You identify with dev and gamer culture and feel that it reciprocates a sense of belonging. Therefore you have no reason to protest; all your interests align and not protesting is the path of least expended energy. The people complaining do so because they too identify with a culture of devs and/or gamers, however they feel there is an overwhelming majority that identifies its members who are alike and yet does not accept them specifically as part of that culture. So these protesters are not foreign aliens - you could think of them as a version of yourself that enjoys the games and tech but is not fully accepted as being “in” no matter how long you hang around the “in” people. Are we to respond to those people: “Why are you complaining about things being this way or for change - when you knew this has always been who we are, and that this culture is created predominantly by us, for us.”?
Given the list of what makes an execution person, would be a dumb mistake for someone like that to work for someone else. If you can do it all yourself, others would just slowly you down, seemingly.
Yeah, state-actor scale sabotage was one of my first thoughts. And it gives me no joy to contemplate it.
Secondly, the researcher’s attitude sounds high and mighty - making process improvement suggestions when their own ethical compass is in question. Their “experiment” was “what would happen if...”. Well, bans happen. If one starts a fight don’t get indignant over a bloody nose, lol
I would question how much this is also a function of the company or industry in which the union operates. Maybe the company the union negotiated with stipulated such terms, or the union enforces those kind of rules out of an abundance of caution to protect its members. Asking why is more useful.
You can request/demand to be forgotten by services, but a reasonable person can’t expect other people to forget them just because they asked services to do the same. Stored data and human memories are not the same thing lol
I do agree on services sharing banned users data, for safety or compliance reasons. But this should be limited to a set period of time, because the person you were 10 years ago grew up from who you are now and will be in 10, 20, 30 years from now. We all grow and hopefully learn from mistakes.
An implication of this “banned users” data sharing is that this data exchange must be overseen by regulators, to enforce equal access to competitors to this data and also that companies drop people from the “banned users” database after some time, not penalized for life except in rare cases.
I would argue that most users’ petty behaviors that lead to banning do not deserve to make them pay for it the rest of their lives - and that there are rare exceptions who do deserve to be banned for life because certain users’ behavior is so egregious.
Also, consider cases for jurisdictional banning and global banning. Some behaviors are not allowed in certain countries. Take a gay couple kissing in a car in Saudi Arabia - should this couple be banned? If so, just if attempting to use services in Saudi Arabia, or globally? These are serious and important considerations.
No. Unmoderated and anonymous dialog has a way of straying into mudslinging on subjects of political expression. From your suggestion: flagging the “ad hominem part” is moderation and could be open to interpretation if flagged statements are or not. Thus brings to mind Burke, “The majority of the citizens is capable of exercising the most cruel oppressions upon the minority.” True as that is, though, there’s been a growing popularization across groups for adopting a victimhood complex to feel justified in claiming oppression. So, no - ironic to post here, but actually cogent debate requires a base degree of mutual respect - which requires a shared (global) “culture” - and less anonymity.
No? I did respond with the President’s response, and his response is called fomenting - the reason for the ban in question.
> an eventual reiteration that the elections were rigged, they should be furious, but now they should go home and that he loved them very much and were very special people
People branding his flags and hats stormed the Capitol walls and Senate floor, as he delayed an eventual reiteration that the elections were rigged, they should be furious, but now they should go home and that he loved them very much and were very special people. There were nooses propped up, people died, and elected officials were bunkered. His close sources also reported that he watched on TV with manic joy at what people were doing in his name. Hence, the ban and mass 11th-hour resignations.
There’s also a mitigating liability aspect to this. If you start providing minutiae detail, you may start revealing pretty big faults that have escaped to prod. People question the safety of your product and now you’re open to lawsuit or at least micromanaged by some unforgiving end-customers. To cope, you start to not fix certain problems so you won’t have to report the bugs or you start lying what the bugs were. I’m not so sure it’s on net a useful direction to be quite that open.
This is a classic argument for doing nothing, which is a stance promoting existing systems of inequality. Ask government to solve it, they propose paying for services that help lessen inequality with tax strategies that target those most able to - large corporations and the wealthiest - then people get upset that government is too big, sucking dry the wealthiest, and they start moving to Texas lol. So what’s the game plan?
You could also spin this argument to say that testosterone aggression causes people to fail to cooperate and societies would soon fall into chaos as everyone is out for themselves. These pseudo/pop scienciness is poor logic and unprofessional.
And often every price the dental office provides you is an estimate, as once they enter each procedure’s code the insurance may price that work above or below the estimated price. That’s dental, which often isn’t life or death. If you’re in an ER or ICU you’re not processing “by golly, can I afford saving myself or should I negotiate the hospital’s Tylenol?”
This sounds like ennui brought on by burnout, perhaps not necessarily arising from physically manifested work but just overthinking. Totally empathize. Perhaps speak with a therapist to get started. It may not be about rediscovering your love for this again, but just a passion for something new. It does sound like some degree of turmoil there.
The performative sense could have to do with a lack of personal connection to it. It’s a frustration for something not wholly understood, specially when the “performative” express strong conviction. I’m trying to understand how one could imagine someone would risk imprisonment, bodily injury, or death just for performance.
From reading Jeff Dean phrase her request, this was the sense of what he and the company want to illustrate. But reading his assistant’s termination email and Gebru’s emails to management and subsequently to allies (for which she was quoted as not being worthy of a manager), the real issue is the company feels she’s too independent and threatened by her lack of submissive attitude. This has spoken more about the company’s attitude toward culture and perception, elucidating the very points in Gebru’s email to Brain allies that the company doesn’t care about opinions or humanity. Ironically, the very reason she is in her role to help with as an ethicist - which also puts into question how they see this role not as innovative but as a shill. Gebru’s mistake is she worked for the wrong employer.
I’m not sure how unique that is, though. Most companies once you’re in doing technical, your peers will trust you to switch teams or broaden out a little. Re-testing a coworker would come off anywhere between amusing and insulting.
Hard to judge without the story published, but it also sounds like the company is frustrated it didn’t get line-editing power. This is in contrast to even showing gratefulness for being alerted about the story’s imminent publishing and probably being contacted for sources from all views. The company has invited more scrutiny; like a kid running up to parents saying, “Whatever my brother says, it’s not true.”
> the energy and networking opportunities ... good tech jobs, balanced economy ... wasn’t driven by a hyper focus on money
You shape your environment, as much as it shapes you. This is a list of careerist wishes. Not that there’s anything wrong with it per se, but if it’s careerism without chase for money then go for a city big on public service and charity work. Else, it’s not SF you’re running away from.
I have virtually no cap. But in regards to bandwidth speed. That’s about my marketed down/up anyway. It’s what they sold me, big asterisk, but I usually get 1/5 - 1/4 of that, which is still decent. However, if they have a family all working, studying, streaming, and playing games from home they may need closer to the 1 Tb. It’s their use case, why does it have to be policed and justified as “you don’t actually need that, let me tell you what you really need.” Put another way, even all current use cases do not encompass all future use cases so why promote the restrictions? All of which boils down to: the entitled gall, to dictate.
Yeah. The alternative is they see a lot of big tech regulation headed their way. They preemptively set the rules of the negotiation by pushing their limits that come into question. After that, negotiating down a little makes government funded crackdowns more appealing for everyone, and they’ve still effectively set their own rules. Even if they lose a few million in fights, it’s something they’re committed to fighting.
I believe it’s a platitude of “fair centrism”, not for its concrete weight but it’s symbolism in addressing “both sides”. Veracity and sincerity come to question, when I see this.
Not disagreeing, but I think calling it political correctness is actually granting those folks too much credit. It was people who were unqualified to process or understand the company’s findings chiming in with pop interpretations, just because they wanted to feel a part of what was supposed to be an intelligent conversation backed by data.