HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gits1225

2,840 karma · joined May 12, 2012

  Name: Aby James (എബി ജയിംസ്)
  Email: aj@abyjames.com
submissionscomments
gits1225··on When Haskell Is Not faster than C
>>"Precisely. The whole "my language is better" argument is completely void."

You say later that the difference is "only on how you will do it". If you stop to think for a second, you come to realise that syntax, abstractions and the big elephant in the room: how "tuned" a language is for the myriad of computing platforms/operating systems/domains (scientific, business, web) -among many other factors- play a HUGE part in how you can develop software and how performant it can/will be. So languages does matter.

>>"Note that there is no theoretical bound preventing an Haskell compiler to generate code equally fast than the one of a C compiler for any program."

But it won't, because at the end of the day, a machine has to execute the programs written in a language and C was designed for a machine with certain characteristics in mind while Haskell/Lisp and other higher level languages are an exploration in abstractions.

When Abelson & Sussman says: "Programs must be written for people to read, and only incidentally for machines to execute.", there is an implicit understanding that trade-offs are being made and its not the same as C and other lower level programming languages. Until a machine appears that isn't limited by the constrains of the present, making trade-offs is inevitable and that too, does matter.

@jacquesm: Great write-up. Enjoyed every line of it.

P.S: I make no distinction between a language and its implementation here.

gits1225··on Our Django Book is Launched
Just what pydanny said above, only that I noticed it a little late.
gits1225··on Our Django Book is Launched
You misunderstood me. I wasn't asking for a free copy or that you shouldn't charge for it.
gits1225··on Our Django Book is Launched
It always puts a bad taste in my mouth when information/knowledge is locked behind a pay-wall. It frustrates me when I think that someone somewhere is getting turned down from what they want to learn from because they had no money to pay for it or doesn't have the means to pay for it. I know the authors should profit but why can't they do something like https://mitpress.mit.edu/sicp/ or http://debian-handbook.info/ or http://www.aosabook.org/en/index.html or http://philip.greenspun.com/seia/ or http://learncodethehardway.org/ or http://10print.org/ etc etc etc... Aren't the authors of these books making money? Or is it the fear that people just won't pay for it if its also free to download even if they can?

EDIT: I didn't 'click-through' to the book's original site because there was no mention that the book is also available to those who can't afford on this announcing page. My mistake.

Another great resource: http://gettingstartedwithdjango.com/ and videos here: http://gettingstartedwithdjango.com/pages/gigantuan/

gits1225··on John Carmack's comment on Doom 3's code style
Bartosz Milewski's blog: http://bartoszmilewski.com/
gits1225··on Getting Started With Clojure
"When I was going through all this myself a few months back, there was a weird period of a good few weeks when I had basically no mental map of the Clojure ecosystem and had no idea how to assemble one."

One of the things you can do when learning something new is to hop onto IRC and join a channel related to the topic. I almost always have got a good overview of things just by asking around what I am supposed to know.

gits1225··on How Harvard's CS50 Renewed My Hope For Online Education
The difference between CS50 and others is that CS50 gives you a similar experience of taking a class in flesh and blood, while offering all the flexibility of online education; in other courses, it feels like the professors are held at gun point and are asked to teach the material in 10-15 mins intervals.

It is awkward to both the teacher and the student, because teaching with a camera up so close to one's face is so, and just because Salman Khan (Khan Academy) did so, doesn't mean every Udacity, edx, and Coursera should. Remember that in the beginning, Salman Khan intended those videos for his cousins.

Just look at SEE[1], to see how effective a traditional class room style teaching can be. SICP[2], SEE and CS50 are hands down the best lectures I ever had the pleasure to learn from.

[1] http://see.stanford.edu/see/courses.aspx

[2] http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/classes/6.001/abelson-sussma...

gits1225··on Python for Beginners
PyCon India and foss.in are good events to meet passionate developers. Likewise, local developer meetups (like Bangpypers; Banglore python group), are another great venues.

``'number of coders in java' > 'number of coders in python'

Well, that is a no-brainer, since its the most popular language taught in colleges with C++ a close second. That said, there are a _lot_ of smarties coming out of colleges and its just a matter of polishing the diamonds in the rough before they get 'lured in' by low paying IT companies. I don't see why Joel Spolsky's tactic of 'snatching' promising young talents before even hitting their final year in college won't work; albeit a little work from your part.

gits1225··on FXT: a library of algorithms
Check:

http://www.algosort.com/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_algorithms

http://xlinux.nist.gov/dads/

gits1225··on Ask HN: What unknown technical blogs or sites do you read?
My recent subscription: http://bartoszmilewski.com/ The blog in one sentence: Think in Haskell, code in C++ & multi-core to spice it all up.
gits1225··on Stroustrup on next-gen C++: I didn't want to let go of my baby
C++ Primer, 5th Edition, by Stanley B. Lippman, Josée LaJoie, Barbara E. Moo: https://www.informit.com/store/c-plus-plus-primer-9780321714... and http://isocpp.org/
gits1225··on Commanding your text editor
I have tried watching a couple of peepcode videos, but at some point, sooner or later, I invariably fall to sleep no matter how interesting the topic they present is. Somehow the videos feel lifeless and monotonous. Maybe its just me, but thats been my experience.
gits1225··on [dead]
For comparison: http://www.redhat.com/. Just saying.
gits1225··on Linux desktop user experience
Any font that doesn't ship with the default install needs some amount of tweaking to "get right". That said, like mentioned before, fonts in the Ubuntu family works well in all areas. Personally, I have been alternating between Ubuntu mono (bold) and terminus for a while now on the terminal and Ubuntu Regular as the system font.
gits1225··on Linux desktop user experience
The reason I suggest CentOS (or Debian) is because it met the needs of a large majority of people I dealt with. Also remember that a lot of these people work in offices and having printers (or java) set-up correctly is integral to their work, which I haven't had any problems setting up thus far (or directing people "How to" on the phone) in CentOS. Every single one of 'em has then installed the same distribution they use at work at home as well.

One of the reasons why this all works really well is that, these distributions are installed on hardware which is relatively old (2-3 years), which is the case for the majority. Distributions need to realise that when an operating system is installed, it is supposed to run without issues for a very very long time.

P.S: I did test openSUSE (12.1), but, it had its own share of issues that I don't recommend it to newbies.

gits1225··on Google's Go Programming Language Grows Up: Now What?
Also this quote explains the design of Go (even thou he said it in the context of Plan9/Inferno)[1]

"Thompson. The aggressive use of a small number of abstractions is, I think, the direct result of a very small number of people who interact closely during the implementation. It's not a committee where everyone is trying to introduce their favorite thing. Essentially, if you have a technical argument or question, you have to sway two or three other people who are very savvy. They know what is going on, and you can't put anything over on them."

Rob Pike says the same thing. "All three of us need to be convinced for a feature to make it into the language"

[1] http://genius.cat-v.org/ken-thompson/interviews/unix-and-bey...

gits1225··on Unix and Beyond: An Interview with Ken Thompson
"My experience and some of my friends' experience is that Linux is quite unreliable."

I don't think any software is "reliable". Well tested/battle hardened? Yes. Reliable? No.

gits1225··on A Generation Lost in the Bazaar & The Design of Design
I didn't see it on the front page when I was submitting, and HN link checker didn't catch it since the url is different.
gits1225··on A Generation Lost in the Bazaar
>>Later, he emphasizes that they didn't even look at each others' code:

I remembering reading somewhere (Dennis Ritchie's C History article?) that once they both programmed a solution without consulting each other, and later when they read it, the solution was exactly the same, even down to the variables' name.

Power of C? Two people who thought alike?

>>KT: [Shaking head] We were all pretty good coders.

Which the modern world doesn't have enough of. Demand is so high that quality of supply doesn't matter, just enough to satiate the demand; which is in stark contrast to the early days, when computer science was a research field only privy to scientists and later to hackers and crackers. When it went mainstream, and grew to an industry, its no wonder that it acquired all that which comes with it.

gits1225··on So you want to learn to code
First - how old are you? If you're more than 8 or 9 and aren't already writing code, there's a good chance you're not a 'hard core hacker'

How daft.

gits1225··on When Art, Apple and the Secret Service Collide: 'People Staring at Computers'
The melancholic nature of the article and the easy going attitude of the author really made the article different and original for me. I really liked reading and thinking about the points raised in it. But really, all it was, was revealing the one obvious aspect of human nature: how we react to objects. Here its a computer.

When someone had your password, it’s not just that they could access any information, but that they could become you.

When people send you an email, there is an expectation of privacy.

But most of the emails were from reporters and journalists. I wrote a form response and started replying to everyone, letting them know the EFF had encouraged me not to talk about it. This was a really difficult moment. I felt like everything was arranged in a way to keep discussion limited, to keep people working against each other instead of working together.

Hundreds and hundreds of comments, on dozens of major blogs. I’m no stranger to publicity, but this was on a completely different scale. Everyone had an opinion and wanted to argue with each other. Yet I had to remain completely silent.

The above quotes when left to ponder are really profound. Pointing the easy to notice things are indeed the easy to ignore.

In the other comments, I started to notice a trend: people were trying to establish definitions. They were arguing about ethics and ontology (even though no one called it that). The project hit a nerve that made people uncomfortable enough that they had to share their opinions and argue their positions. If you’re at school studying art, philosophy, or politics, this isn’t a big deal. These discussions happen over lunch, or in the hallways. But this was happening on the internet.

Everything and anything happens on the internet, and if there is no identity attached to the actions, the truer they become of the person, than in real life where people are bound to act by social commonsense.

With “People Staring at Computers,” I saw something new: a massive audience engaged in a collective decision-making about the culture they wanted to adopt, in realtime, via comment threads strewn across blog posts and news articles

Its not new. It started right when internet started. If some other way to mass communicate was possible before, it would have started then as well.

gits1225··on Interview with Alan Kay
Yes it was "Internet by Brilliant minds, Web by Amateurs, Browser a lament - Alan Kay"
gits1225··on Interview with Alan Kay
I do agree on 'cheap' sensational titles, but I don't think mine was. I think it was a better title more in-line to what Alan Kay emphasized in the article, giving it a bit of context to interest someone to read a great interview, instead of just a generic 'Click Here' like the previous submitter's, leading people to think it was not worth 'clicking through'.
gits1225··on Interview with Alan Kay
Why is the title of the post renamed? Should the titles be boring and dry instead of being informative one line summary of the article that people may find interesting enough to read it?

Look what happened to the previous submission of the same article here on HN: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4224966. Such a good article went unnoticed because the title was plain unattractive.

Can we have a little bit of 'submitters freedom' here?

P.S: Original title was: "Internet by Brilliant minds, Web by Amateurs, Browser a lament"

gits1225··on The True Problem With PHP
http://hashphp.org/: What should I know about building a website? is an amazing resource. Thanks a lot.
gits1225··on Rob Pike: "Current Unix tools are weakened by the built-in concept of a line"
I am using emacs and doing the same things in acme at the moment for around 2 weeks now. Its just that, whenever I need to type I have to disconnect from the mouse and whenever I need to do I have to disconnect from the keyboard. Also when using the mouse I miss the precision with which I can navigate to different parts of the screen real quick and efficiently. There is always a delay and re-focus to get to the target
gits1225··on Rob Pike: "Current Unix tools are weakened by the built-in concept of a line"
offtopic:

sam(and acme) sounds like an interesting method at first, but when you try it out, its really weird and slow to get stuff done. Its because for me, mouse is really inferior to keyboard to do the majority of the tasks.

This is an except from coders at work:

Seibel: Is there anything you would have done differently about learning to program? Do you have any regrets about the sort of path you took or do you wish you had done anything earlier?

Thompson: Oh, sure, sure. In high school I wish I’d taken typing. I suffer from poor typing yet today, but who knew. I didn’t plan anything or do anything. I have no discipline. I did what I wanted to do next, period, all the time. If I had some foresight or planning or something, there are things, like typing, I would have done when I had the chance. I would have taken some deeper math because certainly I’ve run across things where I have to get help for math. So yeah, there are little things like that. But if I went back and had to do it over I’m sure that I just wouldn’t have it in me to do anything differently. Basically I planned nothing and I just took the next step. And if I had to do it over again, I’d just have taken the next step again.

It would be interesting to know if Ken Thompson is using sam because he is a slow typist and hence doing stuff the sam way (mouse oriented) boosts his productivity or simply because he likes using sam.

gits1225··on Why Django Sucks

  "You sound institutionalized."
  I'm not sure what that even means
mattdeboard is referring to Red's dialogue from The Shawshank Redemption: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TsiFanovOSI
gits1225··on Java Leads Programming Language Popularity, by books sold?
It's not a typo. http://shop.oreilly.com/product/9780596527358.do
gits1225··on Ask HN: Favorite HN threads of all time
I was so looking for that post frantically for the past couple of days but it just kept eluding me. Thanks a lot for posting it.

It makes me wonder how effective a well implemented human powered search engine could be. Its kinda overwhelming just thinking about it.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →