HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gisely

127 karma · joined March 5, 2014

submissionscomments
gisely··on Driverless Hype Collides with Merciless Reality
Geometry inferred from range sensors can certainly provide an additional useful source of information, but it's far from clear that the right approach to controlling a self-driving vehicle is mostly to solve a geometry problem. For example, even if a range sensor can provide a perfect estimate of the location and geometry of pedestrian, how do you predict whether the pedestrian will dart out into the road or stop because they see a car coming. Human drivers have learned from years of (mostly) visual experience observing human behaviors to make reliable predictions about such things. Perhaps machines can too.

Since evolution didn't provide us with our personal lidars, human drivers are an existence proof that it is possible to learn reliable driving performance from vision alone. Which isn't to say that machine learning based on vision alone is already close to human-level or competency or that human-level competency is sufficient for a automated driving system or that sophisticated sensors don't make the problem a bit easier. But I don't know how you can be so confident that vision alone (or primarily) won't be route that eventually succeeds.

gisely··on MacOS System 6, Version 6.0.8: run in browser
Maybe they'll bring it back one in VR/AR.
gisely··on California teacher pension debt overwhelms school budgets
I agree that public sector unions becoming politically active is problematic, but it's problematic is same way that wealthy individuals throwing money into politics is. Wouldn't this better handled through campaign finance law rather than an outright crippling of public sector unions? Teachers shouldn't be allowed to buy politicians, but they I do think they should allowed organize and petition to better their working conditions. If you deprive labor of a voice then only money speaks.
gisely··on California teacher pension debt overwhelms school budgets
Do you really think of teachers as a community of people who try to perpetrate scams on the general public? I'm trying to count on one hand all the teachers I know who are sitting fat the money they bilked from the voters, but I'm just not getting very far. Perhaps a more plausible explanation is that education funding measures reoccur repeatedly because public education is chronically underfunded as a standard budget item?
gisely··on California teacher pension debt overwhelms school budgets
While this quote makes a good point that the Government is not like other employers, I am not sure what exactly is implied about the role collective bargaining for government employees. The government can't serve as neutral party to moderate negotiations with public sector employees because they are themselves are the employer. Does this imply that public sector employees should be allowed to organize and negotiate for their interests? I think not.
gisely··on Complicating the Narratives
Please take a moment to glance as the name of the author before assuming that all voices on the internet are male. Or at least use "they/their" as your default instead of "he/his".

To your point, why does this quote undermine her narrative? She isn't saying she's saw herself as rational and others as emotional. Note that her use of "myself and others" in the quote clearly indicates that she's putting herself in the same boat as her audience rather that separating herself from them.

gisely··on U.S. lawmakers want Google to reconsider links to China's Huawei
We can't help them to learn arithmetic either! They'll raise a generation of killer robot engineers and enslave us ;)
gisely··on U.S. lawmakers want Google to reconsider links to China's Huawei
Even assuming Huawei is wholly controlled entity of the CCP, Google's collaboration with them is for generally peaceful purposes. Obviously, widespread use of Android phones manufactured by Huawei could present a security risk. But peaceful collaboration inherently creates such risks.
gisely··on Scientists plan huge European AI hub to compete with US
The BRAIN initiative came after the Human Brain Project so it would be more accurate to call the BRAIN initiative America's attempt to compete with the European HBP.
gisely··on I Hate the News (2006)
The author argue for something patently false (reading the news never did anyone any good) instead of some likely true but more pedestrian claim (e.g. most of us would be better off if we read news less frequently) with the goal of drawing attention.

Don't we call this clickbait?

gisely··on Jupiter is deep
Not interesting to who? Coincidences can interesting even if they don't point to a causal relationship. I find it interesting that word for Jupiter in Chinese is wood simply because it's an interesting association to make.
gisely··on Mazda hopes to achieve 56% thermal efficiency with gasoline engine
Considering that many countries have announced plans to fully eliminate gas and diesel engine production in less than 25 years (e.g. 2030 for China), I think it's quite unlikely that internal combustion engines will continue to dominate the industry for the next 25 years. Also, there is pretty big irony in the analogy that you make. Obviously, Microsoft moved too slowly to focus on mobile computing and they missed the boat. I'm hopeful that car companies which aren't focusing on EVs today will similarly be left behind in a few years.
gisely··on Whole Foods employees reveal why stores are facing a crisis of food shortages
The article indicates she contacted Whole Foods corporate and they didn't respond. So what exactly is wrong with her coverage? Also, you say you are Whole Foods employee. But are you store employee or a corporate headquarters employee?
gisely··on The De Bruijn-Newman constant is non-negative
I love this story! Both mathematics and pop-culture have an abundance of names and terminology that can make their discussion very foreign to people who haven't encountered the lingo.

I've been thinking about this as a way to understand why many people hate math. I think a lot of people tend to miss that learn math is a lot like learning any other lingo. They assume somehow when they don't understand something it's due to their lack of intelligence rather than simple unfamiliarity with the terms being used. "It is well known that..." gets interpreted as "Even a moron would understand that..." rather than "It is a key piece of cultural knowledge of this domain that...".

Now no one would ever make a statement like "It is well known that Katy Perry is a celebrity" as part of discussing American pop-culture. They'd just laugh at you instead for not knowing who she is. Not sure which way is better.

gisely··on Plastics Pile Up as China Refuses to Take the West’s Recycling
And I'm looking forward to a phase change to a society where 100% waste recycling is the norm. When a society aspires to be much better than it is currently, should we really be surprised that this leads to various forms of hypocrisy? This seems to be the only ecosystem supporting planet in our solar system, so a little over-eager hope about our ability to keep it healthy for a long term future might not be completely irrational.
gisely··on Initial Release of Mozilla’s Open Source Speech Recognition Model and Voice Data
Does it? That would certainly be pretty alarming, but I can't seem to find any evidence that it does. The only relevant article I could find was this one on Gboard on iOS: https://www.macworld.com/article/3070767/ios/googles-gboard-... Seems to suggest that that at least their iOS keyboard doesn't send any data while typing. Could be different on Android, but I didn't find any articles suggesting that they are doing this. Wouldn't put past them to make a quiet change of a policy though.
gisely··on Atom text editor 1.4 released
I've stopped using atom due to horrendous latency issues. Pretty disappointed. Would really love a modern open source text editor, but noticeable lag between pressing a key and having it appear on the screen is a no go.
gisely··on The Problem of the Many
Make sure to enable Cloud To Butt before visiting.
gisely··on Amazon Echo
Doesn't mean the NSA or Chinese equivalent won't figure out how to hack Echo to plant a little piece of stealthware on it that records all conversations of suspects in "terrorism related" investigations. Such stealthware might get detected once or twice (though not often-- it won't be ubiquitous), but such detections will easily covered up by forcing Amazon to announce a rare and obscure firmware bug backstory. Actually, come to think of it, with proper contextual targeting, such stealthware wouldn't even need to send full conversations. Just wait for detection of "the meeting" or "the rally" and boom spend off all the info you need to effectively disrupt pro-democracy rallies in Hong Kong.
gisely··on Ask HN: What are your sources of inspiration and motivation?
This:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eaIvk1cSyG8

I seriously I find that kid's enthusiasm inspirational. Sure, maybe learning to ride a bike is really no big deal, but the euphoria of having truly mastered something new is incredible.

gisely··on Hostile AI: You're soaking in it
I really like your articulation of this. It has struck me for a while now that the people working on friendly AI could have more impact if they invested their energy and intellectual prowess on the real threats to humanity we currently face rather than an amorphous future hypothetical we are ill prepared to understand.

I also like the alternative problem that you posit: what can we do about existing semi-autonomous systems whose functioning is harmful to humanity? However, I don't feel very hopeful about any sort of solutions we might have to these problems. Semi-autonomous systems at societal level have existed for probably nearly as long as as humanity itself. Are there some good examples of such systems that were initially harmful but have been carefully cultivated by humanity to make their effects largely beneficial?

← PreviousPage 3 of 3