HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gitrog

395 karma · joined April 15, 2019

submissionscomments
gitrog··on Parler App delisted from Google Play; Apple threatening same within 24h
Liberals, aka centrists, own most of the major media platforms. Actual leftists (especially radicals) tend to get silenced as much as far-right individuals do. Only "moderate" opinions are marketable on the mainstream media.
gitrog··on Parler App delisted from Google Play; Apple threatening same within 24h
I don't know anything about the WalkAway group, but from your description and nothing else it seems like it shouldn't have been taken down and that it could have been very useful.

But I don't see how Facebook taking down the group is the fault of the Left at large (or in the US). I don't know many serious Leftists who are fond of Facebook, not to mention feel the company represents them.

gitrog··on USA vs. Julian Assange Judgment
I agree with most of what you say. It's just that culture in the US isn't nearly as homogeneous as culture in Japan, and I have my doubts now as to whether the poster in question was talking about US as a whole or the culture (read race) of a specific demographic. Also, your examples here entirely sidestep the subject, which is crime and recidivism, things that are also found in Japan, probably lower than in the US but probably still higher than in Norway.
gitrog··on USA vs. Julian Assange Judgment
Now you're losing me. In what way does "culture" matter? Socioeconomic status has nothing to do with "culture".
gitrog··on USA vs. Julian Assange Judgment
I didn't read too much into his use of "descendants", trying to be charitable in my interpretation. But having read his response to you I'm starting to have second thoughts...
gitrog··on USA vs. Julian Assange Judgment
Hold up. That's a bit of a strawman argument. He didn't say "country full of white people", he specifically mentioned socioeconomic status. Socioeconomic status generally correlates negatively with criminality. There's nothing inherently racist about that statement, it's just stating that:

- desperate people will do desperate things to survive

- oppressed people are bound to lash out

- the poor are powerless against authority

- people in poorer neighbourhoods are prone to overpolicing

- destitute people are more likely to succumb to substance abuse

If he said recidivism or crime rates were higher because the population was black/hispanic/etc, that would obviously be racist.

gitrog··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
What I asked for was an example where BLM is calling for violence. What you've provided was evidence of protests - some violent, some not - in the name of various causes.

What you've now basically claimed, is that none of these protests have any legitimacy - violent or not. What you've explicitly claimed is the notion that police don't disproportionately act violently towards minorities. Why do you say BLM is built on disinformation?

Edit: there is just footage of the Paris protests thrown in there for good measure? Do you even know why people are protesting in Paris right now? Come on, man, I'm willing to look over your sources but don't just throw someone's twitter profile at me, shrug and go: "If you don't believe this then clearly nothing will convince you."

gitrog··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
Would you mind providing an example of that?
gitrog··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
Come on, it's not being censored based solely on the fact that it's false and misleading, it's being censored because it has the potential to incite violence and cause serious social upheaval.
gitrog··on Drone Footage of Arecibo Observatory Collapse
Side note: thank you for mentioning the shortcut keys to skip frames. I did not know that!
gitrog··on Ask HN: Is my preference for RubyOnRails over Laravel justified?
Would you say either framework has much over the other on each of these points (besides point 5 - of course)?

That's kind of more what I'm wondering about.

gitrog··on Engels: The Communist as Hedonist
Surely socialist activists are no closer to having any sort of power now than they did when you were in your twenties?

Also, would you mind to be a bit more specific about who these people are? In my experience Americans aren't particularly good at identifying what constitutes a socialist to the rest of the world.

gitrog··on Looking for Voter Fraud (In Old Elections) with Data Visualization
Also, if it was organised in advance, then what exactly is the problem? This year hasn't exactly been like any before in living memory either...
gitrog··on Looking for Voter Fraud (In Old Elections) with Data Visualization
> And please, kicking out GOP poll watchers (and only GOP poll watchers) and blocking their ability to observe

Could you please provide a source for this?

gitrog··on Ruby on Rails in a week
I 100% agree that Rails is in a good place as a framework, and that that is largely because of a very active and engaging community and devs who take criticisms and opinions in consideration.

I also think that it is generally easy to find answers to things by Googling them and finding blog entries or stackoverflow answers. But honestly, the Rails documentation is absolutely terrible. Be it apidock.com/rails or api.rubyonrails.org, it's just way too sparse. It's funny because the Ruby documentation is great.

gitrog··on Arctic Sea Ice not freezing In October – first time since measurements began
Science is specifically not just using "common sense", what are you talking about?

And no, I don't need to buy into the idea of climate change at all to take the contents of the article at face value.

gitrog··on Arctic Sea Ice not freezing In October – first time since measurements began
I find it absolutely incredible the mental gymnastics you're performing to conclude that your "common sense" take is a more accurate representation of reality than what these scientists are telling us.

> but I don't automatically believe we are all going to die just from that article.

Nowhere in the article does it say that. Nothing about this article is alarmist.

The simple truth is you've already made up your mind about climate change in general, and now you're just looking for tiny crumbs of evidence that researchers are slipping up somewhere, and criticizing anything that doesn't fit your notion of how this should play out.

gitrog··on Arctic Sea Ice not freezing In October – first time since measurements began
https://nsidc.org/news/newsroom/20050801_floatingice.html

Salt water is denser than fresh water. The displacement of the Arctic ice is less than the displacement of the water contained in that ice when it melts. So the sea levels will rise. Though, that's not the only problem...

Think of the Arctic as exactly what it is, a giant ice cube, keeping your drink (or, you know, the world) cool. The smaller the ice cube gets, the smaller its effect on keeping your drink cool. When it's gone, your drink quickly goes to room temperature. It's highly unlikely that we can survive like we currently do without the Arctic. Sure, the ice might come back in 10 000 years or so, not particularly useful to us in the short term though, is it?

And the problem isn't that the Earth goes through natural cycles of cooling and warming, it's that our actions are accelerating the warming of the Earth, meaning we've got even less time to figure out how we as a species would survive the natural heating of the Earth.

gitrog··on Arctic Sea Ice not freezing In October – first time since measurements began
> Meanwhile Antarctic sea ice has trended up over the past 5 decades

https://nsidc.org/cryosphere/seaice/characteristics/differen...

The Antarctic is a physical land mass. The Antarctic sea ice always melts away during the spring/summer. The Antarctic is surrounded by ocean, making precipitation an often occurrence, which funnily enough means that it snows more on the land when ocean temperatures rise slightly, and this snow helps build the seasonal ice around the Antarctic.

In contrast, the Arctic isn't a land mass, it's only ice, and it's mostly surrounded by land, making precipitation a less often occurrence and making the effects of rising ocean temperatures more devastating.

Basically, there's no going back once the Arctic melts, and by the time we see the Antarctic ice receding we'll be in serious trouble.

> Sea ice volume is above 2012 in the Arctic

2012 was an outlier, but sure.

> And Greenland has had massive, earlier than usual gains in ice this year

See the explanation for landmasses above.

> Cheyenne, WY saw record breaking cold this past week > Northern Hemisphere snow mass is nearly 400 Gigatons above average for this time of year

Climate change will have variable effects on local weather around the world. An upward trend in global average temperature doesn't mean everywhere is going to get hotter all the time.

gitrog··on YouTube bans coronavirus vaccine misinformation
I just mean that they should have their work peer reviewed first.
gitrog··on YouTube bans coronavirus vaccine misinformation
I guess we're going off on a tangent here, but then I'm not sure what a person's right to freedom from violent crime actually provides them, if not a systematic process by which they can get justice.
gitrog··on YouTube bans coronavirus vaccine misinformation
> So when they decide what is misinformation they position themselves above public scrutiny.

But aren't Youtube doing this specifically because of pressure from government?

gitrog··on YouTube bans coronavirus vaccine misinformation
> I don't see how your Double Jeopardy example demonstrates 'ranking' of rights.

I was thinking, for example, one person's right to freedom from violent crime over another person's right to not be put on trail again for the same crime.

> I would say that (2) and (3) go further than one. You could say that they are subsets of (1).

Agreed.

gitrog··on YouTube bans coronavirus vaccine misinformation
No one here is advocating strong censorship though, and there is a massive chasm between banning specific topics during a pandemic and having generally strong censorship.

This slippery slope is fallacious.

gitrog··on YouTube bans coronavirus vaccine misinformation
> YouTube is almost certainly going to be banning literal doctors with actual PHDs from expressing scientific opinions which later turn out to be substantiated.

To be fair, Youtube shouldn't be the platform where doctors express their scientific opinion or try to win over support.

gitrog··on YouTube bans coronavirus vaccine misinformation
> 1) Some rights are more important than others.

If you've been found not guilty of a crime in the US and admit to it afterward, you cannot be prosecuted again by protection of Double Jeopardy, correct?

Is that not the same thing as saying some rights are more important than others?

And is (2) and (3) not just variations on (1)?

gitrog··on The Making of “My Octopus Teacher“
By that logic anyone disagreeing with a comment is guilty of some "nth level of negativity porn".

He admits to not being able to be a good father to his son. No one mentioned bills and groceries - that is not what raising a teenager entails - that's something you added to fit your narrative. It's a simple, specific criticism that is half addressed in the film and for some people not sufficiently resolved.

It's hardly assuming the worst about him.

gitrog··on The Making of “My Octopus Teacher“
I had exactly the same feeling. I didn't sympathise with the guy's situation either. South Africa has massive inequality problems and this guy is living the life in one of the most expensive places you can live (easily rivaling European cities) and he abandons his family over writer's block?!

All of that also made me question the entire narrative of the friendship with the octopus. I'm sure it's possible, but it's also easy to edit things to fit a narrative if you're a documentary film maker. I'm probably just being cynical though...

gitrog··on Emacs is special regarding UIs
I would say it's more like driving a race car but - provided you use one of the many configurations or frameworks ala Spacemacs/Doom out there - having the gears automated by the car's system.

An experienced racer would be much better off with driving in manual, but for a beginner or someone never expecting to push the car to its limits the automated gears are plenty good enough.

gitrog··on Feds say Yale discriminates against Asian, white applicants
A published study doesn't make the theory mainstream. This study is heavily criticised in the field, for p-hacking amongst other things. Also their conclusion is about IQ, which itself isn't seen in the mainstream as an indication of general intelligence, so they're really reaching from the get go. You have to have a serious agenda to read this paper and sincerely think the conclusion correct...
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →