HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

goatinaboat

2,889 karma · joined May 23, 2019

Welsh and proud 󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿
submissionscomments
goatinaboat··on GitHub, fuck your name change
Slavery has defined the country

I don't think this is true. What percentage of White Americans, during the period of slavery, owned any slaves? Was it even 1%?

It is one facet of American history yes, but it is very far from the "definition" of the country.

goatinaboat··on GitHub, fuck your name change
I'm in the UK so maybe it is different, but lately "woke" is anyone that is seen as an enemy of the far right.

I am also in the UK and there is lots of hand-wringing about "the extreme far right" but if you gently probe what people mean by "extreme far right" they mean "Brexit" or "not electing Jeremy Corbyn".

I expect in a few months the term "ultra extreme far right" will enter the lexicon, and we'll keep adding superlatives as the term "right-wing" becomes more and more diluted and gradually encloses the entire population except for a few Momentum die-hards.

goatinaboat··on GitHub, fuck your name change
They are doing it to avoid being a target of a woke mob feigning offense for their own ideological gain in the on-going identity culture war which is happening in the west.

Another example, Bezos recently banned books critical of transgender from being sold on Amazon. And just like that, everyone forgot about Amazon's brutal suppression of union organising activity in their warehouses. Similarly the rest of Big Tech thinks it can toss out token gestures and placate those who are critical of its business practices.

goatinaboat··on Common Mistakes of New Engineering Managers
here are companies where managers are truly in a supporting function. I'm not here to advertise but my last two jobs were like that

Unless programmers have equal knowledge of and input into their managers salary as their manager does in their's, there's still that fundamental top-down structure.

goatinaboat··on Common Mistakes of New Engineering Managers
It's been over a decade since I've worked at a company with managers. However, it was common for the top programmers to make more money than their managers there.

Programming and managing are completely different jobs that accomplish different things for the organisation, but they are typically arranged in a top-down fashion, the manager has power over the programmer. A manager's job is to do the function of interacting with the wider organisation in order to determine the best way for the programmer to spend his time, in effect it's a research job, then he presents the programmer with the results of his research and they both agree that the most value can be added to the organisation by working on bug X today instead of feature Y. But what actually happens is the manager says "do this, because I said so, and if you don't I'll block your next raise". Or so-called engineering managers cherry-pick the most rewarding work for themselves and assign the unfulfilling work to subordinates as punishment. That's deeply dysfunctional but it's what happens when you have a group who wants to do real work, and another group who has plenty of time on their hands for full-time politicking.

goatinaboat··on Docker Raises $23M
Production workload on k3s? It’s what you run on a laptop!
goatinaboat··on Docker Raises $23M
should have went the SPAC route

Or issued Doggercoin

goatinaboat··on Docker Raises $23M
Considering how entrenched Docker has been in global tech infrastructure for so many years

It is not entrenched at all, that's their problem. You can literally drop in Podman as a replacement and alias the command it it will "just work" - and Podman has some significant advantages in many environments/use cases. Docker, the company or the product, has no concrete barriers to entry to protect itself.

goatinaboat··on Docker Raises $23M
I beg to differ. The jump from learning Docker (and containers generally) to learning Kubernetes is not “hard”.

Unless you are at a scale that you can employ a full-time Kubernetes team, you probably don't need Kubernetes, and if you insist on using it for production anyway, you absolutely should use one of the many managed offerings (DO is probably cheapest, I have no affiliation with them), or shrinkwrapped product like Tanzu.

Bootstrapping from scratch on bare metal remains non-trivial and an in-place upgrade is an order of magnitude harder.

goatinaboat··on Facebook has 10k engineers working on AR/VR
This is a bizarre couple of sentences. I don't think you understand the technology _at all_.

I'm taking the "close to your eyeballs" as a metaphor, but with AR you literally are trusting Facebook to mediate between you and the world. The ads you see, or don't see, on every flat surface, potentially. And that's just the start.

goatinaboat··on Facebook has 10k engineers working on AR/VR
I hope the best for VR/AR, and the worst for Facebook

It's funny, Tron was one of the most memorable movies of my childhood. Later I watched Star Trek with the Holodeck, read Neuromancer and Snow Crash, dabbled with VRML, played with the SGI CAVE at university. I ought to be hugely excited by the progress in VR. But... I'm just not. Because Facebook and friends are not doing it because it's cool or because it will be useful to humanity, to them it's just another siphon to hoover up and monetise your personal data by steering you into purchasing and voting decisions that benefit them, not you. After literally decades of anticipation, I doubt I will bother to participate in VR.

goatinaboat··on Stay-at-home policy is a case of exception fallacy
The factors in COVID are age and obesity, countries with older and/or fatter populations have more cases per capita and hence deaths. Lockdown is a rounding error.
goatinaboat··on Gun sales rise in past year, especially among women and African Americans
Do you know that the talibans had and still have bases in Pakistan that allowed them to lead the gorilla war that they did?

Yes I'll concede that fighting a guerrilla war without external support is difficult but it was always thus. Another example would be the Cuban revolution. However civil wars are often fought without any external backing being the decisive factor.

goatinaboat··on Gun sales rise in past year, especially among women and African Americans
overwhelming well-organized, well-supplied, highly technological armed force that has no restrictions to be civilized or respect individual rights

The Soviets had no qualms whatsoever, even booby-trapping childrens toys. But they couldn't hold Afghanistan.

goatinaboat··on Gun sales rise in past year, especially among women and African Americans
Only because all criminals have guns. Because guess what. Guns are legal.

There were many stories during the "firey but mostly peaceful" demonstrations last year of people who were ordinarily liberals trying to buy guns for personal and home defence and discovering to their horror that that actually there is a background check and a waiting period, you can't just buy one on a whim. Nor can a friend legally just lend you one.

goatinaboat··on Why inflation is not a threat
Economically speaking, increasing base money supply (giving money directly to people) does in fact increase inflation

Well, sure, if you give a bunch of people some money and they all decide to spend it on re-doing their homes at the same time then the prices charged by local tradesmen will probably go up, then correct themselves again when the peak demand passes. I'd argue that's not a bad thing in the sense that real work is being done, and the money is circulating in real goods and services - because if value is actually being created then there is something backing the new money.

goatinaboat··on The Miseducation of Americas Elites
The difference is that by late 1980s there were few true believers.

This was one of the striking things about the collapse of the USSR, former KGB, the supposed final bastion of defence of the Soviet system, became hyper-capitalist oligarchs overnight seemingly without skipping a beat. We see the same thing happening where the one-time stronghold of enlightenment and liberalism doesn't believe in it either.

What's also strange is that there are many people in the US with lived experience of the Soviet system, and they are sounding the alarm that what's happening now leads to some very dark places, and their voices are being completely ignored or even shouted down.

goatinaboat··on Why inflation is not a threat
At the moment we have new money being created by central banks and given to privileged institutions who get access to free money. They use that to buy investments: real estate, stocks, etc. These are precisely the things getting really expensive. The last things to get more expensive during big cycles of inflation are employee wages.

Indeed. If a government is dead set on printing money then it should give that money directly to people - many of whom will use it to pay down mortgages so the banks will get it anyway, but it will also do some good on the way.

goatinaboat··on Career levels, designation, momentum, etc. (2018)
All of us are frustrated about the company's (lack of) leveling system

A previous employer took the explicit decision not to have formal levels because they didn't want people to fixate on individual promotion, instead to focus on the organisations goals. To me that seems in conflict with some basic commercial forces operating in the market. You can possibly pull that off if you're also offering a job for life with salary that keeps pace with the market, and amazingly interesting work so noone ever gets bored and just fancies a change. Bell Labs or Xerox or a legendary company like those could do it. But very few companies like that exist now, and this wasn't one of them.

goatinaboat··on Ask HN: Is Minix dead? No commits since 2018
This is sad. I have fond memories of running MINIX on the Atari ST - my first encounter with Unix.
goatinaboat··on Docker Security Cheat Sheet
Well sure, but I'm not using systemd.

I hear you but fighting systemd in 2021 is like pushing water uphill. With a fork.

goatinaboat··on The internet didn’t kill counterculture – you just won’t find it on Instagram
Faceblock, Twatter, Instaglam, Discard, Snapper, TikTak, LinkedOut

I really hoped that Clubhouse would corral all the hardcore narcissists away from all other social media, but it's made them worse, they spend all their time on Twitter bragging about how they're on Clubhouse now. Pathetic.

goatinaboat··on Routing the Technical Interview
If you are asked a stupid question it is reasonable to give a stupid answer
goatinaboat··on RethinkDB: why we failed (2017)
But it’s the only real player in their market

Not at all. All of MongoDB is just a feature in Postgres, and Postgres does it better, and Postgres does hundreds more things too.

goatinaboat··on RethinkDB: why we failed (2017)
RethinkDB could have been a huge player along with the likes of MongoDB

MongoDB is a weird one because what they had didn't even meet the most basic requirements of "a database", that you could store something in it and reliably get it back out. But they somehow converted their joke of a product into enough money to buy WiredTiger, rebrand its product as theirs, and profit. It's the ultimate expression of "fake it 'til you make it" and they did it by giving away stickers at conferences!

The best technology and product doesn't always win.

Once you realise what we do is not engineering, it's fashion, it will all make sense.

goatinaboat··on UK to depart from GDPR
The care provided by the NHS is very poor while paying its employees very little and forcing to work with garbage equipment.

Doctors and administrators are very well paid. Even nurses are when you factor in the pension. The only genuinely underpaid staff in the NHS are its cleaners who are the REAL frontline against infectious diseases. Didn’t see them doing many Tiktok dances however, too busy with real work.

goatinaboat··on The Sovietization of the American Press
treasonous

Genuine question: what do you think about “autonomous zones”? Isn’t seceding from the state usually pretty serious? The US fought a civil war over it last time someone did that.

goatinaboat··on Has Y Combinator lost its way when the latest company is a Mac only widget?
I don't think you can reply to say, a slack message from it

I think Slack post-dates BlackBerry but you could definitely reply to e.g. a FB message from within it. BB wrote and maintained their own FB connector to facilitate it, FB never shipped a BB app.

goatinaboat··on UK to depart from GDPR
The EU isn't perfect, but you'll struggle to argue that it hasn't expanded peace, prosperity and human rights across the continent. This is motherhood-and-apple-pie stuff.

The ECSC then EEC did that, and of course NATO, ECHR, Schengen and various other institutions and agreements. The EU came into existence much later and claimed credit for things that were set in motion decades before. Noone would have voted to leave the EEC, the EEC was great.

goatinaboat··on Has Y Combinator lost its way when the latest company is a Mac only widget?
As someone who has never owned a Blackberry, can you explain what this means?

BlackBerry funnelled everything - email, BBM, tweets, Facebook messages, whatever - into a unified interface. Basically you didn’t need to care where a message came from, you saw it all in one place and could just reply from there. You would not need to check one app for email, another for IMs, another for tweets etc.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →