HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gngeal

987 karma · joined March 2, 2013

submissionscomments
gngeal··on Sympathy for the Luddites
Yes, that is why whenever you invent something independently you're fucked because of this nasty thing called "the patent system" that essentially guarantees that most things you create already belong to someone else.
gngeal··on Red Hat ditches MySQL, switches to MariaDB
Oh My. What a question.
gngeal··on The Code You Don't Write
"The cheapest, fastest and most reliable components are those that aren’t there."

-- Gordon Bell

gngeal··on Hundreds march in Singapore against website licensing regime
That's precisely why I said that this is no false dichotomy here. False dichotomy is something completely different. False dichotomies are things like "if you're not with us, you're against us", or "The new research shows that one part of the theory of evolution is wrong, therefore creationism is right". There's nothing like this here; his was a simple statement of the form "X is not bad, because Y is even worse". See the difference? False dichotomy means (falsely) asserting that when you disprove the factuality of one alternative, only one other alternative remains and therefore it's automatically true. (Whereas apeeal to worse problems is not about factual truths but about the weights of problems to be solved.)
gngeal··on Hundreds march in Singapore against website licensing regime
That's not a false dichotomy. That's an appeal to worse problems.
gngeal··on Hundreds march in Singapore against website licensing regime
The language is amazing. And as a side benefit, you can read Old Norse sagas with very little effort if you learn it!
gngeal··on Bradley Manning leaked Granai Airstrike "~86-147, mostly women and children"
I means that when you're a scrooge and decide not to attract people to fill positions that you need by offering them some monetary incentive, you have to spend even more money on bombs and spare parts that fall in the wrong places.
gngeal··on Bradley Manning leaked Granai Airstrike "~86-147, mostly women and children"
Which is precisely the thing that is incompatible with Western democracy. Of would you like to amend the First Amendment?
gngeal··on Palantir Denies Its 'Prism' Software Is The NSA's 'PRISM' Surveillance System
The creators of Angry Birds would probably be aware if their software were an NSA-grade surveillance system rather than a cartoon physics game.

The question is: do they use a compiler written for the NSA by Ken Thompson?

gngeal··on What We Don't Know About Spying on Citizens: Scarier Than What We Know
but don't you remember the huge political battle over Obamacare?

Well, I do, but only very vaguely; after all, it took place thousands of kilometers from where I happen to live and it's not like we don't have enough of our local issues to take care of.

gngeal··on What We Don't Know About Spying on Citizens: Scarier Than What We Know
Can anyone imagine that happening here, in the country where flag burning is constitutionally protected?

Well, that feels sort of disingenuous. From the POV of a scheming politician in power, harmless gestures would certainly seem much less important than agents of your potential downfall communicating in ways that you can't penetrate. In most cases, those loudmouths are the devils you know.

I think a lot of this is ignorance about how modern counter terrorism works. The most effective tool we have is social network analysis. Find a terrorist and see who calls them, then see who calls those people and out and out. Look at the vertices and edges and dependencies networks and we can learn a lot about complex organizations without risking any lives.

I believe that's exactly happened half a year before 9/11. Then, someone thought, "what an interesting scenario, let's file it into our record system".

If you want to know why government agency's are engaging in this wildly unpopular behavior, here's the answer: On 9/11 a lot of people swore to god that it would never happen again.

OK, I'll bite: Didn't lousy healthcare kill more people in the US in the last decade (certainly, possibly even in a year) than 9/11 ever did? Do people swear to god that this must never happen again? I don't think so. It's the salami slicing effect, only with people. As long as it's not visible, nobody cares (or extremely few are actually bothered by it to any extent).

Ditto for people killed by burning all that coal.

gngeal··on New York Times silently edits its "lost all credibility" line
I'm reasonably certain that archive.org must be using some differential encoding of pages. Otherwise the archiving process would waste a lot of space. They're just not making it visible.

EDIT: Also: http://www.changedetection.com

gngeal··on Replacing Clever Code with Unremarkable Code in Go
Not unless he had a TARDIS at his disposal. I mean, skip lists were discovered in 1989, and by that time, the Oberon compiler had already existed for a few years. I don't recall the source now (I'd have to dig for it) but I believe that the Wirth anectode referred to his intervention in a case of overzealous students some time before that.
gngeal··on Exhibit A – the “child pornographer”
Except that the Henry V in question was a German guy. :) "The Holy Roman Empire", despite its name, was initially a Frankish and then a purely German institution, comprising a lot of the lands of Central Europe (plus a bit of Western Europe, for as while).
gngeal··on Exhibit A – the “child pornographer”
I'd say that "somehow not ready for marriage" DOES include material reasons. If most marriages didn't happen early because of this, that still makes early marriages quite unusual for most contemporary people. That was the point I was trying to make. (And I do have the experience that people regularly scoff at things that defy social norms and customs, and I have no reason to believe that people in the Middle Ages were any different.)
gngeal··on Exhibit A – the “child pornographer”
this number may have been roughly accurate for Britain/ Northwest Europe, but not for the Mediterranean

I admit that I have significant holes in knowledge regading the "Middle Ages in the Mediterranean" region of space-time. I am biased towards the NW region of Europe partly because there's a wealth of material accessible to me pertaining to the area, partly because I derive most of my income from providing language services for the language spoken in the region, and therefore I am expected to have more than just a passing familiarity with this region's culture and history (although I am partially excused from having to know it to any significant depth as I specialize mostly in technical and engineering texts where this knowledge isn't all that important, and history is merely my part-time hobby). I haven't seen a general work dedicated to the Romance-speaking and Mediterranean regions either in English or in my native tongue yet, therefore I plead incompetent on this charge. :-)

I might, however, try to dig up some data pertaining to my native, i.e., Central European environment; however, not on such a short notice for it to be relevant to this discussion.

EDIT: I wonder about the tradeoffs involved here. Tentative hypothesis: in Northern climates, the labor of daughters was more valuable, so fathers kept them around for longer before marrying them off.

My take on this - I believe that some of the factors involved were:

- the necessity for young people to help their families work on the household,

- the necessity for young women to earn their dowry, if their families couldn't provide it for them (usually by entering into service of nobles or townsmen for a few years),

- the stagnation of land development outside periods of borderland colonization (different periods in various countries, in Central Europe, this period of colonization would have taken place between 11th and 13th century), meaning that someone had to retire first for another pair of young people to get their household.

I'm quite sure there would have been other reasons that I can't recall right now.

gngeal··on Exhibit A – the “child pornographer”
Citation needed.

Of course, here you are:

"Historians have demonstrated that peasants married at significantly later ages than aristocrats. Whereas members of the nobility usually married between age 14 and age 20, peasants probably married in their mid- to late twenties. It is likely that new families could not form until the parents of the potential couple were either dead or old enough to retire, so that they could turn over their land and dwelling to the new couple." [Linda Mitchell, Family Life in the Middle Ages, Greenwood 2007, p. 40]

"Reliable statistics are rare for the Middle Ages, but the evidence suggests that the typical age of marriage among the peasantry was the late twenties for men, the early twenties for women; similar ages probably applied for the urban laboring classes. The ages decline, particularly for women, further up the social scale. Among prosperous urban families, the marriage age for women was typically the late teens; the age varied widely for men. In the aristocracy, ages in the mid-teens for women and early twenties for men seem to have been common." [Jeffrey L. Forgeng, Daily Life in Medieval Europe, Greenwood 1999, p. 27]

[The following text is concerned with the very beginning of Early Modern period-post Late Middle Ages] "When individual ages are looked at, however, we do find very occasional marriages in the early teens. One girl gave her age as thirteen, none as fourteen, four as fifteen, twelve as sixteen, but all the rest of the brides in the sample, 990 of them, were seventeen or over, and more than four out of five had reached the age of twenty. Only ten of the men were younger than this. The commonest age for women was twenty-two, for men twenty-four; the median - the age below which as many got married as above it - was some 22.75 for women, 25.5 for men." [Peter Laslett, The World We Have Lost: Further Explored, Routledge 2001, p. 83]

gngeal··on Exhibit A – the “child pornographer”
A bit on the creepy side for someone on the other side of 20 to date

For some people, perhaps. Individuals differ, I've met a few 16yo girls who were very much adult, as far as their intellect, personality and temperament were concerned, and I have a very hard time trying to picture a relationship with someone more mature than an average 20yo male as "creepy".

gngeal··on Exhibit A – the “child pornographer”
Age of consent is one thing, but "the idea that people under 18 are somehow not ready for marriage" certainly IS old. Just FYI, the median age for a bride on her first wedding was somewhere around 22-23 in the Middle Ages.
gngeal··on Replacing Clever Code with Unremarkable Code in Go
I’d love someday to hear a young coder tell a story about someone they idolized like, “There was this guy I worked with who once optimized a complicated red- black tree getting 300% performance boost. I was baffled and ask, ‘How’d you do that? That’s impossible.’ To which he responded…”

“‘That’s my linked list my son.’”

I believe that this is exactly what Niklaus Wirth did in the Oberon compiler.

gngeal··on Visual Studio 2013
Well, you might want to do that if you were building a colinux-style paravirtualized system on top of the Windows kernel.
gngeal··on Cold fusion reactor independently verified, has 10k x the energy density of gas
"The cold fusion device being tested has roughly 10,000 times the energy density and 1,000 times the power density of gasoline. Even allowing for a massively conservative margin of error, the scientists say that the cold fusion device they tested is 10 times more powerful than gasoline"

Such idiotic claims. What comes next, that meat has twice the energy energy density of a fruit blender? Since when does one compare a fuel and a machine, instead of two fuels?

gngeal··on Learn C
The LiSP book only describes self-hosting implementations while in Forth it's heresy to implement it in anything else than Forth or assembly. Well, perhaps Java implementations are excused for not being implemented in terms of themselves. :-)
gngeal··on Learn C
Are you sure? From where I stand, it looks as though andrewvc and betterunix were both talking about compilers rather than interpreters, while dysoco didn't specify either, so I inferred that the compiler topic still stood.
gngeal··on Learn C
Really? I'd say that a Forth compiler in Forth is going to be somewhat smaller than a Brainfuck compiler in Brainfuck.
gngeal··on Poll: Full-time software engineers in London, what's your annual salary?
but politically and culturally the line gets a little blurry

Politically and culturally, it's in Europe. Greek Orthodoxy and Greek-derived scripts are something you find in Europe since the Middle Ages.

gngeal··on Processing and Racket
that pictures excite people and draw them in, keep them around

They may also excite them because doing pictures the "traditional" way (PHP/GD, GDI, even Cairo) feels like using stone age tools, while combinator libraries (such as Alex Shinn's fmt, for example) are a hip new thing, for a reason.

Where Racket succeeds over Lisp and Scheme

Huh, that's almost like like saying "Where Visual Studio C++ succeeds over C". It's still on the inside, isn't it? It was a shady move on their part :-), but I guess that whatever helps Racket helps Scheme in general as well.

Nice article, BTW. Thanks. :-)

gngeal··on The Linux kernel trumps the moonshot by a few orders of magnitude
Well, yes, but the individual GNU tools are to a large degree independent. I'm not an insider, but to me it seemed that the kernel development effort really pushed the limits in the area of distributed development of a single large code base. (I'm not sure, though, how exactly did the kernel code base measure with the contemporary GCC code base, which is probably the closest in complexity from all the GNU stuff.)
gngeal··on The Linux kernel trumps the moonshot by a few orders of magnitude
I agree with you. Linux is possibly a bad example, there's nothing special about writing it.

Are you sure about it? Wasn't it one of the first really large software projects with the distributed development model? (Were there any predecessors to that?)

gngeal··on The Linux kernel trumps the moonshot by a few orders of magnitude
Decades of research in numerous fields were required before the Apollo missions could happen.

Actually, it was less than one decade of research post-Kennedy's-announcement, and a lot of groundwork had already been laid by then. The whole thing was standing on the shoulders of giants from day one. It's really difficult to pick any single ground-breaking development in the Apollo project; it was more like a lot of R&D trickle in disparate areas converging on a solution for a single goal, all of which was being built on a solid foundation we had already had by that time.

For example, the Apollo Guidance Computer was, AFAIK, the first serially produced digital computer made of integrated circuits, and I believe that for quite some time, the manufacturers of ACGs in the Charles Stark Draper Laboratory (an offshoot of MIT) were the single largest purchaser of ICs on this planet. The consequence was that the use of ICs in complex computers had been validated, Fairchild Semiconductor (who provided the NOR gates used in the computer) amortized their investments and went on churning them out in ever increasing numbers. You know what followed. But this was more about speeding up the adoption rather then stimulating the development of something completely new.

Experts in numerous fields had to collaborate on the mission.

Since it's a software project, you could also argue that you need experts in various fields of programming. The guy who writes a driver for a new device manufactured by his employer to be included in the mainline kernel probably isn't somenone who you're going to trust with redesigning the kernel memory allocator.

← PreviousPage 10 of 16Next →