of the patient survives that long. Many of the consultant recommendations may also be contradictory, someone has to take responsibility for picking and choosing a course of action

[edit: fixed typo]

ghufran_syed··on Things I've noticed while visiting the ICU
It’s also impossible to infer the logical process from a superficial observation of the tests being done - that would be like inferring the code architecture from what’s displayed on an output device, in rare cases it might be possible, but usually not
ghufran_syed··on Things I've noticed while visiting the ICU
ability to afford the ICU is not relevant at all when the docs decide to put someone there or not, based on my 14 years practicing in the US. Do you have any experience to the contrary? I’m pretty sure that would be illegal in the US
ghufran_syed··on Things I've noticed while visiting the ICU
pretty much every patient in the intensive care unit - that’s kind of what the “intensive” is referring to.

If nothing else, you either take the blood pressure the normal way with a pressure cuff, which is going to wake you up. Or you put an intra arterial catheter, which reads continuously without bothering the patient, but has a small risk of damage to the vessel, infection etc

ghufran_syed··on If you (still) work at Twitter and you can code, head to the HQ now
Plus he could just search for that code in the repo to get the overall context, he probably has access :)
ghufran_syed··on Show HN: Posterity Automations – Get things done from the afterlife
or maybe structure the organization as two parts, an independent trust that acts as a custodian with set aside assets to cover the running costs over the expected lifetime of the covered population , and a technology company that builds markets and operates the service on behalf of the trust (or trusts)?

kind of like how a regulated brokerage, pension fund or insurance company operates. The difficult part is credibly ensuring that the companies will follow the rules when there is no legal big stick hanging over them. Maybe you could have the company buy and issue performance bonds to the policy holders , so if the company disappears, the policy holder or their family gets a lump sum? And have the (independent) company issuing the bonds have the contractual right to display the current pricing of the performance bonds, so if the bond company starts to suspects mismanagement, the price goes up, and that has an immediate effect on the company’s standing (and is therefore likely to deter bad behavior)

ghufran_syed··on Mohammed bin Salman: Saudi leader given US immunity over Khashoggi killing
analogously, would you also agree with the following statement?

“How is the investigation of US president trump by the US congress an independent investigation…?”

ghufran_syed··on Deliveroo is leaving Australia
I wonder if the people who just lost their jobs feel relieved that their exploitation has ended…?
ghufran_syed··on The fall of Sam Bankman-Fried is crypto’s Enron moment
I think reading warren buffet’s letters to shareholders of berkshire hathaway is definitely worth it, there’s a lot of common sense about companies and investing, and kind of proves the feynman quote about “you don’t really understand a topic unless you can explain it to a motivated freshman” (“freshman” = 1st year undergraduate student in th US) . By that standard, Buffet clearly does understand finance, the ones who can’t explain either don’t really understand, or, as you implied, are trying to scam you
ghufran_syed··on What Happened at Alameda Research
right, but if a counter-party ends up losing money because of incorrect assessment of credit or liquidity risk, isn’t that their own responsibility? It’s like when someone can’t pay the mortgage loan a bank lent them - the borrower isn’t performing under the terms of the contract, but part of the payments that borrowers make to the lender is to account for that credit risk - what matters is if the lender has accurately priced this over their portfolio, taking into account how “independent” (or otherwise…) the individual loan risks really are. The liquidity problem is usually when it turns out that the individual loans credit and liquidity risk are NOT independent at times…
ghufran_syed··on New Long March 5B Uncontrolled Reentry Tracked by Aerospace's Experts
the real issue is “what is the probability of human injury or death?” Is it 1% per launch? 0.01% 0.000001%

The area of the earth’s surface occupied by humans (not their stuff, but the people themselves) is around 8000 km^2 (1m^2 per person) out of a total Earth surface area of 510 million km^2. so the probability is around 1.6E-5 or 0.0016% per launch. This obviously doesn’t account for the specific trajectory or population distribution, but gives us a rough order of magnitude.

I would prefer they didn’t do it also, and it definitely loses them international good will - but it’s a pretty low (but non-zero) risk.

[typo corrected]

ghufran_syed··on New Long March 5B Uncontrolled Reentry Tracked by Aerospace's Experts
charitable interpretation: “china” = “chinese government“ in the statement you are responding to.

I try to use the latter form myself when talking about nation state actions to aid people who have trouble translating from one to the other, but it doesn’t seem that hard to figure out in this case. otoh e.g. “the chinese value education highly” is a bit more ambiguous since the statement is true for both the chinese people and the chinese goverment

ghufran_syed··on Level responds to lock picker opening its $330 Apple Store lock in seconds
so this lock plus a hidden camera solves the issue?
ghufran_syed··on Texas solar and wind resources saved consumers nearly $28B over 12 years
Part of the problem of these kind of studies is that the allocation of costs between solar+wind vs fossil is difficult when fossil fuels alone can provide all the energy, but solar+wind are intermittent and have to be backstopped by fossil fuel plants. So if you have to use short-term and therefore expensive fossil fuel plants when solar+wind can't supply enough energy, the additional cost over long-term fossile fuel use should be allocated to the renewable side IMO. If you don't do that, you make renewables look cheaper than their real economic cost.

Another way to think about it is if renewables were saving us a lot of money over fossil fuels, shouldn't our fuel billsbe going down? Most utilities are regulated so they are not allowed to keep excess profits. But even before the spike in oil prices related to Ukraine, the places with a higher proportion of renewables have higher energy costs than those without. So where are these so-called savings?

You could make the alternative argument that we need to use renewables despite their greater cost to help the environment, and in the hope that greater use leads us down the learning curve to lower costs in future, but that's clearly not the argument being made by the posted article

ghufran_syed··on Hyundai investigating child labor in its U.S. supply chain
I have a hobby, thanks. It involves trying to learn more about the world, making reasonable judgements about authenticity of what I hear, and asking in good faith for more evidence when what is provided is insufficient - "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence"
ghufran_syed··on Tesla faces U.S. criminal probe over self-driving claims
My commute is 80 miles each way - I would have left that job long ago if I didn't have "autopilot" reducing the mental effort of the drive.YMMV
ghufran_syed··on Hyundai investigating child labor in its U.S. supply chain
"One actually had a jail cell in the factory used as a disciplinary measure for misbehaving employees."

This seems like a fairly easy thing for the media (or the union) to expose - so is there any evidence this is true? Seems more likely to be union FUD if the union doesn't expose the evidence

ghufran_syed··on My PhD Genealogy
usually it means that the “parent” was a phd supervisor for the “child” researcher who studied for a PhD under that supervisor
ghufran_syed··on Rent going up? One company’s algorithm could be why
Having thought about it a little more, I think we don't like the idea of it because "shelter" is a basic human necessity, not an optional purchase. But a lot of the problem of unaffordable housing has been created by our own policies in the US, this article is a good summary of the issue:

'"Zoning is not a good institution gone bad. … On the contrary, zoning is a mechanism of exclusion designed to inflate property values, slow the pace of new development, segregate cities by race and class, and enshrine the detached single‐ family house as the exclusive urban ideal.” So writes M. Nolan Gray in Arbitrary Lines: How Zoning Broke the American City and How to Fix It.'

https://www.cato.org/regulation/fall-2022/case-abolishing-zo...

ghufran_syed··on Rent going up? One company’s algorithm could be why
This whole discussion seems to miss the point that sellers always want to sell for as much as they can, and buyers always want to pay as little as they can. If the price goes too high, buyer's won't buy. You could get the same effect by having an auction every month for all the units that would be available in the next month - the price would still rise, but then you could blame the other buyers for "overbidding"

The optimal price for a seller is always "whatever the market will bear" - which we don't like the sound of it's a big "evil" corporation. But if any of us as individuals were selling a car for example, and some software would help us maximize the sale price, we would gladly use it - I don't see how the seller has a moral duty to take less money, same as the buyer has no moral duty to pay more

ghufran_syed··on Low Earth Orbit Visualization
No, not until the density of objects in LEO is much higher IMO
ghufran_syed··on SpaceX exploring mission to boost Hubble
you’re right, thanks!
ghufran_syed··on Granting Pardon for the Offense of Simple Possession of Marijuana
i just read the article you linked to - what part of it is “attacking” this? The whole article is basically a rehash of the White house press release (which is fine - it just reports the facts)

Or is the “cesspool” you are describing no longer just consist of people who disagree with you, but has now become people who could disagree with you in the future?

ghufran_syed··on How Americans edit sex out of my writing
This reminds me of Thomas Sowell’s take on writing and editors specifically https://www.tsowell.com/About_Writing.html

The section on editing is about 2/3 of the way through, although the whole thing is a great read.

TLDR: writers don’t like being edited (particularly by bad writers acting as editors)

ghufran_syed··on How Americans edit sex out of my writing
The first example is the following magazine: https://www.nplusonemag.com/ “n+1 is a print and digital magazine of literature, culture, and politics published three times yearly

The second example is the english translation of his novel: https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374720889/thewomenilove

ghufran_syed··on SpaceX exploring mission to boost Hubble
although now I think about it, if starship works, they could capture hubble, return it to earth, fix it and then relaunch it
ghufran_syed··on SpaceX exploring mission to boost Hubble
The polaris dawn mission is planned to use starship, and will aim to do the first private EVA. And the hubble boost mission would also use starship. So it’s definitely a possibility!
ghufran_syed··on Free Markets Don’t Buy Peace
The article uses the example of the US and China - but free trade is one-way with china, china could historically sell freely into the US, but selling into China was always made much harder by the Chinese government, by artificially keeping their currency low, as well as more overt control. This is one (of several) reasons why the top US tech firms dominate everywhere except china.

Maybe there is a useful analogy here: mutual love and respect is a great foundation for a strong long-term relationship between two humans. But one party dominating or abusing the either is not a good basis for such a relationship.

I suspect it's also true as another comment noted, that mutual free trade is necessary but not sufficient. As the old saying goes, "No nation has friends only interests." So if a core national strategic interest (e.g. "Taiwan is part of china" from the Chinese government's point of view) comes into tension with the idea of mutually beneficial trade, it's obvious which one will make way for the other.

ghufran_syed··on HHS purchases $290M worth of drugs for nuclear emergencies
do you think the obama administration depleting the stockpile of N95 masks from 2009-2016 made any difference?

see section 3 “The Atrophy of Vigilance in the Strategic National Stockpile”

https://ethics.harvard.edu/files/center-for-ethics/files/23p...

← PreviousPage 7 of 29Next →