1,366 karma · joined June 5, 2009
If you are a sufficiently high net-worth individual or investing on behalf of a sufficiently large fund, you may be able to make a private deal with one of the investment banks participating in the IPO, but I don't know much about that.
Ensure powder from Amazon[0] gets you to about 205 calories per dollar, which comes to $305/month for the same adult male. I don't buy the 'it's a lot cheaper than Ensure' line.
Another competitor, "Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass" is on Amazon in 12 pound bags for $49. It works out to 408 calories per dollar. Only $154/month for the same example male.
Admittedly Ensure and Serious Mass have different marketing than Soylent (Ensure for old people and Serious Mass for bodybuilders), but if you compare their ingredients you'll find they aren't very different.
[0] http://www.amazon.com/Ensure-Nutrition-Powder-Vanilla-Flavor... [1] http://www.amazon.com/Optimum-Nutrition-Serious-Chocolate-Po...
If I was choosing between multiple offers from startups, the ones using this model would have a huge advantage in my book.
The one (big) issue I can think of is that it does not provide a way to value the common stock. The valuation events in a startup will very often be investors purchasing preferred shares. Preferred shares tend to be worth quite a lot more than common shares (and the gap tends to be larger the younger the company is), so assuming a 1:1 value between them will severely undervalue the common stock grants.
From 1949 to 1989, the stock market averaged 7.2% annually. Saving and investing only $20,000 per year for those years would net you about $5m at the end.
The second-order option is what makes them valuable. Most startups either grow aggressively during those 4 years or they die. If they fail early, you don't have to sacrifice much salary for the now worthless options. If they are doing well, the options are now worth much more yet you are still only sacrificing the same amount of salary for them.
The problem is that the value of this presents a direct conflict between the company and employee. When the value of the unvested options grow, the company can reduce the unvested amount (or fire them if they don't agree)[1] because it will be disproportionate to the value the employee is providing. Note that they don't actually have to go after the unvested shares to recapture this value. They can go after any other form of compensation they are providing since it will still be more than the employee can get elsewhere. Essentially, this means the employee's upside potential is severely limited. Since the value of a share in a startup is based almost entirely on a massively higher future value, this tremendously reduces the value of typical startup vesting options.
If I worked for a startup I'd want straight equity. Find the value of the common stock and pay 10-30% of my salary in common stock. The amount of shares will float as the value of the company does, but this is required in order to keep incentives aligned. I'll pay the tax out of my salary (at ordinary income rates). If the company succeeds, almost the entire value derived from the equity will still be taxed at capital gains rates.
[1] See Zynga, Skype, and probably many others we never hear about.
I think everyone will have relatively large 4k displays eventually, but can't imagine paying 2-3x the cost (for now) for something that is only 60-70". I doubt you could tell the difference for movies/TVs unless they were side by side at that size (or you were sitting a only a few feet away). As a computer monitor though, it's a huge difference I think.
It was recently raised to 20% for people in the highest income tax bracket. AMT of 28% may be used instead in certain circumstances.
You could probably even find someone to sell a partial stake to which would get you set for life and still allow you to ride the bet to the end.