HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

goatsneez

245 karma · joined January 4, 2019

submissionscomments
goatsneez··on When Is It Ok to Lie?
Many a greater men have reached before a conclusion that it is never ok to lie (period). If that was strictly followed by everyone then 100% of contrived situations that seemingly appeal to allow to lie (for greater good or whatever other reasons) would never occur. There would be no nacism, or any other ism (even green-ism of today).

But that would be true only on individual level. However, the crux of the problem is that societal institutions are not human beings, and human beings entrusted into decision making positions of such institutions cannot (psychologically speaking) hold their ethical/moral integrity as a value over the values they represent as representative of said institutions/corporations.

Therefore, the question is not well posed in my view. A more proper and interesting question is: is it ok to lie to institutions (nb, people representing during the interaction an institution)? [as per fact that you are not talking to a moral entity but to an abstract amoral --> immoral entity]. Same question in reverse is also an exercise....

goatsneez··on Europe Day 2023
Why? How does European culture and collective ethos benefits from something that is aimed at erasing, forgetting and twisting reality and turned into artificially created, (short-term) politically motivated, shallow-cheap-advertisement-like-substitute.

Somehow, unfortunately, it fits into the times into which the European elites got into and are unable to find a practical neither philosophical/ideological way out.

goatsneez··on EU lawmakers approve effective 2035 ban on new fossil fuel cars
I would be of opinion that by 2035 the gasses to liquid fuels transformation of CO2 + CH4 from the atmosphere (using SE) will overtake the electrification idea of today. The liquid fuels are here to stay, not necessarily for the entire chain of transportation system, but for a significant portion of it (and certainly for humanty's ever larger scope of war efforts which cannot run on electricity).
goatsneez··on Why Smart People Hold Stupid Beliefs
It is not an issue of intelligence vs stupidity. Everybody/one can only make (mental) models of reality. The danger while "deadly" without being immediate lies in that people (true on institutional and societal level as well) try to avoid a feedback loop to inform their models. Feedbacks imply evolution.

People reject data points because they believe their models too much; they are in love with their intelligence. And this is in my view more proper way of start thinking about this. Do not love your intelligence, do not worship it less you become "stupid". There is always a circumstance, an issue or topic which you will be ignorant and your own mental model of reality and of yourself will be wrong.

Knowing is a process not a destination (perhaps too simple a statement but does cover the essence of things).

goatsneez··on A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it’s bad for you
That is a rather well constructed rant... agreeable in the substance behind the rhetorical questions. Especially in this anti-intellectual social-climate that is all-pervasive through and through all institutions of the west, and the infantile ideologies of that took hold of the western elites. (I single out west here purely for the contrast of where we come from intellectually/philosophically to where we are currently which to me is easy study case).

However, while we would agree, I wonder which "natural" processes are really to be understood to stand behind this decay. Of cause, it is not new, we can read already in Sumerian tablets, Greek and Roman then witness accounts of their empire's disintegration and how in fact people did clearly perceived the rotting (just as we do now).

In other words, identifying the symptoms (as implied in the question you posed), is one thing. To understand processes inherent in the system of systems itself is yet another level. And then, thought I do not think possible, one can postulate how to slow down, or even reverse such trend. (I would say natural trend in the phase of natural systems of societies).

goatsneez··on I was a useful idiot for capitalism
My own observations of this 'blame capitalism' trend in collective social murmuring gained amplitude perhaps a decade ago, becoming really strong in the past 5 years. I am profoundly puzzled at the 'ad-hocness' and superficiality of the oft presented argument (which this articles is just an sample of). It is not because 'capitalism' is some sacred cow, or that the social maladies affecting communities are irrelevant or unimportant. It is the lack of understanding the very assumptions one makes about the alternatives (as well as 'capitalism' as a concept).

Just as any non-material concept, such as democracy, love, courage, and etc, so capitalism is a model, an abstraction of reality, which is context dependent.

So my contribution to the argument is to bring to attention that just as social-democracy can be de-facto a dictatorship, or 'love' can be a prison, or dictatorship can bring religious freedom and the end of slavery (e.g. early Persian empire) and contrast it with early America colonization governments, similarly capitalism as a concept can be approached.

Fundamentally, it is the mixture of government (power) with private enterprise (wealth) that historically is known to generate the greatest human corruption. Just like there people recognized that religion and state should be separated to avoid corruption of both, it should be followed by a divorce of private enterprise and state. [if one should summarize it in one sentence]. It has nothing to do with capitalism, socialism, nationalism, communism... the principle lies elsewhere.

goatsneez··on How to begin fixing the ‘nonsensical’ humanitarian financing system
amen to that
goatsneez··on Don’t let the great ESG self-deception infect climate tech investing
This is excellent start of a debate, spot on on all points.
goatsneez··on EU to ban all crypto assets, accounts, and custody services belong to Russians
The precedents we are setting up here are ominous on several levels simultaneously: how we view private property of individuals, due-process, jurisdiction, as well as state-state non-military war waging, reciprocity is declared unjust -> no value no rule seems not worth the attempt, etc.

Im most concerned with attitudes and precedent this will have on understanding western value system of ownership, due-process, total surveillance and total control of an individual. In my reading, these developments spell a sad future on these issues.

That such fundamental questions and core values upon which we lay the very justifications of such proposals are undone nobody seems to be bothered with (no opposition from any political party or public at large). That is what is puzzling me.

goatsneez··on The Chinese Government’s Growing Surveillance State
Which state/country has not grown (or better reduced) its surveillance capability. As far as I observe, even EU countries are announcing ever more frequently its ever growing appetite (ad-hoc justifications) for more of it? [scandals of secret and not-so secret as well as illegal surveillance by states are features on countless post on HN, and theintercep.com for that matter).

Which country last 1-2 decades has grown less totalitarian? (I fail to think of one example).

goatsneez··on EU wants to install car-recharging stations every 60km, and hydrogen every 100km
The final proof of how institutionally removed from reality are the dreaming incompetent elites of EU. However, more importantly, there is no excuse not to see that any state central planned idiocy has the same roots, causes, and effects/results.

Sure, private sector is also planned but they have a hard-core reality check in terms of being economic (at least some who are removed the wickedness of lobbying for state favoritism). This brings memories of all the USSR style stories/books/movies from 50-90ties of comical inefficiency, bureaucratic paralysis, and faking of everything post-fact (statistics, narratives, etc). There are entire libraries documenting idiocy of such practices, its detrimental effects on economy as well as environment. I do not see (as expected) no assessment nor processes for basic feedback to reality how to metric the original goals, and unintended effects (which dominate). It seems that there is no choice, I was born in communism and will die in communism, with completely predictable outcome.

Laugh because its funny and cry because its true.

goatsneez··on John J. Mearsheimer: The Causes and Consequences of the Ukraine War
Of cause J. M. is right (since 2015) because of the facts of events (however, there is entire array of experts in international affairs from Oxford to Yale who wrote actual research papers on this. In fact even current CIA director remarked in his published notes consistent with J.M. explanation, or even longer memory is Z. Brzezinski's work). He predicted the response, he explain the causes of the response and they are indeed contained in the speeches of V.P., and he also predicted that this fiasco of diplomacy of both sides will not have a solution because diplomatic solutions can only present themselves at the intersection of understanding of each party's concerns in question.

West is trying to isolate, decimate, breakup and breakdown RU (and later also CHI). These are official goals of the West (total evil has to be totally annihilated is the phrase), stated explicitly in fact. This is clearly not a path to diplomacy, hence, escalation can only increase and Nuc.war is inevitable, inescapable and a logical end-result of this narrative the West has fallen into. It is just as paranoid attitude as that of RU.

goatsneez··on Examining the utility of climate model projections
"While building some internal capability might seem confronting and expensive, building future strategies on information that is not understood and is potentially misleading is likely more so, and quite possibly exposes the global financial system to systemic risks of its own making."
goatsneez··on Chomsky: US Must Join Global Call for Negotiations as Russia Escalates Actions
There is a plan for that too: https://www.esd.whs.mil/Portals/54/Documents/FOID/Reading%20...
goatsneez··on The West is testing out a lot of shiny new military tech in Ukraine
Collecting such news into a conceptual picture of what has been going on (really all around the world, though became open in the UA conflict), it is a pretty much expose on how things ( military <-> corporations <-> state-apparatus of US) are in fact running this world; foreign and economic-international politics (pressure games as well as wars). It is not really news for those who follow events since 20 years, however, this time it is nearly impossible to hide or shroud it anymore (perhaps only to the most gullible sectors of populations may be blind to this -- there will always be some percentage of populace).

What kind of implications it will have on self-perception of the general west population, and also then on the perception of adversarial actors in the global scheme(?) It seems to be that elites are no longer able or lost concern for hiding the growing abyss of disconnect of what is desire/concern of normal people versus elite's visions.

goatsneez··on In Ukraine, the US is dragging us towards war with Russia – John Pilger
Exactly the point.
goatsneez··on Understanding why our ancestors were stuck in poverty
This is, unfortunately (as this is a respectable datasite), a mother of improper data analysis. The story that is woven together over such a large time frame over which number of socio-politico-economic shifts happened do not inform what so ever the conclusion squeezed out this dataset.

The economies of countries of 1200, 1600, 2000, and 2022 along with the inter-networking relationships, dominance of petro-dollar with many latent variables render this approach useless toward thinking about such matters.

goatsneez··on U.S. has sent private warnings to Russia against using a nuclear weapon
Future historians (if there will be any) will analyze this period of time (last 10-15 years) having the luxury of 'abstand' for the diplomatic blunders, ideological blindness supported by new found capability of waging propaganda on its own citizens (by both sides) lead to this situation, which in in turn, without any uncertainty what so ever leads to a major (WW) clash within few months (nuclear war is not only not off the table, it is, by remarks from RUS and USA almost an inevitability. (this are just words to us, but the inner rapture of sadness that this is indeed coming cannot be communicated).

I always wondered as a kid reading or learning about WWs how come nobody wanted to stop it. Why the elites are so eager for blood of other country's "peasants" (for those are the people who die), and even more so I wondered why are people willing to go and die for the elites. Clearly, as and adults I still do not have (the key) the answers. (Sure, states are not sentient entities, the expression I use is for convenience only).

goatsneez··on Putin’s Energy War with Europe Seems to Falter
Im sure there were, however, from my point of view it seems (and Im not trying to fight that, just observing) the collective "mania" and false logic predicated on tribal mentality of emotions (for emotions can be controlled unlike reasoned populace) is thoroughly hammered into the populace . So, any thread, as you point out, has the nearly identical tones, emotions, and false claims.
goatsneez··on Putin’s Energy War with Europe Seems to Falter
The myths we live by...

My remark is of a philosophical nature how a culture/society creates its myths and their role in the dynamics of elites and the subjects. None of the comments, neither the original article nor on this thread cover even 1% of the reality on the origin of the crisis (energy), nor does it explain how the current EU energy market has been developed by whom and who it keeps in power, and what might be the solution (bashing Putin and puffin our proverbial chest is not it I know that much).

How such medieval mentality that we display here and in general media (us vs Putin) is so pervasive gives little hope that we even care to know the truth, care for real solution, or even care for ourselves. There is just so much to unpack that there is no chance here from such a simple sentence.

goatsneez··on Ask HN: Why do we need central bank digital currency (CBDC)?
A CBDC system would radically simplify the current system of intermediaries approving/checking/extracting-fee/etc shifting 0 and 1 from one digital ledger to another [e.g. https://www.bankofcanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/sdp20...]. Under CDBC a person has open account only with a single 'independent federal/global bank', making it the only liability to government not a private institution (technically Fed would is private institution, but that is topic on its own).

The abolition of an analogue payment system (cash) is from the first principles a tragic idea regardless of the actual implementation mechanism, despite the few pros one can but forward in this argument. The system with CBDC can make money have an 'expiration date' ! This is not a theoretical construct, but its discussed as a way to 'manage' economy (and private individuals). Inflation, spending, propping up economy is fully in the hands of a government entity and can be matter of coordinating policies and laws. This alone, this principle goes against all the progress of modern times from Babylon. The opportunity for tyranny (not used lightly) under such system is limitless (I will not enumerate it here, Im just outlining an argument on a important and complex issue).

goatsneez··on Russia’s Unfounded Claims of Secret U.S. Bioweapons Linger on and On
This is bizarre ...

We went from 'the labs don't exist' to 'okay they exist but they are benevolent' to 'if the labs fall into Russian hands there will be a biological attack', now again to 'unfounded claims'. V. Nuland testified before SFRC in March this year: ...“Ukraine has biological research facilities” that are dangerous enough to warrant concern that they could fall into Russian hands. (Nuland is not even mentioned in this blatant pr.)

This is such a bad propaganda spin, similar to that of denying that US has torture prisons on foreign soil to which both US and foreign citizens are subjected to torture not allowed by both, the US and the international law.

goatsneez··on American workers need lots and lots of robots
An argument well done, although not complete. (Yes, I know, the prevailing journalistic school of thought we have become adopted to is to always have an angle (single bend) toward which the entire argument is aimed at).

Im no Luddite, humanity's well being is due to creative forces of fashioning new resources, processes, and industries. However, we should always keep in mind when discussing these things that there are, generally two branches (which are not de-correlated): economic-requirements and human needs. A government (as evil and necessary as that institution is) when biasing a system only toward one extreme will find itself in the midst of revolutions at the other one. In a reasonably well constrained free-market economy system the role of government would not be to choose one over the other branch. [All monopolies, and I have yet to find an exception, are due to lobby of government/laws by private business... biasing the entire system in a uncontrollable way].

Transient balance is needed; building deep roots in physical reality of both, human needs and economic requirements for a particular society structure. This is not possible in totalitarian and/or purely socialistic systems of governments, yet, the west is not so slowly turning toward these concepts of governance. No amount of automation will solve these issues, since the other branch of the problem will suffer unbearable stresses until it breaks.

goatsneez··on Oberon (2009)
FYI, a flavor of Oberon will also fly to space soon it turns out...

https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.03404v1

goatsneez··on Life is good in America, even by EU standards
Well, this 'controlled demolition' of EU economy and relationships with the East (RU and CHI) has been the point since very long time ago (B. Obama had a very clever strategic trade deals which would assure that be established before D. Trump pulled out). Every serious economists wrote many article about the disastrous consequences for EU not pursuing peace but going for US induced 'proxy' war, which has no cost for the USA (if they play their cards right, they will be able to retain their hegemony and dollar as a reserve currency. This will in turn mean that they can continue to live in monetary bubble while the rest of the world has to get dollars only by producing real commodities).
goatsneez··on Trees Are Spreading North in Alaska. That’s Not Good
How is this not 'good'? This is exactly what nature/life has been doing, adapting and responding to changing conditions. Life as we understand it does not evolved to maintain a static equilibrium of any given region but a global biotic stability (this has been recognized at least 6-7 decades) - this is exactly what is needed (as per nature determination) for stability of climate, hence life.

If Alaska is warming and (biotic) life does not respond at all, then we have something to worry about. It would be a dessert.

goatsneez··on Universal basic income: the basic trade-offs
With all due respect to the author of this, this is not particularly strong reasoning for or against UBI. It is very myopic, shallow point of view a single implementation issue, without even discussing others.

However, it turns out that the very principle of UBI itself is the gravest danger to a civilized free society. UBI will work probably great in totalitarian setting, where individual human life is the last thing of value to the state itself.

People have to realize that with a right comes attached a duty. If someone else has a duty to secure my right to income, he is my slave so to speak. He has to create value/wealth and there must be force to transfer it to me. This FORCE is government. The natural tyranny of states using FORCE to redistribute wealth should be so scary to humans anywhere (more so in self-proclaimed free societies).

If someone can tackle this issue in real-world setting good on you. But even a moderate thought will convince anyone that as a whole to a society nothing comes as a right. Everything (wealth) has to be produced by someone. There is no automatic wealth in nature; poverty is the default condition of humanity.

goatsneez··on Determinants of lithium-ion battery technology cost decline†
Unfortunately this is 2021 article. That was a year with virtually the lowest lithium prices, which right now are 5 fold higher putting unspeakable pressures on the entire industry. The rest of the materials are in even worst shape, just today few smelting plants are considering closing in EU due to energy prices.
goatsneez··on Ask HN: Is AI goal to make most people dumb/the same?
I see where you coming from (I can concur a kind of similar trend in space research academia in the leading EU countries as far as I can tell and hear from colleagues). Although, I do not think this is a 'directed' by someone or something (AI). This is just a convergence of factors, a natural outcome of enacted social myths into policies and bureaucratic processes (covering most of the 'west' countries).

The self-deception about reality of things (physical, emotional, civic, societal, etc) are in fact rewarded, they carry advantages to those who engage in it (implicitly or even explicitly). Empty activism, proper slogans, proper hate against the 'right' group of people, or pretend solidarity with the right people is what counts today. (As you say, we are scripted by social media). On the other hand, calling it out directly, or even voicing skepticism, or rejecting binary/hypocritical world views are punished (quite severely in many instances, no grant money, institutional shunning, etc). In other words, western way nowadays is to proceed on a moral/political plane such being wrong ideologically is a 'sin' of much severe kind than being factually wrong (reality error). Not realizing that being in error per se is not the danger, the danger lies in not allowing corrective feedbacks to reality. We are in a dangerous process of (collectively) sealing ourselves off from feed-backs to reality.

Has these processes ever been different in kind or only in degree for civilization at this phase of evolution?

At the same time Im not sure that this should be considered as a problem-and-solution issue. This is our culture at this point, it has been going on for quite some time, there is a large 'momentum' already gained. As I mentioned, even academia is for the most part infected by these parasitic processes (and academia is in-fact the very source of most of these trends-in-ideas. As I said, it is a convergence of interests, factors, and conditions, a natural process).

Taking a step back to this view for a larger field of view: ... has there ever been a different progress in evolution of civilization (from any starting conditions) than to totalitarian regime as the asymptote we move towards? [This is just a symptom - implicit or explicit mono-culture, the least variability of opinion. How did Christianity begin in Roman times and to which it evolved by ? How different are ideals of a rising peoples from poverty to prosperity and toward which they evolve? Another terms for this is borrowed from physics, unless one can export properly cultural/social entropy a given civilization in a given territory will 'undergo' a cycle. This is necessary as physics of life abhor fully correlated systems -- they are infinitely fragile (at the same time diversity has also several kinds -- variance in non-linear systems is not an absolute good). Of cause Im borrowing from physics for these analogies, but they give a notion of proper characteristics and constraints of a model of the world in which we live in. To be patient and bear each other's delusions without zealotry and fundamentalist attitudes).

goatsneez··on Russia Backs Europe’s Far Right
Neither of those statements make any sense no matter which direction one tries to go with it (they are just blank statements of no significance, no validity and neither is rooted in reality -- just spending one day at wikipedia may help to be less ignorant (as Tim Minchin says in one of his songs). [Start with the political parties of UA in recent pas, throw in some Yarosh and other western UA figures. They should balance your view and get you to scale better the political power of the said ideology]. Of cause, 'freedom' you have to remain uniformed, and that is ok, we can exchange short messages as this one.

However, already Jefferson put it strongly back at his days "If a nation expects to be both ignorant and free in a state of civilization, it expects what never was and never will be".

... and I leave off with a latin proverb: "where there is doubt there is freedom". Lets leave hypocrisy of demagoguery at the door in civilized opinions.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →