HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

godelzilla

-20 karma · joined September 30, 2019

submissionscomments
godelzilla··on The Teetering Towers of Abstraction
Modern mathematics is based on formal systems, not an "abstraction" of counting jelly beans. That's like saying that chess is an abstraction of war. It seems like a reasonable analogy but they're actually entirely different things.

A formal system of category theory is no more abstract than a formal system of natural numbers. The apparent difference in abstraction is relative to the subjective (and irrelevant) choice of application. Category theory seems abstract for counting jelly beans, but for other applications it might be less of an abstraction than arithmetic.

https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/298912/real-world-a...

Similar to how computer programs can be broken down into physical laws about the movement of electrons, mathematical proofs can be broken down into deductive statements about ZFC set theory, etc. In both cases this is ideally about concretely building upon previous work, not creating abstractions.

The problem of incomprehensible proofs isn't about a "tower of abstraction". There's no abstraction within formal systems. The system is described and the implications are deduced. The problem is expanding complexity with a lack of detail and exposition that allows for misunderstandings and perhaps even errors.

godelzilla··on The strange properties of the infinite power tower
This analysis can also be expanded to the complex numbers yielding "power tower fractals" aka "tetration fractals".

http://paulbourke.net/fractals/tetration/

https://thatsmaths.com/2016/04/14/the-power-tower-fractal/

godelzilla··on An alternative argument for why women leave STEM
Pretty sure that the systemic bias against motherhood is a crucial part of sexism, rather than an alternative explanation.
godelzilla··on How Tesla's battery costs impact its gross margins
Well they're not overthrowing Bolivian democracy for the quinoa.
godelzilla··on When good ideas make bad business
The point of healthcare under capitalism is to profit from sick people, not to heal them.
godelzilla··on Show HN: Rewtro plays tiny videogames encoded in origami GameBoy cartridges
Somewhat misleading. The videogames are encoded in QR codes which can be printed onto "origami". I was expecting the games to actually be encoded in origami via folding patterns, etc.

Still fun though!

godelzilla··on This year’s Nobel prizes prompt soul-searching among economists
TBH I've found that nonsense gets upvoted quite regularly here.
godelzilla··on AI Clones Your Voice After Listening for 5 Seconds (2018)
Thanks... Too long of a scroll to find somebody posting the actual science behind the click-bait.
godelzilla··on Adversarial design printed on a shirt to fool object recognition algorithms
In a world of click-bait "invisible to AI" is the same as defeating two models most of the time.
godelzilla··on AI Detects Heart Failure from One Heartbeat: Study
I guess adding "Congestive" to the title would've ruined the click bait.

Also how can the detection of a progressive disease be 100% accurate? I guess details ruin the click bait too.

godelzilla··on Exposure to air pollution is linked to an increase in violent crime
Agreed. It's impossible to have a reasonable discussion about an article that barely anybody can actually read.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2