305 karma · joined March 21, 2008
Additionally, your real question does not belong on Hacker News. You're dealing with the problem of how to accomodate the uselessness of mediocre people whom you're obligated to tolerate. The numbing pain of tolerating mediocrity has no place on a startup site.
The kids make me wish I had a flamethrower, but so do people who talk in the office, and the kids are at least cuter than the office people. Except some of the chicks. I sure hope they don't read that. Anyway, working from home is basically awesome, but yeah, you do need human contact, and context for conversation.
actually, it appears to be a good strong argument. I can't say for sure. it's not totally clear to me as I don't know a damn thing about statistics and as far as I remember a median was a type of average. iirc median represents absolute middle; by average you probably mean mean average.
I really have no idea what you're saying, so I have no answer. unless you're making an argument for becoming a serial entrepreneur, since you'll probably have a startup which succeeds sooner or later, if you start young enough. that must be what you're saying, five fails in a row won't matter if number six is a win, and on average, it probably will be.
that's easy to shoot down, though. first of all you might need a lot more than six to beat the averages. second and more importantly: this post was a response to a specific person and that specific person is very probably still in college. I believe he has not created any startups yet. I could be wrong but I am very confident in this particular hunch. his next startup will very probably be his first, so the chance that it will fail remains very very high, since the averages are currently against him.
So no, I don't think that is my mistake at all. I think the mistake would be on the part of anybody attempting to over-generalize, from my specific answer to a specific person, to learn broader lessons for the startup and aspiring-startup communities. but I didn't post this here. that might have been a mistake, but it wasn't mine.
the specific person I'm responding to, OK - he can say "but my other startup might succeed." he'd have me there, maybe. but my reasons for believing his startup will fail, I think it's fair to assume that means his next startup, which will be his first, and could be his only. so yeah, my logic holds.
boo yah.
I appreciate having to work for that, though.
So: I've never been married. And I think your statistics are wrong, especially if you only posted this here and not anywhere else.
Every time, that's all it ever comes down to. Every one of you who ever disagrees with me. You either don't understand how to use what I'm saying, or you don't understand what I'm saying itself in the first place. Sorry to skip it, but it's boring as hell.
Anyway, here's the one thing I wanted to add: PLENTY OF MOTHERFUCKING FISH. In 2000 the millionaires were in porn and the crazy fuckers who do shit that doesn't work were in startups. Some of you remember this. Others of you will have to just trust that we old-timers remember what happened and are not in fact hallucinating or making things up.
In 2009, it's not about porn. Today if you want to be a millionaire, you still don't get in a car and drive down Sandhell Road. But you don't hire a bunch of emo girls from Hawaii to take their clothes off, either. You study strategy constantly, you spend less than four hours working per week, and you put cash in the bank by the truckload.
Boom. You're done.
I haven't made it work for myself yet, but I had Warcraft characters who were living it. It's a great economics sandbox. Everybody thought my characters were twinks because they had crazy gold at low levels. No twinking, just a system. And of course Plenty Of Fish and Tim Ferriss have made it happen in reality in at least two cases. I think the millionaires are paying more attention to that than to VC.
I even see blog posts by monkey motherfuckers who say they believe that the four-hour work week works, but they want to spend more time than that working, because they're passionate about what they do. That's the stupidest goddamn thing anyone could say. The whole point of the four hour work week is it only takes four hours. Take four hours a week out of your busy schedule to do something that actually works, put the money in the bank, and get on with your day. That day, and that busy schedule, can include anything you want it to, including working your ass off on a startup.
OK, come to think of it, if you disagreed with me because of this reason - if you're that particular idiot - then you don't need to study strategy or re-read my post. You need to learn the fundamentals of logic. Discover the difference between necessary connections and incidental connections.
Come to think of it, I encounter that one all the time too, so if you're that particular idiot, sorry for missing your case in the above condescending blanket dismissal. Here's a special condescending blanket dismissal of your very own: go study logic, you idiot.
And fallentimes, it was hard to skip your post because it was at the top of the page. You would have made it a lot easier to respond to if you had numbered your reasons. However, your reasons mostly aren't worth responding to. They don't represent a cogent response to my specific argument; you're mostly just sticking your fingers in your ears and going "lalalala I'm not listening." Your response is a filibuster.
You do have a few specific responses, however, so I'll answer them.
"You understand that your odds of having an enjoyable job paying 200k are roughly the same as owning a profitable small business."
I'm fairly certain that's factually inaccurate, but I can't prove it, and I'm not going to stick around for your answer, so I'll let it go. What I can nail you on is that this is a comparison on uneven criteria: for 200K to win, you have to enjoy it; for a small business to win, it has to turn a profit. Technically a prostitute has a profitable small business, so in this uneven comparison, a prostitute pulls ahead of anyone making 200K, even if they do enjoy it, since you say their chances are equal. You need to set up even comparisons to be fair. I think we can throw out this part of your filibuster, or at least require you to come back with an even comparison.
"You know IPOs or acquisitions aren't required to make a good living.."
and
"You avoid blanket statements like this: All the millionaires were in porn in 2000 and realize that not every "startup rule" or any rule applies. Businesses can be very different from each other."
I think it's obvious I'm only talking about VC-funded startups here. You appear to be suggesting that the way your startup can succeed is by being a different type of startup than the type of startup I'm talking about. That's not refuting my argument. That's merely changing the subject. I apologize for not making it clear that we were only discussing VC-funded startups. However, since this was an answer to a specific person, and a continuation of a specific conversation, let me tell you, as it happens, that's what the conversation was about.
The blanket statement thing is a legitimate dis. You've got me there. But rephrase it: the majority of millionaires were in porn. The core of my argument remains unchallenged. There were people doing a simple thing that worked. If your goal is to be a millionaire, it makes a lot more sense to do something that many millionaires do, which often works, than to do something that few millionaires do, which often fails.
That's why I made the analogy with acting. If you're going to work very hard and the odds are against you, you need to have something which fuels that, and if the only thing that fuels it is a desire for money, that won't be enough to take you to the finish line. Actors come and go in Los Angeles all the time because they think it's going to be easy. I don't get close enough to startups to say this with the confidence of fact, but my intuition is that this is very true of startup founders as well. You need to believe in the technology, or the way you'll change the world, or the corporate culture even. If you set out to become a millionaire using a strategy that very infrequently makes anyone a millionaire, you're going to give up the minute your common sense kicks in.
"You don't care about material possessions."
Again, you're changing the subject. This is a response to a guy who was interested in VC because he wanted to become a millionaire. Obviously, if you're putting forward that somebody who cares about something more than the money might have a better chance, well yeah, that's my point.
Sorry everybody else if there was some devastating, incisive refutation somewhere else on this page. I just don't have the patience, the even-handed temper, or the time.
Remember, Lisp is at least a 50-year language, and Lisp was originally created as a joke or a teaching example or something. The great bearded wonder, the one that Lisp guys make shirts of, Schultz or McCarthy or whatever his name was, only wrote up the spec to make a point, some kind of math thing iirc, and somebody egged him on and they ended up implementing it. But it wasn't that he just had this magic ability to build a great language. He made a thousand other snarky points in his life, and this one just happened to be so well phrased, mathematically, that it trumps all other languages, in the opinion of many people. That's not a one-time stroke of luck in the language design department; it's the results of decades honing his craft as a master of snark.
trying to extract lessons from the design of PHP is like trying to win the lottery by wearing a trucker hat because you saw some dude in a trucker hat win the lottery. there's nothing there! you might as well be reading tea leaves. which is what I said in the rant, but you didn't get the point. you might as well be posting a picture of some tea leaves and then having a discussion about that.
yes a good enough conversationalist can extract something meaningful from anything, and that's the real challenge I was after when I wrote the rant, but if your goal is to write something interesting about what you saw on Hacker News, let me tell you, Hacker News does not make it easy for you by talking about PHP.
hahaha. dude even after I clicked that I had no idea what you were talking about. however, I had to turn off a Greasemonkey script to even find the comments here. I have it set up to automatically block me from seeing whether my posts are on HN or not. if I see them, I read the comments, and get pissed off. so not I'm not still angry but yeah I did get quite mad at the time, whatever it was about.
regarding the whole discussion vs. linkroll thing, I have to say the quality of the discussion is one place where Hacker News still really shines. I have no theory to explain that atm.
it's not contemptuous, although it may seem contemptible. I just did the math, knew the tactic would become infallible over time, and used it when signs indicated it would succeed.
of course this implicitly challenges your statement that the site's the same as it ever was. I actually don't have any proof to back that up. I think it would actually be reallllllllllllllllly hard to quantify. I could say there's a frog in boiling water effect there, but then there's the possibility that HN aka News.YC simply had a bad day yesterday, and if I had chosen another day for my random return, I could have come away with the impression it was improving.
At 1000+ karma, you take off your helmet and guess what you're a chick. If you win three times in a row on impossible mode with perfect karma without getting shot once, using nothing but the annoying gun that takes forever, you take off your armor and guess what you're a hot chick. Then you can play the game again wearing a bikini.
At 2000+ karma, Paul Graham comes to your house, tells you the meaning of life, and makes you a sandwich. It is the best sandwich known to man. Only rich people can make this sandwich.
my Spanish teacher a few years ago told me that the word in Spanish is the same in either case: aburrido. the downside is that most English speakers will assume you mean "a burrito." the upside is that it makes a lot of sense to combine these two words into one thing.
anyway, if your friends annoy you, spend less time with them, and go to places you haven't been before, pursuing whatever interests you have, and see if you meet people.
personally I deal with alienation by telling everyone I know to go to hell and seeing who sticks around anyway. I'm not actually qualified to give anybody advice on this topic, but I'm just reiterating my initial point now.
might as well reiterate my second point. I have the opposite problem: making too many new friends and not having the time to follow through on the friendship. this comes about because I have a lot of interests that I pursue really intensely. if you pursue a lot of interests, you'll meet people. so do that, but without being too intense about it to make any space for new friendships to develop, and you're good.
besides, it just shows how bankrupt passwords are. we use the same mechanism online to protect our bank accounts and our most meaningless babble. that's just trouble waiting to happen.
building a business on that is like a building a house on the San Andreas faultline and then filling it with priceless Ming vases. it might be fun, might look nice, but it's not exactly strategic.
YMMV.
Anyway, in terms of the question, workflow, yes, overwhelming improvements in workflow. You get all the shiny goodies of a consumer GUI OS and all the power-user magic of Unix. I'm much, much faster writing code on my Mac than I was on Windows - better editors, imho, and a much better command line.
In the Ruby community we have the Ruby Quiz. I'm pretty sure that's copied from some other community, I think Perl. Every programming language community has practices of this nature.
It's absurd to suggest that deliberate practice has anything to do with body memory intrinsically. How many times will you write a regular expression in your life? There's no element of repetition there? The literature on deliberate practice cites Mozart, Bobby Fischer, and Bill Gates. Body memory has nothing to do with it.
The feedback comes from sharing with others, as in the Ruby Quiz, or benchmarking your code, or posting it on a blog. Another form of feedback would be seeing if your programs run at all. ;-)
No. The trend in the research is that "natural talent" is a MYTH. It does not exist.
Agree or disagree, I don't care, but as a summary of my post, your comment is inaccurate.
they make the same mistake here that everybody else makes with tagging. if you look at the research on tagging, the big tagging success story was delicious - which leveraged SELF-INTEREST in its tagging system and produced a useful public resource as an emergent byproduct. this is not coincidence! read James Surowiecki. seriously. economics 101 for social software.
leveraging independent self-interest is THE key factor which differentiates the wisdom of crowds from the stupidity of groupthink. "the wisdom of crowds" is really just a reiteration of adam smith's invisible hand. to create an invisible hand effect, you must leverage independent self-interest within a shared context where independent self-interested actions are visible to other independent self-interested agents.
every tagging system that fails to leverage self-interest fails to capture that. you can't just sprinkle magic web 2.0 fairy dust on something and go "Tagging!" if you want delicious results, you have to find out what made delicious work and emulate that. what made delicious work was a fundamental principle of economics. the reason so many sites have useless tags is that their makers are ignoring this fundamental principle. it's cargo cult site design.
similarly, this flagging nonsense flat-out ignores another basic fundamental of economics. what makes it even more insane is that Paul Graham already explained in one of his first blog posts about Bayesian filtering exactly why spam filters should be tuned to an individual's preferences and not to a group's. if you had a bunch of individually-tuned spam filters, you could find a way to leverage that. since you have a group-tuned spam filter, you have nothing but a tragedy of the commons magnet.
anyway, just ranting about why Hacker News should hurry up and cease to exist already.
edit: just for the record I'm responding to Reg's comment. I don't know if that's clear from the UI. it is a non sequitur rant, but it's not a complete non sequitur rant.
Mugsy Bogues.
I can't even read every random piece of stupidity I encounter. Neither this nor the one about New York was worth reading all the way through. I'm a writer, I need to avoid stupidity "for the same reason models avoid cheeseburgers."
I agreed that you were wrong about New York, and I took the effort to conceal my contempt for the post itself because I figured it was the low point and people would move on. Obviously the low point was yet to come!
In either case what's more important is the expression of dissent - people on the site are disagreeing with you. They're trying to launch arrows of criticism but the points are so pathetically blunt it's more a feeble attempt at a public stoning than anything else.
My hope was the dissent might provoke you to work harder. That nonsense about New York, you wouldn't have wasted anyone's time with that in the "Hackers & Painters" days. This site has completely ruined you as a writer, and you used to be pretty fucking good. You too need to avoid stupidity for the same reason models avoid cheeseburgers. I bet you read this ridiculous Eric Sink crap all the way through, every last word. Those braincells are dead now and nothing will bring them back.
You should kill Hacker News. Revenge for your slaughtered neurons. A favor to those of your readers who actually understand the things you write and don't just read them to kill time after lunch when they should be working. Any site of this nature is inherently, inevitably, built into its design, a magnet for the type of jackass who only reads blogs because if they played Warcraft in the office they wouldn't be able to fool themselves. This site is a diseased mutant doomed from birth. Give it some tranquilizer so it dies in peace, but the minute it loses consciousness, take it out back and CUT OFF ITS HEAD.
And before you build the next one, read "The Wisdom Of Crowds." Free votes for everyone is a recipe for groupthink factories.
Also, the thing about my dog? TOTALLY TRUE. My dog was absolutely smarter than this Eric Sink guy. Probably by orders of magnitude. Eric Sink has gills and lives on a diet of algae, pond scum, and moss.
And they're not "essays", dude. They're blog posts. It's a good intention to elevate the discourse, but it won't work, because what really elevates the discourse (or lowers it) is the economics of participation. You can call it anything you want but if it's cheap to publish, cheap to link, and everybody has one, then it'll display a very wide range in quality and maturity, and that's just life.
I don't know what the hell is wrong with people that this economics of participation thing is so obscure. Vote costs nothing but time? Vote becomes expensive for people with no time and cheap for people with nothing but. Supply and demand.
The same thing holds for comments, which is why I made it so personal. I'm going to remember writing it, so you're going to remember reading it. I don't have time for another one.
Kill this fucker. KILL IT.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=7Ynw9RT9coU
All right let me dress up in a suit and monocle to accomodate the distinguished gentleman. I've gone into great detail as to why sites of this nature are all inherently doomed via a flaw in their paradigm.
http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2008/05/summon-monsters-ope...
If my learned colleague shalt consult the appended citation, he will see that my predicated futures have come to trespass, and verily this event doth match the anticipatification in profile.
a business based on SourceSafe.
Easily one of the stupidest things I've ever read. I've seen better logic on the back of cereal boxes. I seriously, sincerely believe that my dog Kaia who recently passed away (RIP) was smarter than the person who wrote this post.