HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gjm11

14,641 karma · joined August 5, 2008

http://www.mccaughan.org.uk/g/

gareth full_stop mccaughan at_sign pobox.com

submissionscomments
gjm11··on Where did all the public bathrooms go?
Pretty much all of that is false.

The rules I'm expected to follow based on the bottom quintile are generally rules that are no trouble for me to follow.

The taxes I pay support way more than just the bottom quintile. I'm actually in the UK but I guess you're in the US, so here's a rough breakdown based on this infographic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending_in_the_Uni....

Much the biggest chunk of US federal spending is Social Security, the great majority of which is pensions. Pensioners are very variable but they're mostly not in the bottom quintile. Then "nondefense discretionary" spending which is a mixed bag but again is mostly not bottom quintile. After that comes Medicare which again is mostly pensioners. Then defense, which isn't really "to support" any particular subset of the population. Then Medicaid, a lot of which is for poorer people, so I'll give you that one. Then "other" which from the description in the chart is mostly not bottom quintile. Then income security programs, which is probably mostly bottom quintile. If we say that all of Medicaid and income security are "bottom quintile", 10% each of Social Security and Medicare, and 20% each of "nondefense discretionary" and "other", go to support the bottom quintile -- which I think is probably all on the generous side -- then that comes to about $1.56T out of $6.1T of spending, or out of $5.5T if you prefer not to count debt servicing.

The greatest risks to my life and property are from disease (for my life), wear and tear plus accident (for my physical property), and stock market instability (for my investments). None of those things has much to do with the bottom quintile.

In the US, homicides are about 0.02% of deaths, and most of those happen to people within that bottom quintile you evidently resent so much.

The dearth of comfortable public spaces is because you have to allow the bottom quintile to be there and not-bottom-quintile people like you want to make those spaces as unwelcoming to them as possible even at the cost of making them less comfortable for everyone. And also because your society has failed to provide the bottom quintile with better places for the things you don't like them doing than those public spaces.

It may well be true that zoning laws are developed for fear of the bottom quintile. You might want to consider the possibility that the fear is as much of a problem there as the bottom quintile itself.

gjm11··on Dynamical dark energy and the week that broke cosmology
A couple of other remarks.

1. In the first of those cases, with the biased coin, suppose that in the second phase you flip it _thousands_ of times and it comes up with N+1 heads and N tails. Then the statistical significance of the overall bias can become arbitrarily small, and if you had a concrete alternate hypothesis along the lines of "at least 5% more likely to come up H than T" the overall evidence can be extremely strong evidence against that.

2. In the second case, with the coloured balls, note that we can readily make each bit of evidence for A > B > C much stronger than the 2 : 1 : 0 above; the bag in hypothesis B could be, say, 1% red, 1% blue, 98% green. We'd still end up with B being the only one of our viable possibilities after both observations.

3. There are real-world situations with the sort of structure we see in that second case. Suppose hypothesis A is "there is a god who not infrequently works miracles", hypothesis B is "there are no gods, but people not infrequently fabricate evidence of miracles", and hypothesis C is "nothing at all miraculous-looking ever happens". Then you see what looks like a convincing case of evidence for one god, and then what looks like a convincing case of evidence for a different one. The two gods are from different religions each of which adamantly insists that the other one is pure invention.

4. The real world is never as neat as these examples. E.g., in the gods scenario you also need to consider possibilities like "actually both those religions have some truth to them, and rivalry between their gods is why each one's followers insist that the other religion is completely imaginary" and "there is a miracle-working god, but also followers of other gods fabricate miracles" and "there are no gods and very little fabrication, but sometimes incredibly unlikely things happen just by chance" and "there are no gods but there are super-advanced aliens who enjoy messing with us" and so forth. Even in the balls-from-bags scenario -- if it happens in the real world rather than in a textbook -- you have to consider things like "I was mistaken about what ball I picked the first time" and "actually sometimes one blue ball gets into a big bag of red balls by accident" and so forth.

(A lot of the most important work in, e.g., science consists not of testing rival hypotheses but of figuring out viable hypotheses to test.)

gjm11··on Dynamical dark energy and the week that broke cosmology
It is not true that another finding in the same direction should always increase the statistical significance.

Suppose you've got a coin; null hypothesis is that it comes up heads and tails equally often. I flip the coin 5 times and get heads every time. Probability of at least this many heads on the null hypothesis is 1/32. Now I flip the coin another 9 times and get 5 heads / 4 tails: evidence in the same direction. Between the two experiments I have 10 heads / 4 tails. Probability of at least this many heads on the null hypothesis is [(14 choose 0) + ... + (14 choose 4)] / 2^14 ~= 0.09, much bigger than 1/32.

There are also other circumstances in which even additional strong evidence for X can reduce the probability of X.

Suppose I have three hypotheses A,B,C which initially I think are all equally likely. Then two things happen that both have probability 1/2 if A is true, probability 1/4 if B is true, and probability 0 if C is true. After one of them, I should think A is true with probability 2/3. After both, I should be more confident, right?

Nope. Suppose e.g. what I'm doing is pulling balls out of a bag. Hypothesis A is "I have either a bag of red balls or a bag of blue balls, with equal probability". Hypothesis B is "I have a bag with 25% red balls, 25% blue balls, and 50% green balls". Hypothesis C is "I have a bag containing only green balls".

So I pull out a ball from the bag and it's red. That happens half the time in scenario A, 1/4 the time in scenario B, and never in scenario C, like I claimed.

I put the ball back and shake things up so I'm starting afresh, and pull out another ball. This one's blue. Again: half the time in scenario A, 1/4 the time in scenario B, never in scenario C.

But those two things can't ever both happen in scenario A, because in that scenario I have a monochromatic bag. They can both happen in scenario B. And of course neither of them can happen in scenario C.

So I got a result that (on its own) was evidence for A over the other two hypotheses, and then another result that (on its own) was evidence for A over the other two hypotheses, and the effect of both together is that I know A is false and B is true.

gjm11··on Guess which of these LLM outputs is watermarked
I don't think anyone is, or plans to be, watermarking AI-generated code as opposed to text.

[EDITED to add:] As pointed out by a helpful comment below, I was misremembering: Anthropic do apply their watermarking to code, they just say that it will have negligible impact on the actual code (because there's generally less scope for variation in that) but e.g. it will have its usual effect on comments in the code.

gjm11··on Principia Mathematica is modern and insightful
> I got downvoted to -4 points

> You burned me at the stake like a witch for heresy.

I think you should try to get a better sense of proportion.

Also:

> my simple point that although the Principia Mathematica tried to do the impossible, there is still utility for its value as a programming self-teaching resource

I don't know what your original intention actually was, but your comment read to me very much as (1) implying that the OP was claiming that PM is useful for making people into better Typescript programmers (which OP very much does not claim) and (2) making fun of the OP for making such a claim while (3) calling the enterprise of which PM was a part "childish".

All of which seems to me like rather the sort of thing that does deserve downvoting to -4, though for what it's worth I didn't downvote you.

gjm11··on Principia Mathematica is modern and insightful
The version of this story I heard is in Littlewood's "A Mathematician's Miscellany"[1] and it's a sigma rather than an x. But he tells it as something that happened specifically to him -- he wrote a memo that ended with "thus sigma should be made as small as possible", and that bit was absent but there was in its place a very very tiny sigma. Unless he's outright lying, I think this one actually happened!

[1] The more recent edition is titled "Littlewood's Miscellany"; I am fairly sure this story is in both the older and the newer version.

gjm11··on The Claudyssey: A line-for-line translation of Homer's Odyssey by Claude Fable 5
I agree that "tell me the man" feels weird. I still don't see what's wrong with "of many turnings". To me, "driven far journeys" is a bit worse than "tell me the man" (and quite similar in kind), and much worse than "of many turnings". But maybe I just have terrible taste.

(I'm glad to hear that "secret" wasn't real. It seemed quite inexplicable to me.)

gjm11··on The Claudyssey: A line-for-line translation of Homer's Odyssey by Claude Fable 5
You're making two separable criticisms: (1) that Fable's translation is a mere "mishmash of Lattimore and Fagles" and (2) that it's a crappy one.

I'm not seeing, from what you quote, how this is more "mishmash" than "translation of the same underlying text as them".

As for whether it's crappy, that's a pretty subjective matter; for what little it's worth "of many turnings" doesn't seem particularly dreck-y to me; it seems in fact a rather literal rendering of "polytropos" and -- as Fable's footnote says -- one that maintains some of the ambiguity between "one whose paths have turned many ways" and "one with a twisty-turny sort of disposition". I am no scholar of ancient Greek and there's no reason why anyone should pay particular regard to my tastes on this; but what is asserted without evidence may be controverted without evidence.

(The one thing in those three lines that I would describe as dreck is "driven far journeys" which to me seems barely grammatical. "Secret" seems like a weird choice, too.)

gjm11··on A Surveillance Treaty in Disguise: Canada Signs UN Cybercrime Convention
No. (I would try to explain how my meaning differs from what you thought I meant, but I am quite unable to figure out what you thought I meant.)
gjm11··on How to Do Great Work (2023)
There are and have been lots of people doing great work without generating large investment returns, because they aren't doing the kind of work that generates large investment returns at all.

Bach, Mozart, Beethoven. Newton, Gauss, Euler. Dante, Shakespeare, Goethe. Faraday, Darwin, Einstein.

(If you're looking for greatness on their scale, then of course the number will be "not that large" because work that great is very rare. But there are plenty of artists and scientists and whatnot achieving lesser levels of greatness and most of them are not getting large investment returns.)

gjm11··on RipGrep musl binaries occasionally segfault during very-large searches
Unfortunately the prompt may have been something like "investigate this bug and file an issue when you think you understand what's going on". The "better just to share the prompt" heuristic falls down when the actual underlying intellectual work was also done by the machine.

(Feel free to pretend that I used some phrase other than "intellectual work" if you dislike seeing it used to describe something done by AI.)

gjm11··on A Surveillance Treaty in Disguise: Canada Signs UN Cybercrime Convention
I'm not sure whether your "adversary determined to reclaim its own lands" is Europe's adversary (Russia, wanting to take Ukraine) or Canada's adversary (the United States, wanting to take Canada) but in neither case does "its own lands" seem like a reasonable description of what it is they want.

And from where I'm sitting (in the UK, so I don't have a front-seat view of any of this) it seems as if "it's pissed off its largest trading partner" is pretty inaccurate too: isn't it much more the case (1) that the US picked pretty much all the fights here and (2) that it's largely Donald Trump who's pissed off with Canada, and most US individuals and institutions think Canada is perfectly OK? Mr Trump isn't dictator of the United States yet, and pissing him off is not the same thing as pissing off the US.

gjm11··on The Maxwell Conjecture Is False (GPT 5.6 Sol)
I'm not sure that's right. The conjecture is (claimed to be, by the people who explicitly made it) simply a reformulation of a claim made by Maxwell in his "Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism" of 1873.
gjm11··on Steganographic Language Output Process Encoding
This seems very closely related to this: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2510.20075 which describes how you can use LLMs to hide a piece of text in another text of (typically approximately) the same length.

Here's what that does: Take your first piece of text and feed it into an LLM in predict-the-next-token mode, starting in some known initial state. For each token, note down the actual next token's position in the list of predicted next tokens, ordered by probability. Now get the LLM into a different initial state, e.g. by giving it some text predisposing it to predict text about a particular topic. And now repeat the following: look at the list of predicted next tokens, pick the one whose position in the list is the same as that of the corresponding token in the original input, output that token.

You'll typically get a coherent output, containing the same number of tokens as your original text, on (at least initially) whatever topic your initial input was about, from which you can reconstruct the original text.

The steganography scheme proposed here is basically the second half of this without the first, I think.

It's also reminiscent of Scott Aaronson's LLM-output-watermarking scheme. Searching for stuff about this I found https://www.scottaaronson.com/talks/watermark-iclr.pptx which, when I try to view it in LibreOffice, seems to be missing a lot of content; I suspect this is a LibreOffice problem or even a my-installation-of-LibreOffice problem. There's also a talk he gave, which you can find at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Kx9jbSMZqA .

gjm11··on Towards a Theory of Bugs: The Ruliology of the Unexpected
Most of Wolfram's discussion of "bugs" is not about the following situation:

You want a program that does X. So you think about what a program that does X should look like, and write a program that does what you think should produce result X, but maybe you made some mistakes.

but about the following, to my mind completely different, situation:

You want a program that does X. So you write a bunch of random short programs and after a while you find one that looks on small examples as if it's doing X. You use that one, but maybe actually it doesn't always work.

The key difference here is that in the first case you try to make there not be bugs by understanding what the program is doing and in the second you try to make there not be bugs by looking at the program's output.

(Perhaps some super-extreme practitioners of test-driven development might argue for something like the latter. Perhaps some AI-driven programming is uncomfortably close to it. But it's not, generally, how people have produced and debugged software.)

Wolfram kinda tries to justify this perspective by saying:

"Fundamentally the only way to make sure a program will always do what you want is to understand everything it can do. But there’s a kind of paradox implicit in that: if you can really understand everything your program can do that basically means the program is doing something computationally reducible, and you probably in the end didn’t actually need to run the program with all its steps to get the result you wanted."

but I think this is silly (and suspect it's the result of Wolfram trying to shoehorn his pet notion of "computational (ir)reducibility" into places where it brings no actual insight). It happens all the time that you write a program that (at least in principle) you understand completely, but that you don't know a much cheaper way to do it.

gjm11··on Worse on Purpose
> This is not really worse on purpose. They made a product so good no one ever bought it again and they couldn't afford to keep making immortal products.

I don't understand how "their first product was too good, so they had to start making worse ones" isn't "worse on purpose". It seems like a paradigm case of "worse on purpose" to me. What am I missing?

gjm11··on Scanning for Pangram Errors
On the other hand, see https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/i-wouldnt-say-pangram-i... where Freddie deBoer shows some instances where Pangram is definitely giving wrong or misleading results.

(Somewhat-plausible-to-me explanation: It's looking for various stylistic features; older writing very rarely has the most AI-like features, or perhaps almost always has some non-AI-like features that outweigh whatever signs of AI-ness might be there. Present-day writers are more likely to get wrongly flagged as AI.)

gjm11··on Terence Tao's ChatGPT conversation about the Jacobian Conjecture counterexample
Apologies if I am simply missing a joke (which I think is true with p~=0.3), but:

At least some of these are definitely real things. For instance: "BGP" is the Boundary Gateway Protocol. "Lamport OTS" is a one-time digital signature scheme due to Leslie Lamport. k8s is an abbreviation for a piece of software called Kubernetes.

gjm11··on How to read more books
I think I might have trouble with that approach for "harder/denser non-fiction" because for such reading I might well want to stop and think from time to time -- maybe there's an argument I'm not convinced by and want to reason through step by step, maybe there's a mathematical calculation with a non-obvious step, maybe there's a clever observation that I want to think about the implications of, maybe I've just realised that I lost focus and haven't really taken in the last page, etc. -- and I'd expect the extra friction of pausing and restarting the audiobook to get in the way a bit.

I assume you don't find that; is that because you very rarely feel the need to stop and think, or because it turns out that doing so isn't significantly impeded by having an audiobook playing?

(More generally I'd expect that sort of book to have easier and harder bits and I'd likely want to read them at different speeds. But I could believe that the advantages of doing this are enough to make up for it being harder to do that.)

Disclaimer: I basically never listen to audiobooks, so my guesses at what might or might not work well for me are (1) sheer guesswork and (2) not very interesting except in so far as other people have the same sort of experience I'm guessing I would.

gjm11··on Grok 4.5
Oh, come on.

Some things require skill to use most effectively. It's fair enough to consider this a failure if the thing in question is "making a phone call", but when it's something like "getting an AI system to do a good job for you" this is not a reasonable thing to make fun of it for.

It's like...

"I wrote a program, and it segfaulted instead of printing out a list of prime numbers." "Yeah, look, you've got an off-by-one error here." "You mean I'm holding it wrong?"

"I'm trying to play the violin and it's making horrible noises." "You want to change your grip on the bow like this, and be more careful in where you put your fingers on the strings to get the right notes, and there's a whole art to how you adjust the speed and pressure and so forth to make it sound good." "You mean, I'm holding it wrong?"

"I'm managing a team, and one of the people on the team doesn't always do the things I tell her to." "Maybe you should sit down with her and see whether somehow your explanations of what you want aren't getting across, or whether she feels like you aren't treating her with the respect and dignity she deserves, or whether she's bored with the work, or etc. etc. etc." "You mean, I'm holding it wrong?"

Yes. In the second case you're literally holding it wrong. Some things don't work as well when you hold them wrong and it's worth some effort to learn to hold them right.

I hold no particular brief for Anthropic. I don't know whether Fable is really much better than Opus or whether the alleged improvements are all just pareidolia or something. But "getting the most out of this immensely complicated thing that's in some ways kinda like another human being can be tricky" doesn't seem to me like an implausible proposition, and if it's really doing something akin to human-like work[1] then it's not unreasonable if you have to approach working with it in something a bit like the ways you approach working with other people.

[1] If it isn't really doing something akin to human-like work, then why are you bothering with it at all?

gjm11··on Show HN: 18 Words
Some thoughts about the timer, since it's what everyone wants to talk about :-) --

I find that with things like this my distribution of times is extremely uneven: I get most words in a few seconds, but every now and then one comes along that for whatever reason my brain doesn't want to see and then it takes much longer. (And if that "much longer" is over the 30-second limit, too bad, I lose.)

And something about this makes playing with the timer annoying for me: I feel some combination of "surely I should get some credit for getting all those others so much quicker than the timer allows" and "oh, come on, that was just unlucky and doesn't reflect what I can generally do".

(I am not claiming that it's right to feel anything like that. Just that I do and I suspect I'm not alone.)

I wonder about a mechanic like this: the timer starts at 30 seconds; when you solve a word, rather than resetting to 30 seconds the timer increments by 10 seconds. So if you're solving in <10s on average then (at least after the first few, easier, words) you can afford to have the occasional brain failure without getting thrown out of the game. And your overall performance depends on how well you do on all the words, not how you do on the single worst one.

(I agree with others that there should also be a no-timer mode for those who just don't want to feel tested and/or stressed in that way.)

gjm11··on Amazon without the knockoffs
That's pretty much the default Amazon experience, no?
gjm11··on Astrophysicists Puzzle over Webb’s New Universe
The institutions, projects and individuals named in the article are, in order of appearance:

--1-- Charlotte Mason (not, so far as I can tell, affiliated with or funded by the Simons Foundation)

of the Cosmic Dawn Center (not, so far as I can tell, affiliated with or funded by the Simons Foundation)

which is associated with the Niels Bohr Institute at the University of Copenhagen (not, so far as I can tell, affiliated with or funded by the Simons Foundation, except that the NBI hosts something called the "Niels Bohr International Academy" that has taken money from the Simons Foundation; it doesn't look to me as if Charlotte Mason has any connection with this)

and also with the National Space Institute at the Technical University of Denmark (not, so far as I can tell, affiliated with or funded by the Simons Foundation)

--2-- The James Webb Space Telescope (not, so far as I can tell, affiliated with or funded by the Simons Foundation)

--3-- Jenny Greene (not, so far as I can tell, affiliated with or funded by the Simons Foundation, though she did once give a talk at the Center For Computational Astrophysics at the Flatiron Institute which is part of the Simons Foundation)

of Princeton University (not, so far as I can tell, affiliated with the Simons Foundation though I expect it's taken some of their money, but in any case no one needs an excuse for reporting on work done at Princeton)

--4-- Unnamed-in-the-article researchers who found that a "little red dot" is likely a supermassive black hole without stars around it; the Simons Foundation is not mentioned anywhere in the paper they published about this; neither the first-named author of that paper nor the one quoted in the linked article has obvious Simons connections, and both are at the University of Cambridge which, again, no one needs an excuse for reporting on the doings of.

--5-- Rachel Sommerville of the Flatiron Institute. Here there really is a Simons connection; the Flatiron Institute is part of the Simons Foundation. It does computational research in scientific fields, astrophysics being one of them.

--6-- "a meeting in April 2026 in Helsingør, Denmark" about the early universe; this was titled "Charting Cosmic Dawn in Copenhagen" and so far as I can tell has no Simons connection other than the fact that two of the 21 people listed as "invited speakers and tutorial leads" are from the Flatiron Institute, which seems innocuous since the F.I. does in fact do scientific research in this area.

--7-- Hakim Atek (no Simons connection so far as I can see)

of the Paris Institute of Astrophysics (no Simons connection so far as I can see, though I did find evidence that at least once the Simons Foundation has provided funding for a person working there)

of the Sorbonne University (not affiliated with the Simons Foundation; I'm sure they sometimes take S.F. money but, yet again, this is not an institution that anyone needs excuses to report on the work of)

So, I find one, count 'em, one, instance of a Simons-associated entity in the article. How very sinister of Quanta to mention them and hide their own affiliation. Oh, wait: "Editor’s note: The Flatiron Institute is funded by the Simons Foundation, which also funds this editorially independent magazine. Simons Foundation funding decisions have no influence on our coverage."

You may, of course, choose not to believe that last claim. You might be right. But in this article I don't see any obvious sign of bias; they reported on a whole lot of things most of which have no particular connections with the Simons Foundation, and the one S.F.-affiliated thing they reported on does seem relevant. I can't rule out the possibility that Sommerville's work is actually bad and was reported on here only because of the Simons connection, but e.g. she is one of those invited contributors to that conference in Copenhagen which doesn't seem to have had a Simons connection and does seem to have been run by reputable astrophysicists.

gjm11··on The fall of the theorem economy
A convolutional neural network is really somewhat like a visual cortex. Obviously AlphaZero doesn't literally have a visual cortex -- actual literal visual cortices are features of actual literal brains made out of meat -- but it definitely has something that does something akin to visual processing, in a way that LLMs don't. Or at least they don't on the face of it; maybe well trained large enough LLMs have effectively implemented something kinda-visual-cortex-like on top of the transformer architecture.

(I bet there are people at all the big AI labs working on ways to incorporate something more CNN-like into LLMs somehow.)

gjm11··on How many of the 170k English words do you know?
"Yahoo" and "Lilliputian" come from the same 1726 novel by Swift as "Brobdingnagian".
gjm11··on Zenzizenzizenzic
Also, a Scrabble board is 15 squares across and ZENZIZENZIZENZIC is 16 letters, so even with a Scrabble set with extra Zs or blanks you couldn't ever play it.
gjm11··on Letter from the Duke of Wellington to the British Foreign Office (1809)
Also, the letter is allegedly (1) dated 1812 and (2) signed "Wellington". In 1812 he was still plain old Arthur Wellesley; he wasn't duked[1] until 1814.

[1] I am sure this is not actually the right term. I do not care.

gjm11··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
The demand is that there shouldn't be anywhere on that ladder where you are expected to pay taxes and aren't given the right to vote.

Is it a sensible demand? I dunno. Some people have thought so. Some other people have thought not. I'm not trying to settle that question; just trying to bring some clarity as to what the issue is.

gjm11··on Search engines alternatives now that Google isn't Google anymore
Kagi gets flak from time to time for getting some of its search results from Yandex[1]. Whether that means it is compromised or isn't compromised (or doesn't mean either) is a question I think different people will decide differently depending on their own geopolitical leanings, but if your question is meant sincerely[1] then you should probably regard them as less "compromised" than you otherwise would have.

[1] I think the usual concern is more "they pay Yandex, and Yandex has ties to the Putin regime, so they are indirectly funding bad things done by Russia" than "their results have whatever biases Russia forces Yandex to have", but the latter could definitely also be a concern; there have definitely been allegations of Yandex results for e.g. searches related to Ukraine having pro-Russian biases.

[2] Rather than as a way to remind people who would object to Kagi's use of Yandex that it's happening.

gjm11··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
When someone says "No taxation without representation!" they don't mean "As a matter of fact, no one ever gets taxed by a government they don't have the power to vote for or against". (If that were true, there'd be no need to demand it.)

They mean "I would like our government to stop taxing people who don't get to vote for it" or "It is unjust for a government to tax people who don't get to vote for it" or something of that sort.

The fact that things aren't already the way you want them to be doesn't make it absurd to demand that they change to be that way.

(You might argument that governments don't give a damn what anyone demands and for that reason it is absurd to demand change. But I think that in fact governments do take notice of what people want, if they fear what the people might do if they don't get it. Whether that's voting them out of office or putting their heads on pikes or anything in between. And they will take more notice if more people are demanding whatever it is, and a large part of the point of saying things like "No taxation without representation!" is to get other people who aren't in the government to sympathize with your cause and maybe start demanding the same thing. So I think it's manifestly not absurd to make such demands, as such. Some particular demands -- "No taxation without $1M/year universal basic income!" -- would be absurd, but this one seems obviously not to be in that category.)

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →