HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gmadsen

994 karma · joined August 13, 2018

submissionscomments
gmadsen··on Can AI do maths yet? Thoughts from a mathematician
I don't disagree, I just don't think it is done well or at least as seriously as it used to. In modern philosophy, there are many mathematically specious arguments, that just make clear how large the mathematical gap has become e.g. improper application of Godel's incompleteness theorems. Yet Godel was a philosopher himself, who would disagree with its current hand-wavy usage.

19th/20th was a golden era of philosophy with a coherent and rigorous mathematical lens to apply with other lenses. Russel, Turing, Godel, etc. However this just doesn't exist anymore

gmadsen··on Can AI do maths yet? Thoughts from a mathematician
I hear these arguments a lot from law and philosophy students, never from those trained in mathematics. It seems to me, "literary" people will still be discussing these theoretical hypotheticals as technology passes them by building it.
gmadsen··on The unbearable slowness of being: Why do we live at 10 bits/s?
it is a categorization, like all things in biology. One of the most robust and significant ones for all of life is sexual versus asexual reproduction. It is intentionally blurring understanding to say that it is not a binary. This is not a gaussian situation, and not fitting into this categorization is exceedingly rare due to defect/mutation which largely does not proliferate genetically.
gmadsen··on Twitter kills its San Francisco headquarters, will relocate to South Bay
Palo Alto is suburbs. It is also home to the best medical care in the world...
gmadsen··on Ask HN: Is it possible to make FAANG salaries without working there?
isnt this the purpose of LLCs?
gmadsen··on The Point of the Banach Tarski Theorem (2015)
Right, but those were self imposed requirements based on intuition. The axioms of sigma algebras are different than these requirements. If anything measure theory highlights the limits and conditions of when to consider something measureable. That is the point of the Paradox and the need for measure theory.
gmadsen··on The Point of the Banach Tarski Theorem (2015)
why is this a critique of measure theory? Measure theory is the answer to the paradox. The partition uses unmeasurable sets, so comparing the surface areas before and after doesn't make sense. You could do the partition a billion times and expand the volume as well..
gmadsen··on Creativity has left the chat: The price of debiasing language models
Italy has great architecture from fascism days
gmadsen··on Sheaf Theory Through Examples
there are a few books that make it accessible to non mathematicians. Both by Eugenia Cheng, "How to Bake Pi" and "The Joy of Abstraction"
gmadsen··on Apple's risky bet on CarPlay
kind of funny a back up camera is now considered a "dumb" car feature
gmadsen··on Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous cars in the U.S.
failed to scale? You can read their public operation plans which outline their plans to scale.
gmadsen··on Florida's DeSantis signs law restricting social media for people under 16
because the legal adult age in the US is 18?
gmadsen··on Flowers for Algernon (1965) [pdf]
Maybe try to seek out that experience then? I think its a little dangerous to go through life not understanding that there are levels of intrinsic intelligence. It should be fairly obvious. And it applies to everyone, you can read quotes of old physics nobel laureates that speak about Von Neumann as if he was not a human.

The take away should be that, yes some people are intrinsically smarter, but that is a crappy system to base self worth off of, because then only one person in the world gets to be happy.

gmadsen··on Flowers for Algernon (1965) [pdf]
How is that possible to not know? Have you never worked on a team?
gmadsen··on Ask HN: Any advice on navigating this job market or pivoting out of tech? (US)
that is what the interview is for
gmadsen··on PID Without a PhD (2016) [pdf]
you can output a control action with mpc
gmadsen··on Apple Vision Pro review
its not really self inflicted when it literally determines how many sales you will have. Plenty of people are put off of VR because of the form factor. Quest looks like a nerdy toy, which does indeed influence who buys and/or uses it
gmadsen··on Relearning math as an adult
fair enough, I was only speaking for the US, which has a slower pace and lack of motivation throughout k-12 + calc series. I still have no idea why they don't teach basic algebra with matrices, so it doesn't seem like a giant bad of tricks, or why linear algebra is so separated from multi-dim calculus, it really makes it more difficult with busy work and you never really comprehend anything.
gmadsen··on Relearning math as an adult
how do you motivate formal functions and relations to 5th graders, and more importantly why? Relations are important because of the natural partitions of a set they create and the development of group theory. Functions are useful in calculus, but not really the algebraic properties, those are glossed over, i.e kids learning calculus are usually not learning the formalization of functions. That isn't important until analysis or abstract algebra, hence why its included in the textbooks
gmadsen··on Relearning math as an adult
Sure, texts like "linear algebra done right" or "Understanding Analysis" do a unusually good job of integrating large multi part examples where the reader works through them and proves the theorems themselves before they are explained in the book. The nominal case for most math texts is definition, lemmas, theorems, and sometimes they provide examples, and other times, readers are expected to make their own examples. For example, basic topology really only needs 10-20 pages to completely define, but to really understand why the axioms are chosen and the implications, you must work through examples, it is the only way. In fact there is a good book on topology specifically due to this " Counterexamples in Topology"
gmadsen··on Culture Change at Google
Caretaker or guardian is the word you are looking for.
gmadsen··on Culture Change at Google
For one, I have never heard the term "child raiser" in my life so I assume its even more confusing for those with english as a second language. It also just sounds so emotionless, like children are cattle. I'm really struggling to see what is gained by not using parent. For all intents and purposes, people use the term parent for those raising a child.
gmadsen··on Relearning math as an adult
that is a little bit of hyperbole. No school in 5th or 6th grade is giving formal definitions of relations and functions. There is a reason nearly all undergrad math books in analysis, topology, algebra, all devote an entire first chapter to it.
gmadsen··on Relearning math as an adult
This is just not true. Reading is necessary but hardly about as important. If you are lucky and get a good text, the exercises guide you to "invent" the important parts of the theory. Otherwise its just definitions and theorems, and its up to you to make your own examples to gain an intuition, which to be fair is closer to life outside of a classroom.
gmadsen··on MIT MicroMasters
its not completely binary, but the comment was specific to MIT, which is known for having strong academic extra curriculars, which is instilled as a core value into all incoming classes of students. It matters and people care what you do outside of class at MIT.

but even state schools, you get out of it, proportional to what you put in. I'm not sure your exact association with the word "value" , but even basics like resume building are directly impacted by clubs you are a part of. I know many that received job offers explicitly because of their involvement in a robotics F1 or nasa affiliated competition

gmadsen··on Facebook bans ads for Votes for Women boardgame, claims "sensitive social issue"
in what way? I think we collectively figured out democracy doesn't work a few thousand years ago. That's why we have a democratic republic.
gmadsen··on You are never taught how to build quality software
I would assume something like this? https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/79551
gmadsen··on Building end-to-end security for Messenger
for 2, I will say anecdotally I have never in my life bought something directly from an ad until the last 2 years on instagram. It actually found things directly useful to me that I did not know about beforehand (I did still go through an hour of research or so, but was amazed at the algorithm discovery capability)
gmadsen··on Building end-to-end security for Messenger
its the "right" thing to do only by a small population of tech workers. Most people do not care, and ad customers would be very upset if this degrades targeting.
gmadsen··on Ousted propaganda scholar accuses Harvard of bowing to Meta
sure, my point still stands. It is a reasonable evolutionary hypothesis that groups that err on the side of trusting a leader succeed more that distrustful groups. Obviously there is a learned behavior component. I'm just not certain its completely that.
← PreviousPage 3 of 20Next →