HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

godelski

28,841 karma · joined September 22, 2016

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/godelski; my proof: https://keybase.io/godelski/sigs/ITXd1PN0tKNiQYxLgpyMs4xX2HIQy0uyX-09Z4DbV48 ]
submissionscomments
godelski··on Apple has added persistent 'ads' to iOS, and it's driving users crazy

  > What are you going to do? Switch to android which has even more ads?
We're on HN. If you're on Android and seeing ads then you're doing something wrong.

I don't disagree with your main point, but the H is important context here

BTW, in iPhone I tend to get lots of ads because Safari doesn't have ad block, I can't repackage APKs, can't edit DNS, not to mention all the spam calls/texts (especially from icloud emails...). Thank God the ublock folks got an iPhone app. I mean it isn't a fair comparison, a rooted Android vs stock iPhone, but it's trivial to root a pixel and on an iPhone I can't even access my photos from a terminal emulator... so there's no fair comparison that can be made

godelski··on Apple has added persistent 'ads' to iOS, and it's driving users crazy

  > Think Different indeed

  - Make the phone thinner
  - Make the laptop thinner
  - Make the iPad thinner
Extreme innovation
godelski··on Apple has added persistent 'ads' to iOS, and it's driving users crazy
I knew we were cooked when Costco started upselling its cookies at the self-checkout food court.

I think it really speaks to the situation we've gotten ourselves into. Capitalism requires us to constantly grow but I think the problem is we're myopic and believe we need to grow faster and faster. With the high concentration of power these companies have the easiest lever to pull is by making a service worse and having users pay for a better experience. That's a very different strategy than offering new products and/or features.

I call this myopic because it really only works when there's little to no competition but using it too much causes more backlash and causes people to get pissed enough to become the competition (and not sell out). I think Pournelle's Iron Law of Bureaucracy comes into play here. People aren't aligned with the goals of the organization. To be honest, it's hard to think of any company where it's clear the leaders, let alone employees, are dedicated to the goals of the company[0].

It's really sad too, since all these big companies seem to just be a shell of what they used to be. They used to be inspiring and it was exciting to see all the change and innovation. But it just seems to be more and more disappointment lately. Small changes so people can push their small org's status. No one taking any risks to really push things forward. These companies cornered the markets, have trillion dollar evaluations, yet act like they're poor. That boy ain't right...

[0] don't give me that nonsense of "the goal is to make money". The comment is about myopia. If this is your first reaction, you're being myopic and missing my point. You're welcome to disagree, but don't strawman

godelski··on The senior engineer death spiral

  > the thing they do is they tell themselves they need to almost cosplay being a more senior engineer than they are.
Isn't this explicitly written in every promotion guide? Every one I've ever read says you need to be working at X level for Y months before getting promoted to X. Thats not delusion, that's codified. There's good reason people work like that.

  > like, for two, three weeks, you won’t hear anything from them.
Two might be fine, three is probably pushing it, but a lot of times this is just bad communication (which I think is more the point). But also our field is extremely rushed for some reason, especially with AI. Sometimes things do take time. Honestly, I think the whole industry could move a heck of a lot faster if we just cooled our jets for a bit. Innovation doesn't happen by slamming your head against the wall, it happens in the quiet moments after lots of head banging. But our culture acts like we can brute force our way.

We constantly say "I'll fix it later" and we never do or do it when the problem has turned from a small one into a big one. Why can't we fix problem while they're still small? It's penny wise and pound foolish. Does your manager actually know if it will become a big problem? More than you, the person in the weeds? How would they even know? Would you even tell them? Are you afraid to tell them?

We're constantly jumping from bandwagon to bandwagon, not taking any time to even check where we are or look up to see where we're going. And we attack anyone who pokes their heads up like we're afraid we'll get hosed reaching for a banana.

Is it really any wonder people burn out? You can't operate at high anxiety forever.

godelski··on ChatGPT now knows what you do on other websites via ad collector
That's how bags work
godelski··on ChatGPT now knows what you do on other websites via ad collector

  > the people who were fooled in the past often were not fools themselves.
I think this can't be said enough. Propaganda's greatest weapon is making you think you are immune to it. Maybe some, but so much is propaganda. We all fall for propaganda (and ads), constantly

Being fooled doesn't make you a fool. But being unwilling to change your mind does. Being unable to admit you don't know or don't have enough information to make a strong opinion makes you a fool too.

Propaganda wants to take shortcuts, to simplify things. To trivialize. "It's so easy, you just..." because the fool is the person who already knows, the person who has nothing to learn, the person who thinks they're better than everybody else.

godelski··on ChatGPT now knows what you do on other websites via ad collector
We do.

There's a lot of innate knowledge but all neuroscience demonstrates how incredibly flexible the brain is. Brains constantly learn and rewire.

Here's a few things that I think show how crazy it is AND stress those points

  - people that have had corpus callosotomy (brain cut in half) *may* be indistinguishable from a normal person. Depends on how young you were when you underwent the procedure
    - true for most brain injuries
    - can even include the frontal cortex
  - you can learn to ecolocate
  - people with Aphantasia are indistinguishable from others
  - people without an internal monologue are indistinguishable from those with one
  - people can learn to use prosthetics
    - even without disabilities
    - or look into MRI scans with tool use
You can convince yourself that we're just organic robots (after all, there's no magic), but you would be a fool to convince yourself we're the ordinary kind.

We are constantly learning. You aren't just born with your knowledge and it stays static. We are extremely proficient at metalearning (learning how to learn, few shot learning, zero shot learning [0,1]). Our brains are constantly rewiring, able to heal from traumatic damage.

I could go on and on. Does information pass down through genetics? Of course! But that's far from the whole story.

I'm tired of people trying to make AI sentient by making humans robotic. Stop trying to trivialize everything and be okay not knowing the answer to everything. You're human, you're designed to learn and explore, not sit and argue from an armchair

[0] and I mean these in the original sense. Not in the sense that you train on a billion examples of labeled animals and then congratulate yourself on your ImageNet-1k held out test performance. That's not zero shot, that's just a test set

[1] I can literally make up words and you'll understand them. Or use words in novel ways. That's literally how slang works and how new words come to be. Don't be a walibanut ya glufus. Read some SciFi

godelski··on The Hugging Face Hack Wasn't What It Was Cracked Up to Be
I never felt like I could be a hacker until I read these AI debriefs. I too can edit /etc/hosts, am I an elite hacker now?
godelski··on Android 17 is the first since 3.x to add new APIs without releasing to the AOSP
That's crazy! I'm commenting from Firefox! What a crazy world! How is this even possible?!
godelski··on Android 17 is the first since 3.x to add new APIs without releasing to the AOSP
You act like it hasn't been done before.

Also, switching browsers is trivial. I do it on my parents' machines and they don't notice

godelski··on Android 17 is the first since 3.x to add new APIs without releasing to the AOSP
Tbh I don't think fighting open source is Google's best play. I think it is in their own best interest to keep it fully open. It is free labor by those who are most passionate. It gives strong signals at what people want, this direction you develop. It strengthens security as more people try to test it. It means people work on forks rather than alternatives. All this is true even with a monopolistic market share.

So yes, I do think they are being naïve. The stance is myopic. It is only a good move in the short term, and barely even that. It is under the false belief that we operate in a zero sum game.

godelski··on Android 17 is the first since 3.x to add new APIs without releasing to the AOSP
I hope people remember this when advocating for chromium. Just because it is open source doesn't mean they don't control it. We need to start the long process of hard forking now or turn to alternatives like Firefox as a new foundation.

  > Google simply regrets android being open source.
Android wouldn't be what it is if it wasn't open source. With all the work from outside Google. The same is true chrome.

But they won't learn that on their own. They are breaking the deals. So we move. We force their hand

godelski··on Giving up on smart rings
It is difficult to get off. If they can't smash it, they remove the finger. But if your ring gets caught you lose your glove. The one made of skin
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough

  > You seem to conflate "no one is powerful" with "no one has any power in any situation at all".
The problem is not this, it is your claim that all power is equal, that there is no imbalance. No one is claiming God, only men
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
It really sounds like you're trying hard to define a square circle. Your argument isn't even self consistent because what you described sure sounds like someone has power...
godelski··on Giving up on smart rings
Don't look up how they get removed from your finger at the ER
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
If that is true then we all are in charge and it is up to all of us. As you agreed elsewhere, cooperation exists.
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
But the comment above wasn't about an explicit conspiracy, with billionaires meeting in dark rooms colluding. It was about implicit, uncoordinated conspiracy, where objectives align. My comment is defending the latter
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
Plenty has come from all those things. But it's those in power who want you to feel like those are fruitless endeavors. That's why their strategy is to overwhelm. Good news takes time to be received and by then your focus will be on something else. But I promise you if you look them up you'll find real progress. It may not be as much as you want, but that's a different thing. Progress is made by small and successive steps. So the strategy to upend progress is to interrupt those steps and make them feel as small as possible. Don't fall for the trap

  > We clearly need ... sharks
I am afraid of sharks, just as I am scorpions. It is in their nature to draw blood. Bloodshed should be the last resort. By putting sharks in power is the problem with the current administration. Replacing with a different shark doesn't reduce attacks, it just changes targets. If sharks must be used, they must be well contained.
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough

  > your enemies can potentially gain access to the same surveillance
Which has already happened. Though it is less obvious if high profile targets have been blackmailed or coerced. There's at least signs that some have. Even if not foreign governments, Epstein certainly had leverage
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough

  > A wanton disregard of the treasure that is digital data. Most people just don't seem to care.
I think the problem is a bit more subtle. People do seem to care but feel powerless. In addition to that, complexity is high. When you tell people what is possible with massive data they label you as a conspiracy theorist because it's much easier to believe that Facebook is listening to you with a microphone than piecing that information together through thousands if individual pieces of data (especially when you're more likely to notice the hits rather than the misses). So now when they do record everything you say it feels like nothing changed.

It's exhaustion, it's impotence, it's desolate. But that's different than apathy. People care, they are just overwhelmed

godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
This seems to contradict itself. You first claim that there's no organization but then you claim billionaires have no power because of the more powerful above them. Hierarchy is organization, so which is it
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough

  > You could make this statement about any group at all. 
Yes, that's the point

  > And then once you realize people are in multiple groups, the whole thing devolves into chaos.
You have bad priors. That would only happen if groups could only have singular and simple goals. It requires those goals to be mutually exclusive. Because as soon as they overlap, even just a little, cooperation becomes an effective strategy.

Hell, history shows us enemies often cooperate. Mostly to defeat a mutual enemy, so they can go back to fighting each other, but that's still cooperation

godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
It doesn't need any intelligence at all. There's mutually beneficial things to any group of people. So it doesn't require explicit coordination. Even fairly unintelligent animals have symbiotic relationships with other species. So your argument is what, that billionaires are less intelligent than an ant?
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
Honestly, my worry is that the longer we put it off the more likely any revolution or change will happen more chaotically. It should be organized, with strong leaders. But if that fails, I think Reverend King has a famous quote about the unheard. And I think that ends up being chaotic and bloody. I don't want that, I hope we've evolved enough to do transitions of power peacefully, or at least as peacefully as possible
godelski··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
I believe the parent is implying that we sit uncomfortably at home, silently, rather than uncomfortably marching through the streets, demanding. Yet, I say that while uncomfortably sitting in my home, typing on a screen
godelski··on Why don't machine learning research agents overfit?
It is even wrong about things

  > A validation set is one you consult repeatedly while building the model — to compare candidates, tune hyperparameters, and decide what to try next.
The validation can be done like that but it is better to do a cross-fold validation or selecting a random subset. These are equally valid. Keeping the validation like a hold-out set can end up creating biases if the statistics don't match. Honestly, this is true about the test set too. Though I've found that most people really don't think about this much. It's mundane, boring, hard to do, but deceptively important.
godelski··on A Beginning for Mathematics

  > What about the next 3,900 words after the first sentence?
But had I read those I wouldn't have been able to feel smart with egg all over my face.
godelski··on A beginning for mathematics
Not everyone needs to be a communicator.

Why should we expect everyone to be both a great researcher and communicator? The obvious result is that it is as effective as engineering managers. Sure, there's some amazing ones, but most aren't. Though that also doesn't mean no expertise in the field (i.e. non-engineering manager) is any better. It is just that managing/communicating is a different and orthogonal skill.

What needs to happen is we need to make it okay for people to specialize in more things. More nuance to this rather than trying to throw everyone into nice easy to manage buckets. Those buckets are just unrealistic abstractions filled with hope, denial, and laziness. Reality is surprisingly complex. Math can do a really good job helping you understand that, but it's a sufficient condition, not a necessary one

godelski··on A beginning for mathematics

  > Mathematics is a part of physics
This feels backwards. I frequently joke "physics is the subset of mathematics that reflects the observable world". Math can be as abstract as it wants, but physics has a constraint. It must model an observable world (related, this us part of why people say String Theory is math and not physics)
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →